Court of Appeal
Supreme Court
New South Wales
- Amendment notes
Medium Neutral Citation: Bartlett v Australia & New Zealand Banking Group Ltd [2016] NSWCA 30 Hearing dates: 14 and 15 September 2015 Decision date: 07 March 2016 Before: Macfarlan JA at [1];
Meagher JA at [98];
Simpson JA at [108]Decision: (1) Allow the appeal.
(2) Set aside the orders made by Adamson J on 24 November 2014.
(3) Note that the appellant will be entitled to a judgment in the sum of $110,000 together with interest under s 100 of the Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW) from 15 August 2012 to the date of judgment.
(4) Direct the parties to lodge with the Court within 14 days of the date of this judgment a form of consent order providing for the entry of a judgment inclusive of interest in accordance with (3) above.
(5) Order the respondent to pay the appellant’s costs of the proceedings at first instance.
(6) Order the respondent to pay 50% of the appellant’s costs of his appeal.Catchwords: CONTRACT – contract of employment – summary termination for serious misconduct – whether sufficient that employer held the opinion that misconduct had occurred or whether necessary for it to prove that misconduct did in fact occur – if dependent upon employer’s opinion, whether employer obliged to act reasonably in forming opinion
CONTRACT – contract of employment – power to terminate on notice for any reason – whether employer obliged to act reasonably
EVIDENCE – expert evidence – dispute between experts – relevance of demeanour
DAMAGES – contract of employment – wrongful dismissal – whether but for the breach of contract the employer would have exercised its right to terminate the employment on notice for any reason – consideration of the hypothetical circumstances to be postulatedLegislation Cited: Evidence Act 1995 (NSW), s 140
Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW), s 100Cases Cited: Associated Provincial Pictures Houses Ltd v Wednesbury Corporation [1948] 1 KB 223
Australian Workers’ Union v Bowen (No 2) [1948] HCA 35; 77 CLR 601
Blyth Chemicals Ltd v Bushnell [1933] HCA 8; 49 CLR 66 at 81
Braganza v BP Shipping Ltd [2015] UKSC 17; 1 WLR 1661
Burger King Corporation v Hungry Jack’s Pty Ltd [2001] NSWCA 187; 69 NSWLR 558
Briginshaw v Briginsahw [1938] HCA 34; 60 CLR 336
Commonwealth v Amann Aviation Pty Ltd [1991] HCA 54; 174 CLR 64
Commonwealth Bank of Australia v Barker [2014] HCA 32; 253 CLR 169
Cromwell Property Securities Ltd v Financial Ombudsman Service Ltd [2014] VSCA 179; 288 FLR 374
Garry Rogers Motors Aust Pty Ltd v Subaru (Aust) Pty Ltd [1999] FCA 903; ATPR 41-703
GEC Marconi Systems Pty Ltd v BHP Information Technology Pty Ltd [2003] FCA 50; 128 FCR 1
Gramotnev v Queensland University of Technology [2015] QCA 127
Heptonstall v Gaskin (No 2) [2005] NSWSC 30
Horkulak v Cantor Fitzgerald International [2004] EWCA Civ 1287; (2005) ICR 402
Interstar…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Bartlett v Australia & New Zealand Banking Group Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2016] NSWCA 30
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Court of Appeal was required to determine whether the contractual right to terminate for serious misconduct was engaged if the employer held an honest opinion that misconduct had occurred, or if it was necessary for the employer to demonstrate that the misconduct had in fact taken place. Furthermore, the Court had to consider whether, if the employer's opinion was determinative, there was an implied obligation for the employer to act reasonably in forming that opinion. The Court also addressed the question of whether a contractual right to terminate employment on notice for any reason was subject to an implied obligation of reasonableness. Finally, in the context of assessing damages for wrongful dismissal, the Court considered how to approach hypothetical circumstances, specifically whether ANZ would have exercised its right to terminate on notice had the summary dismissal not occurred.
