Howards Storage World Pty Ltd v Haviv Holdings Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 46 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Howards Storage World Pty Ltd v Haviv Holdings Pty Ltd [2010] FCAFC 5

Citation: Howards Storage World Pty Ltd v Haviv Holdings Pty Ltd [2010] FCAFC 5
Appeal from: Haviv Holdings Pty Limited v Howards Storage World Pty Limited (No 2) [2009] FCA 652
Parties: HOWARDS STORAGE WORLD PTY LTD (ACN 094 719 490), PLAZA HOME-IMPORTS PTY LTD (ACN 069 891 201) and DIRK SPENCE v HAVIV HOLDINGS PTY LIMITED (ACN 101 265 730) and PAUL AGHION
File number: NSD 665 of 2009
Judges: GRAY, LINDGREN AND EDMONDS JJ
Date of judgment: 8 February 2010
Catchwords:

COSTS – multiple claims – where applicant succeeded on only one claim – whether costs should follow the event – whether it was appropriate to apply the “rule of thumb” to apportion costs between the parties – the award of costs is in the discretion of the Court – no error has been identified in the manner in which costs were awarded.

Held: the appeal be dismissed.

Legislation:

Trade Practices Act1974 (Cth)

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 43(2)

Cases cited:

Currabubula Holdings Pty Ltd v State Bank of New South Wales [2000] NSWSC 232 considered
Dansk Rekylriffel Syndikat Aktieselskab v Snell [1908] 2 Ch 127 considered
Dodds Family Investments Pty Ltd (formerly Solar Tint Pty Ltd) v Lane Industries Pty Ltd (1993) 26 IPR 261 referred to
Elite Protective Personnel Pty Ltd & Anor v Salmon (No 2) [2007] NSWCA 373 referred to
House v R (1936) 55 CLR 499 applied

Haviv Holdings Pty Limited v Howards Storage World Pty Ltd (2009) 254 ALR 273 cited
Haviv Holdings Pty Limited v Howards Storage World Pty Limited (No 2) [2009] FCA 652 cited

Hughes v Western Australia Cricket Association (1986) ATPR 40-748 referred to
Jeffery & Katauskas Pty Limited v SST Consulting Pty Ltd; Jeffery & Katauskas Pty Limited v Rickard Constructions Pty Limited [2009] HCA 43 cited
Korner v H Korner & Co Ltd [1951] Ch 10 considered
Milne v Attorney General (Tas) (1956) 95 CLR 460 referred to
Oshlack v Richmond River Council (1998) 193 CLR 72 considered

Ruddock v Vadarlis (No 2) (2001) 115 FCR 229 referred to

Date of hearing: 20 November 2009
Place: Sydney
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 75
Counsel for the Appellants: Mr M Christie SC with Mr L Shipway
and Mr D Klineberg
Solicitor for the Appellants: Diamond Conway Lawyers
Counsel for the Respondents: Ms J Baird SC and Mr A Connolly
Solicitor for the Respondents: Aron I Mucsnik

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 665 of 2009

ON APPEAL FROM THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
BETWEEN:

HOWARDS STORAGE WORLD PTY LTD (ACN 094 719 490)
First Appellant

PLAZA HOME-IMPORTS PTY LTD (ACN 069 891 201)
Second Appellant

DIRK SPENCE
Third Appellant

AND:

HAVIV HOLDINGS PTY LIMITED (ACN 101 265 730)
First Respondent

PAUL AGHION
Second Respondent

JUDGES:

GRAY, LINDGREN AND EDMONDS JJ

DATE OF…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Howards Storage World Pty Ltd v Haviv Holdings Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] FCAFC 5
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Howards Storage World Pty Ltd appealed against an order as to costs made by the primary judge in the Federal Court of Australia. The substantive dispute between the parties, which was not the subject of this appeal, involved a franchise agreement between Howards Storage World Pty Ltd (HSW) and Haviv Holdings Pty Ltd (Haviv) concerning a Howards Storage World business at Burwood. Haviv claimed damages from HSW for the breach of the franchise agreement, alleging that HSW had granted a second franchise store within Haviv’s exclusive franchise territory. Haviv and Mr Aghion also claimed damages from HSW, Plaza Home-Imports Pty Ltd, and Mr Spence for misleading and deceptive conduct under the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth). The primary judge found that HSW had breached the franchise agreement by granting a second franchise store within Haviv’s exclusive franchise territory and awarded damages to Haviv. The claims under the Trade Practices Act were dismissed. The primary judge then considered the issue of costs, opting to aggregate the parties and the causes of action to view the contest as a single dispute. The judge concluded that the respondents were entitled to their costs from one or other of the applicants. The appeal was dismissed, and HSW and Plaza were ordered to pay Haviv’s costs of the appeal.

The court was required to decide whether the primary judge's approach to awarding costs was appropriate. The primary judge had aggregated the parties and the causes of action, treating the contest as a single dispute between two entities. The court considered whether this approach was justified by the relationships between the parties, their representation in the proceedings, and their involvement in the transactions. The court also assessed whether the primary judge had correctly exercised her discretion in awarding costs. The court found that the primary judge had not erred in her assessment of the costs, noting that the award of costs is within the discretion of the Court, and no error had been identified in the manner in which costs were awarded. The aggregation approach was deemed appropriate given the circumstances, and the appeal was dismissed. The appellants were ordered to pay the respondents' costs of the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be dismissed.

