Telstra Corporation Ltd v Seven Cable Television Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 68 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Telstra Corporation Ltd v Seven Cable Television Pty Ltd [2000] FCA 1160

TRADE PRACTICES – telecommunications – promotion of competition in relation to analogue cable television services – facilitation of access under Part XIC of Trade Practices Act 1974 – specification of eligible services by Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (“ACCC”) pursuant to transitional legislation – whether invalid by reference to elements purportedly specified – effect of invalidity – whether void ab initio – later declaration by ACCC of services pursuant to s 152AL of the Trade Practises Act – whether earlier specification if valid was deemed a declaration under s 152AL – whether could co-exist with later declaration of services dealing with same subject matter – whether revocation of earlier declaration necessary

TRADE PRACTICES – telecommunications – declaration of listed services by ACCC pursuant to s 152AL of Trade Practices Act – ACCC required to have regard to extent declaration likely to result in achievement of objective of promotion of competition in markets for listed services – whether required to define relevant market – whether took into account irrelevant considerations or did not take into account relevant considerations – whether no evidence for findings – extent of judicial review of ACCC

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – JUDICIAL REVIEW - appeal from review of administrative decision – determination by ACCC in relation to promotion of competition – relevance of expert evidence to reviewing judge – whether failure to take into account relevant considerations – alleged taking account of irrelevant considerations – alleged predetermination – alleged error of law – whether no evidence to support conclusions – whether sought impermissible review of merits

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – effect of invalidity of determination – whether void ab initio – co-existence of declarations where one is a deemed exercise of other power – whether can be later declaration if earlier declaration in existence

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – expert economic evidence – admissibility – trail judge discretion – relevance to judicial review of ACCC findings

Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth)
Telecommunications Act 1997 (Cth)
Telecommunications (Transitional Provisions and Consequential Amendments) Act 1997 (Cth)
Acts Interpretation Act 1901(Cth)
Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 (Cth)
Telecommunications Act 1997 (Cth)
Trade Practices Amendment (Telecommunications) Act 1997(Cth)
Broadcasting Services Act 1992 (Cth)

Ousley v R (1997-8) 192 CLR 69
Collector of Customs (NSW) v Brian Lawlor Automotive Pty Ltd (1979) 2 ALD 1
Calvin v Carr [1980] AC 574
Hoffman Laroche v Trade Secretary [1975] AC 295
Reg v Wilks [1998] AC 92
Forbes v New South Wales Trotting Club Ltd (1979) 143 CLR 242
South Australia v The Commonwealth (1942) 65 CLR 373
GJ Coles v Retail Trade Industry Tribunal (1987) 7 NSWLR 503
Re Governor; ex parte Eastman (1999) 73 ALJR 1324
Rail Access Corporation v NSW Mineral Council Ltd (1998) 87 FCR 517
Hammersley Iron Pty Ltd v National Competition Council (1999) 164 ALR 203
In re Sydney International Airport [2000] ACompT 1

Price v Elder [2000] FCA 133
Foster v…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Telstra Corporation Ltd v Seven Cable Television Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] FCA 1160
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Telstra Corporation Ltd v Seven Cable Television Pty Ltd, the primary dispute revolved around the validity of certain declarations and statements made by the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) under the Telecommunications Act 1997 (Cth). The court was required to determine whether these declarations and statements were legally sound and if they correctly identified services that should be subject to the competition regime. The case involved several appeals by Foxtel against the decisions of the Australian Competition Tribunal and the Federal Court, questioning the validity of a 1997 Deeming Statement and a 1999 Declaration concerning analogue subscription television broadcast carriage services.

The central legal issues included whether the ACCC's publication of the Deeming Statement in the Gazette complied with statutory requirements, the interpretation and certainty of the Deeming Statement, and the validity of the 1999 Declaration. Specifically, the court examined if the omission of a full copy of the Deeming Statement in the Gazette rendered it invalid, whether the Deeming Statement was uncertain due to its reference to optional adjunct services, and if the Declaration correctly identified services to be subject to the competition regime. The court also had to assess if the Deeming Statement and Declaration aligned with legislative objectives, such as promoting competition and efficient use of infrastructure.

The court, in its reasoning, held that while the ACCC did not strictly comply with the requirement to publish a full copy of the Deeming Statement in the Gazette, this non-compliance did not invalidate the statement as it was intended to take effect immediately upon its making. However, the court found that the Deeming Statement was uncertain because it specified a service of variable content, which did not comply with the requirement for certainty. Consequently, the Deeming Statement was declared void. Regarding the 1999 Declaration, the court found it to be valid as it correctly identified the analogue subscription television broadcast carriage service and aligned with the legislative objectives.

