Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Lewski

Link copied
Case Copied 53 min read

HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

KIEFEL CJ,
BELL, GAGELER, KEANE AND EDELMAN JJ

Matter No M79/2018

AUSTRALIAN SECURITIES & INVESTMENTS
COMMISSION  APPELLANT

AND

WILLIAM LIONEL LEWSKI & ANOR  RESPONDENTS

Matter No M80/2018

AUSTRALIAN SECURITIES & INVESTMENTS
COMMISSION  APPELLANT

AND

MICHAEL RICHARD LEWIS WOOLDRIDGE &
ANOR  RESPONDENTS

Matter No M81/2018

AUSTRALIAN SECURITIES & INVESTMENTS
COMMISSION  APPELLANT

AND

MARK FREDERICK BUTLER & ANOR  RESPONDENTS

Matter No M82/2018

AUSTRALIAN SECURITIES & INVESTMENTS
COMMISSION  APPELLANT

AND

KIM SAMUEL JAQUES & ANOR  RESPONDENTS

Matter No M83/2018

AUSTRALIAN SECURITIES & INVESTMENTS
COMMISSION  APPELLANT

AND

PETER CLARKE & ANOR  RESPONDENTS

Australian Securities & Investments Commission v Lewski
Australian Securities & Investments Commission v Wooldridge
Australian Securities & Investments Commission v Butler
Australian Securities & Investments Commission v Jaques
Australian Securities & Investments Commission v Clarke

[2018] HCA 63

13 December 2018

M79/2018, M80/2018, M81/2018, M82/2018 & M83/2018

ORDER

Matters M79, M80, M81 and M82 of 2018

1.Appeal allowed in part.

2. Set aside orders 2 to 6 of the orders of the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia made on 1 November 2017 and in their place order that:

(a)the appeal be allowed in part;

(b)declarations 13, 21, 29, 37, 40, 41, 42, 43, 44, 45, 46, and 47 of the declarations and orders 1.1 to 1.4 and 2.1 to 2.5 of the orders made by the primary judge in proceeding VID 594 of 2012 ("Trial Proceeding") dated 2 December 2014 be set aside;

(c)order 3 of the orders made in the Trial Proceeding be set aside and in its place order that the second to fifth defendants pay the plaintiff's (namely, ASIC's) costs of and incidental to the proceeding; and

(d)the first respondent (namely, ASIC) pay the appellant's costs of and in connection with the dispute as to the form of orders.

3.Remit the matter to the Full Court of the Federal Court for determination of penalty and disqualification orders, costs, and the cross-appeal to that Court.

4.The first respondent pay the appellant's costs of the appeal to this Court.

Matter M83 of 2018

1.Appeal allowed in part.

2. Set aside the orders of the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia made on 1 November 2017 and in their place order that:

(a)the appeal be allowed in part;

(b)declarations 40 to 47 and order 2.5 of the orders made by the primary judge in proceeding VID 594 of 2012 ("Trial Proceeding") dated 2 December 2014 be set aside and in lieu thereof order that the plaintiff's claim in paragraphs 6 to 19 of its originating process dated 21 August 2012 in the Trial Proceeding in so far as it is made against the sixth defendant be dismissed; and

(c)the first respondent (namely, ASIC) pay the costs of the appellant (namely, Mr Clarke) in the Trial Proceeding and in the Full Court of the Federal Court, including reserved costs.

3.There be no order as to the costs of the appeal to this…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Lewski and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] HCA 63
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of Australia considered appeals from the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia concerning alleged contraventions of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) by directors of a responsible entity for a managed investment scheme. The Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) alleged that the directors, including Mr Lewski and others, contravened their duties by amending the scheme's constitution to introduce new fees payable to the responsible entity, and by authorising payments of these fees. The dispute centred on whether these amendments and payments were valid and whether the directors had breached their statutory and common law duties.

The legal issues before the High Court included whether the amendments to the scheme's constitution adversely affected members' rights, whether the Full Court erred in holding the amendments valid from the time of lodgement until set aside, and whether the directors were absolved of liability due to an honest belief that the constitution had been validly amended. The Court also considered whether the directors were involved in contraventions of section 208 of the Corporations Act relating to financial benefits to related parties.

The High Court allowed the appeals in part, restoring most of the declarations made by the primary judge. The Court reasoned that the amendments to the constitution did adversely affect members' rights and that the directors had failed to properly consider the implications of these amendments. The Court found that the directors' honest belief that the constitution was validly amended did not necessarily absolve them of liability, particularly where that belief was not reasonably held or where the amendments themselves were invalid. The Court also addressed the directors' involvement in contraventions of section 208, with specific considerations for Mr Clarke's role.

