Lewski v Australian Securities & Investments Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 96 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Lewski v Australian Securities & Investments Commission
(No 2) [2017] FCAFC 171

Appeal from:

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Australian Property Custodian Holdings Limited (Receivers and Managers appointed) (in liquidation) (Controllers appointed) (No 3) [2013] FCA 1342

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Australian Property Custodian Holdings Limited (Receivers and Managers appointed) (in liquidation) (Controllers appointed) [2014] FCA 1308

File numbers: VID 752 of 2014
VID 753 of 2014
VID 783 of 2014
VID 784 of 2014
VID 795 of 2014
Judges: GREENWOOD, MIDDLETON AND FOSTER JJ
Date of judgment: 1 November 2017
Catchwords:

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Reopening the appeal – reconsideration of earlier reasons – form of declarations

CORPORATIONS – duties of responsible entity of managed investment scheme under s 601FC – duties of officers of responsible entity under s 601FD – statutory duty to act in best interests of members – statutory duty to exercise care and diligence – statutory duty not to make improper use of position to gain advantage – statutory duty to take all reasonable steps to comply with scheme constitution

CORPORATIONS – members’ rights – whether right to have scheme administered according to existing constitution is a “members right” under s 601GC – failure to consider members’ right to have scheme administered according to existing constitution – amendment invalid as outside power

CORPORATIONS – related party transaction in managed investment scheme – breach of s 208 (as modified) of responsible entity – involvement of officers of responsible entity in breach of s 208 – essential elements of the prohibition in s 208 – whether s 208(3) is an exception to the prohibition – officers’ honest belief that constitution contain provision allowing payment

CORPORATIONS – company procedure – reconsideration of earlier decisions – whether conduct amounts to or conveys assent to a resolution

CONTRACT – deeds – when does an undated deed come into effect – intention of the parties to the deed

Legislation: Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)
Cases cited:

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Australian Property Custodian Holdings Limited (Receivers and Managers appointed) (in liquidation) (Controllers appointed) [2014] FCA 1308

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Australian Property Custodian Holdings Limited (Receivers and Managers appointed) (in liquidation) (Controllers appointed) (No 3) [2013] FCA 1342

Forrest & Forrest Pty Ltd v Wilson [2017] HCA 30

Lewski v Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2016] FCAFC 96

Plaintiff S157/2002 v Commonwealth of Australia (2003) 211 CLR 476

Rudd v Bowles [1912] 2 Ch 60

Rudd v Bowles ASIC v Cassimatis (No 8) [2016] FCA 1023

Date of hearing: 12-13 December 2016
Registry: Victoria
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Corporations and Corporate Insolvency
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 201
Counsel for the Appellant in VID752/2014: Mr B Walker QC with Mr M Osborne and Mr J Tomlinson
Solicitor for the Appellant in VID752/2014: SBA Law
Counsel for the Appellant in VID753/2014, VID783/2014, VID784/2014 and VID795/2014: Mr NC Hutley SC with Mr RG Craig
Solicitor for the…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lewski v Australian Securities & Investments Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] FCAFC 171
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Lewski v Australian Securities & Investments Commission, the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia dealt with an appeal regarding the decision of the trial judge in relation to certain declarations made against Australian Property Custodian Holdings Limited (APCHL) and its directors. The original appeal by the directors was allowed, but the question arose as to the effect of this on the outstanding declarations against APCHL. The court considered whether it should set aside the declarations against APCHL or if they should remain in place. APCHL, which had been joined as a party to the appeal, argued that certain declarations should not be set aside. The Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) sought to have the court reconsider its earlier conclusions and reopen the appeal.

The court found that there was no error in its earlier conclusions and that there was no need to revisit the appeal. The Full Court held that the appeal would be allowed, and the orders and declarations made by the trial judge were set aside. The directors were ordered to pay the costs of the appellant, while APCHL was ordered to pay the costs of the appellant in relation to the dispute as to the form of orders. The court also ordered that APCHL be joined as the second respondent to the appeal. The decision reaffirmed the importance of statutory duties and the administration of managed investment schemes according to the existing constitution.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Australian Property Custodian Holdings Limited ACN 095 474 436 (Receivers and Managers Appointed) (In Liquidation) (Controllers Appointed) be joined as the second respondent to the appeal.

2. The appeal is allowed.

3. The orders and declarations made by the trial judge in proceeding VID 594 of 2012 (Trial Proceeding) dated 2 December 2014 are set aside and in lieu thereof the plaintiff’s claim by originating process is dismissed.

