Perpetual Trustees Australia Ltd v Heperu Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 82 min read

NEW SOUTH WALES COURT OF APPEAL

CITATION:
Perpetual Trustees Australia Ltd v Heperu Pty Ltd [2009] NSWCA 84
This decision has been amended. Please see the end of the judgment for a list of the amendments.

FILE NUMBER(S):
40018/2008

HEARING DATE(S):
28 - 29 August 2008

JUDGMENT DATE:
23 April 2009

PARTIES:
Perpetual Trustees Australia Ltd (Appellant)
Heperu Pty Ltd (1st Respondent)
Kirisi Holdings Pty Limited (2nd Respondent)
Barry Samuel Landa (3rd Respondent)
Drymmoyne Administrative Services Pty Ltd (4th Respondent)

JUDGMENT OF:
Allsop P Campbell JA Handley AJA   

LOWER COURT JURISDICTION:

LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S):
6165/03

LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER:
Palmer J

LOWER COURT DATE OF DECISION:
12 December 2007

LOWER COURT MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION:
Heperu Pty Ltd & Ors v Morgan Brooks Pty Ltd & Ors (No 2) [2007] NSWSC 1438

COUNSEL:
R E Dubler SC (Appellant)
G K Burton SC; C L Cochrane (Respondents)

SOLICITORS:
TressCox Lawyers, Sydney (Appellant)
Schreuders Partners Lawyers, Sydney (Respondents)

CATCHWORDS:
BANKING AND FINANCE - instruments – cheques –passing of title - delivery by an agent – apparent authority of agent – fraudulent agent - condition attaching to the agent to deliver does not have to be complied with for title to pass - no requirement of a pre-existing contractual relationship between true owner and payee other than that of the drawing and endorsement of the cheque for title to pass
BANKING AND FINANCE - instruments – cheques – conversion – voidable title – whether title of retrospective true owner of cheque related back retrospectively to the date of the fraud to allow title to sue in conversion – no conversion where payee gave value bona fide and without notice
RESTITUTION – mistake – recovery of money paid under fundamental mistake of fact or induced by fraud – unjust enrichment – circumstances where order to make restitution unjust – retention of moneys required to remain unjust – defence of change of position – payments made on faith of receipts 
NEGLIGENCE – duty of care – pure economic loss- trustee company managing a common fund - no duty of care to avoid economic loss to potential investors in the fund who suffer from dishonesty of their agents – no vulnerability –no direct relationship – no assumption of responsibility by the trustee company
MISLEADING DECEPTIVE OR UNCONSCIONABLE CONDUCT – representations - no representations – reliance - no relevant reliance upon the documents said to give rise to the representations – Fair Trading Act 1987 (NSW) s 42   

LEGISLATION CITED:
Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 1989 (Cth)
Bills of Exchange Act 1909 (Cth)
Cheques Act 1986 (Cth)
Corporations Law (Cth)
Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)
Fair Trading Act 1987 (NSW)
Suitors' Fund Act 1951 (NSW)
Trustee Companies Act 1964 (NSW)
Trustee Companies Act 1984 (Vic)
Trustee Comapnies Act 1947 (ACT)
Trustee Companies Act 1968 (Qld)
Trustee Companies Act 1988 (SA)

CATEGORY:
Principal judgment

CASES CITED:
Associated Midland Corporation Ltd v Bank of New South Wales [1983] 1 NSWLR 533
Associated Midland Corporation Ltd v Bank of New…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Perpetual Trustees Australia Ltd v Heperu Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] NSWCA 84
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal before the Court of Appeal of New South Wales concerned the liability of Perpetual Trustees Australia Ltd (Perpetual) to the respondents, Dr Landa and his companies, for the conversion of six cheques. The dispute arose from a fraudulent investment scheme orchestrated by Mr Cincotta, who had induced Dr Landa to invest substantial sums by representing that these funds would be placed in an "offset mortgage account" with Perpetual. In reality, no such scheme existed, and Mr Cincotta misappropriated the funds. Dr Landa drew the cheques in favour of Perpetual, which were then delivered to Mr Cincotta, who was found to have no actual authority to act on behalf of Perpetual in this manner.

