Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Ingham (The 180 Brisbane Construction Case)

Link copied
Case Copied 80 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Ingham (The 180 Brisbane Construction Case) [2019] FCA 1052

File number: QUD 388 of 2016
Judge: COLLIER J
Date of judgment: 9 July 2019
Catchwords:

INDUSTRIAL LAW – alleged contraventions of Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) ss 417(1) and 500 – whether contractors and subcontractors authorised or agreed to conduct of Union representatives – entry permits and entry notices – whether “open door” policy or requirement for Union representatives to give notice before entering site – where Union representative claimed to have entered site to raise money for injured Union worker and workers took opportunity to raise workplace issues – genuine and reasonable concerns about imminent risks to health and safety

INDUSTRIAL LAW – whether Union representatives organised work stoppages – whether stoppages authorised by enterprise agreements –  interpretation of “industrial action” – onus of proving the “organising” of industrial action within meaning of Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) s 19(2) – whether Union representatives exercised or sought to exercise rights under Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) Pt 3-4 – whether Union representatives “involved in” contraventions of civil remedy provisions – accessorial liability – aiding and abetting contraventions

INDUSTRIAL LAW – whether respondent Union liable for contraventions of Union representatives pursuant to Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) ss 550 and 793 – whether Union representatives intentionally hindered or obstructed or acted improperly – whether Union representatives acted with actual or apparent authority – where individual respondents “clothed with apparent authority”

Legislation:

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) ss 12, 19, 19(1), 19(1)(b), 19(2), 19(2)(a), 19(2)(b), 19(2)(c), 417, 417(1), 417(1)(a), 478, 484, 486, 487, 489, 500, 500(2), 512, 545, 550, 550(2)(c), 793, Pt 3-4 Div 2, Pt 3-4, Pt 3-4 Div 2 Subdivs A, AA, B, Pt 3-4 Div 3, Pt 3-4 Div 4

Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth)

Property Law Act 1974 (Qld) s 55

Work Health and Safety Act 2011 (Qld) ss 117, 119, 121(1), 122

Fair Work Bill 2008 (Cth)

Cases cited:

Always Resource Holdings Pty Ltd v Samgris Resources Pty Ltd [2017] QSC 74

Antaios Compania Naviera SA v Salen Rederierna AB [1985] AC 191

Apple and Pear Australia Ltd v Pink Lady America LLC [2016] VSCA 280

Asia Pacific Joint Mining Pty Ltd v Always Resource Holdings Pty Ltd [2018] QCA 48; (2018) 3 Qd R 520

Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Australian Manufacturing Workers' Union (The Australian Paper Case) [2017] FCA 167

Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union (The Laverton North and Cheltenham Premises Case) [2018] FCAFC 88; (2018) 357 ALR 510

Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union (The Parliament Square Case) [2018] FCA 1080

Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Huddy [2017] FCA 739

Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Huddy (No 2) [2017] FCA 1088

Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v McDermott (No 2) [2017] FCA 797; (2017) 252 FCR 393

Australian Workers' Union v Leighton Contractors Pty…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Ingham (... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] FCA 1052
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case involved proceedings brought by the Australian Building and Construction Commissioner (ABCC) against various individuals and a union, the Construction, Forestry, Maritime, Mining and Energy Union (CFMMEU), concerning alleged contraventions of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth). The dispute arose out of the construction of a 34-storey office tower, where the principal contractor was Watpac, and several subcontractors were employed. The CFMMEU had enterprise agreements with the subcontractors that allowed union representatives to enter the site. The ABCC alleged that union representatives engaged in various activities that contravened the Fair Work Act, including organising industrial action without authorisation and failing to comply with entry requirements. The central legal issues were whether the union representatives organised the industrial action, whether they acted with actual or apparent authority, and whether the union was liable for the actions of its representatives.

The Court examined the conduct of each union representative individually, considering whether their actions amounted to organising industrial action and whether they hindered or obstructed the employer. The Court found that while some representatives were seeking to exercise rights under the Fair Work Act, their actions were not authorised by the enterprise agreements or the law. Notably, the Court held that Mr Griffin acted improperly by failing to give the required notice before entering the site and not complying with the site safety protocols. The Court also concluded that Mr Sutherland did not organise the industrial action but acted improperly by entering the site without notice. The union was found not liable for the actions of its representatives as they were not acting with actual or apparent authority.

The Court ordered the parties to file draft orders reflecting the judgment and listed the matter for case management. The final orders were to give effect to the reasons for judgment and address the contraventions of the Fair Work Act by the union representatives.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. By 4.00 pm on 24 July 2019 the parties file draft orders, if possible by consent, giving effect to the reasons for judgment in Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Ingham (The 180 Brisbane Construction Case) [2019] FCA 1052 delivered 9 July 2019.

