Buchwald v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection

Link copied
Case Copied 47 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Buchwald v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2016] FCA 101

File number: VID 726 of 2014
Judge: BROMBERG J
Date of judgment: 16 February 2016
Catchwords: MIGRATION – application for review of Minister’s decision under s 501 Migration Act to cancel applicant’s visa – whether Minister erred by ignoring relevant material or making finding based on no evidence in assessment of seriousness of applicant’s offending (ground 1) – whether Minister erred by relying on irrelevant (and ignoring relevant) material or by failing to make decision based on most-current material available in relation to applicant’s criminal record (ground 2) – as to ground 1, Minister’s finding not constitutive of jurisdictional error – consideration of whether “no evidence” ground of review must relate to jurisdictional fact – as to ground 2, applicant not denied possibility of successful outcome even if jurisdictional error established – consideration of whether document constructively before Minister – discussion of what are “relevant considerations” for s 501 Migration Act – jurisdictional error not established – application dismissed  
Legislation: Migration Act 1958 (Cth) ss 501(2), (6), (7)
Cases cited:

Australian Postal Corporation v D’Rozario (2014) 222 FCR 303

Ayoub v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2015) 231 FCR 513

Buchwald v the Queen [2011] VSCA 445

Buchwald v the Queen [2012] HCASL 181

Gbojueh v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2015] FCAFC 43

Gbojueh v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (2012) 202 FCR 417

Lu v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs (2004) 141 FCR 346

Minister for Aboriginal Affairs v Peko-Wallsend Limited (1986) 162 CLR 24

Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v SZIAI (2009) 83 ALJR 1123

Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v SZMDS (2010) 240 CLR 611

Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v SZRKT (2013) 212 FCR 99

Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Yusuf (2001) 206 CLR 323

Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs v SGLB (2004) 78 ALJR 992

Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs v Huynh (2004) 139 FCR 505

Moana v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2015) 230 FCR 367

Plaintiff M70/2011 v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (2011) 244 CLR 144

Plaintiff S156/2013 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2014) 254 CLR 28

SFGB v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs (2003) 77 ALD 402

SZNBX v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (2009) 112 ALD 475

SZNKV v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (2010) 118 ALD 232

SZSSC v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2014) 317 ALR 365

Te Puke v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2015) 230 FCR 499

Television Capricornia Pty Ltd v Australian Broadcasting Tribunal (1986) 13 FCR 511

VAAD v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural & Indigenous Affairs [2005] FCAFC 117

Videto v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1985) 8 FCR 167

VKAC v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural & Indigenous Affairs [2005] FCA 974

Date of hearing: 10 September 2015
Registry: Victoria
Division: General
National Practice…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Buchwald v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] FCA 101
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Buchwald v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection, the applicant, Mr Buchwald, challenged the Minister's decision to cancel his visa under s 501(2) of the Migration Act. The key issues before the court were whether the Minister erred by ignoring relevant material or making a finding based on no evidence in assessing the seriousness of Mr Buchwald's offending and the risk he posed to the Australian community, and whether the Minister erred by relying on irrelevant material and failing to make his decision based on the most-current material available concerning the applicant's criminal record.

The court found that the Minister's finding regarding the victim's injuries was not an error of law and did not constitute jurisdictional error. The court considered whether the "no evidence" ground of review must relate to a jurisdictional fact and concluded that it did not in this case. Regarding the second ground, the court determined that even if there was a jurisdictional error, Mr Buchwald was not denied the possibility of a successful outcome. The court discussed what constitutes "relevant considerations" for s 501 of the Migration Act and concluded that a jurisdictional error was not established. Consequently, the application was dismissed.

The final orders of the court were that the application be dismissed, and that the applicant file and serve any submissions in relation to the costs of the application by 1 March 2016. If the applicant filed such submissions, the respondent would have until 8 March 2016 to file their own submissions. If no submissions were filed, the applicant would pay the respondent's costs of the application.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application be dismissed.

2. On or before 1 March 2016, the applicant file and serve any submission in relation to the costs of the application, and any affidavits in support.

3. If the applicant files and serves any submission in relation to costs pursuant to Order 2, then on or before 8 March 2016 the respondent file and serve any submission in relation to the costs of the application, and any affidavits in support.

