Sydney Water Corporation v Turano

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read

HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

FRENCH CJ,
GUMMOW, HAYNE, CRENNAN AND BELL JJ

SYDNEY WATER CORPORATION  APPELLANT

AND

MARIA TURANO & ANOR  RESPONDENTS

Sydney Water Corporation v Turano [2009] HCA 42
13 October 2009
S104/2009

ORDER

1.     Leave to file the amended notice of appeal dated 9 July 2009 granted.

2.     Appeal allowed.

3.Set aside the following orders of the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of New South Wales:

(a)     orders 4, 6, and 8 of the orders made on 31 October 2008;

(b)that part of order 5 of the orders made on 31 October 2008 which set aside orders and declarations stated at [155] of the judgment of Delaney DCJ numbered 2 and 3; and

(c)     order 1 of the orders made on 2 July 2009.

In lieu thereof, order that the cross-appeal to the Court of Appeal be dismissed with costs.

4.     First respondent to pay the costs of the appellant in this Court.

On appeal from the Supreme Court of New South Wales

Representation

J T Gleeson SC with N J Owens for the appellant (instructed by DLA Phillips Fox Lawyers)

B M Toomey QC with M J McAuley and E G Romaniuk for the first respondent (instructed by Paul A Curtis & Co)

Submitting appearance for the second respondent

Notice:  This copy of the Court's Reasons for Judgment is subject to formal revision prior to publication in the Commonwealth Law Reports.

  1. On 18 November 2001 Mr Napoleone Turano sustained fatal injuries when a eucalyptus tree fell onto the car that he was driving.  His wife, Mrs Turano (the first respondent), and their two children were travelling in the car at the time and each sustained injury in the incident.  Mrs Turano brought proceedings in negligence in the District Court of New South Wales on her own behalf and on behalf of the two children against the second respondent, the Council of the City of Liverpool ("the Council"), and the appellant, Sydney Water Corporation ("Sydney Water"), claiming damages for physical and psychological injury and for loss of dependency.

  2. The liability of the defendants was determined as a separate issue by the primary judge (Delaney DCJ).  His Honour found that the Council was liable in negligence, directing a verdict for Mrs Turano, and that Sydney Water was not liable, directing a verdict for Sydney Water.  He considered that in the circumstances Sydney Water did not owe a duty of care for the benefit of Mrs Turano.  Cross-claims brought by the Council and Sydney Water against each other were dismissed.

  3. The Council appealed to the New South Wales Court of Appeal against the primary judge's order and Mrs Turano cross-appealed against the dismissal of her claim against Sydney Water.  It was not clear whether the trial of the separate issue had been confined to the determination of the defendants' liability to Mrs Turano only, or to Mrs Turano and the two children.  The Council and Sydney Water each stated that it considered itself bound in all three cases…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sydney Water Corporation v Turano and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] HCA 42
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of Australia heard an appeal from the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of New South Wales concerning the liability of Sydney Water Corporation. The dispute arose from a fatal storm in 2001 when a roadside tree fell onto a vehicle, causing death and injury to its occupants. The plaintiffs alleged that Sydney Water's installation of a water main in 1981 had altered subsoil drainage, compromising the tree's root system and leading to its eventual collapse. Sydney Water had not relied on section 43A of the Civil Liability Act 2002 (NSW) regarding the exercise of special statutory powers.

The central legal issues before the High Court were whether Sydney Water owed a duty of care to the occupants of the vehicle and, if so, whether the death and injuries sustained were a reasonably foreseeable consequence of the installation of the water main approximately 20 years prior. The court was required to consider the significance of the temporal gap between the alleged negligent conduct and the occurrence of the injury, as well as Sydney Water's lack of control over the tree during the intervening period.

The High Court allowed Sydney Water's appeal, finding that it did not owe a duty of care to the injured parties. The court reasoned that injury to road users as a result of the tree's collapse was not a reasonably foreseeable consequence of laying the water main. Alternatively, the court concluded that in the absence of control over any risk posed by the tree in the years following the installation, there was not a sufficiently close and direct connection between Sydney Water and the injured persons for Sydney Water to be considered a "neighbour" in the sense contemplated by the principle of negligence. The court noted that while the water main's installation altered drainage and may have affected the tree's health, the risk of collapse and subsequent injury was too remote and attenuated by the passage of time and the intervening lack of control.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Leave to file the amended notice of appeal dated 9 July 2009 granted.

2. Appeal allowed.

3. Set aside the following orders of the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of New South Wales:

(a) orders 4, 6, and 8 of the orders made on 31 October 2008;

(b) that part of order 5 of the orders made on 31 October 2008 which set aside orders and declarations stated at [155] of the judgment of Delaney DCJ numbered 2 and 3; and

(c) order 1 of the orders made on 2 July 2009.

In lieu thereof, order that the cross-appeal to the Court of Appeal be dismissed with costs.