2. The matter be listed for case management on 31 July 2019 at 9.30 am.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

TABLE OF CONTENTS

BACKGROUND

[4]

CLAIMS OF THE ABCC

[25]

DEFENCE

[32]

PRINCIPAL ISSUES IN DISPUTE

[35]

1. 26 JUNE 2014

[40]

Organising industrial action

[40]

(a) Did Mr Ingham organise the stoppage within the meaning of s 417(1)?

[40]

(b) In the event that Mr Ingham did not organise the stoppage, did he involve himself within the meaning of s 550?

[70]

Right of entry contraventions

[90]

(a) Was Mr Ingham exercising or seeking to exercise a right conferred by Pt 3-4?

[90]

(b) When Mr Ingham was at the Project Site did he intentionally hinder or obstruct Watpac or otherwise act improperly?

[108]

Conclusion

[109]

2. 27 JUNE 2014

[110]

Organising industrial action

[110]

(a) Who bears the legal onus in respect of disproving or proving that circumstances identified in s 19(2) applies?

[110]

(b) Was the stoppage industrial action within the meaning of s 19?

[127]

(c) If the stoppage was industrial action, did Mr Myles organise the stoppage within the meaning of s 417(1)?

[159]

(d) In the event that Mr Myles did not organise the stoppage, did he involve himself within the meaning of s 550?

[160]

Right of entry contraventions

[161]

(a) Was Mr Myles exercising or seeking to exercise a right conferred by Pt 3-4?

[161]

(b) When Mr Myles was at the Project Site, was the hindrance or obstruction caused by Mr Myles intentional or did Mr Myles otherwise act improperly?

[179]

Conclusion

[190]

3. 1 JULY 2014

[191]

Right of entry contraventions

[191]

(a) Was Mr Griffin seeking to exercise a right conferred by Pt 3-4?

[191]

(b) If Mr Griffin was seeking to exercise a state or territory right of entry in accordance with Pt 3-4, did he intentionally hinder or obstruct Watpac or otherwise act improperly?

[199]

Conclusion

[213]

4. 4 JULY 2014

[214]

Right of entry contraventions

[214]

(a) Was Mr Griffin seeking to exercise a right conferred by Pt 3-4?

[214]

(b) If Mr Griffin was seeking to exercise a state or territory right of entry in accordance with Pt 3-4, did he intentionally hinder or obstruct Watpac or otherwise act improperly?

[218]

Conclusion

[219]

5. 7 JULY 2014

[220]

Organising industrial action

[220]

(a) Did Mr Sutherland organise the stoppage within the meaning of s 417(1)? or

[220]

(b) In the event that Mr Sutherland did not organise the stoppage, did he involve himself within the meaning of s 550?

[220]

Right of entry contraventions

[232]

(a) Was Mr Sutherland seeking to exercise a right conferred by Pt 3-4?

[232]

(b) When Mr Sutherland was at the Project Site did he intentionally hinder or obstruct Watpac or otherwise act improperly?

[232]

Conclusion

[235]

6. 17 JULY 2014

[236]

Organising industrial action

[236]

(a) Was the stoppage authorised by the sub-contractor EBAs?

[236]

(b) Did Mr Bragdon organise the stoppage within the meaning of s 417? or

[239]

(c) In the event that Mr Bragdon did not organise the stoppage, did he involve himself within the meaning of s 550?

[239]

Right of entry contraventions

[245]

(a) Was Mr Bragdon seeking to exercise a right conferred by Part 3-4? and

[245]

(b) When Mr Bragdon was at the Project Site did he intentionally hinder or obstruct Watpac or otherwise act improperly?

[245]

Conclusion

[249]

7. CLAIMS AGAINST THE SIXTH RESPONDENT

[250]

Conclusion

[257]

APPROPRIATE ORDERS

[257]