4. Should no submission as to costs be made pursuant to Order 2, the applicant pay the respondent’s costs of the application.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

For reasons that follow, I am not satisfied that the Minister erred in either of the ways contended for by Mr Buchwald.BACKGROUNDMr Buchwald’s offending In early 2008 Mr Buchwald set in motion a plan the intended consequence of which was that his then girlfriend of two years (whom I shall refer to as Ms W) would marry him. That plan involved kidnapping Ms W but creating the appearance that the kidnapping had been perpetrated by other persons. In February 2008, under the guise of taking Ms W out for a picnic, Mr Buchwald drove with her to his parents’ farm near Boolarra. He stopped the car, ostensibly to investigate some oddity involving a dead deer. When he returned to the car he was disguised and wearing a balaclava. He hogtied and blindfolded Ms W, placed her in the rear of the vehicle, and drove with her (whilst she remained restrained in that manner) for six hours to the Alpine National Park. He did not speak during the journey, so as to ensure that Ms W would not recognise his voice. Having arrived, Mr Buchwald commenced to dig several holes while Ms W remained blindfolded and bound. He cut off all of her clothes with a knife. Ms W believed her kidnapper intended to rape and murder her, and bury her in a hole that he was preparing. He then cut off his own clothing, removed Ms W’s blindfold and untied her, and pretended that he, too, had been kidnapped. Having collected foodstuffs and other items that he had earlier left in the area, they went into the bush. There they remained for a period of days. During that period, Mr Buchwald asked Ms W to marry him and asked her for sex, but she rebuffed him. Ultimately, they were found by a farmer and taken to Buchan. Mr Buchwald told the police that he had been kidnapped. After some investigation, Mr Buchwald was charged with the kidnapping. Consequently he was also charged with having made a false report to police, being the report that he had been kidnapped when, in truth, he had not. On 17 August 2009, Mr Buchwald was convicted of one count of kidnapping and one count of making a false report to police. His bail was extended. While on bail, he absconded. On 18 September 2009 he was sentenced by Judge Smallwood of the County Court of Victoria, in absentia, to 90 months’ imprisonment for the kidnapping and 6 months’ imprisonment for the false report (3 months of which to be served concurrently with the kidnapping sentence). Two days earlier, on 16 September 2009, Mr Buchwald had departed Australia on a false Indian passport, and travelled to India. The falsity of his passport was detected and he was returned to Australia. He was charged with, and pleaded guilty to, a count of failing to answer bail and a count of using a false passport. On 21 October 2009, Judge Smallwood sentenced Mr Buchwald to 6 months’ imprisonment for his failure to answer bail. Some years later, on 21 September 2011, he was sentenced for his use of a false passport. An appeal against conviction and sentence in regard to the kidnapping and false report offences was refused: Buchwald v the Queen [2011] VSCA 445. Special leave to appeal the Court of Appeal’s decision was refused: Buchwald v the Queen [2012] HCASL 181.The cancellation decision

