Queensland North Australia Pty Ltd v Takeovers Panel

Link copied
Case Copied 73 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Queensland North Australia Pty Ltd v Takeovers Panel [2014] FCA 591

Citation: Queensland North Australia Pty Ltd v Takeovers Panel [2014] FCA 591
Parties: QUEENSLAND NORTH AUSTRALIA PTY LTD (ACN 146 828 122), CLOSERIDGE PTY LTD (ACN 010 560 157) and CLIVE FREDERICK PALMER v TAKEOVERS PANEL, THE PRESIDENT’S CLUB LIMITED (ACN 010 593 263), PRESIDENT, TAKEOVERS PANEL and AUSTRALIAN SECURITIES AND INVESTMENTS COMMISSION
File number: QUD 526 of 2012
Judge: COLLIER J
Date of judgment: 5 June 2014
Catchwords:

CORPORATIONS – first applicant acquired control of company holding 41.4% of voting shares in second respondent – application to the Takeovers Panel seeking declaration of unacceptable circumstances – s 657A and s 657C(2) Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) – alleged breaches of ss 606, 631(1) and 633(1) Corporations Act – Takeovers Panel declared circumstances unacceptable – regard to effect of circumstances on control of second respondent company and acquisition of a substantial interest in the second respondent company – orders by Takeovers Panel restricting exercise of voting rights by applicants, acquisition and disposal of shares in second respondent – whether s 657A circumstances can be ongoing – deed poll restricted holding company’s exercise of voting rights attached to shares in the second respondent – whether acquisition of holding company constituted an increase in voting power of first applicant – s 606 and s 610 Corporations Act – constitution of second respondent company contemplated each holder of share parcel also holding associated one-quarter interest in a villa property – whether evidence to support finding that shares and interest in villa properties stapled – whether orders of Takeovers Panel ensured takeover bid proceeds in way it would have if circumstances had not occurred – s 657D(2) Corporations Act

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – judicial review of decision of Takeovers Panel in relation to first applicant’s acquisition of interest in second respondent – s 5 Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 (Cth) – declaration of unacceptable circumstances under s 657A Corporations Act – no notice of intention to extend time – extension of time granted in alternative – whether breach of natural justice by Takeovers Panel in granting extension of time for application – primary finding that circumstances ongoing and application made in-time – whether Takeovers Panel erred in law in construing s 657B(a) Corporations Act as referring to continuing circumstances – whether circumstances can be ongoing – whether Takeovers Panel made decision to extend time in absence of evidence to justify doing so – whether Takeovers Panel erred in finding first applicant’s acquisition of holding company breached s 606 Corporations Act – whether evidence to support findings of Takeovers Panel – whether declaration an improper exercise of power – whether Takeovers Panel took into account irrelevant considerations – whether Takeovers Panel stated conclusions without setting out evidence on which findings based – whether orders made by Takeovers Panel constituted Wednesbury unreasonableness – whether Takeovers Panel denied natural justice in making orders affecting third applicant director of first applicant – President of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Queensland North Australia Pty Ltd v Takeovers Panel and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] FCA 591
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Queensland North Australia Pty Ltd v Takeovers Panel involved an application by The President’s Club Ltd, an unlisted public company, against the Takeovers Panel, seeking a declaration of unacceptable circumstances under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). The President’s Club alleged that Queensland North Australia Pty Ltd (QNA) had breached several sections of the Corporations Act, including sections 606, 631(1), and 633(1), due to QNA’s acquisition of a significant interest in the company and subsequent conduct. The Takeovers Panel had declared the circumstances unacceptable and issued orders restricting QNA’s voting rights and acquisition and disposal of shares. The legal issues before the court included whether the circumstances declared by the Panel could be ongoing, whether QNA’s acquisition constituted an increase in voting power, and whether the Panel’s orders ensured the takeover bid proceeded as if the unacceptable circumstances had not occurred.

The court found that the Panel's decision to declare the circumstances unacceptable was lawful and that the orders made by the Panel were within its powers. The court examined whether the Panel had erred in its interpretation of the Corporations Act and found that the Panel had correctly applied the statutory provisions. The court also considered whether the Panel had breached natural justice by extending the time for making the application and found no such breach. The court upheld the Panel’s finding that the circumstances were ongoing and that QNA’s acquisition breached section 606. The evidence supported the Panel’s conclusions, and the court found that the orders made by the Panel were not Wednesbury unreasonable. The court also dismissed the argument that the Panel had an apprehension of bias due to a conflict of interest involving one of its members.

