FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
WIJOAV Services Pty Ltd v Goldstone Private Equity Pty Ltd [2025] FCA 622
File number(s): NSD 310 of 2025 Judgment of: JACKMAN J Date of judgment: 13 June 2025 Catchwords: CORPORATIONS – claim brought in oppression under s 232 of Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (Corporations Act) – where venture capital private equity business consisted of two registered companies and two limited partnerships – where two directors each owned 50% of shares in the two registered companies – where irretrievable breakdown of business relationship – where one director terminated employment of the other and through four separate resolutions of the entities, excluded the other director from management of the companies and partnerships – whether company validly formed opinion that the director had engaged in serious misconduct as a ground for termination – where nine particulars relied upon by defendants – held in relation to all nine particulars that no reasonable person could have formed the opinion that the director engaged in serious misconduct – directors termination and removal from boards held invalid – whether the four resolutions were legally valid – resolution 1 held legally valid on basis that the definition of “insolvency event” was constructed by parties with intention of avoiding risk to limited partnership – resolution 4 held legally valid on basis that strictly there was a winding up application at play
CORPORATIONS – whether oppression established – where ss 232 and 233 of Corporations Act apply to companies but not to partnerships that are not registered under or generally subject to Corporations Act – whether statutory provisions relating to oppression extend to operation of limited partnerships conducted or managed by company – where only way limited partnership can act is through its general partner, a corporate entity – where the resolutions vividly illustrate that control and management of limited partnerships is effected via corporate entities – where exclusion from management already held invalid – clear case of oppression established
CORPORATIONS – question of appropriate relief – where purpose of relief is to alleviate consequences of oppressive conduct and no more – where buy-out direction is to be determined by what the justice of the case requires, balancing all circumstances – whether buy-out order can and should extend to compulsory purchase of partnership interests – purchase of company assets deemed capable of falling within s 233(1)(j) – company’s affairs extend to management of limited partnerships in present circumstances – whether order for buy-out of partnership interests is “in relation to the company” not “in relation to the affairs of the company” – held in the affirmative due to direct implications on relations between companies and limited partnerships – question of who should buy out who – circumstances of the case considered extensively – held the defendants should buy-out the plaintiffs’ shares in the two companies and interests in the limited partnership – questions of valuation and pecuniary remedies to be deferred to subsequent hearing on 20 June 2025
DAMAGES – plaintiffs entitled to damages for…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read WIJOAV Services Pty Ltd v Goldstone Private Equity Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2025] FCA 622
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court had to determine whether WIJOAV's termination of Ms Commins' employment and exclusion from management were valid. It also needed to decide if the resolutions were legally valid and if the statutory provisions relating to oppression extended to the limited partnerships. Furthermore, the court had to consider the appropriate relief, including whether a buy-out order could extend to the compulsory purchase of partnership interests. The court concluded that none of the particulars of serious misconduct relied upon by the defendants could justify Ms Commins' termination and exclusion from management. Consequently, the directors' termination and removal from boards were deemed invalid. The court also found that the statutory provisions relating to oppression applied to the limited partnerships because their control and management were effectively exercised through the corporate entities. The court ruled that the defendants should buy out the plaintiffs' shares in the companies and their interests in the limited partnership. The questions of valuation and pecuniary remedies were deferred to a subsequent hearing.
The court ordered that Angel Holdco purchase WIJOAV's shares in Goldstone Private Equity Pty Ltd and Goldstone Fund Management Pty Ltd and Ms Commins' partnership interest in Goldstone Private Equity VCMP, LP. The price for these purchases would be determined by the Court, based on the corporate structure of the Goldstone Fund as at 31 March 2025. The quantification of pecuniary remedies for the breaches and the determination of the prices were to be heard together. The court also restrained the defendants from enforcing the plaintiffs' compliance with a specific clause in the Shareholders' Deed. The proceedings to wind up one of the limited partnerships were adjourned to the hearing on the valuation date. The plaintiffs were granted costs of the proceedings to date on a party-party basis. The matter was set for a case management hearing on 20 June 2025.
Orders
Orders of the court
5. Pursuant to s 233 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth):
(a) the fourth defendant (Angel Holdco) purchase, and WIJOAV transfer, WIJOAV’s shares in Goldstone PE and Goldstone FM at a price to be determined by the Court; and
(b) Angel Holdco or, at its election, Mr Angelis purchase, and Ms Commins transfer, Ms Commins’ current partnership interest as a Limited Partner of the fifth defendant (VCMP) at a price to be determined by the Court.