4. The first respondent pay the costs of the defendants in the Trial Proceeding, including reserved costs.

5. The first respondent pay the costs of the appellant in the appeal, including reserved costs and the costs of and in connection with the dispute as to the form of orders.

6. The second respondent pay the costs of the appellant in the appeal proceeding of and in connection with the dispute as to the form of orders.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Directors (but not APCHL) subsequently appealed to this Full Court: Lewski v Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2016] FCAFC 96 (‘Appeal Judgment’). The appeal was allowed on the basis that the trial judge had erred in holding that the Directors had contravened the Act. However, before orders disposing of the appeal were made, the Directors contended that a further consequence of the Full Court allowing that appeal was that it also removed the foundations for the declarations made by the trial judge against APCHL. Applications to join APCHL to each appeal were made, and ASIC now seeks leave to file a notice of contention. Submissions have also been made by ASIC that this Court should reconsider its Appeal Judgment. Therefore, in broad terms, the question confronting this Court is as follows: given the findings made in the Appeal Judgment and in light of the submissions of the original parties to the appeal and APCHL, what action should this Court take in respect of the outstanding declarations of the trial judge against APCHL? PROCEDURAL MATTERS Before going any further, we need to address certain procedural matters. In relation to the joinder of the APCHL to each appeal, whether this is necessary or not, it is appropriate that APCHL be joined as a party. This was not contested by any existing party to the appeal or APCHL. We propose to order that APCHL be joined as a second respondent to each appeal. All parties and APCHL participated in and had the opportunity to be heard at the hearing before the Court on the issues considered in these reasons. One of the consequences of APCHL being joined as a party to each appeal is that APCHL had a right to be heard on the issue of the setting aside of the declarations, which right it exercised. APCHL made submissions that certain declarations affecting it should not be set aside. Those declarations were 5 and 7; otherwise APCHL did not oppose the setting aside of the other declarations against it. ASIC took the opportunity, with the addition of APCHL as a party to each appeal, to submit that none of the declarations against APCHL should be set aside, not only on the basis of the reasons of the Full Court in the Appeal Judgment, but also by reference to additional submissions relevant to the position of APCHL. These additional submissions were in effect seeking to have this Court revisit some of its conclusions reached in the Appeal Judgment. This revisiting by this Court of certain conclusions reached by it (relevant to the Directors), could have resulted in the spectre of inconsistent findings by this Court, if we were persuaded by ASIC that our earlier conclusions in the Appeal Judgment were incorrect. We should indicate at the outset that we have not been persuaded that any error in the Appeal Judgment has been made that requires correction. Therefore the occasion for inconsistent findings does not arise. However, ASIC did submit that in the event that this Court did consider it was previously in error, the Court should then reopen the appeal as far as it concerned the Directors, and correct the record accordingly. It was in this context that ASIC effectively requested this Court to re-open its consideration of the appeal brought by the Directors.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