Background

Background to the litigation

The parties filed a Statement of Agreed Facts in the proceedings. It is helpful to have regard to this as well as evidence before the Court in setting out the background to these proceedings.BACKGROUND At all material times work on the Project Site involved the construction of a 34 storey office tower, at an estimated cost of $200 million. Construction commenced in or around May 2013, and was in progress in June and July 2014. Watpac was the principal contractor at the Project Site, and for the purposes of the FW Act was the occupier of the Project Site. At all material times Watpac was in management and control of the Project Site. Watpac employed workers (Watpac Employees) to perform construction work on the Project Site, including in the roles of crane operators, hoist drivers, traffic controllers and general labourers. Watpac also engaged numerous subcontractors to work on the Project Site including ECB Scaffolding Pty Ltd, Oneform, Marveldale Pty Ltd, Specialised Concrete Plumbing, Talbrace and Tensioned Concrete Pty Ltd (Project Subcontractors). The Project Subcontractors and their employees performed work in structural trades on the Project Site, including formwork, blocklaying, steelfixing, concreting and concrete pumping. A Project Safety Management Plan had been promulgated by Watpac. The Project Subcontractors were contractually bound to comply with that document. Each of the Project Subcontractors had an approved enterprise agreement (EBA) within the meaning of ss 12 and 417(1)(a) of the FW Act with the Union. Each agreement was operative at all material times, and contained the following terms:8.1… Authorised Representatives of Employee Organisations (AREOs) under the Workplace Health and Safety Act are not required to provide any information or particulars of any suspected contravention of safety law prior to conducting inspections or discussions on site.…33.4A standing invitation exists for any representative of the Union covered by this agreement to enter any place where company employees or representatives are for purposes including, but not limited to, dispute resolution or consultation meetings but not for purposes for which a Right of Entry exists under Part 3-4 of the Fair Work Act.…33.9Employees are entitled to have paid time off to attend union meetings of up to 2 hours (or more by agreement) or participate in union activities. At material times the individual respondents were employees and officers of the Union, and held the following positions with the Union:(a)Mr Ingham: Assistant Divisional Branch Secretary(b)Mr Myles: Organiser(c)Mr Sutherland: Crane Co-ordinator(d)Mr Bragdon: Organiser(e)Mr Griffin: Organiser. Each of the individual respondents held entry permits under the FW Act and the Work Health and Safety Act 2011 (Qld) (WHS Act). The Union at all material times was entitled to represent the industrial interests of (inter alia) Watpac Employees and employees of Project Subcontractors. The workers on the Project Site had lunch room sheds (Sheds) at the Project Site on basement level 3 of the building under construction.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

For similar reasons to those I found in relation to 1 July 2014, I am satisfied that Mr Griffin did not intentionally hinder or obstruct Watpac, but that he did act improperly. In particular:·I consider the stoppage of 4 July 2014 was authorised by cl 33.9 of the EBAs (being a meeting of less than two hours in duration);·There is no evidence about the presence or otherwise of Watpac employees at the meeting;·However Mr Griffin entered the Project Site on 4 July 2014 but failed to give required notice prior to doing so; and ·Mr Griffin did not provide an entry notice or sign the visitor’s register as required by Watpac’s Site Safety Protocols. Conclusion In relation to the issues the parties identify as requiring determination:(a)Was Mr Griffin seeking to exercise a right conferred by Pt 3-4?Yes.(b)If Mr Griffin was seeking to exercise a State or Territory right of entry in accordance with Pt 3-4, did he intentionally hinder or obstruct Watpac or otherwise act improperly?Mr Griffin acted improperly in exercising or seeking to exercise a right conferred by Pt 3-4.5. 7 JULY 2014Organising industrial action(a) Did Mr Sutherland organise the stoppage within the meaning of s 417(1)? or(b) In the event that Mr Sutherland did not organise the stoppage, did he involve himself within the meaning of s 550? The facts in respect of events on 7 July 2014 are, in key respects, agreed. In particular the parties agree that on 7 July 2014 the workers of the Project Subcontractors engaged in industrial action within the meaning in s 417(1) of the FW Act. It is convenient to deal together with questions of Mr Sutherland’s role (if any) in those events. In support of its claim that Mr Sutherland organised (or was involved in) the industrial action on 7 July 2014 the ABCC submits that the Court should infer that Mr Sutherland organised or was involved with the stoppage on 7 July 2014 because, in summary:·The 8.30 am meeting must have been planned as 100 people do not coincidentally gather in a single room and wait for two hours·The plan must have been put into execution at or about the time of Mr Sutherland’s arrival at 6.10 am, because according to evidence of Mr Ross (for example his witness statement at [186]-[187] and at transcript pp 91-92) at 6.10 am Messrs Geelan and Henry were able to accurately inform Mr Ross of events which would occur later that morning (namely that the Union members would wait in the Sheds until the Oneform members had completed their involvement in climbing the jump form, and that the Oneform members would then join the rest of the workers for the meeting).·The issue of Mr Nailon was apparently only raised while Mr Sutherland was present, and once he left the Project Site it was not mentioned again. There is no evidence that Mr Sutherland informed Mr Ross what the supposed problem with Mr Nailon actually was. The respondents submit however that:·The only evidence in respect of the meeting of 7 July 2014 was that of Mr Sutherland.·There is nothing inherently unlikely in his account that he received a telephone call requesting that he come to site and speak to the workers. The fact that when he arrived at the site the workers had assembled to talk to him was consistent with someone having requested his presence.·Mr Sutherland gave evidence that he attempted to stop the workers going on strike, which evidence was inherently reasonable and did not constitute organising industrial action.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established