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

There was no issue that Mr Buchwald had been sentenced to a term of imprisonment of 12 months or more. It was equally uncontroversial that he therefore had a “substantial criminal record” for the purpose of s 501(6), and thus that he did not pass the character test. That enlivened the Minister’s discretion to cancel Mr Buchwald’s visa. The Minister’s Statement of Reasons deals substantially with the exercise of that discretion, and it is in relation to that exercise of discretion that both grounds arise.GROUND 1: IGNORING RELEVANT MATERIAL / NO EVIDENCE Ground 1, in full, is this:1. The Minister erred in law by:a. failing to address the merits of the applicant’s case; orb.failing to give proper and genuine consideration to the risk of harm to the Australian community; orc.making a legally unreasonable or irrational decision;by ignoring relevant material, or making a finding based on no evidence, in his assessment of the seriousness of the applicant’s offending and the risk the applicant posed to the Australian community.Particularsi.The Issues Paper provided to the Minister indicated at paragraph [33] that the victim’s injuries included ‘permanent injury to the nerves on her neck and back’, and the Minister found at paragraph [18] of his reasons that the victim suffered ‘permanent injury to the nerves on her neck and back’.ii.There was no evidence to support the finding of [sic] that a ‘permanent injury to the nerves’ was sustained by the victim.iii.The Minister ignored material that characterised the victim’s physical injuries as temporary, in particular Judge Smallwood’s 18 September 2009 sentencing remarks, which noted at [33] that ‘her greatest injury, in her mind, was to her back and neck, that nerves were damaged in her neck where she struggled with good circulation for nearly a year afterwards’. As is apparent, this ground focuses on the Minister’s findings as to the nature of Ms W’s injuries. This ground was advanced on three basis, reflecting what Wigney J said in Te Puke v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2015) 230 FCR 499 at [60]–[61] and [73]. As they will be referred to for various propositions in what follows, those paragraphs will be set out in full:[60]Difficult questions may arise concerning how far it is possible to take the broad statement by the majority in Huynh that the Minister is not bound to consider “specific factors, personal to the visa holder”. There is no doubt, for example, that the Minister is not free to entirely disregard the particular circumstances of the visa-holder. As pointed out in NBMZ v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2014) 220 FCR 1 at [26] (Allsop CJ and Katzmann J) and [153] (Buchanan J) and NBNB v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2014) 220 FCR 44 at [123] (Buchanan J; Allsop CJ and Katzmann J agreeing at [7]), it is not permissible to put to one side, or fail to address, the merits of a particular visa-holder’s case; see also Khan v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1987) 14 ALD 291; Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v SZJSS (2010) 243 CLR 164 at [26].[61]It does not follow, however, that the Minister is bound, in the Peko-Wallsend administrative law sense, to take into account every or any particular facts or factors personal to the visa-holder that might be relevant to the exercise of the s 501(2) discretion in the particular circumstances of the case. It is ultimately up to the Minister to decide, in the light of the matters put before him (or her), what facts are relevant and what weight should be given to them. In some cases, a failure by the Minister to take into account certain facts concerning the offence or offences committed by the visa-holder may indicate error on the Minister’s part. It may, for example, indicate that the Minister failed to address at all the merits of the visa-holder’s case, or failed to give proper and genuine consideration to the risk of harm in the particular circumstances, or even made a legally unreasonable or irrational decision. That will depend on the particular facts and circumstances of the case and the particular fact or facts that it is alleged the Minister ignored. The point is, however, that the error in such a case is best addressed in these terms, rather than as a failure to take into account a mandatory consideration.…[73]There may equally also be cases where the failure by the Minister to consider the risk of the person re-offending might indicate error. The preferable approach in such cases, however, would not be to ask whether the failure to consider that matter amounted to a failure to have regard to a mandatory relevant consideration. Rather, the question in such a case would be whether, in the particular circumstances and context of the case, the failure to consider the likelihood of the visa-holder re-offending reveals that the Minister failed to consider or decide the visa-holder’s case on its individual merits, or failed to give proper or genuine consideration to the risk of harm posed by the visa-holder’s continuing presence in Australia, or misunderstood the correct approach to the assessment of the risk of harm, or otherwise made a legally unreasonable decision.(emphasis added)