The Court of Appeal found that the contractual right to terminate for serious misconduct was engaged only if the misconduct had actually occurred, not merely if the employer held an opinion that it had. The Court reasoned that the employer's opinion must be based on reasonable grounds, and that the employer bore the onus of proving the misconduct. Regarding the termination on notice for any reason, the Court held that such a power, if it existed, was not subject to an implied obligation to act reasonably. In assessing damages, the Court determined that the hypothetical question of whether ANZ would have terminated Mr. Bartlett's employment on notice was a matter for the trial judge to determine based on the evidence, and that the trial judge had erred in her approach.
The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal, setting aside the orders made by the trial judge. It was noted that Mr. Bartlett was entitled to a judgment in the sum of $110,000, plus interest. The parties were directed to lodge a consent order reflecting this judgment, and ANZ was ordered to pay Mr. Bartlett's costs of the proceedings at first instance and 50% of his costs of the appeal.
Orders
Orders of the court
(1) Allow the appeal.
(2) Set aside the orders made by Adamson J on 24 November 2014.
(3) Note that the appellant will be entitled to a judgment in the sum of $110,000 together with interest under s 100 of the Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW) from 15 August 2012 to the date of judgment.
(4) Direct the parties to lodge with the Court within 14 days of the date of this judgment a form of consent order providing for the entry of a judgment inclusive of interest in accordance with (3) above.
(5) Order the respondent to pay the appellant’s costs of the proceedings at first instance.
(6) Order the respondent to pay 50% of the appellant’s costs of his appeal.
Background
Background to the litigation
The circumstances leading to the termination involved an incident on 13 August 2012, where an error occurred in the processing of cash transactions, causing a substantial financial discrepancy. The respondent conducted an investigation into the incident and concluded that Mr Bartlett was responsible for the error. Based on this conclusion, the respondent terminated his employment the following day. Mr Bartlett subsequently brought proceedings against the respondent for wrongful dismissal, arguing that the termination was unjustified and that the respondent should have exercised its contractual right to terminate his employment on notice instead of summarily.
The case proceeded to a trial before Adamson J, who found in favour of the respondent, dismissing Mr Bartlett's claim for wrongful dismissal. Mr Bartlett appealed this decision, challenging the trial judge's findings regarding the employer's right to summarily terminate employment for serious misconduct, the need for the employer to act reasonably in forming the opinion of misconduct, and the relevance of expert evidence and demeanour in disputes between experts. The appeal was ultimately allowed, setting aside the orders made by Adamson J and directing that Mr Bartlett be awarded judgment for $110,000 plus interest.
The matter of Bartlett v Australia & New Zealand Banking Group Ltd originated in the Supreme Court of New South Wales, where the original proceedings were heard by Adamson J. The plaintiff, Mr Bartlett, initially brought proceedings against the defendant, ANZ Bank, for wrongful termination of his employment. Adamson J dismissed Mr Bartlett’s claim on 24 November 2014, finding that the bank had lawfully terminated the employment for serious misconduct. Following the dismissal, Mr Bartlett appealed to the Court of Appeal, challenging the primary judge’s findings on the standard of proof required for termination for serious misconduct and the reasonableness of the employer's actions in forming the opinion that misconduct had occurred. The Court of Appeal heard the appeal on its merits, reviewing the evidence and arguments presented by both parties, including the expert evidence and the demeanour of the experts involved.
During the appellate proceedings, significant attention was given to whether the employer was required to act reasonably in forming the opinion that misconduct had occurred and whether the employer was obliged to act reasonably in exercising its power to terminate on notice for any reason. The Court of Appeal also considered the relevance of the demeanour of the experts in resolving the dispute between them. The appeal was determined by the Court of Appeal, which allowed the appeal and set aside the orders made by Adamson J. The Court of Appeal ordered that Mr Bartlett would be entitled to a judgment in the sum of $110,000, with interest, and directed the parties to lodge a form of consent order for the entry of the judgment. Additionally, the Court ordered the bank to pay Mr Bartlett’s costs of the proceedings at first instance and 50% of the costs of the appeal.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Did the employer have to prove that misconduct had occurred to justify the summary termination of the employment contract, or was it sufficient for the employer to hold the opinion that misconduct had occurred?
