Tallerman & Co Pty ltd v Nathan's Merchandise (Victoria) Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 87 min read
98 CLR 93

TALLERMAN AND COMPANY PROPRIE-

TARY LIMITED PLAINTIFF,

NATHAN'S MERCHANDISE (VICTORIA) PRO-

PRIETARY LIMITED DEFENDANT,

ON APPEAL FROM THE SUPREME COURT OF

NEW SOUTH WALES. Contract-Original agreement-Subsequent agreement-Same parties-Same subject

matter-Earlier contract-Abrogation-Particular provisions-Particular term-

Rescission Variation"-Effect-Performance in manner not originally approved- Without prejudice "____" Accord Satisfaction '-Completion of contract-When made--W hen made-Contract made outside State-Inrisdiction of State court-Implied rescission-Parties-Intention.

It appeared that the plaintiff and the defendant entered into written contracts for the sale of goods and that those contracts were made in Victoria. Some of the goods were delivered and accepted but the defendant sent back a shipment comprising the greater part. There was evidence of a parol agree- ment with respect to terms of delivery and the defendant relied on this in sending the goods back. In subsequent correspondence between the parties the defendant in a letter headed ' without prejudice " made a fresh proposal about conditions for delivery of the balance of the goods. The plaintiff rejected the proposal and suggested alternatives the defendant replied rejecting the alternatives and added that it was not prepared to vary its former proposal. After a lapse of two months the plaintiff in a letter posted in New South Wales to the defendant in Victoria also headed without prejudice wrote that it accepted the proposal. A month later the defendant wrote in terms which made plain that it was not prepared to carry out the terms suggested in its former proposal. A writ was issued out of the Supreme Court of New South Wales, indorsed with a declaration containing counts to recover the price of the goods, or alternatively to recover damages for breach of contract. The defendant entered a conditional appearance and a summons

98 CLR 94

was issued by which the defendant sought to have the writ set aside on the ground that the Supreme Court of New South Wales had no jurisdiction in the matter. By consent the summons was dismissed and it was understood and agreed by counsel for both parties that the contract alleged in the indorse- ment on the writ was a contract alleged to have been made in Sydney and to be found in the correspondence. Amendments were made in the indorsement for the purpose of making it conform with this understanding. The trial (VICTORIA)

judge gave judgment for the plaintiff for the full purchase price, apparently on the first count. The Full Court of New South Wales allowed the appeal and ordered judgment to be entered for the defendant. On appeal,

Held: by Dixon C.J. and Fullagar J. that the correspondence brought about not a new contract nor even a varied contract but a mere accord executory;

by Williams and Kitto JJ. that the offer and acceptance in the correspond- ence constituted a new contract made in Sydney as sued on by the plaintiff;

by Taylor J. that the correspondence brought about either an accord executory or a variation of the original contracts in which case the plaintiff had not…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Tallerman & Co Pty ltd v Nathan's Merchandise (Victoria) Pty... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1957] HCA 10
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The plaintiff, Tallerman & Co Pty Ltd, and the defendant, Nathan's Merchandise (Victoria) Pty Ltd, entered into written contracts for the sale of goods, which were made in Victoria. The defendant returned a significant portion of the delivered goods, relying on a subsequent parol agreement regarding delivery terms. Correspondence between the parties, some marked "without prejudice," led to a dispute over whether a new contract or a variation of the existing contracts had been formed. The plaintiff issued a writ in the Supreme Court of New South Wales, and by consent, the parties agreed that the contract in question was one alleged to have been made in Sydney through the correspondence. The trial judge found for the plaintiff, but the Full Court of New South Wales allowed the defendant's appeal.

The central legal issues before the High Court were whether the correspondence between the parties constituted a new contract, a variation of the original contracts, or merely an executory accord, and consequently, whether the Supreme Court of New South Wales had jurisdiction to hear the matter based on the alleged place of contract formation. The court also considered the legal effect of agreements made "without prejudice" and the distinction between rescission and variation of existing contracts.

A majority of the High Court (Dixon C.J., Fullagar and Taylor JJ.) held that the correspondence did not create a new contract nor a varied contract, but rather an accord executory. They applied the principle that a contract is completed upon communication of acceptance to the offeror, and that a contract is made where the act creating the contractual obligation occurs. They also reasoned that a variation of a contract does not create a new contract but affects the existing one, which remains made at its original place of formation. Williams and Kitto JJ. dissented, finding that the correspondence constituted a new contract made in Sydney.

Ultimately, the appeal was dismissed, but the High Court varied the order of the Full Court to a judgment of non-suit, acknowledging that the merits of the real dispute had not been fully investigated due to the restricted basis on which the case had been dealt with in the lower courts.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established