Decision

Reasons for decision

An appeal against conviction and sentence in regard to the kidnapping and false report offences was refused: Buchwald v the Queen [2011] VSCA 445. Special leave to appeal the Court of Appeal’s decision was refused: Buchwald v the Queen [2012] HCASL 181.The cancellation decision While Mr Buchwald was still incarcerated, by letter dated 30 November 2009 addressed to the Department of Immigration, Mr Buchwald asked that the Department “inform [him] how the Department of Immigration views [his] case, and whether or not [his] visa will be cancelled once [he is] released from custody … .” It appears that the Department replied that it was too early to decide his case. He wrote again, by letter dated 9 January 2012, listing certain items that he asked be taken into consideration. It appears that he was again told that it was still too early to make a decision. By letter dated 2 April 2014, Mr Buchwald once more wrote to the Department providing further information that he considered was relevant to any decision concerning cancellation of his visa. He indicated that he could provide certain documentary evidence, in the event it would be of assistance in determination of his case. A further letter dated 28 May 2014 said that Mr Buchwald had not received a reply to his previous letter. It seems he enclosed that earlier letter as an attachment and re-iterated his offer to provide supporting documentation should that be of assistance. By letter dated 20 June 2014, the Department of Immigration and Border Protection (Department) informed Mr Buchwald that consideration was being given to cancelling his visa under s 501(2) of the Migration Act. Mr Buchwald was invited to comment. There were various enclosures to that letter, including a copy of the sentencing remarks of Judge Smallwood dated 18 September 2009 (September 2009 remarks), and a copy of the sentencing remarks of Judge Smallwood dated 21 September 2011 (September 2011 remarks). Judge Smallwood’s sentencing remarks dated 21 October 2009, in regard to the failure to appear charge (October 2009 remarks), were not enclosed. Mr Buchwald replied by letter dated 2 July 2014. His letter enclosed a “Personal Details Form,” letters from his mother and stepfather describing what would be the impact upon them of his deportation, letters of offer of employment, various references he evidently procured subsequent to his arrest for the kidnapping charge, certificates and other documentation evidencing the training and educational courses he had completed during his incarceration, and documents showing his involvement in other constructive activities. The Department came into possession of a Prisoner Report of Corrections Victoria dated 11 July 2014, and of an Australian National Police certificate dated 8 July 2014, both in relation to Mr Buchwald. The Department provided each to Mr Buchwald, under cover of letters dated 11 July 2014 and 14 July 2014 respectively, inviting comment. Mr Buchwald replied by letter dated 22 July 2014. Further correspondence then passed between the Department, Mr Buchwald, and his mother, by letter and email. None of that last-mentioned correspondence is relevant to the disposition of this matter.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

By his application dated 3 December 2014, Mr Buchwald sought an order in the nature of certiorari setting aside the Minister’s decision. The Minister’s decision was made under subsection 501(2) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (Migration Act). That provision permits the cancellation of a visa where the Minister reasonably suspects that the visa-holder does not pass “the character test,” and the visa holder fails to satisfy the Minister that the visa holder passes “the character test”. As a result of Mr Buchwald’s “substantial criminal record,” the Minister was not satisfied that Mr Buchwald passed the character test. By his amended originating application dated 31 July 2015, Mr Buchwald advanced two grounds, which he summarised in written submissions as follows: first, that the Minister erred by ignoring relevant material or making a finding based on no evidence in his assessment of the seriousness of Mr Buchwald’s offending and the risk that Mr Buchwald posed to the Australian community; and, second, that he erred by relying on irrelevant (and ignoring relevant) material and failing to make his decision on the basis of the most-current material available in relation to the applicant’s complete criminal record. For reasons that follow, I am not satisfied that the Minister erred in either of the ways contended for by Mr Buchwald.BACKGROUNDMr Buchwald’s offending In early 2008 Mr Buchwald set in motion a plan the intended consequence of which was that his then girlfriend of two years (whom I shall refer to as Ms W) would marry him. That plan involved kidnapping Ms W but creating the appearance that the kidnapping had been perpetrated by other persons. In February 2008, under the guise of taking Ms W out for a picnic, Mr Buchwald drove with her to his parents’ farm near Boolarra. He stopped the car, ostensibly to investigate some oddity involving a dead deer. When he returned to the car he was disguised and wearing a balaclava. He hogtied and blindfolded Ms W, placed her in the rear of the vehicle, and drove with her (whilst she remained restrained in that manner) for six hours to the Alpine National Park. He did not speak during the journey, so as to ensure that Ms W would not recognise his voice. Having arrived, Mr Buchwald commenced to dig several holes while Ms W remained blindfolded and bound. He cut off all of her clothes with a knife. Ms W believed her kidnapper intended to rape and murder her, and bury her in a hole that he was preparing. He then cut off his own clothing, removed Ms W’s blindfold and untied her, and pretended that he, too, had been kidnapped. Having collected foodstuffs and other items that he had earlier left in the area, they went into the bush. There they remained for a period of days. During that period, Mr Buchwald asked Ms W to marry him and asked her for sex, but she rebuffed him. Ultimately, they were found by a farmer and taken to Buchan. Mr Buchwald told the police that he had been kidnapped. After some investigation, Mr Buchwald was charged with the kidnapping. Consequently he was also charged with having made a false report to police, being the report that he had been kidnapped when, in truth, he had not.