Haviv Holdings Pty Ltd v Howards Storage World Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 75 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Haviv Holdings Pty Limited v Howards Storage World Pty Ltd [2009] FCA 242

CONTRACTS – franchise agreement – breach of exclusive territory provision – grant of another franchise within exclusive franchise territory already granted

DAMAGES – loss arising from breach of franchise agreement – loss of net profits – causation – question of evidentiary onus – date and period of assessment – calculation – discount rate – loss of gross profits – fixed costs

TRADE PRACTICES – misleading and deceptive conduct – misrepresentations – franchise agreement – exclusive territory provision – financial benefit provision – whether reasonable grounds for making representations – whether representations misleading

Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth)

Alexander v Cambridge Credit Corporation Ltd (1987) 9 NSWLR 310
Brambles Holdings Ltd v Bathurst City Council (2001) 53 NSWLR 153; [2001] NSWCA 61
Chappel v Hart (1998) 195 CLR 232; [1998] HCA 55
The Commonwealth of Australia v Amann Aviation Pty Ltd (1991) 174 CLR 64
The Commonwealth of Australia v Silverton Ltd (1997) 130 ACTR 1
Fightvision Pty Ltd v Onisforou (1999) 47 NSWLR 473
Fink v Fink (1946) 74 CLR 127
Hadley v Baxendale (1854) 9 Exch 341; 156 ER 145
Henville v Walker (2001) 206 CLR 459; [2001] HCA 52
Johnson v Perez (1988) 166 CLR 351
Malec v JC Hutton Pty Ltd (1990) 169 CLR 638
Marks v GIO Australia Holdings Ltd (1998) 196 CLR 494; [1998] HCA 69
Murray Irrigation Ltd v Balsdon (2006) 67 NSWLR 73; [2006] NSWCA 25
Otrava Pty Ltd v Mail Boxes Etc (Australia) Pty Ltd [2004] NSWSC 1066
Reg Glass Pty Ltd v Rivers Locking Systems Pty Ltd (1968) 120 CLR 516
Rosser v Marine Ministerial Holding Corporation [1999] NSWCA 72
Sellars v Adelaide Petroleum NL (1992) 179 CLR 332
State of New South Wales v Moss (2000) 54 NSWLR 536; [2000] NSWCA 133
Tabcorp Holdings Ltd v Bowen Investments Pty Ltd 83 ALJR 390; [2009] HCA 8
Wenham v Ella (1972) 127 CLR 454

Luntz, H. Assessment of Damages for Personal Injury and Death, 4th ed. Australia: LexisNexis Butterworths, 2002
Pratt, S, Reilly, R and Schweihs, R. Valuing a Business: The Analysis of Closely Held Companies, 4th ed.  McGraw-Hill: United States of America, 2000
Seddon, N C and Ellinghaus, M P. Cheshire and Fifoot’s Law of Contract, 9th Australian ed. Sydney: LexisNexis Butterworths, 2008
Willis, Justin B. “Independent Experts’ Reports and Valuations”. Ch 122 in Freckelton, Ian R and Selby, Hugh. Expert Evidence. Australia: Law Book Company, 2001

HAVIV HOLDINGS PTY LIMITED (ACN 101 265 730) AND PAUL AGHION v HOWARDS STORAGE WORLD PTY LTD (ACN 094 719 490), PLAZA HOME-IMPORTS PTY LTD (ACN 069 891 201) and DIRK SPENCE

NSD 523 of 2007

JAGOT J
18 MARCH 2009
SYDNEY

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

NSD 523 of 2007

BETWEEN:

HAVIV HOLDINGS PTY LIMITED (ACN 101 265 730)
First Applicant

PAUL AGHION
Second Applicant

AND:
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Haviv Holdings Pty Ltd v Howards Storage World Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] FCA 242
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Haviv Holdings Pty Ltd v Howards Storage World Pty Ltd involves a dispute between the parties over damages for breach of contract and trade practices. Haviv Holdings (Haviv) claimed damages from Howards Storage World (HSW) for breach of a franchise agreement, as well as for misleading and deceptive conduct under the Australian Consumer Law. The court had to determine several issues regarding the calculation of damages for Haviv’s loss of net profits and the assessment of lost gross profit.

The legal issues before the court included whether Haviv's "scenario 2" claim for damages was tenable on the evidence, whether Haviv had proved any loss of net profits from the Burwood store caused by the breach, and how the net lost profits should be assessed, among others. The court examined the evidence presented by expert accountants, Darel Hughes and Brendan Halligan, who used different methods to calculate the damages. HSW argued that Haviv's evidence was insufficient to prove causation and that certain assumptions made by Hughes were flawed.

