Hassan v Minister for Home Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 50 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Hassan (formerly AFX21) v Minister for Home Affairs [2025] FCAFC 57

Appeal from: Hassan v Minister for Home Affairs [2024] FCA 527
File number: NSD 844 of 2024
Judgment of: KATZMANN, THAWLEY AND KENNETT JJ
Date of judgment: 22 April 2025
Catchwords: TORT – where appellant medically evacuated to Australia from offshore immigration detention in Papua New Guinea – where appellant requested removal to Papua New Guinea under s 198(1) of Migration Act 1958 (Cth) – where appellant remained in detention until removal to United States of America over 500 days after request made – where appellant pleaded respondents owed him a duty of care to limit the duration of his detention to that required for the purpose of removal – where appellant pleaded respondents breached that duty by failing to establish system for administering requests for return to regional processing country – whether primary judge erred in concluding respondents did not owe pleaded duty – whether primary judge erred in finding respondents had a system to administer requests for return to regional processing countries – whether primary judge erred in finding that border restrictions in response to Covid-19 pandemic broke chain of causation – whether primary judge erred in assessment of quantum of damages
Legislation:

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) ss 140(2),

Migration Act 1958 (Cth) ss 5AA 14, 189, 196, 198, 198AD

Wrongs Act 1958 (Vic) s 51(1)

Cases cited:

Blatch v Archer (1774) 1 Cowp 63; 98 ER 969

Briginshaw v Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 336

CQR17 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2019] FCAFC 61; 269 FCR 367

Hampton Court Ltd v Crooks (1957) 97 CLR 367

Plaintiff M96A/2016 v Commonwealth [2017] HCA 16; 261 CLR 582

Roads and Traffic Authority of NSW v Dederer [2007] HCA 42; 234 CLR 330

Sydney Water Corporation v Turano [2009] HCA 42; 239 CLR 51

Wallace v Kam [2013] HCA 19; 250 CLR 375

WAIS v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2002] FCA 1625

Division: General Division
Registry: New South Wales
National Practice Area: Administrative and Constitutional Law and Human Rights
Number of paragraphs: 91
Date of hearing: 3 and 4 March 2025
Counsel for the Appellant: Mr JF Gormly with Mr C Honnery
Solicitor for the Appellant: Hall & Wilcox
Counsel for the Respondents: Mr P D Herzfeld SC with Ms N A Wootton
Solicitor for the Respondents:

Australian Government Solicitor

Table of Corrections
1 July 2025 At [14(v)], the reference to paragraphs “[44]-[45]” has been corrected to “[46]-[47]”.

ORDERS

NSD 844 of 2024
BETWEEN:

YASSIR HASSAN (FORMERLY AFX21)

Appellant

AND:

MINISTER FOR HOME AFFAIRS

First Respondent

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION, CITIZENSHIP AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS

Second Respondent

COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA (and another named in the Schedule)

Third Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

KATZMANN, THAWLEY AND KENNETT JJ

DATE OF ORDER:

22 APRIL 2025

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The appeal be dismissed.

2.The appellant file any submissions (not exceeding five pages) and any relevant evidence on the question…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hassan v Minister for Home Affairs and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] FCAFC 57
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Hassan v Minister for Home Affairs, the appellant, an asylum seeker who had been detained in offshore immigration detention in Papua New Guinea, was medically evacuated to Australia. He requested removal to Papua New Guinea under section 198(1) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth), but remained in detention until his removal to the United States of America, over 500 days after his request was made. The appellant argued that the respondents, being the Minister for Home Affairs and the Department of Home Affairs, owed him a duty of care to limit the duration of his detention to that required for the purpose of removal and that this duty was breached by failing to establish a system for administering requests for return to regional processing countries.

The primary judge was tasked with determining whether the respondents owed the pleaded duty, whether they had a system to administer requests for return to regional processing countries, whether border restrictions in response to the Covid-19 pandemic broke the chain of causation, and the assessment of the quantum of damages. The court examined the relevant statutory provisions and the circumstances of the appellant's detention, including the impact of the Covid-19 pandemic on his removal process.

The court concluded that the respondents did not owe the pleaded duty of care, as the appellant's detention was governed by specific statutory provisions, and there was no general duty of care owed to detainees in such circumstances. The court found that the respondents had a system in place to administer requests for return to regional processing countries, albeit that the system was not perfect. The court also determined that the border restrictions in response to the Covid-19 pandemic did not break the chain of causation, as the appellant's detention was primarily due to his own actions and the delays caused by the respondents. Lastly, the court assessed the quantum of damages and found that the appellant was not entitled to any damages for the period of his detention.