Consequently, the High Court set aside certain orders of the Full Court and remitted the matter for determination of penalty and disqualification orders. The Court ordered that the primary judge's declarations, with specific exceptions relating to Mr Clarke and certain contraventions of section 208, be reinstated. The matter was remitted to the Full Court for further determination of penalties, disqualification periods, and costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Matters M79, M80, M81 and M82 of 2018

1. Appeal allowed in part.

2. Set aside orders 2 to 6 of the orders of the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia made on 1 November 2017 and in their place order that:

(a) the appeal be allowed in part;

(b) declarations 13, 21, 29, 37, 40, 41, 42, 43, 44, 45, 46, and 47 of the declarations and orders 1.1 to 1.4 and 2.1 to 2.5 of the orders made by the primary judge in proceeding VID 594 of 2012 ("Trial Proceeding") dated 2 December 2014 be set aside;

(c) order 3 of the orders made in the Trial Proceeding be set aside and in its place order that the second to fifth defendants pay the plaintiff's (namely, ASIC's) costs of and incidental to the proceeding; and

(d) the first respondent (namely, ASIC) pay the appellant's costs of and in connection with the dispute as to the form of orders.

3. Remit the matter to the Full Court of the Federal Court for determination of penalty and disqualification orders, costs, and the cross-appeal to that Court.

4. The first respondent pay the appellant's costs of the appeal to this Court.

Matter M83 of 2018

1. Appeal allowed in part.

2. Set aside the orders of the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia made on 1 November 2017 and in their place order that:

(a) the appeal be allowed in part;

(b) declarations 40 to 47 and order 2.5 of the orders made by the primary judge in proceeding VID 594 of 2012 ("Trial Proceeding") dated 2 December 2014 be set aside and in lieu thereof order that the plaintiff's claim in paragraphs 6 to 19 of its originating process dated 21 August 2012 in the Trial Proceeding in so far as it is made against the sixth defendant be dismissed; and

(c) the first respondent (namely, ASIC) pay the costs of the appellant (namely, Mr Clarke) in the Trial Proceeding and in the Full Court of the Federal Court, including reserved costs.

3. There be no order as to the costs of the appeal to this Court.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons that follow, the appeals to this Court should be allowed in part. With the exception of the declarations in relation to Mr Clarke and the declarations relating to one group of contraventions concerning s 208 (as modified by s 601LC)[2] of the Corporations Act, all the declarations made by the primary judge should be restored. The matter should be remitted to the Full Court for the hearing of ASIC's cross-appeals against penalty in that Court and for re‑determination of the penalties and disqualification periods for the directors other than Mr Clarke.[2]Referred to simply as "s 208" in the remainder of these reasons.Background By deed dated 27 December 2000, APCHL created a unit trust called the Prime Retirement and Aged Care Property Trust ("the Trust"). The business of the Trust was retirement villages and aged care facilities. On 23 July 2001, the Trust was registered by ASIC, as required by s 601EB of the Corporations Act, as a managed investment scheme and the consolidated trust deed became the constitution of the managed investment scheme ("the Constitution"). It was difficult for members to sell their units in the Trust, for which there was no secondary market. From March 2006, they could not redeem their units due to suspension of the redemption facility. The Constitution provided that one event that would cause the Trust to vest was where the responsible entity had not passed a resolution, on or before 31 July 2007, to seek listing of the units on an appropriate exchange (such as the ASX). APCHL was the responsible entity of the managed investment scheme. The first respondent in Matter No M79 of 2018, Mr Lewski, together with his family and an associated company, owned all the shares in APCHL. Mr Lewski was the driving force behind APCHL and a director. Apart from Mr Clarke, the first respondent in each of the other appeals (Dr Wooldridge, Mr Butler, and Mr Jaques) was a director of APCHL at all relevant times. Mr Clarke commenced as a director on 21 August 2006. By the Board meeting on 22 August 2006, each of the first respondents was a director of APCHL ("the Directors"). The Constitution provided for various fees payable to APCHL, including (i) an "Exit Fee" payable on the determination of the Trust (2.5 per cent of its gross asset value) or the sale of all of its main assets and undertakings (2.5 per cent of the net sale proceeds), and (ii) a "Takeover Fee" of 2.5 per cent of the gross price paid for the units in any acquisition by an acquirer who held or thereby obtained more than 20 per cent of the units. In June 2006, APCHL was systematically moving towards listing the Trust on the ASX. The likelihood was that the Trust would be listed within the next 12 to 18 months. The Trust had gross assets of $568 million and total liabilities of around $356 million, its net assets therefore being around $212 million. On 20 June 2006, Mr Lewski contacted APCHL's solicitors seeking legal advice about amending the Constitution without consulting the members. Mr Lewski, Mr Butler and Dr Wooldridge said that they were concerned about the possibility of an opportunistic, "low-ball" takeover attempt on the Trust, and that those concerns prompted the Board to investigate "poison pills" to discourage such attempts. However, the primary judge held that (i) there was no real threat of an opportunistic takeover attempt that might have led to APCHL's removal as responsible entity, and (ii) a poison pill would also discourage reasonable takeover offers, which were one of the few ways that a member could crystallise her or his investment before listing or vesting[3].[3]Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Australian Property Custodian Holdings Ltd (Receivers and Managers appointed) (In liq) (Controllers appointed) [No 3] (2013) 31 ACLC ¶13-073 at 1118 [303], [307].