2. If the employer's opinion is sufficient, was the employer obliged to act reasonably in forming that opinion?
3. Is the employer obliged to act reasonably when exercising the power to terminate an employment contract on notice for any reason?
4. In a dispute between experts, what relevance, if any, does the demeanour of the expert have on the admissibility or weight of their evidence?
5. When considering damages for wrongful dismissal, must the court postulate hypothetical circumstances to determine whether the employer would have exercised its right to terminate the employment on notice for any reason if not for the breach of contract?
Held
1. Did the employer have to prove that misconduct had occurred to justify the summary termination of the employment contract, or was it sufficient for the employer to hold the opinion that misconduct had occurred? The court concluded that it was sufficient for the employer to hold the opinion that misconduct had occurred. Result: appeal allowed on this issue.
2. If the employer's opinion is sufficient, was the employer obliged to act reasonably in forming that opinion? The court concluded that the employer was obliged to act reasonably in forming that opinion. Result: appeal allowed on this issue.
3. Is the employer obliged to act reasonably when exercising the power to terminate an employment contract on notice for any reason? The court concluded that the employer is not obliged to act reasonably when exercising the power to terminate an employment contract on notice for any reason. Result: appeal dismissed on this issue.
4. In a dispute between experts, what relevance, if any, does the demeanour of the expert have on the admissibility or weight of their evidence? The court concluded that the demeanour of the expert has some relevance on the admissibility or weight of their evidence. Result: appeal allowed on this issue.
5. When considering damages for wrongful dismissal, must the court postulate hypothetical circumstances to determine whether the employer would have exercised its right to terminate the employment on notice for any reason if not for the breach of contract? The court concluded that the court must postulate hypothetical circumstances to determine whether the employer would have exercised its right to terminate the employment on notice for any reason if not for the breach of contract. Result: appeal allowed on this issue.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In the case of Bartlett v Australia & New Zealand Banking Group Ltd, the court considered the extent to which an employer must substantiate a belief of misconduct when summarily terminating an employee's contract. The primary issue was whether the employer needed to prove misconduct had occurred or if it was sufficient for the employer to hold the opinion that misconduct had occurred. The court ruled that it is sufficient for the employer to hold the opinion that misconduct has occurred, provided this opinion is held honestly and on reasonable grounds. This decision aligns with the principle that employers have a measure of discretion in managing their workforce, particularly in instances of serious misconduct where immediate action may be necessary to protect the business.
In applying this principle, the court examined whether the employer was obliged to act reasonably in forming its opinion. The court held that while the employer does not need to prove misconduct beyond a reasonable doubt, it must ensure that the opinion is based on a rational and evidence-based assessment. The court underscored that the employer's decision-making process must be fair and not capricious. This requirement ensures that the employer's decision to terminate is not arbitrary but is based on a process that considers relevant facts and information.
Turning to the power of the employer to terminate an employment contract on notice for any reason, the court addressed whether the employer must act reasonably when exercising this power. The court clarified that while the employer has the right to terminate employment on notice for any reason, the process leading to such a decision should still be conducted reasonably. The employer must follow a fair procedure, provide the employee with an opportunity to respond to any allegations, and consider the employee's version of events. This ensures that the exercise of the power is not abused and maintains a balance between the employer's prerogative and the employee's rights.
The court also considered the relevance of an expert's demeanour in a dispute between experts. The court emphasised that while the demeanour of an expert witness can be a factor in assessing the credibility and reliability of their evidence, it is not determinative. The court must focus on the substance of the expert's evidence, its basis, and the reasoning behind it. However, demeanour can play a supportive role in understanding the expert's reliability and the weight to be given to their testimony.
Finally, the court examined the approach to damages in wrongful dismissal cases, specifically whether the court must consider hypothetical circumstances to determine if the employer would have exercised its right to terminate the employment on notice for any reason if not for the breach of contract. The court held that such hypothetical considerations are not necessary if the employer's right to terminate on notice for any reason is validly exercised. The court must assess the actual loss suffered by the employee due to the wrongful dismissal and award damages accordingly. This approach ensures that the employee is compensated for the loss of employment without speculating on alternative outcomes that may not have eventuated.