In conclusion, the appeal was dismissed, and the question of costs was to be decided on the papers. The appellant was required to file submissions and evidence on the question of costs by a specified date, with the respondents given a subsequent opportunity to respond. If the appellant did not file any submissions on costs, the orders regarding costs were to be vacated, and an order would be made that the appellant pay the respondents' costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be dismissed.

2. The appellant file any submissions (not exceeding five pages) and any relevant evidence on the question of costs by 4pm AEST on 6 May 2025.

3. The respondents file any submissions in response (not exceeding five pages) and any relevant evidence by 4pm AEST on 13 May 2025.

4. The question of costs be decided on the papers.

5. In the event that the appellant does not file any submissions on costs in accordance with order 2, orders 3 and 4 be vacated and instead an order be made that the appellant pay the respondents’ costs.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

It is apparent from the terms of s 198AH(1) that an unauthorised maritime arrival, who has been brought back to Australia for a “temporary purpose” under s 198B, becomes subject once again to s 198AD at the point where the relevant temporary purpose no longer requires them to be in Australia (and at that point s 198(1A), which would otherwise apply to them, is excluded). However, until that time, s 198AD does not apply. A consequence is that, until that time, s 198 is not prevented from applying; so that a written request by the person to be removed from Australia can trigger an obligation under s 198(1) to remove the person. This somewhat convoluted relationship between the provisions was explained in Plaintiff M96A/2016 v Commonwealth [2017] HCA 16; 261 CLR 582 at [12]-[18] (Kiefel CJ, Bell, Keane, Nettle, Gordon and Edelman JJ).Agreed facts in the present case The parties filed an agreed statement of facts covering the appellant’s immigration history and the attempts to return him to PNG. The basic facts relevant to the resolution of this appeal can be summarised as follows (based on that statement of facts and uncontroversial evidence before the primary judge).(a)The appellant arrived at Christmas Island on 13 September 2013 as an unauthorised maritime arrival seeking asylum and was detained under s 189(3) of the Act.(b)On 28 October 2013 the appellant was taken to Manus Island in PNG under s 198AD.(c)On 23 October 2015 the government of PNG recognised the appellant as a refugee.(d)In November 2019 steps were taken under what was then s 198E of the Act for the transfer of the appellant to Australia for treatment of mental health issues. This included a recommendation from a Medical Officer of the Commonwealth (MOC) that the transfer should occur for that purpose. However, s 198E and associated provisions were repealed with effect from 5 December 2019.(e)On 6 December 2019 an officer in the Department approved the appellant’s transfer to Australia under s 198B for the purpose of receiving medical treatment.(f)That transfer occurred on 18 December 2019. On arrival in Australia the appellant was detained under s 189(1) of the Act.(g)During January 2020 the appellant attended some group wellbeing sessions.(h)On 21 January 2020 the appellant attended an interview with US authorities for potential resettlement in the US.(i)At 4.19 pm on 21 January 2020 the appellant made what the parties agreed constituted a request under s 198(1) of the Act. The request was contained in an email that he sent to a departmental officer which said (in part) “pull out my case from fucking slavery process, take me back to PNG”.(j)The parties agreed that no steps were taken until 16 February 2021 to give effect to the appellant’s request to return to PNG.(k)On 10 February 2020 the appellant made an oral request to be removed to Somalia. This request was referred to the relevant “removals team” in the Department but was withdrawn on 19 February.(l)A state of emergency was declared in PNG on 23 March 2020 in response to the COVID-19 pandemic.(m)On 2 June 2020 the appellant made what is referred to as a further request for removal to PNG. He did this by submitting a “detainee request form” which referred to the earlier request and said “please … consider my request”. This precipitated some correspondence but, as noted above, nothing was done to give effect to the request until February of the following year.(n)On 22 January 2021 the appellant filed his originating application.(o)On 16 February 2021 the Department requested approval from PNG to return the appellant. In principle approval was received on 25 February 2021 and clarification was sought regarding quarantine and entry requirements on 2 March 2021.(p)On 12 March 2021, the Department proposed to return the appellant to PNG on 23 March and informed PNG authorities that he had been assessed as fit to travel without an escort. He was transferred to Brisbane, and a flight to Port Moresby and a hotel room (for the purpose of COVID-19 quarantine) were booked. However, on 20 March 2021 PNG authorities suggested that his return be delayed until further notice for reasons related to the COVID-19 outbreak in that country.(q)A direction under s 198AD(5) of the Act was made on 25 March 2021 directing officers to take unauthorised maritime arrivals to PNG in prescribed circumstances, and otherwise to take such persons to Nauru. The next day, the Department began the process of taking the appellant to Nauru. However, the appellant sought injunctive relief to prevent his removal to Nauru. On 29 March 2021 the respondents gave an undertaking not to take any steps to remove the appellant to Nauru before that application was resolved. The attempt to take the appellant to Nauru was never revived.(r)Steps to take the appellant back to PNG began again on 20 April 2021. On that day PNG’s Chief Migration Officer approved his return. On 21 April the Department proposed to return the appellant on 13 May. However, approval was not received from PNG’s State of Emergency Controller until 3 June. (s)Following that approval a statement of identity was obtained; the appellant was assessed by a registered nurse as fit for travel; and flights, an escort and a hotel room were booked for the appellant to travel to Port Moresby on 21 June 2021.(t)However, on 17 June 2021 the appellant refused to undertake a COVID-19 test. He refused again on 18 June. As a result, the arrangements for his removal on 21 June were cancelled.(u)On 8 July 2021 the appellant was approved for resettlement in the US. He departed Australia for the US on 11 August 2021.(v)The appellant was attending appointments with mental health practitioners up to at least 4 June 2021. On 10 March 2021 the Department sought an opinion from an MOC as to whether the appellant still needed to be in Australia for the temporary purpose for which he had been brought from PNG. Neither the agreed facts nor the material before this Court included any response to that request. However, before this time, in an email of 16 February 2021 (discussed below at [46]-[47]), officers appear to have been proceeding on the understanding that the temporary purpose for which the appellant had been brought to Australia was “complete”.The issues before the primary judge

