Marmax Investments Pty Ltd v RPR Maintenance Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 70 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Marmax Investments Pty Ltd v RPR Maintenance Pty Ltd [2015] FCAFC 127

Citation: Marmax Investments Pty Ltd v RPR Maintenance Pty Ltd [2015] FCAFC 127
Appeal from: RPR Maintenance Pty Ltd v Marmax Investments Pty Ltd [2014] FCA 409
RPR Maintenance Pty Ltd v Marmax Investments Pty Ltd [2014] FCA 514
File numbers: NSD 629 of 2014
NSD 632 of 2014
Parties: MARMAX INVESTMENTS PTY LTD ACN 001 147 511 v RPR MAINTENANCE PTY LTD ACN 003 610 231 and SPANLINE WEATHERSTRONG BUILDING SYSTEMS PTY LTD ACN 002 968 087 v RPR MAINTENANCE PTY LTD ACN 003 610 231
Judges: MIDDLETON, FOSTER AND GLEESON JJ
Date of judgment: 9 September 2015
Catchwords:

CONTRACTS – franchising agreements between franchisor and two franchisees – where franchisees granted franchises over adjacent territories – where franchisor gave permission to franchisee to do work in other franchisee’s territory – construction of commercial contracts – whether appellants breached express and implied terms – obligation to act in good faith – duty to cooperate – duty to do all things necessary to give other contracting party the benefit of the contract – whether respondent had exclusive rights to service all customers living in its franchise territory – whether franchisor obliged to take positive steps to prevent franchisee from servicing customers in other franchisee’s territory

DAMAGES – whether franchisor breached obligations to franchisee in relation to all of the jobs done by other franchisee in respondent’s franchise territory – whether primary judge should have applied discount for loss of opportunity  

Cases cited: Abigroup Ltd v Sandtara Pty Ltd [2002] NSWCA 45
Ansett Transport Industries (Operations) Pty Ltd v Commonwealth [1977] HCA 75; (1977) 139 CLR 54
Australian Broadcasting Corporation v Australian Performing Right Association Ltd [1973] HCA 36; (1973) 129 CLR 99
Australis Media Holdings Pty Ltd v Telstra Corporation Ltd (1998) 43 NSWLR 104
BP Refinery (Westernport) Pty Ltd v Shire of Hastings (1977) 180 CLR 266
Burger King Corporation v Hungry Jack’s Pty Ltd [2001] NSWCA 187; (2001) 69 NSWLR 558
Butt v McDonald (1896) 7 QLJ 68
Campbell v Backoffice Investments Pty Ltd [2009] HCA 25; (2009) 238 CLR 304
Central Exchange Ltd v Anaconda Nickel Ltd [2002] WASCA 94; (2002) 26 WAR 33
CGM Investments Pty Ltd v Chelliah [2003] FCA 79; (2003) 196 ALR 548
Chen v Kevin McNamara & Sons Pty Ltd [2012] VSCA 229
Commissioner of Taxation of the Commonwealth of Australia v Sara Lee Household & Body Care (Australia) Pty Ltd [2000] HCA 35; (2000) 201 CLR 520
Commonwealth Bank of Australia v Barker [2013] FCAFC 83; (2013) 214 FCR 450
Commonwealth Bank of Australia v Barker [2014] HCA 32; (2014) 253 CLR 169
DTR Nominees Pty Ltd v Mona Homes Pty Ltd [1978] HCA 12; (1978) 138 CLR 423
Esso Petroleum Pty Ltd v Southern Pacific Petroleum NL [2005] VSCA 228
Far Horizons Pty Ltd v McDonald’s Australia Ltd [2000] VSC 310
Franklins Pty Ltd…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Marmax Investments Pty Ltd v RPR Maintenance Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] FCAFC 127
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Marmax Investments Pty Ltd appealed against a decision of the Federal Court of Australia, which had ruled that Marmax had breached its contractual obligations to RPR Maintenance Pty Ltd and that Spanline, the franchisor of both Marmax and RPR, had also breached its obligations to RPR. The court was required to decide whether Marmax and Spanline had breached their respective contractual obligations with RPR, whether RPR had demonstrated that it suffered loss as a result of any breaches of contract, and whether the primary judge had correctly assessed the damages awarded to RPR. The court also needed to determine whether the primary judge should have applied a discount for loss of opportunity and whether the primary judge's findings on the exclusivity of the franchise territories were correct.

The court concluded that Marmax had not breached its contractual obligations with RPR as there was no contractual relationship between them after February 2005. Therefore, Marmax's conduct in doing work in RPR's territory between September 2007 and July 2008 did not breach the sub-franchise agreement. The court also found that Marmax's "incursions" into RPR's territory in 2007 and 2008 did not breach the transfer of business agreement between Marmax and RPR. Consequently, Marmax was not liable to pay damages to RPR. However, the court held that Spanline had breached its contractual obligations to RPR by allowing Marmax to perform work in RPR's territory, which caused RPR to lose the opportunity to secure the work performed by Marmax. The permission given by Spanline to Marmax to perform work in RPR's territory involved a breach of contract, and this breach caused RPR loss in the form of lost opportunity to earn profits.