For the purposes of this judgment, it is now useful to set out briefly the positions that the parties have adopted in respect of appropriate orders following the delivery of the Appeal Judgment on 14 July 2016.The declarations against APCHL As already indicated, the Directors contend that the declarations in respect of APCHL, which are declarations 1 to 7 of the trial judge in the Penalty Judgment, should now be set aside as a result of the decision in the Appeal Judgment. ASIC contends that the APCHL declarations should not be set aside. ASIC also submits that this Court should contemplate reviewing and revising its Reasons in the Appeal Judgment if necessary. APCHL contends that declarations 5 and 7 of the trial judge should not be set aside. APCHL has an interest in making this contention because it is making its own claims against the Directors in separate proceedings in the Supreme Court of Victoria. APCHL brought civil proceedings against Mr Lewski and others in the Supreme Court of Victoria alleging breaches of duty in respect of similar conduct and events considered in the Appeal Judgment. APCHL’s interest in maintaining the declarations against it arises because of the operation of s 1317F of the Act, which the Directors fear will be employed against them in the Supreme Court of Victoria proceedings and may prejudice their defence to the various claims brought against them. For the purposes of these appeals we do not need to consider this aspect further. We just mention this matter because it explains the position of APCHL and its desire to maintain declarations otherwise thought to be against its own interests (being declarations of wrongdoing). Because the issues before this Court concern the impact of our previous findings on the declarations of the trial judge, it is now useful to set out those findings from our Appeal Judgment in further detail.FINDINGS OF THE FULL COURT The Full Court’s findings in respect of the Directors’ grounds of appeal were organised by reference to the three groups of contraventions pleaded by ASIC. The Full Court described the three groups of contraventions as follows:The first group of contraventions[11]ASIC pleaded three groups of contraventions. The first group of contraventions was based in the allegation that, at its meeting on 22 August 2006, the Board resolved to lodge with ASIC a consolidated Constitution incorporating the Amendments so that they would become effective pursuant to s 601GC(2) of the Act (the ‘Lodgement Resolution’). [12]It is uncontroversial that on 23 August 2006 APCHL in fact lodged a consolidated Constitution with ASIC with the intent that the Amendments would become effective. [13]The trial judge concluded that in passing the Lodgement Resolution, APCHL and each of the Directors breached their duties under ss 601FC(1) and 601FD(1).Listing[14]On 3 August 2007, the Trust units were officially quoted on the ASX. It is uncontentious that over the period from 26 June 2007 to 27 June 2008 the Listing Fee of about $33 million was paid out of scheme property to APCHL and then to entities associated with Mr Lewski.[15]The second and third groups of contraventions are based on the conduct of APCHL and the Directors on 26 June 2007, 27 July 2007, 3 August 2007, 13 March 2008, 28 April 2008 and 27 June 2008 in making the decisions to pay, and in paying the Listing Fee to APCHL (and through it to Mr Lewski).The second group of contraventions[16]In the second group of contraventions, ASIC alleged that, in paying the Listing Fee to itself and to one of Mr Lewski’s associated entities, APCHL contravened s 208 (as modified by Pt 5C.7 of the Act) which prohibits payments to a RE or to a related party without the approval of the members. Section 208(3) provides that a RE may pay itself fees from scheme property where the Constitution provides for the fees.[17] The trial judge concluded that:(a)cl 25.1 of the Constitution operated to prohibit APCHL from making the Amendments and they were made outside power; and(b)the statutory power of amendment in s 601GC(1)(b) of the Act was not engaged as the Board gave no consideration to the members’ right to have the Trust administered for the fees provided in the existing Constitution, and the Board could not have reasonably considered that the Amendments would not adversely affect the members’ rights.[18]The trial judge thus concluded that the Amendments were invalid, and did not accept the contention that, even if not validly made, the Amendments became effective upon lodgement with ASIC and that they would remain so until declared invalid.[19]It was and is uncontentious that in paying the Listing Fee, APCHL had given a benefit to itself and to a related party, and that it did not seek the members’ approval to do so. Upon deciding that the Amendments were invalid and of no effect, the trial judge concluded that ASIC made out its claim that APCHL breached s 208.[20]ASIC also alleged that each of the Directors contravened s 209 by being involved in APCHL’s breach of s 208. This allegation involved construing s 208 (as modified) in order to determine the essential elements of the contravention therein defined. The trial judge concluded that on the proper construction of s 208, it was for the Directors to prove that the Constitution provided for the Listing Fee, which, because the Amendments were invalid, they could not do so. The Directors’ unchallenged evidence (accepted by the trial judge) was that they honestly believed that the Constitution had been validly amended to include the Listing Fee. The third group of contraventions[21]In the third group of contraventions, ASIC alleged that in making the decisions to pay the Listing Fee:(a) APCHL contravened s 601FC(5) in that it breached its duty:(i)to act in the best interests of, and give priority to the interests of the members of the Trust over the interests of APCHL, under s 601FC(1)(c); and(ii)to ensure that all payments out of the scheme property were made in accordance with the Constitution, under s 601FC(1)(k); and(b)each of the Directors contravened s 601FD(3) in that each of them breached his duty:(i)to act in the best interests of, and give priority to the interests of the members of the Trust over the interests of APCHL, under s 601FD(1)(c); and(ii)to take all steps that a reasonable person would take to ensure that APCHL complied with the Act, under s 601FD(1)(f).[22]It was and is uncontentious that APCHL made the decisions to pay the Listing Fee. The Directors’ argument before the trial judge (and in each appeal) turned on their honest belief that the Amendments were valid. They denied that there could be any breach of the duties under ss 601FC(1) and 601FD(1) in making the decisions to pay the Listing Fee when the fee was (apparently) provided for in the Constitution. The trial judge concluded that contraventions had been demonstrated by ASIC.