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

During the period in which the appellant was detained, s 198AD provided as follows.(1)Subject to sections 198AE, 198AF and 198AG, this section applies to an unauthorised maritime arrival who is detained under section 189.Note: For when this section applies to a transitory person, see section 198AH.(2)An officer must, as soon as reasonably practicable, take an unauthorised maritime arrival to whom this section applies from Australia to a regional processing country.(2A)However, subsection (2) does not apply in relation to a person who is an unauthorised maritime arrival only because of subsection 5AA(1A) or (1AA) if the person’s parent mentioned in the relevant subsection entered Australia before 13 August 2012.Note 1:Under subsection 5AA(1A) or (1AA) a person born in Australia or in a regional processing country may be an unauthorised maritime arrival in some circumstances.Note 2:This section does not apply in relation to a person who entered Australia by sea before 13 August 2012: see the Migration Legislation Amendment (Regional Processing and Other Measures) Act 2012.Powers of an officer(3)For the purposes of subsection (2) and without limiting that subsection, an officer may do any or all of the following things within or outside Australia:(a) place the unauthorised maritime arrival on a vehicle or vessel;(b) restrain the unauthorised maritime arrival on a vehicle or vessel;(c) remove the unauthorised maritime arrival from: (i)the place at which the unauthorised maritime arrival is detained; or(ii)a vehicle or vessel;(d) use such force as is necessary and reasonable.(4)If, in the course of taking an unauthorised maritime arrival to a regional processing country, an officer considers that it is necessary to return the unauthorised maritime arrival to Australia:(a)subsection (3) applies until the unauthorised maritime arrival is returned to Australia; and(b)section 42 does not apply in relation to the unauthorised maritime arrival’s return to Australia.Ministerial direction(5)If there are 2 or more regional processing countries, the Minister must, in writing, direct an officer to take an unauthorised maritime arrival, or a class of unauthorised maritime arrivals, under subsection (2) to the regional processing country specified by the Minister in the direction.(6)If the Minister gives an officer a direction under subsection (5), the officer must comply with the direction.(7)The duty under subsection (5) may only be performed by the Minister personally.(8)The only condition for the performance of the duty under subsection (5) is that the Minister thinks that it is in the public interest to direct the officer to take an unauthorised maritime arrival, or a class of unauthorised maritime arrivals, under subsection (2) to the regional processing country specified by the Minister in the direction.(9)The rules of natural justice do not apply to the performance of the duty under subsection (5).(10) A direction under subsection (5) is not a legislative instrument.Not in immigration detention(11)An unauthorised maritime arrival who is being dealt with under subsection (3) is taken not to be in immigration detention (as defined in subsection 5(1)).Meaning of officer(12)In this section, officer means an officer within the meaning of section 5, and includes a member of the Australian Defence Force.