6. The determination of the prices in Order 5 be conducted on the basis of the corporate structure of the Goldstone Fund (as defined in the reasons for judgment) as at 31 March 2025, noting that the date of valuation is yet to be determined.
7. The question of the quantification of pecuniary remedies for the breaches which are the subject of Declarations 3 and 4 be heard together with the determination of the prices in Order 5.
8. Mr Angelis, Angel Holdco, Goldstone PE and Goldstone FM be restrained from relying on or enforcing the plaintiffs’ compliance with cl 3.4 of the Shareholders’ Deed (as defined in the reasons for judgment).
9. Leave be granted to the plaintiffs to amend the Second Further Amended Originating Process in the form of the Third Further Amended Originating Process and Annexure handed up during their final address, except for the amendments concerning the appointment of a receiver set out in paras 7T to 7Y of the draft Third Further Amended Originating Process and Option 1 in the Annexure.
10. Mr Angelis’s proceedings to wind up VCMP be adjourned to the hearing referred to in Order 7.
11. Costs reserved.
12. The matter stand over to a case management hearing on 20 June 2025 at 10.30 am.
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Until 1 April 2025, the legal structure of the Goldstone Fund involved four entities. Two of them were companies registered under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (the Corporations Act), namely Goldstone Private Equity Pty Ltd (Goldstone PE), being the first defendant, and Goldstone Fund Management Pty Ltd (Goldstone FM), being the second defendant. The shares of each of those companies are held as to 50% each by WIJOAV and Angel Holdco. On about 2 November 2023, a Shareholders’ Deed was entered into in relation to the two companies (the Shareholders’ Deed). The other two entities are limited partnerships, namely the Goldstone Private Equity VCLP, LP, ILP2300031 (VCLP), being the sixth defendant, and Goldstone Private Equity VCMP, LP, ILP2300030 (VCMP), being the fifth defendant. VCLP and VCMP are limited partnerships pursuant to Pt 3 of the Partnership Act 1892 (NSW) (the Partnership Act). Deeds establishing those limited partnerships were executed on about 2 November 2023, and were subsequently replaced by new deeds executed in the case of VCMP in mid-September 2024 (VCMP Deed), and in the case of VCLP on 16 December 2024 (VCLP Deed). The General Partner of VCLP is VCMP, and it is common ground that the only Limited Partner of VCLP is Angel Holdco. Angel Holdco has committed $100 million in capital to VCLP, of which $32 million has been called and paid. Goldstone PE is the Manager of VCLP. The General Partner of VCMP is Goldstone FM. The Limited Partners of VCMP are three trusts, of which Ms Commins is the trustee of two trusts, and Mr Angelis is the trustee of the other trust. Those four entities are the first, second, fifth and sixth defendants. The other defendants are corporate entities associated with Mr Angelis, and Mr Angelis himself (the Angelis Defendants). The Goldstone Fund presently has two investments, being shares in companies known as Parabellum International Pty Ltd (Parabellum) and M Strata Group Holdings Pty Ltd (Neighbourly). VCLP holds 47.5% of the shares in Parabellum and 63% of the shares in Neighbourly. Neither of those companies is a party to these proceedings. From about 2 November 2023, Ms Commins served as Managing Director of Goldstone PE and Goldstone FM, responsible for sourcing, executing and managing VCLP’s investments and raising further capital. Ms Commins’ employment was purportedly (and as I find below, wrongly and invalidly) terminated on 27 February 2025, and again on 2 April 2025, on the ground of alleged serious misconduct. On 6 March 2025, WIJOAV and Ms Commins commenced these proceedings. On 1 April 2025, Mr Angelis procured a number of steps to be taken including applying to the Supreme Court of New South Wales to wind up VCMP (the NSWSC Proceedings), removing VCMP as General Partner of VCLP, removing Goldstone PE as Manager of VCLP, and appointing his own entities, Goldstone Capital Pty Ltd (Goldstone Capital), being the seventh defendant, and Goldstone Capital FM Pty Ltd (Goldstone Capital FM), being the eighth defendant, as General Partner and Manager of VCLP respectively.