The appeal was allowed in part, and the orders made by the Federal Court of Australia on 3 June 2014 were set aside in so far as they concerned the appellant. The parties were required to file and serve either a joint proposed minute of order or, in the event of disagreement, proposed minutes of order with short written submissions in support, reflecting the court's reasons, including as to costs. Costs were reserved, and the parties had liberty to apply. Entry of orders was dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be allowed.

2. Orders 1, 2 and 11 (in so far as they concern the appellant) made by the Federal Court of Australia on 3 June 2014 be set aside.

3. Costs be reserved.

4. Within 14 days of the date of this judgment, the parties file and serve either:

(a) a joint proposed minute of order in relation to costs; or

(b) in the event of disagreement, proposed minutes of order in relation to costs with short written submissions in support.

5. The parties have liberty to apply.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

1. The appeal be allowed in part.

2. Within 14 days of the date of this judgment, the parties file and serve either:

(a) a joint proposed minute of order; or

(b) in the event of disagreement, proposed minutes of order with short written submissions in support,

reflecting these reasons, including as to costs.

3. Costs be reserved.

4. The parties have liberty to apply.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Accordingly, Spanline succeeds in part on grounds 5, 7 and 16 and on grounds 19 and 20 of its notice of appeal.RELEVANT FACTS Through a national network of franchises and sub-franchises, Spanline designs, manufactures and sells home extensions or additions, including patios, roof awnings or covered verandas, glass and screened enclosures and carports. At all relevant times, Mr Anthony Way was the managing director of Spanline.Franchise agreements between Spanline and RPR At the relevant times, the directors of RPR were Mr and Mrs Marron. In 2001, RPR entered into a written five year franchise agreement with Spanline to conduct a business called “Spanline Home Additions South Coast” (“first RPR franchise agreement”). Under the agreement, Spanline granted to RPR “an exclusive Franchise to conduct the Franchised Business in the Territory”. The “Franchised Business” was defined to mean “the business of retail sale, installation and trade wholesales conducted by the Franchisee under this Agreement”. The “Business” was defined to include “the building of additions and improvements to residential and commercial buildings and the granting of franchises to conduct the Business”. The “Territory” was defined as “NSW South Coast Area, as per attached hatched map”. The map identified the south coast of New South Wales from just south of Campbelltown to the border with Victoria, and included an area known as the “Southern Highlands” covering the towns of Mittagong and Bowral. The first RPR franchise agreement was accompanied by a document entitled “Spanline Home Additions Disclosure Document” (“first disclosure document”). The first RPR franchise agreement was expressed to expire on 17 January 2006. There is no evidence that it was replaced with a further agreement until August 2009, when RPR and Spanline executed another written franchise agreement (“second RPR franchise agreement”). By this time, RPR had entered into the various agreements with Marmax described below. It is convenient to set out relevant terms of the second RPR franchise agreement, because the primary judge focussed his attention on that agreement when considering the proper interpretation of various agreements between the parties. Clause 2.1 of the second RPR franchise agreement provides:The Franchisor grants to the Franchisee an exclusive Franchise to conduct the Franchised Business within the granted Spanline Franchise area and also provides the rights to manufacture and wholesale and/or supply of Spanline patented products to other Spanline Franchisees throughout New South Wales … in consideration of payment by the Franchisee to the Franchisor the Franchise Fee and the other Payments on the terms of this Agreement. The phrase “granted Spanline Franchise area” was not defined. However, “Territory” was defined as “South Coast Area as per attached hatched map”. The primary judge noted that this map “excised” Marmax’s franchise area in the Illawarra (around Wollongong) from the hatched area. In other words, the “Territory” was the same as the area identified in the first RPR agreement except that it did not include Marmax’s franchise area. Although his Honour did not say so explicitly, we understand his Honour’s subsequent references to “RPR’s territory” to refer to the area identified by the map attached to the second RPR franchise agreement.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Then, there were issues concerning whether Spanline or Marmax had breached their respective contractual obligations; whether RPR had demonstrated that it suffered loss as a result of any breaches of contract by either Spanline or Marmax; whether that loss was a simple loss of profits or a loss of the opportunity to earn profits; and whether any losses included the costs and expenses of the litigation.Summary of conclusions For the reasons given below, we will allow Marmax’s appeal, although not on all grounds. In summary, we have concluded that the primary judge erred in finding that there was a contractual relationship between Marmax and RPR (pursuant to a sub-franchise agreement) after about February 2005. As a result, we have concluded that Marmax’s conduct in doing work in RPR’s territory during the period September 2007 to