The final orders of the court were to dismiss the application and to award costs against the applicants. The court held that the applicants were responsible for the costs of the first, second, third, and fourth respondents of and incidental to the proceeding.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application be dismissed.

2. The costs of the first, second, third and fourth respondents of and incidental to this proceeding are to be paid by the applicants.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The background facts to this application are outlined in the Reasons for Decision of the Panel in The President’s Club Ltd [2012] ATP 10 published on 24 August 2012, and expanded in submissions of the applicants. It is useful to summarise those facts before turning to the grounds of review before the Court.BACKGROUNDShareholdings and offers The President’s Club is an unlisted public company. Its capital is divided into 7,488 ordinary shares and five subscriber shares. The subscriber shares are irrelevant to this case. The President’s Club operates a time share scheme at the property previously known as the Hyatt Regency Coolum but now known as the Palmer Coolum Resort (“the resort”). The President’s Club is the tenant under two leases, both dated 21 December 1988 and each for a term of 80 years over all the lots in The President’s Club Golf Community Titles Scheme and The President’s Club Tennis Community Titles Scheme (“community titles schemes”). The constitution of The President’s Club contemplated that each holder of ordinary shares in the company would hold one or more parcels of 13 ordinary shares, and would own an associated one-quarter interest as tenant in common in a lot (“a Villa Interest”) in either of the community titles schemes. The effect of a set of interlocking agreements was that a purchaser of one timeshare interest must become both:·a member of The President’s Club, holding 13 shares; and·the registered proprietor of a corresponding one-quarter interest in either of the community titles schemes. Purchasers of timeshare interests were also required to execute:·a deed poll, binding them, if they sold their Villa Interest, to sell the corresponding shares in The President’s Club to the same person; and·an assignment of a letting pool agreement, under which their Villa Interest was made available with others as part of a pool. At all material times Lion Holdings was the sole shareholder of Coeur de Lion Investments (“Lion Investments”), which in turn owns 3107 or 41.4% of the shares in The President’s Club. Helpfully, the applicant tendered a diagram explaining the share structure of relevant entities, as follows: On 31 January 2005 ASIC exercised its powers pursuant to s 601QA(1)(a) of the Corporations Act to conditionally exempt The President’s Club and Lion Investments from registration as a managed investment scheme under Ch 5 of the Corporations Act. The exemption was provided on the basis that Lion Investments entered into a deed poll (“the deed poll”) whereby Lion Investments covenanted that it would not exercise more than 10% of its voting rights on any resolution other than:·in circumstances consented to in writing by ASIC; or·in relation to a resolution to wind up the scheme. Clause 4.2 of the deed poll allowed Lion Investments to revoke the deed poll upon providing to ASIC and The President’s Club at least 180 days prior written notice. In July 2011 QNA acquired 98% of the shares in Lion Holdings from Lend Lease. The remaining 2% of shares were acquired by the second applicant, Closeridge Pty Ltd (“Closeridge”). Both QNA and Closeridge are companies associated with the third applicant, Mr Palmer.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Final orders sought by The President’s Club were that:·QNA and its associates be restrained from voting more than 20% of The President’s Club;·QNA proceed with its takeover bid for The President’s Club on terms no less favourable than in the original bidder’s statement;·QNA raise the offer price per share to $1.00 per share and the price per Villa Interest to $65,000, being the highest price paid in the preceding 4 months; and·QNA remedy the information deficiencies in a second replacement bidder’s statement.Decision of the Panel The Panel observed that ongoing circumstances in the nature of contraventions of the Corporations Act were alleged in the application before it, or alternatively that the Panel had extended the time for making the application to the date on which it was made by The President’s Club (that is 26 June 2012). The Panel decided to conduct proceedings. In a detailed decision the Panel decided, in summary, that the circumstances of the acquisition of shares in The President’s Club in July 2011 were unacceptable having regard to:·The effect the circumstances had, were having, will have or were likely to have on:othe control, or potential control, of The President’s Club; orothe acquisition, or proposed acquisition, by a person of a substantial interest in The President’s Club; and·The purposes of Ch 6 as set out in s 602 of the Corporations Act; and·The fact that they constituted, constitute, will constitute or were likely to constitute a contravention of a provision of Ch 6. Section 602 of the Corporations Act provides:602 Purposes of ChapterThe purposes of this Chapter are to ensure that:(a) the acquisition of control over:(i)the voting shares in a listed company, or an unlisted company with more than 50 members; or(ii) the voting shares in a listed body; or(iii) the voting interests in a listed managed investment scheme;takes place in an efficient, competitive and informed market; and(b)the holders of the shares or interests, and the directors of the company or body or the responsible entity for the scheme:(i)know the identity of any person who proposes to acquire a substantial interest in the company, body or scheme; and(ii) have a reasonable time to consider the proposal; and(iii)are given enough information to enable them to assess the merits of the proposal; and(c)as far as practicable, the holders of the relevant class of voting shares or interests all have a reasonable and equal opportunity to participate in any benefits accruing to the holders through any proposal under which a person would acquire a substantial interest in the company, body or scheme; and(d)an appropriate procedure is followed as a preliminary to compulsory acquisition of voting shares or interests or any other kind of securities under Part 6A.1.Note 1: To achieve the objectives referred to in paragraphs (a), (b) and (c), the prohibition in section 606 and the exceptions to it refer to interests in “voting shares”. To achieve the objective in paragraph (d), the provisions that deal with the takeover procedure refer more broadly to interests in “securities”.Note 2: Subsection 92(3) defines securities for the purposes of this Chapter.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