4. First respondent to pay the costs of the appellant in this Court.

Background

Background to the litigation

It should be added that at the trial Sydney Water did not lead any evidence of its financial or other resources, so as to raise the operation of s 42 of the CLA with respect to its liability to Mrs Turano. Section 42 lays out certain principles respecting resources and responsibilities of public authorities, which apply in determining the existence or breach of a duty of care. The facts of the case The evidence at trial largely comprised expert opinion. The Court of Appeal was critical of the primary judge's failure to analyse aspects of the evidence and to record findings in these respects[32]. Each of the Justices reviewed the evidence. Justices Beazley and Hodgson were in agreement as to the factual findings and the legal conclusions that flowed from them. Justice McColl came to a different conclusion on critical questions of fact. It is sufficient to refer to the primary judge's unchallenged findings of fact and to the further findings of the majority in the Court of Appeal in order to demonstrate that Sydney Water did not owe a duty of care to Mrs Turano and accordingly that the appeal should be allowed. [32]Liverpool City Council v Turano (2008) 164 LGERA 16 at 52-53 [220] per Beazley JA, 56 [236] per Hodgson JA, 64 [278] per McColl JA. Edmondson Avenue, Austral, runs in a generally north/south direction. It is located in a semi-rural area. On either side of the sealed road surface is a grassed shoulder forming part of the road reserve. The tree was standing on the western grassed shoulder, about 4 metres from the western outlet of a culvert. The culvert had been installed under Edmondson Avenue in the 1960s and was designed to drain water from east to west. Water flowing from the culvert pipe on the western side drained into an outlet pit and from there it had been designed to drain by means of a scalloped area of excavation (a "tail-out drain") to pasture land lying to the west. In about 1981 Sydney Water laid the water main, a cast iron pipe, 900mm below ground in a trench which ran parallel to Edmondson Avenue, under the western grassed shoulder. The water main transversed the outlet pit of the culvert. It was laid at a higher level than the invert of the culvert pipe and this caused it to obstruct the free flow of water from the culvert pipe. The earth of the outlet pit was impermeable clay. The water main was laid on a bed of sand 300mm deep. The sand that was laid in the trench was much more permeable than the clay of the outlet pit. One consequence of this difference was that the trench acted as a drain for the water that periodically collected in the outlet pit. It was probable that excess water reached the roots of the tree by travelling north along the sand-filled trench[33]. [33]Liverpool City Council v Turano (2008) 164 LGERA 16 at 51-52 [214] per Beazley JA. On the day of the accident there was a strong windstorm, which was the immediate cause of the tree's fall. An underlying cause of the fall was that the tree's root system had been compromised by the presence of phytophthera, a root pathogen. The intermittent water-logging of the root system had facilitated the introduction of the pathogen[34]. [34]Liverpool City Council v Turano (2008) 164 LGERA 16 at 51-52 [214] per Beazley JA.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

FRENCH CJ, GUMMOW, HAYNE, CRENNAN AND BELL JJ
Nonetheless, it was necessary in considering the liability of Sydney Water to take into account that, in the years between the installation of the water main and Mrs Turano's injury, the risk of the tree's collapse was one over which the Council and not Sydney Water had control. It is true that the Council was not on notice that the water main was laid in a sand-filled trench. However, it would not be right to characterise Sydney Water as having created a hidden danger by the installation of the water main in this location. Its presence transversing the outlet pit was observable. The adverse impact on vegetation brought about by altered drainage might be expected to be apparent to the owner of land. The circumstance that the presence of the pathogen in the tree was not readily observable does not provide a justification for holding Sydney Water liable after an interval of 20 years for the injury occasioned by the tree's failure.Conclusion Sydney Water's conduct in laying the water main in this location in 1981 with the consequential alteration to drainage flows from the culvert and any foreseeable risk to the health of the tree did not impose on it a legal duty of care for Mrs Turano's benefit. The reason for this may be expressed as a conclusion that injury to road users as the result of the tree's eventual collapse was not a reasonably foreseeable consequence of laying the water main, as the primary judge held. Alternatively, it may be expressed as a conclusion that in the absence of control over any risk posed by the tree in the years after the installation of the water main there was not a sufficiently close and direct connection between Sydney Water and Mrs Turano, a person present on Edmondson Avenue in 2001, for her to be a "neighbour" within Lord Atkin's statement of the principle.Orders The appeal should be allowed and the following orders made[62]:[62]In his judgment, delivered on 2 May 2007, Delaney DCJ set out declarations and orders in numbered sub-paragraphs (par [155]). These orders were entered on 22 May 2007. The numbering of the orders entered on that date differs from the numbering set out in par [155] of the judgment. The orders of the Court of Appeal made on 31 October 2008 are expressed by reference to the "orders and declarations stated at [155] of the judgment of Delaney DCJ". Order 3(b) made by this Court reflects this circumstance. 1.Leave to file the amended notice of appeal dated 9 July 2009 granted. 2.Appeal allowed. 3.Set aside the following orders of the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of New South Wales:(a)orders 4, 6, and 8 of the orders made on 31 October 2008;(b)that part of order 5 of the orders made on 31 October 2008 which set aside orders and declarations stated at [155] of the judgment of Delaney DCJ numbered 2 and 3; and (c) order 1 of the orders made on 2 July 2009.In lieu thereof, order that the cross-appeal to the Court of Appeal be dismissed with costs. 4. First respondent to pay the costs of the appellant in this Court.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: FRENCH CJ, GUMMOW, HAYNE, CRENNAN AND BELL JJ

Full text does not contain this section.