Re Michael; Ex parte Epic Energy (WA) Nominees Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 81 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

TITLE OF COURT  :   THE FULL COURT (WA)

CITATION:   RE DR KEN MICHAEL AM; EX PARTE EPIC ENERGY (WA) NOMINEES PTY LTD & ANOR [2002] WASCA 231

CORAM:   MALCOLM CJ

ANDERSON J
PARKER J

HEARD:   21-28 NOVEMBER 2001

DELIVERED          :   23 AUGUST 2002

FILE NO/S:   CIV 2166 of 2001

MATTER                :An application for a writ of certiorari, a writ of prohibition and a writ of mandamus against Dr Ken Michael AM, the Independent Gas Pipelines Access Regulator in Western Australia

EX PARTE

EPIC ENERGY (WA) NOMINEES PTY LTD (ACN 081 609 289)
First Applicant

EPIC ENERGY (WA) TRANSMISSION PTY LTD (ACN 081 609 190)
Second Applicant
 

Catchwords:

Administrative law - Certiorari, prohibition, mandamus, declaratory relief - Third party access to natural gas pipeline - Assessment for approval by Regulator of proposed access arrangement - Whether Regulator misconceived duty and failed to perform statutory function - Whether Regulator misconstrued Access Code, failed to consider relevant matters, considered irrelevant matters, made findings unsupported by evidence - Declaratory relief granted

Administrative law - Certiorari - "Draft decision" - Detailed statutory stages for decision - Whether application premature - Whether rights sufficiently affected

Statutory interpretation - Tariff for use of gas pipeline by third parties - Owner purchased pipeline before Access Code applied to pipeline - Pipeline purchased from State agency - Purchase by public tender - Whether purchase price relevant to establishment of capital base for calculation of tariff - National Third Party Access Code, 1997, s 2.24(a), s 8.1, s 8.10 and s 8.11

Statutory interpretation - Regulator "must take" into account several factors including owner's "legitimate business interests and investment" in pipeline - Whether factors must be given weight as fundamental elements in decision whether to approve - National Third Party Access Code, 1997, s 2.24

Statutory Interpretation - Access Code stipulates factors to be taken into account by Regulator in assessing whether Access Arrangement satisfies principles in s 3.1 - s 3.20 - By s 3.4 compliance with principles in s8 required - Whether stipulated factors to be taken into account in assessing compliance with s 8 - Whether s 8 self-contained "Code" - National Third Party Access Code, 1997, s 2.24, s 3.4, s 8

Statutory Interpretation - Design of tariff for use of gas pipeline by third parties - Statutory objective that "efficient" costs be recovered - Whether imports notion of "economic efficiency"

Statutory objective of "not distorting investment decisions" in pipeline systems - Whether includes investments made before Access Code applied to a pipeline - National Third Party Access Code, 1997, s 8.1(a), s 8.1(d)

Legislation:

Gas Pipelines Access (Western Australia) Act 1998

National Third party Access Code for Natural Gas Pipeline Systems 1997

Result:

Declarations granted

Category:    A

Representation:

Counsel:

First Applicant              :     Mr C L Zelestis QC & Mr G H Murphy & Mr J A Thompson

Second Applicant          :     Mr C L Zelestis QC & Mr G H Murphy & Mr J A…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Re Michael; Ex parte Epic Energy (WA) Nominees Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] WASCA 231
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this case, Epic Energy (WA) Nominees Pty Ltd sought certiorari, prohibition, mandamus and declaratory relief against the Independent Gas Pipelines Access Regulator in Western Australia. The Regulator had declined to approve an access arrangement proposed by Epic Energy for a natural gas pipeline. The court was required to determine whether the Regulator misconceived his duty and failed to perform his statutory function, whether he misconstrued the Access Code, failed to consider relevant matters, considered irrelevant matters, and made findings unsupported by evidence. Additionally, the court had to decide whether the application for certiorari was premature and whether the applicants' rights were sufficiently affected.

The court found that the Regulator misconceived his duty and failed to perform his statutory function by misconstruing the Access Code, failing to consider relevant matters, considering irrelevant matters, and making findings unsupported by evidence. The court held that the factors in s 8.10(a) to (k) of the Code were required to be given weight as fundamental elements in the establishment of the initial Capital Base for the Pipeline. The court also found that the application for certiorari was not premature and that the applicants' rights were sufficiently affected. The court granted declaratory relief in accordance with the views of the court and reflected the conclusion reached in the principal decision.