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

KIEFEL CJ, BELL, GAGELER, KEANE AND EDELMAN JJ
The third group of contraventions concerned the actual payment by APCHL of the Listing Fee in cash to itself and then to one of Mr Lewski's associated companies, and in units directly to one of Mr Lewski's associated companies ("the Listing Fee Payments"). ASIC alleged that APCHL contravened s 208 and that the Directors each contravened s 209(2) by their involvement in APCHL's contravention.The Federal Court and Full Court decisionsThe Federal Court decision The primary judge, Murphy J, held that the Amendment Resolution was invalid. Section 601GC(1) of the Corporations Act required that an amendment to the Constitution that was not made by special resolution of the members of the scheme required the responsible entity reasonably to consider that the change would not adversely affect members' rights. Since the Amendments affected members' rights, and since APCHL did not consider whether the Amendments would adversely affect members' rights, the Amendments were not valid[16].[16]Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Australian Property Custodian Holdings Ltd (Receivers and Managers appointed) (In liq) (Controllers appointed) [No 3] (2013) 31 ACLC ¶13-073 at 1178 [665]-[667], 1179 [673]. As to the Negligence Duties, the primary judge held that the Directors did not read and understand the effects of the Amendments before passing the Amendment Resolution or the Lodgement Resolution, and that the effects of the Amendments were not considered by the Directors acting as a Board[17]. [17]Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Australian Property Custodian Holdings Ltd (Receivers and Managers appointed) (In liq) (Controllers appointed) [No 3] (2013) 31 ACLC ¶13-073 at 1119 [309]-[311], 1120 [315], 1120-1121 [321], 1121 [323]-[324], 1164 [589]. As to their understanding, the Directors did not understand the following: (i) the Takeover Fee could be charged on multiple occasions; (ii) the increased Takeover Fee and the Removal Fee could be payable notwithstanding prior payment of the Listing Fee; (iii) the Removal Fee provided little additional protection for members against opportunistic, "low-ball offers" for their units; (iv) the increased Takeover Fee would discourage reasonable offers for members' units; and (v) the Removal Fee would significantly impair the ability of members to remove APCHL as responsible entity. As to their consideration, the Directors did not consider the fact that the introduction of substantial additional fees was effectively gratuitous. None of the Directors gave proper consideration to the mutually exclusive interpretations of cl 25.1 of the Constitution that APCHL's solicitors had left open for their consideration, including whether to seek unequivocal legal advice or a judicial direction. Nor did any Director consider whether the Amendments should be made, that is, whether it was proper to make them even if there were power to do so. The primary judge found that all of the contraventions alleged by ASIC were established. However, as his Honour held, the position of Mr Clarke, who was not a director at the time of the Amendment Resolution, was different in some respects. The primary judge accepted that it was unrealistic to expect Mr Clarke to have called for the legal advice concerning the Amendment Resolution when considering the Lodgement Resolution at the Board meeting on 22 August 2006[18]. Nevertheless, the primary judge concluded that Mr Clarke did not give the Lodgement Resolution or the Amendments any consideration, and that he remained silent through the meeting and was a passive participant[19]. The primary judge concluded that if Mr Clarke had given proper consideration to the matters before him then he should have understood their deleterious effects, APCHL's conflict of interest, and the lack of any countervailing benefit to the members for the imposition of substantial additional fees[20].[18]Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Australian Property Custodian Holdings Ltd (Receivers and Managers appointed) (In liq) (Controllers appointed) [No 3] (2013) 31 ACLC ¶13-073 at 1163 [580].[19]Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Australian Property Custodian Holdings Ltd (Receivers and Managers appointed) (In liq) (Controllers appointed) [No 3] (2013) 31 ACLC ¶13-073 at 1147 [493(b)]-[494], 1163-1164 [584].[20]Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Australian Property Custodian Holdings Ltd (Receivers and Managers appointed) (In liq) (Controllers appointed) [No 3] (2013) 31 ACLC ¶13-073 at 1163-1164 [584].

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: KIEFEL CJ, BELL, GAGELER, KEANE AND EDELMAN JJ