In its reasoning, the court found that Haviv had indeed suffered loss due to HSW's breach of the franchise agreement. It noted that the Burwood store, despite being unprofitable in its first two years, was a long-term business proposition. The court preferred Halligan's method of calculating damages over Hughes', primarily due to the latter's flawed assumptions about the continued operation of the Burwood store post-breach and the treatment of expenses. The court determined that the damages should be assessed from 29 November 2004 until the end of the option period on 17 July 2022, using specific discount rates and a gross profit percentage. The refurbishment costs and rent were also adjusted according to the court's findings.

The court issued an order adjourning the proceedings for further directions and instructed that the exhibits may be returned. This decision highlights the importance of accurate evidence and the proper application of expert methods in calculating damages for breach of contract.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The proceedings are adjourned for further directions on a date to be allocated.

2. The exhibits may be returned.

Background

Background to the litigation

Haviv Holdings Pty Ltd (Haviv) entered into a franchise agreement with Howards Storage World Pty Ltd (HSW) for the operation of a self-storage facility at Burwood. The agreement granted Haviv an exclusive franchise territory. However, HSW opened a competing facility at Rhodes within Haviv's exclusive territory, breaching the agreement. Haviv claimed damages for the breach and for contraventions of the Australian Consumer Law. Haviv proposed two scenarios for calculating damages. Under "scenario 1", Haviv claimed lost net profits from the Burwood store, while under "scenario 2", Haviv claimed it would have operated the Rhodes store instead. HSW argued that Haviv had not proved the causal link between the breach and any loss, and disputed the method for calculating lost net profits.

