FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Haviv Holdings Pty Limited v Howards Storage World Pty Ltd [2009] FCA 242
CONTRACTS – franchise agreement – breach of exclusive territory provision – grant of another franchise within exclusive franchise territory already granted
DAMAGES – loss arising from breach of franchise agreement – loss of net profits – causation – question of evidentiary onus – date and period of assessment – calculation – discount rate – loss of gross profits – fixed costs
TRADE PRACTICES – misleading and deceptive conduct – misrepresentations – franchise agreement – exclusive territory provision – financial benefit provision – whether reasonable grounds for making representations – whether representations misleading
Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth)
Alexander v Cambridge Credit Corporation Ltd (1987) 9 NSWLR 310
Brambles Holdings Ltd v Bathurst City Council (2001) 53 NSWLR 153; [2001] NSWCA 61
Chappel v Hart (1998) 195 CLR 232; [1998] HCA 55
The Commonwealth of Australia v Amann Aviation Pty Ltd (1991) 174 CLR 64
The Commonwealth of Australia v Silverton Ltd (1997) 130 ACTR 1
Fightvision Pty Ltd v Onisforou (1999) 47 NSWLR 473
Fink v Fink (1946) 74 CLR 127
Hadley v Baxendale (1854) 9 Exch 341; 156 ER 145
Henville v Walker (2001) 206 CLR 459; [2001] HCA 52
Johnson v Perez (1988) 166 CLR 351
Malec v JC Hutton Pty Ltd (1990) 169 CLR 638
Marks v GIO Australia Holdings Ltd (1998) 196 CLR 494; [1998] HCA 69
Murray Irrigation Ltd v Balsdon (2006) 67 NSWLR 73; [2006] NSWCA 25
Otrava Pty Ltd v Mail Boxes Etc (Australia) Pty Ltd [2004] NSWSC 1066
Reg Glass Pty Ltd v Rivers Locking Systems Pty Ltd (1968) 120 CLR 516
Rosser v Marine Ministerial Holding Corporation [1999] NSWCA 72
Sellars v Adelaide Petroleum NL (1992) 179 CLR 332
State of New South Wales v Moss (2000) 54 NSWLR 536; [2000] NSWCA 133
Tabcorp Holdings Ltd v Bowen Investments Pty Ltd 83 ALJR 390; [2009] HCA 8
Wenham v Ella (1972) 127 CLR 454Luntz, H. Assessment of Damages for Personal Injury and Death, 4th ed. Australia: LexisNexis Butterworths, 2002
Pratt, S, Reilly, R and Schweihs, R. Valuing a Business: The Analysis of Closely Held Companies, 4th ed. McGraw-Hill: United States of America, 2000
Seddon, N C and Ellinghaus, M P. Cheshire and Fifoot’s Law of Contract, 9th Australian ed. Sydney: LexisNexis Butterworths, 2008
Willis, Justin B. “Independent Experts’ Reports and Valuations”. Ch 122 in Freckelton, Ian R and Selby, Hugh. Expert Evidence. Australia: Law Book Company, 2001HAVIV HOLDINGS PTY LIMITED (ACN 101 265 730) AND PAUL AGHION v HOWARDS STORAGE WORLD PTY LTD (ACN 094 719 490), PLAZA HOME-IMPORTS PTY LTD (ACN 069 891 201) and DIRK SPENCE
NSD 523 of 2007
JAGOT J
18 MARCH 2009
SYDNEY
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY
NSD 523 of 2007
BETWEEN: HAVIV HOLDINGS PTY LIMITED (ACN 101 265 730)
First ApplicantPAUL AGHION
Second ApplicantAND:
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Haviv Holdings Pty Ltd v Howards Storage World Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2009] FCA 242
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the court included whether Haviv's "scenario 2" claim for damages was tenable on the evidence, whether Haviv had proved any loss of net profits from the Burwood store caused by the breach, and how the net lost profits should be assessed, among others. The court examined the evidence presented by expert accountants, Darel Hughes and Brendan Halligan, who used different methods to calculate the damages. HSW argued that Haviv's evidence was insufficient to prove causation and that certain assumptions made by Hughes were flawed.
In its reasoning, the court found that Haviv had indeed suffered loss due to HSW's breach of the franchise agreement. It noted that the Burwood store, despite being unprofitable in its first two years, was a long-term business proposition. The court preferred Halligan's method of calculating damages over Hughes', primarily due to the latter's flawed assumptions about the continued operation of the Burwood store post-breach and the treatment of expenses. The court determined that the damages should be assessed from 29 November 2004 until the end of the option period on 17 July 2022, using specific discount rates and a gross profit percentage. The refurbishment costs and rent were also adjusted according to the court's findings.
The court issued an order adjourning the proceedings for further directions and instructed that the exhibits may be returned. This decision highlights the importance of accurate evidence and the proper application of expert methods in calculating damages for breach of contract.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The proceedings are adjourned for further directions on a date to be allocated.
2. The exhibits may be returned.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Established by: JAGOT J
Further, I consider that the difference between the actual sales revenues of the benchmark group and the actual sales revenues of the Burwood store (Mr Halligan’s approach) is likely to be a more reliable measure of lost net profits of the Burwood store than applying a growth rate derived from the benchmark group to a hypothesised 2005 sales revenue for the Burwood store (Mr Hughes’ approach). As discussed, Mr Hughes’ baseline for the Burwood store is hypothetical rather than actual because of his assumption of continued growth throughout the 2005 financial year, contrary to the performance of his benchmark group. The dramatic negative growth rates experienced by most Sydney metropolitan HSW stores in the 12 months before June 2005 confirms that actual sales revenues are likely to be a more reliable measure of Haviv’s loss.Assumption about continued operation of the Burwood store (para 6 issue (4)) Mr Hughes’ approach, as Mr Halligan said, assumed that Haviv continued to operate the Burwood store after 17 August 2007 (the date on which Haviv vacated the store). Mr Hughes’ explanation was that, irrespective of the presentation of his calculations (which shows “actual” sales after Haviv ceased to operate the Burwood store), the basis of assessment was simply the assumed sales in 2007 increased by the average growth rate of 9.7% from the benchmark group. Apart from the fact that I have not accepted the assumed sales in 2007 (because it is based on the assumption of continued growth throughout the 2005 financial year), I accept Mr Halligan’s conclusion that, if Mr Hughes’ method is correct, the relevant comparison after 17 August 2007 is between the hypothetical sales revenues of the Burwood store and no sales revenues. This issue is not merely one of presentation because the assumption affects the treatment of expenses. Haviv ceased to earn any sales revenues after 17 August 2007 but it also ceased to pay any expenses. That fact must be taken into account. Finally, although Mr Hughes and Mr Halligan agreed on the percentages for variable expenses, Mr Hughes’ approach, as Mr Halligan pointed out, involved applying those percentages to an incorrect amount of lost sales revenues (because Haviv’s actual sales revenues from the Burwood store ceased after 17 August 2007). These considerations affect the whole approach of each expert. For the reasons given I prefer the Mr Halligan’s overall approach to that of Mr Hughes. I also accept that Mr Halligan’s approach to the actual situation after breach is unaffected by any assumptions with respect to causation (such as whether the breach caused Haviv to vacate the Burwood store); it is simply a reflection of the fact that Haviv ceased to operate the Burwood store on 17 August 2007 and thus earned no more sales revenues after that date. Only Mr Halligan’s periods of assessment are affected by his assumptions about causation, which is a different issue (and addressed at [61]-[62] below).Date of assessment of damage (para 6 (issue (5))