The central legal issues before the Court of Appeal were whether Perpetual was liable for conversion of the cheques, and whether Perpetual's defences, including estoppel and change of position, were valid. Specifically, the court had to determine if title to the cheques had passed to Perpetual, and if so, whether Perpetual's subsequent payment of the proceeds before notice of the fraud meant it was not liable for conversion or unjust enrichment. The court also considered whether a duty of care was owed by Perpetual to potential investors like Dr Landa to prevent economic loss arising from the dishonesty of agents acting in relation to Perpetual's common fund.

The Court of Appeal allowed Perpetual's appeal, overturning the primary judge's finding of liability for conversion. The court reasoned that for title to pass to the payee of a cheque, the drawer must intend to pass title to that payee. In this instance, Dr Landa drew the cheques payable to Perpetual, intending for Perpetual to receive the funds. While Mr Cincotta acted fraudulently, the court held that the condition of delivery to Mr Cincotta did not invalidate the passing of title to Perpetual, as the payee had not been complicit in the fraud. The court distinguished the present case from authorities where the payee was found to have converted the cheque, noting that Perpetual had not been a party to the fraud and had acted in good faith. Furthermore, the court found that Perpetual did not owe a duty of care to Dr Landa to prevent economic loss arising from Mr Cincotta's dishonesty, as there was no sufficient vulnerability or assumption of responsibility by Perpetual.

Consequently, the Court of Appeal set aside the orders made against Perpetual and entered judgment in favour of Perpetual against the plaintiffs. The respondents were ordered to pay Perpetual's costs of the appeal, and were granted certificates under the Suitors' Fund Act 1951 (NSW), if qualified.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be allowed. 2. The orders 5, 6 and 7 made by the Court below on 12 February 2008 against the fifth defendant be set aside and in lieu thereof: a) there be judgment for the fifth defendant against the plaintiffs; and b) the plaintiffs to pay the fifth defendant's costs. 3. The respondents to pay the appellant's costs of the appeal. 4. The respondents to have certificates under the Suitors' Fund Act 1951 (NSW), if qualified.

Background

Background to the litigation

The claims against the sixth, seventh and eighth defendants were settled. The primary judge found in favour of the plaintiffs against Morgan Brooks and the appellant, but dismissed the claim against Ms Belle. It should also be noted that Ms Belle was also found to be entirely innocent and in no way a party to her husband’s fraud. An appeal against the primary judge’s dismissal of the claim against Ms Belle is also before the Court. It has been listed separately because the parties failed to bring to the attention of the Registrar the fact that the two appeals were related. The delivery of judgment in this appeal has been delayed so that the related appeal could be heard by the same bench in order to avoid the risk of any inconsistency in approach. The argument in that appeal having been heard, it is now appropriate to deliver these reasons, no inconsistency being likely.The backgrounds facts This appeal only concerns the found liability of the appellant, Perpetual. Nevertheless, it is important to understand the claim against Morgan Brooks in order to understand and resolve the dispute about the appellant’s asserted liability to the respondents. Morgan Brooks carried on business as a mortgage originator and mortgage manager, finding non-bank lenders for people wishing to borrow on the security of a mortgage. In 1994, Morgan Brooks entered into a written agreement with Mr Cincotta and his then wife, under which Mr and Mrs Cincotta were appointed as the “Coffs Harbour Agent” of Morgan Brooks. In 1995, Morgan Brooks entered into an agreement with ACN 067, to which Mr Cincotta, Mrs Cincotta and another officer of ACN 067 were parties and pursuant to which ACN 067 was appointed as the “Double Bay Agent” of Morgan Brooks. The primary judge concluded that these agreements were not wide enough in their terms to encompass the conduct of Mr Cincotta and ACN 067 of which complaint was made by Dr Landa and his companies. Therefore, his Honour concluded that there was no actual authority (express or implied) in Mr Cincotta or ACN 067 to act on behalf of Morgan Brooks in the way that they did, and as we shall describe. Nevertheless, the primary judge concluded that a contract was formed between Morgan Brooks and Dr Landa and his companies because Morgan Brooks held out Mr Cincotta as having apparent authority on its behalf to enter into the contract for the investment of funds represented by Mr Cincotta to be available and because Dr Landa relied on that holding out in deciding to enter into the contract with an entity he believed to be Morgan Brooks. No appeal was brought by Morgan Brooks. It is now necessary to return to the events in question. These events are set out in somewhat more detail than the primary judge’s findings. There is little dispute about the primary facts, though an important factual dispute must be resolved as to the proper conclusion and characterisation of the primary facts. The primary judge found at [25] of his reasons that in about June 2001, Dr Landa met Mr Cincotta and his wife at a social occasion, being introduced by Dr Landa’s sister-in-law and her brother who told Dr Landa that they had invested money at call with Perpetual through Morgan Brooks. Dr Landa’s evidence was that Mr Cincotta said to him:“I’ll invest it for you at Perpetual as I am doing with Anna and Clara’s [sic]. The investment would be 8% plus 1,000 shares per million dollars invested. That would equate to about 12% per annum.”