The final orders of the court dismissed most of the appeals and cross-appeals, with specific rulings on the validity of the Deeming Statement and the Declaration. The court declared the 1997 Deeming Statement void while affirming the validity of the 1999 Declaration. Costs orders varied across the appeals, with some parties ordered to bear their own costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. In appeal N 527 of 2000, the appeal is dismissed, with costs.

2. In each of the appeals N 508 of 2000 and N 529 of 2000:-

(a) The appeal is allowed in part, with no order as to costs. It is ordered that orders 1 and 3 made at first instance on 8 May 2000 be set aside; and that, in lieu thereof, it be declared that the Deeming Statement dated 30 June 1997 is void; and that there be no order for the costs of proceedings N 1095 of 1999 – at first instance. Appeal otherwise dismissed, with costs.

(b) The cross-appeal is dismissed, with no order as to costs.

3. In appeal N 528 of 2000, the appeal, and the cross-appeal, are dismissed, with no order as to costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Section 152AG provides that a person is taken to be an “access seeker”, in relation to a declared service, if three conditions are fulfilled. First, the person must be a “service provider”. Secondly, the person must wish to have access to that service, or to change their existing access arrangements (s 152AG(3)). Thirdly, the person wishing to have access, or to change access arrangements must have requested, or must propose to request, access to the service under s 152AR of the TPA (s 152AG(2)). Section 152AC of the TPA provides that the term “service provider” has the same meaning as in the TEA (s 86); that is, either a “carriage service provider”, or a “content service provider” (see ss 87 and 97).(2)The background – the ACCC Report As noted, the Declaration took effect on its gazettal on 8 September 1999. It was made in accordance with a report by the ACCC dated August 1999 (“the Report”). It will be recalled that the service was declared in these terms:“The Analogue Subscription Television Broadcast Carriage Service is:A service for the carriage, by means of lines, of analogue signals used for the purposes of transmitting a subscription television service from a facility owned, controlled or operated by a carrier or carriage service provider to any point on, or in, a line link, customer cabling, or customer equipment connected to that facility.” His Honour noted (para 144) that this declaration contrasted with the Deeming Statement in two significant respects:“(a)it is confined to a service for transmitting a subscription television service; that is, it does not include a free-to-air service; and(b)it does not include reference to any of the three optional adjunct services described in Attachment B of the 1997 deeming statement.” Wilcox J added (para 144):“However, the declaration covers a service extending to any one of several end-points: ranging from a point on the line link leading to the end-user’s premises to the end-user’s television set. This means it not only covers that portion of the line link owned by Telstra Multimedia (the HFC cable) but, at least potentially, facilities owned by subscription television providers like FOXTEL and C & W Optus.” It will be necessary to refer to some of the contents of the Report. The Report commenced (Ch 1):“Following consideration of the information received over the course of the inquiry, the Commission proposes to declare an analogue-specific subscription television service limited to line links.The Commission expects that declaration will influence the development of competition for subscription television services, primarily in those areas where a subscription television service using line links is currently operating.Declaration of the subscription television service enables service providers to reach end users in order to deliver a wider range of services than currently available, and reduces the need for full duplication of communications networks.The Commission expects that declaration of subscription television services will promote competition and provide end-users with the ability to choose between different suppliers of subscription television program packages, particularly in areas of niche programming.”