July 2008 did not breach the sub-franchise agreement. Further, we have concluded that Marmax’s “incursions” into RPR’s territory in 2007 and 2008 did not breach the transfer of business agreement between Marmax and RPR. It follows that Marmax is not liable to pay damages to RPR. Marmax succeeds on grounds 3, 4, 7, 12, 16 and 17 of its notice of appeal. Spanline’s appeal will be allowed in part. In our view, the primary judge erred when he found that Spanline breached its contractual obligations to RPR by not taking “reasonable and available” steps to ensure that RPR’s territory remained exclusive. We respectfully disagree that Spanline breached its obligations to RPR by failing to investigate adequately the complaints it received from RPR about Marmax’s activities. We also disagree that Spanline’s failure to demand that Marmax give full disclosure of work it had done in RPR’s territory was a breach of contract. However, we accept that the permission given by Spanline to Marmax to perform work in RPR’s territory did involve a breach of contract and that this breach caused RPR loss being the lost opportunity to secure the work performed by Marmax. Accordingly, Spanline succeeds in part on grounds 5, 7 and 16 and on grounds 19 and 20 of its notice of appeal.RELEVANT FACTS Through a national network of franchises and sub-franchises, Spanline designs, manufactures and sells home extensions or additions, including patios, roof awnings or covered verandas, glass and screened enclosures and carports. At all relevant times, Mr Anthony Way was the managing director of Spanline.Franchise agreements between Spanline and RPR At the relevant times, the directors of RPR were Mr and Mrs Marron. In 2001, RPR entered into a written five year franchise agreement with Spanline to conduct a business called “Spanline Home Additions South Coast” (“first RPR franchise agreement”). Under the agreement, Spanline granted to RPR “an exclusive Franchise to conduct the Franchised Business in the Territory”. The “Franchised Business” was defined to mean “the business of retail sale, installation and trade wholesales conducted by the Franchisee under this Agreement”. The “Business” was defined to include “the building of additions and improvements to residential and commercial buildings and the granting of franchises to conduct the Business”. The “Territory” was defined as “NSW South Coast Area, as per attached hatched map”. The map identified the south coast of New South Wales from just south of Campbelltown to the border with Victoria, and included an area known as the “Southern Highlands” covering the towns of Mittagong and Bowral.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Ms Rees SC argued that the definition of “Restrained Business” expressly included the business acquired by Marmax as an example of a “Restrained Business”.Consideration Clauses 3.8 and 3.9 are directed to protecting RPR and Marmax’s interests in RPR’s territory and the Illawarra franchise area respectively. Clause 3.11 provides an additional protection to Marmax by way of a promise on the part of RPR not to interfere with the Illawarra business. From RPR’s perspective, an obvious source of competition was Marmax’s business to the extent that competition was not prevented (whether as a matter of law, or a matter of practicality) by Spanline’s grants of exclusive franchises. Equally, RPR was an obvious source of competition for Marmax’s business. However, we are not persuaded that clauses 3.8 to 3.10 impose restraints on that competition. We accept that the language of clauses 3.8 to 3.10 reveals that those provisions are directed to restricting the parties’ involvement in other businesses (similar to, competitive with, or supplying similar products and services as the franchised business). In our view, the words “such as the Business” in the definition of “Restrained Business” should be read as giving content to the meaning of “the Spanline franchise businesses” by way of an example. Thus, the words refer to businesses which are similar to, competitive with or which supply similar products and services to the Spanline Illawarra franchise. In further support of this interpretation, we accept that, if the parties had intended to make an agreement that Marmax would not engage in “incursions” into RPR’s territory, the agreement would have contained an agreement of the kind set out in clause 3.11.Conclusion It follows that Marmax’s incursions into RPR’s territory in 2007 and 2008 did not breach clause 3.9 of the transfer of Illawarra business agreement and ground 12 of the Marmax notice of appeal succeeds. Having reached this conclusion, it is unnecessary to consider whether clause 3.9 is an unenforceable restraint of trade. On the assumption that RPR’s interpretation of clause 3.9 is correct, and Marmax’s conduct contravened clause 3.9, we would accept the general proposition, put by RPR, that RPR had an interest in protecting itself from incursions by Marmax into RPR’s territory. The facts of this case bear that out RPR’s right to exclusivity was an important aspect of the value of its franchise which, in our view, and subject to laws to the contrary (such as competition laws), it had a real and legitimate interest in seeking to protect. We do not accept that this interest was fully satisfied by RPR’s rights vis-à-vis Spanline. As this case illustrates, those rights prevented Spanline from engaging in positive conduct derogating from the grant of the exclusive franchise but they did not protect RPR in the event of incursions by Marmax which were not procured or authorised by Spanline. Grounds 10 and 11 of Marmax’s notice of appeal: exclusivity under the transfer of Illawarra business agreement