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Amongst Perpetual’s various defences it pleaded that Dr Landa was estopped from denying the authority of Mr Cincotta, the essence of which was described by the primary judge at [158] of his reasons as:“[158] … – it acted in accordance with the mandate on the face of the cheque in collecting the cheque;– by drawing the cheque in favour of Perpetual Dr Landa intended to pass title to Perpetual, that title has passed to it and it is, at most, a voidable title subject to Perpetual’s defences;– Perpetual paid away the proceeds of the cheques before it had notice of Dr Landa’s title so that it has not been unjustly enriched;– Dr Landa clothed Mr Cincotta with apparent authority to deposit the cheques and to deal with them as he did so that his claims in conversion and for money had and received are estopped.”The conclusions and reasoning of the primary judge The primary judge concluded that Perpetual was liable for the conversion of the six cheques. His Honour also rejected Perpetual’s defences. The primary judge made the following findings at [11] of his reasons in an introduction to the claims against Perpetual:“Dr Landa borrowed substantial sums from Perpetual Trustees Victoria Ltd (‘PTV’) in order to invest the borrowed funds with Perpetual pursuant to an investment scheme, called an ‘offset mortgage account’, which was to result in a profit to Dr Landa. The ‘offset mortgage account’ scheme did not exist: it was an illusion fraudulently created by Mr Cincotta. PTV is a related company of Perpetual but is not a party to these proceedings.”(emphasis added) It was common ground that Perpetual did not offer an account styled “offset mortgage account” or one that operated in the way described by Mr Cincotta to Dr Landa. The primary judge’s conclusions as to conversion were encapsulated in [165] of his reasons:“[165] In the present case, Mr Cincotta held Dr Landa’s cheques on Dr Landa’s behalf. As the supposed investment scheme with Perpetual which had been proposed by Mr Cincotta was a fraudulent illusion from the very beginning, Mr Cincotta had no authority to do anything at all with the cheques which Dr Landa had given him. The title in the cheques remained in Dr Landa. Innocent though Perpetual was of any wrongdoing, it is nevertheless liable in conversion, subject to its defence of estoppel.”(emphasis added) The primary judge then referred to the Queensland Court of Appeal decision in Voss v Suncorp-Metway Limited (No 2) [2003] QCA 252; [2004] 1 QdR 214 (though the primary judge referred to the case as “Voss v Davidson”) and the Victorian Court of Appeal decision in NIML Ltd v MAN Financial Australia Ltd [2006] VSCA 128; 15 VR 156 in concluding that conversion had been established and that the defence of estoppel could not succeed. The primary judge relied heavily on Voss. The primary judge summarised the facts in Voss at [160]-[161] of his reasons:“[160] In Voss v Davidson …, Mr Voss asked the advice of his accountant, Mr Ripper, about investing the proceeds of the sale of his farm. Mr Ripper advised him to invest in ‘an overseas fund’ and that he was able to arrange such an investment through his contacts with a large international firm of accountants. He told Mr Voss to draw a cheque in favour of ‘Southern Pacific Equities Unit Trust’ and to deliver the cheque to him for deposit with that Trust. Mr Voss complied with that direction.[161] Mr Ripper immediately had a trust deed prepared constituting a trust entitled ‘Southern Pacific Equities Unit Trust’. He was the sole beneficiary of that Trust. He opened a savings account with a bank in the name of ‘Southern Pacific Equities Unit Trust’ and deposited Mr Voss’ cheque into that account. The bank collected the cheque and Mr Ripper made off with the proceeds. Mr Voss sued the bank in conversion.”

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.