The court made a declaration to the effect that: "The factors in s 8.10(a) to (k) are relevant to, and are to be given weight as fundamental elements in, the establishment of the initial Capital Base for the Pipeline." Additionally, the court made two further declarations concerning the interpretation of the Code, which were intended to provide additional and more specific guidance to the Regulator as he revisited his assessment of the applicants' proposed Access Arrangement. The court held that it was open to it to make such declarations, but that the appropriateness of doing so at that stage of the process in which the Regulator was engaged was in issue.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

ANDERSON J
JUDGMENT OF THE COURT: Reasons for decision were delivered in this matter on 23 August 2002. Supplementary submissions were heard on 28 November 2002 concerning the precise form of the declaratory relief which should be granted and the question of costs. These supplementary reasons deal with those issues. At par 223 of the reasons for decision six declarations were proposed by the Court. Subject to minor drafting matters there is no issue raised by the parties about these six declarations. The reasons foreshadowed, however, that the parties might identify further matters which were so critical in this case as to warrant a specific declaration. The Independent Gas Pipelines Access Regulator in Western Australia ("the Regulator") has proposed that there should be three additional declarations. AlintaGas Limited and AlintaGas Sales Pty Ltd (the "Alinta parties") propose an additional declaration, substantially in similar terms to one of the three proposed by the Regulator. The applicants are opposed to each of these proposals. The six declarations identified in the reasons dealt in various ways with actual errors of significance which had been identified in the draft decision of the Regulator. The additional declaration which is proposed by both the Regulator and the Alinta parties concerns s 8.10 of the National Third Party Access Code for Natural Gas Pipeline Systems (the "Code") and would be to the effect that:"The factors in s 8.10(a) to (k) are relevant to, and are to be given weight as fundamental elements in, the establishment of the initial Capital Base for the Pipeline." Such a declaration is in accordance with the views of the Court and reflects the conclusion reached in the principal decision at par 56. It was a live issue between the parties whether on its true interpretation the factors in s 8.10(a) to (k) were required to be given weight as fundamental elements. Some of the six declarations proposed by the Court dealt with other aspects of the factors in s 8.10. Another of them deals with the factors in s 2.24(a) to (g) of the Code. We accept that in the absence of this proposed further declaration there is some potential for confusion arising from the declaration with respect to the factors in s 2.24(a) to (g). There is sufficient justification, therefore, for a declaration as proposed by the Regulator and the Alinta parties. The other two declarations sought by the Regulator each concern the interpretation of the Code. However, rather than being directed to an error of the Regulator in his draft decision, the object of these two further declarations appears essentially to provide additional and more specific guidance to the Regulator as he revisits his assessment of the applicants' proposed Access Arrangement, pursuant to the decision of this Court and the further requirements of the Code. We accept that it would be open to the Court to make declarations dealing with the proposed two additional subject matters. The appropriateness of doing so at this stage of the process in which the Regulator is engaged is in issue.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: ANDERSON J

However, as Sackville J observed in Singh v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2001] FCA 389 at [54] the expression "have regard to" is capable of different meanings, depending on its context, and" … can simply mean to give consideration to something (Shorter Oxford English Dictionary). In this sense a direction to a decision-maker to have regard to certain factors may require him or her merely to consider them, rather than treat them as fundamental elements in the decision-making process."In that case, the learned Judge was persuaded that the requirement in s 54(1) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) that the Minister, in determining a visa application, must have regard to all the information in the application, did not require the Minister to take into account the information in the application as a fundamental element in the decision-making process because at [57]:"It could hardly have been contemplated by the drafters that every piece of information selected for mention by an applicant, no matter how marginal its relevance to the issues to be determined, must be treated by the decision-maker as a 'fundamental element' in making the determination."In this context, Alinta relied on Rathborne v Abel (1964) 38 ALJR 293 where the issue was whether, in the determination of the fair rent of prescribed premises under the Landlord and Tenant (Amendment) Act 1948-1961 (NSW), the current capital value of the premises might properly be taken into account even though this was not among a list of matters that by s 21(1) the Board was "to have regard to", and even though it was regarded by the members of the Court as "truly material to the fairness of a determination", per Kitto J at 301. As is apparent from the reasons of Barwick CJ at 295 there was a marked contrast between earlier legislation which for this purpose prescribed what his Honour described as almost a mechanical process of calculation, and the scheme of the 1948 Act which was to give a wide discretion "doing no more than to require the Tribunal, the Board, 'to have regard to' a number of matters, which include 'the justice and merits of the case' and 'the circumstances and conduct of the parties'". The generality of such matters and the breadth of discretion which they contemplated, together with the contrast with the previous legislation, were clearly factors which persuaded the Court that the specified matters were not intended implicitly to exclude a factor which was truly material or necessarily central to the legislative task in question. The decision in Rathborne v Able is strongly influenced by the particular statutory scheme which had a "rather different scope and purpose" from the present Code, to borrow the words and view expressed by Gummow J of Rathborne v Able in Australian Capital Television Pty Ltd v Minister for Transport and Communications & Ors (1989) 86 ALR 119 at 145. In that case, in the context of s 94M(1) of the Broadcasting Act 1942 (Cth), in respect of the matters which the Minister was required "to have regard to" when considering whether or not to approve a television license, Gummow J was persuaded that the matters specified were required to be taken into account by the Minister and to be given weight as fundamental elements in his decision. His Honour reached a similar view of the requirement in the Schedule to the Health Insurance Act 1973 (Cth) that the Minister's Advisory Committee "shall have regard to" certain matters when undertaking a general or fee review in Queensland Medical Laboratory & Ors v Blewett & Ors (supra) at 623.