The case was heard in the Supreme Court of New South Wales. Prior to this hearing, expert accountants had given evidence regarding the calculation of damages under the two scenarios proposed by Haviv. This hearing considered the admissibility and weight of that evidence and the applicable legal principles. The court was tasked with determining the appropriate method for assessing damages, including the benchmark group of stores, the discount rate, the period of assessment, the gross profit percentage, and treatment of fixed costs.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Apart from Haviv’s additional allegations of breach, the contract claims ultimately raised the following issues for resolution:(1)Is Haviv’s “scenario 2” claim for damages consistent with principle and tenable on the evidence? Haviv claimed damages pursuant to two alternative scenarios – “scenario 1” and “scenario 2”. Damages under “scenario 2” are calculated by reference to the hypothesis that, but for the breach, HSW would have granted Haviv the franchise for the Rhodes store and Haviv would have operated that store instead of the Burwood store.(2)With respect to its “scenario 1” claim, has Haviv proved any loss of net profits from the operation of the Burwood store caused by the breach? Darel Hughes and Brendan Halligan (the expert accountants who gave evidence) both calculated damages for the “scenario 1” claim by comparing the net profits Haviv in fact earned from the Burwood store with the net profits it is hypothesised Haviv would have earned but for the breach. HSW submitted that, although the opening of the Rhodes store within Haviv’s exclusive franchise territory was in breach of the franchise agreement, the following circumstances disclosed a fundamental gap in Haviv’s evidence about causation:(a)the opening and operation of the Rhodes shopping centre (and all other shops within that centre, including an IKEA) within Haviv’s exclusive franchise territory was not in breach of the franchise agreement;(b)Mr Hughes and Mr Halligan agreed that their calculations assumed that there was no cause of loss other than the breach of the franchise agreement; (c)Haviv had not proved that the opening of the Rhodes shopping centre alone was not the cause of any net lost profits; and(d)before the opening of the Rhodes store, the Burwood store made a small profit in financial year 2003 ($15,000) and a small loss in financial year 2004 ($(1000)) and thus was unprofitable irrespective of the breach.(3)How should any net lost profits caused by the breach be assessed? Mr Hughes and Mr Halligan agreed that net lost profits should be assessed having regard to the sales revenues of a benchmark group of HSW stores. They disagreed about the stores to include in the benchmark group and how the benchmark group should be used. Mr Hughes included all 11 HSW stores in metropolitan Sydney as at 2007 in his benchmark group. He applied the average rate of growth of sales revenues to determine the net profits Haviv would have earned but for the breach. Mr Hughes also considered that the increase in sales revenues that the Burwood store enjoyed for the first five months of the 2005 financial year should be assumed to continue for the balance of that year but for the breach. Mr Halligan ultimately included two metropolitan Sydney stores in his benchmark group and applied the average of these sales revenues to determine net profits Haviv would have earned but for the breach. Mr Halligan considered Mr Hughes’ approach to the Burwood store’s pre-breach sales revenues inconsistent with his use of the benchmark group (which experienced a decline in sales revenues in the latter half of the 2005 financial year).(4)Does Mr Hughes’ method assume that Haviv continued to operate the Burwood store after 17 August 2007 (the date Haviv ceased operating the Burwood store) and, if so, what effect does that have on the validity of his assessment? Mr Halligan maintained that Mr Hughes’ method of assessment included an invalid assumption that Haviv continued to operate the Burwood store when, in fact, it ceased to do so on 17 August 2007. Mr Halligan said Mr Hughes’ approach was incorrect in principle, understated the lost sales revenue and undermined the application of other variables (particularly fixed and variable costs saved by the cessation of trading). Mr Hughes rejected these concerns.(5)At what date should loss be assessed? Mr Hughes’ assessment was at the date of (a notional) judgment on the basis that the breach of contract was not merely the entry into the franchise agreement for the Rhodes store but also the operation of that store within Haviv’s exclusive franchise territory. Mr Halligan’s assessment was on or about the date when the Rhodes store started trading (29 November 2004), being the date from which HSW’s breach affected Haviv’s net profits.(6)Over what period should loss be assessed? Mr Hughes and Mr Halligan both used the date the Rhodes store opened as the start of their assessment period but disagreed about the date on which the assessment should end. Mr Hughes assessed loss on two alternative bases: - (i) up to 17 July 2012, being the end of the term of the franchise agreement, and (ii) up to 17 July 2022, being the end of the term of an assumed further franchise agreement granted to Haviv pursuant to an option in the franchise agreement. Mr Halligan assessed loss on three alternative bases: - (i) up to 17 August 2007 (being the date on which Haviv vacated the Burwood store) on the assumption that this event was not caused by the breach, (ii) up to 17 July 2012, and (iii) up to 17 July 2022.(7)How should any discount rate be calculated in order to ascertain the present value of net lost profits caused by the breach? Mr Hughes adopted a discount rate of 5% for future net lost profits based on his experience in cases in which Todorovic v Waller (1981) 150 CLR 402 has been applied and noted that, in addition, courts frequently applied a further discount of 15% in such cases to account for vicissitudes or contingencies. Mr Halligan’s discount rates of 30% (past losses) and 35% (future losses) reflected the pre-tax weighted average cost of capital (pre-tax WACC) for the business, using the standard formula for that calculation (which includes the post-tax required rate of return on equity, itself determined by applying a standard formula). Using the same formulae, but different inputs (specifically, the proportions of debt capital and equity capital for the pre-tax WACC calculation and the amount of the premium for the small size of Haviv’s business in the post-tax required rate of return on equity calculation), Mr Hughes calculated a discount rate of 22%.(8)How should any discount rate be applied in order to ascertain the present value of net lost profits? Mr Hughes divided net lost profits into “past” (all net lost profits incurred before the notional judgment date) and “future” (all net lost profits to be incurred after the notional judgment date). Mr Hughes did not discount past net lost profits. Mr Halligan discounted all net lost profits back to 29 November 2004 but at one rate (30%) for those incurred before the notional judgment date and another rate (35%) after the notional judgment date.(9)What gross profit percentage should be used in order to calculate the lost gross profit? Mr Hughes and Mr Halligan both calculated lost gross profit by multiplying lost sales revenues by a gross profit percentage. However, Mr Hughes used the actual gross profit percentage of 52% for 2006 and applied that percentage to 2007 and all future years on the basis that gross profit declined in 2007 by reason of Haviv’s desire to reduce stock. Mr Halligan used the actual gross profit percentages achieved by the Burwood store for 2006 and 2007 and the average of all percentages from 2003 to 2007 for the future.(10)How should fixed costs including rent and refurbishment costs be treated? Mr Hughes and Mr Halligan approached the issue of the rent payable under the lease and fixed costs differently. They also applied different assumptions about the amount and timing of refurbishment costs. Further, Mr Hughes calculated net profits on an accruals basis whereas Mr Halligan used a cash basis (a difference which impacts refurbishment costs).