2. The appellants’ pay the respondents’ costs of the appeal.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

This is an appeal from a judge of this Court against orders as to costs: Haviv Holdings Pty Limited v Howards Storage World Pty Limited (No 2) [2009] FCA 652 (‘the costs judgment’). There was no appeal from the anterior judgment: Haviv Holdings Pty Limited v Howards Storage World Pty Ltd (2009) 254 ALR 273 (‘the substantive judgment’). BACKGROUND TO THE SUBSTANTIVE JUDGMENT The relevant facts are summarised in [2] – [4] of the reasons in the substantive judgment:[2] Howards Storage World is a specialty retailer of household storage items. The franchise agreement, made on 18 July 2002 between Howards Storage World Pty Ltd (HSW) (as franchisor) and Haviv Holdings Pty Limited (Haviv) (as franchisee), related to a Howards Storage World business in a store within the Westfield shopping centre at Burwood (the Burwood store). Paul Aghion is a director of Haviv and negotiated the franchise agreement on Haviv’s behalf. Plaza Home-Imports Pty Ltd (Plaza) is a company related to HSW, initially proposed to be the franchisor and subsequently responsible for the supply of products to Haviv under the franchise agreement. Dirk Spence is a director of HSW and Plaza. He is responsible for the day-to-day operations of both companies and negotiated the franchise agreement on their behalf. [3] By the franchise agreement HSW granted to Haviv an exclusive franchise territory for a radius of 5 kilometres around the Burwood store. However, in August 2004 HSW entered into another franchise agreement for a Howards Storage World business in a store within the Rhodes shopping centre (the Rhodes store). The Rhodes store, and indeed the whole of the Rhodes shopping centre, is within the exclusive franchise territory HSW granted to Haviv (the Rhodes store being between 4837 and 4843 metres from the Burwood store). Haviv vacated the Burwood store on 17 August 2007 leaving it to HSW to operate. Haviv and HSW each purported to terminate the franchise agreement in early 2008, some three years after the opening of the Rhodes store in late November 2004. [4] Haviv claimed to have suffered loss and damage by reason of HSW’s breach of the franchise agreement (the contract claims). Haviv and Mr Aghion also claimed to have suffered loss and damage by reason of two representations by HSW and Plaza allegedly in breach of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) concerning: - (i) the true position with respect to Haviv’s exclusive franchise territory, and (ii) the lack of any financial benefit to Plaza for the supply of goods to Haviv (the trade practices claims). Haviv and Mr Aghion claimed further that Mr Spence is liable as an accessory of HSW and Plaza with respect to the trade practices claims. The primary judge found that the first appellant (‘HSW’) had breached the contractual promise of an exclusive franchise territory which it gave the first respondent (‘Haviv Holdings’) in the franchise agreement by granting the franchise for, and permitting the operation of, the Rhodes store. Her Honour was satisfied that Haviv Holdings suffered loss caused by HSW’s breach of the franchise agreement. The claims made by both respondents under the Trade Practices Act1974 (Cth) (‘Trade Practices Act’) against all three appellants were not accepted by her Honour. THE COSTS JUDGMENTThe Submissions Below

Decision

Reasons for decision

The alternative approach, taken by the primary judge and supported by counsel for Haviv and Mr Aghion in this appeal, was to aggregate the parties and the causes of action, so as to view the contest in the primary proceeding as being essentially one between two entities about a single dispute (save for some subsidiary causes of action that are not of concern in this appeal).The primary judge’s reasons for judgment In the course of summarising the submissions of the respective parties, the primary judge said at [16] of her reasons for judgment of 17 June 2009:During the hearing on costs I observed that the practical effect of the respondents’ submissions is that the respondents would obtain orders entitling them to claim all of their costs from one or other of the applicants. In other words, irrespective of the circuitous route by which the outcome was achieved, the respondents were in fact claiming the usual order as to costs in their favour despite the fact that Haviv succeeded in obtaining a substantial award for damages on its claims for breach of the franchise agreement. At [18]-[19], her Honour justified the aggregation of the parties by reference to the relationships between them, their representation in the proceeding and their involvement in the transactions the subject of the proceeding. Mr Aghion is a director of Haviv and the two were represented by a single solicitor. Mr Spence is a director of Howards and Plaza, which are related companies, and all three were represented by a single solicitor. Mr Aghion and Mr Spence were the negotiators on behalf of their respective companies and the decision to grant the franchise that constituted the breach of the franchise agreement between Haviv and Howards was made by Mr Spence. At [20]-[21], her Honour justified the aggregation of the causes of action. Haviv’s claim for breach of the franchise agreement was in relation to the exclusivity of Haviv’s territory. The claims of Haviv and Mr Aghion for misleading and deceptive conduct also concerned alleged representations about Haviv’s exclusive territory. The quantum of damage claimed by Haviv against Howards for breach of the franchise agreement was the same as that claimed by Haviv and Mr Aghion against Howards and Plaza for misleading and deceptive conduct. Howards was substituted for Plaza as the franchisor after the negotiations had been completed, because of a restructure of the corporate group of which they were part. In addition, as her Honour pointed out at [22], the claims of Haviv and Mr Aghion against Mr Spence were that he was an accessory in respect of claims against Howards and Plaza under the Trade Practices Act. Further, at [24], her Honour pointed out that, because Howards ultimately admitted breach of the franchise agreement, the reasons for judgment of her Honour given on 18 March 2009 were concerned principally with assessment of damages. Her Honour did not accept all of Haviv’s case on damages. Nor did she accept Howard’s case that Haviv had suffered no loss or minimal loss. Haviv obtained a substantial order for damages.