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

It will be convenient to refer to the issues thus raised in the sequence adopted by his Honour.(4) His Honour’s conclusions(a)Did the publication in the Gazette comply with s 39(9) and if not, did this invalidate the Deeming Statement? His Honour said (para 69) that the ACCC failed to comply with s 39(9): “what was published was not a copy of the whole statement – that is, all 80 pages – but only a summary of it”. However, Wilcox J held (para 79) that gazettal of the statement was not a condition precedent to its operation. Rather, Parliament’s intention was that the statement would take effect immediately it was made. It followed, his Honour held (para 81), that the omission to comply with s 39(9) did not invalidate the statement.(b)Could reference be made to Attachment B in considering the meaning and operation of the Deeming Statement in the context of the argument that the Deeming Statement was uncertain? Wilcox J held (para 88) that the complaint of uncertainty should be evaluated in the light of the whole of the Deeming Statement, including the Attachments.(c)Was Attachment B uncertain? Wilcox J said (para 96):“Specification of a service must require identification of the service, although not necessarily of the provider of the service. ACCC did this when, in Attachment B, it referred to ‘an analogue service supplied by an (access provider), necessary for the purposes of enabling the supply by an (access seeker) of a broadcasting service by means of line links that deliver signals to end-users, and of a kind that was used for those purposes on 13 September 1996’. The nature of that service was further explained in section 1 of Attachment B, headed ‘Distribution Access Function’. Technical information was set out in Attachment A. Particularly in the light of that material, it cannot be said there is any uncertainty about the ACCC’s intention in relation to the basic distribution service.” Moreover, his Honour held (para 98), there was no uncertainty about the nature of the optional adjunct services described, i.e. the network management access function, the conditional access function and the subscriber premises servicing function.(d)Did the reference to the optional adjunct services made in the context of a description of a single service render the Deeming Statement uncertain? His Honour said (para 101):“If the statement is seen as a specification of a single service, it is uncertain as to content. A reader of the statement would not be able to determine, in advance of a particular request, what must be provided by an access provider to an access seeker.” Wilcox J went on to hold (para 101) that the requirements of s 39(5) “cannot be discharged by specifying, as a single eligible service, a service of variable content. It must be remembered that, while the request for the adjunct services is optional, from the access seeker’s point of view, from the viewpoint of the access provider, supply is compulsory”.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In determining whether a particular thing promotes the LTIE, regard must be had to the extent to which the thing is likely to result in the achievement of specified objectives, including the objective of promoting competition in markets for listed services (s 152AB(2)(c)), and encouraging the economically efficient use of, and economically efficient investment in, the infrastructure by which listed services are supplied (s 152AB(2)(e)).(a) The Declaration made in September 1999 The Declaration which is the subject of the proceeding, and which took effect on 8 September 1999, declared that the Analogue Subscription Television Broadcast Carriage Service there described is a “declared service” for the purposes of Part XIC of the TPA. The service is there described as follows:“The Analogue Subscription Television Broadcast Carriage Service is:A service for the carriage, by means of lines, of analogue signals used for the purposes of transmitting a subscription television service from a facility owned, controlled or operated by a carrier or carriage service provider to any point on, or in, a line link, customer cabling, or customer equipment connected to that facility.Examples of this service are the delivery of analogue signals used for the purposes of transmitting a subscription television service to:(a)an end-user’s television set;(b)conditional-access customer equipment of an end-user, or potential end-user, of a subscription television service;(c)a wall socket at the premises of an end-user, or potential end-user, of a subscription television service;(d)a point on a line link from which a lead-in connection may be run to the premises of an end-user, or potential end-user, of a subscription television service …” Thus the purported effect of the Declaration was to subject analogue subscription television broadcast carriage services to the statutory competition regime. In this matter Wilcox J rejected FOXTEL’s challenge, and made a declaratory order that the Declaration was valid. FOXTEL now appeals from this order.(b) The Deeming Statement made in June 1997 In the second proceeding (N 1150 of 1995 (on appeal N 528 of 2000)), FOXTEL challenged the validity of a decision of the ACCC being a statement “Deeming” certain “Telecommunications Services” to be “declared services” (“the Deeming Statement”). It was made on 30 June 1997 under s 39 of the Telecommunications (Transitional Provisions and Consequential Amendments) Act 1997 (Cth) (“the Transitional Act”). Section 39 relevantly provides:“(1)As soon as practicable after this section commences, but, in any event, before 1 July 1997, the ACCC must prepare a written statement specifying [certain matters not material here].…(5)The ACCC must also specify in the statement an eligible service that is:(a)necessary for the purposes of enabling the supply of a broadcasting service by means of line links that deliver signals to end-users; and(b)of a kind that was used for those purposes on 13 September 1996.…(7)The ACCC must consult AUSTEL [the Australian Telecommunications Authority] about the preparation or variation of the statement.(8)The ACCC must not prepare or vary the statement unless the ACCC has first:(a)published a draft of the statement or variation and invited people to make submissions to the ACCC on the draft; and(b)considered any submissions that were received within the time limit specified by the ACCC when it published the draft.(9)A copy of the statement, and of any variation of the statement, is to be published in the Gazette.(10)Part XIC of the [TPA] has effect, in relation to an eligible service specified in the statement, as if the ACCC had:(a)made an instrument under subsection 152AL(3) of the Act declaring the service to be a declared service; and(b)complied with the requirements set out in subsection 152AL(3) of that Act in relation to the instrument.(11)This section does not prevent the instrument referred to in paragraph 10(a) from being varied or revoked by the ACCC in accordance with section 152AO of the [TPA].”