Decision

Reasons for decision

JAGOT J
Haviv criticised Mr Halligan in final submissions for adopting a partisan approach to his evidence when, as an expert, his primary duty was to assist the Court. As HSW submitted, this is a serious allegation which was never put to Mr Halligan. I do not accept that Mr Halligan (or, for that matter, Mr Hughes) did anything other than provide opinions consistent with the obligations of an expert witness. Although many differences in method between the experts remained, they prepared a useful joint report and gave evidence in concurrent session which clearly identified the nature of, and reasons for, their differences. Conclusions about contract claims I am satisfied that the evidence establishes that Haviv has suffered loss (in the form of lost net profits by reason of decreased sales revenue) caused by HSW’s admitted breach of the franchise agreement, the remedy for which is damages. I do not accept that Haviv could not have suffered loss because the Burwood store was unprofitable in its first two years of trade. The Burwood store was a long-term business proposition (albeit subject to the risks relating to the expiry of the lease and otherwise). Haviv’s rights included the exclusive franchise territory, rights associated with relocation (if the lease could not be renewed), and the option for a further franchise agreement largely at Haviv’s discretion. Mr Halligan’s method only resulted in no or minimal loss to Haviv when applied to alternatives either not supported by the evidence (specifically, that the Rhodes store could have been located elsewhere in the Rhodes shopping centre or nearby without breaching the franchise agreement) or which I have rejected (specifically, the assessment of damages over periods shorter than I consider necessary). Otherwise, Mr Halligan’s assessment disclosed a material loss to Haviv caused by the breach (described by Mr Halligan as “alternative C”). The adjustments to Mr Halligan’s calculations which are required (for the reasons given above) should result in a conclusion of increased loss. Consistent with the findings above, damages should be calculated in accordance with Mr Halligan’s method subject only to the following matters:(1)Mr Halligan’s “alternative C” period of assessment should be used (that is, damages should be assessed from 29 November 2004 until the end of the option period, being 17 July 2022).(2)The benchmark group should comprise the Hornsby, East Gardens, Macquarie and Bondi Junction stores.(3)The discount rates applied should be 28% for losses to the date of judgment and 30% for losses thereafter.(4)The rent increase should reflect the true position where known (that is, $138,490.56 per annum for seven months from 1 September 2007 and an annual rental of $187,000 from 1 April 2008 to the end of the current lease on 31 March 2013, with appropriate adjustments thereafter from that base).(5)The figure of 50.3% should be used as the gross profit percentage for the 2007 financial year onwards.(6)The refurbishment costs should be $40,000 in July 2007, $155,000 in July 2012 and $40,000 in July 2017 and subject to mid-period discounting. THE TRADE PRACTICES CLAIMSGeneral

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: JAGOT J

Further, I consider that the difference between the actual sales revenues of the benchmark group and the actual sales revenues of the Burwood store (Mr Halligan’s approach) is likely to be a more reliable measure of lost net profits of the Burwood store than applying a growth rate derived from the benchmark group to a hypothesised 2005 sales revenue for the Burwood store (Mr Hughes’ approach). As discussed, Mr Hughes’ baseline for the Burwood store is hypothetical rather than actual because of his assumption of continued growth throughout the 2005 financial year, contrary to the performance of his benchmark group. The dramatic negative growth rates experienced by most Sydney metropolitan HSW stores in the 12 months before June 2005 confirms that actual sales revenues are likely to be a more reliable measure of Haviv’s loss.Assumption about continued operation of the Burwood store (para 6 issue (4)) Mr Hughes’ approach, as Mr Halligan said, assumed that Haviv continued to operate the Burwood store after 17 August 2007 (the date on which Haviv vacated the store). Mr Hughes’ explanation was that, irrespective of the presentation of his calculations (which shows “actual” sales after Haviv ceased to operate the Burwood store), the basis of assessment was simply the assumed sales in 2007 increased by the average growth rate of 9.7% from the benchmark group. Apart from the fact that I have not accepted the assumed sales in 2007 (because it is based on the assumption of continued growth throughout the 2005 financial year), I accept Mr Halligan’s conclusion that, if Mr Hughes’ method is correct, the relevant comparison after 17 August 2007 is between the hypothetical sales revenues of the Burwood store and no sales revenues. This issue is not merely one of presentation because the assumption affects the treatment of expenses. Haviv ceased to earn any sales revenues after 17 August 2007 but it also ceased to pay any expenses. That fact must be taken into account. Finally, although Mr Hughes and Mr Halligan agreed on the percentages for variable expenses, Mr Hughes’ approach, as Mr Halligan pointed out, involved applying those percentages to an incorrect amount of lost sales revenues (because Haviv’s actual sales revenues from the Burwood store ceased after 17 August 2007). These considerations affect the whole approach of each expert. For the reasons given I prefer the Mr Halligan’s overall approach to that of Mr Hughes. I also accept that Mr Halligan’s approach to the actual situation after breach is unaffected by any assumptions with respect to causation (such as whether the breach caused Haviv to vacate the Burwood store); it is simply a reflection of the fact that Haviv ceased to operate the Burwood store on 17 August 2007 and thus earned no more sales revenues after that date. Only Mr Halligan’s periods of assessment are affected by his assumptions about causation, which is a different issue (and addressed at [61]-[62] below).Date of assessment of damage (para 6 (issue (5))