No further replacement bidder’s statement had been provided as of 26 June 2012 when The President’s Club lodged an application with the Panel for a declaration of unacceptable circumstances pursuant to s 657A and s 657C(2) of the Corporations Act.Application to the Panel by The President’s Club for declaration of unacceptable circumstances In its application to the Panel The President’s Club contended (in summary) that:·QNA appeared to have breached and continued to be in breach of s 606 of the Corporations Act. Inter alia, s 606 prohibits transactions which result in someone’s voting power in a defined company increasing from below 20% to above 20%, or increases from a starting point that is above 20% and below 90%.·The circumstances giving rise to a breach of s 606 first occurred when QNA acquired an initial 41.1% interest in The President’s Club through QNA’s acquisition of Lion Holdings in or about July 2011. QNA continued to hold a relevant interest in The President’s Club in excess of 20% without qualifying for an exemption under s 611.·QNA (together with its associates) had not lodged a bidder’s statement which complied with the minimum bid price principle set out in s 621(3) of the Corporations Act. Section 621(3) requires the bidder to pay all shareholders no less than it paid for shares during the four months before the date of the bid.·The bidder’s statement was materially deficient in that it included material which was misleading and/or confusing, and omitted information that shareholders of The President’s Club and their professional advisers would reasonably require to make an informed assessment of QNA’s offer. These deficiencies included:oan absence of disclosure of QNA’s breach of s 606 of the Corporations Act and the possible effects of this on QNA and The President’s Club;omisleading disclosure in relation to the revocation of the ASIC exemption;odeficient disclosure in relation to the funding of the offer;odeficient disclosure in relation to compliance with the resort administration agreement and QNA’s intentions for The President’s Club; andodeficient disclosure in relation to the net asset value of shares in The President’s Club and the comparative value of the offer.·QNA appeared to have breached and continued to breach s 631(1) and s 633(1) of the Corporations Act by not lodging a complying bid within the time limits of the Corporations Act. Under s 631(1) it is an offence for a person who has publicly proposed to make a takeover not to proceed with offers within two months of that proposal. Circumstances relevant to breach of s 631(1) first occurred on or about 12 June 2012 when QNA failed to lodge a complying bid within two months of making a public proposal to make a takeover bid. Further, s 633(1) sets out the steps required of a bidder in order to make an effective off-market bid. Circumstances relevant to breach of s 633(1) first occurred on or about 7 June 2012 when QNA failed to dispatch a complying bidder’s statement to shareholders of The President’s Club as required by s 633(1).