FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA
(DIVISION 2)
Haley v Laing O’Rourke Australia Management Services Pty Ltd (No 8) [2024] FedCFamC2G 779
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Haley v Laing O'Rourke Australia Management Services Pty Ltd... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
Details
- Case
- [2024] FedCFamC2G 779
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
In the case of Haley v Laing O'Rourke Australia Management Services Pty Ltd (No 8), the dispute centred around the wrongful termination of an employment contract and the subsequent assessment of damages and compensation under sections 545(2)(b) and 340(1) of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth). The primary legal issues revolved around whether the employer would have lawfully terminated the employee's contract but for the wrongful summary dismissal, and if so, the appropriate measure of damages and compensation. The court was required to determine the likelihood of the employer giving notice of termination instead of summarily dismissing the employee, and then assess the damages and compensation in light of that probability.
The court adopted a factual approach, considering the employer's previous conduct and intentions to dismiss the employee. Macfarlan JA emphasised that the court needed to postulate a scenario where the employer realised it could not summarily terminate the employment and would instead give notice. The evidence suggested that the employer had repeatedly expressed a desire to terminate the employee's contract, and the misconduct at the Sales 2.0 conference provided the opportunity and justification to do so. The court concluded that it was a natural inference that the employer would have given notice of termination, albeit reluctantly.
The reasoning of the court was grounded in the need to balance the employer's adverse view of the employee's conduct with the statutory requirement to provide notice. The application of precedents such as TCN Channel Nine and Bartlett was noted, reinforcing the approach that the employer's lawful termination would have been on notice, not summarily. The court underscored the importance of assessing damages despite the inherent difficulties, referencing Amann Aviation Pty Ltd v Commonwealth, which highlighted the obligation to estimate damages as accurately as possible.
The outcome of the case was that the damages and compensation were awarded based on the assumption that the employer would have retained the employee but for the wrongful summary dismissal. However, this amount was discounted to reflect the contingencies involved, acknowledging that there was no certainty the employer would have retained the employee in the postulated scenario. This approach ensured that the compensation reflected both the losses suffered and the uncertainties inherent in the case.
The court adopted a factual approach, considering the employer's previous conduct and intentions to dismiss the employee. Macfarlan JA emphasised that the court needed to postulate a scenario where the employer realised it could not summarily terminate the employment and would instead give notice. The evidence suggested that the employer had repeatedly expressed a desire to terminate the employee's contract, and the misconduct at the Sales 2.0 conference provided the opportunity and justification to do so. The court concluded that it was a natural inference that the employer would have given notice of termination, albeit reluctantly.
The reasoning of the court was grounded in the need to balance the employer's adverse view of the employee's conduct with the statutory requirement to provide notice. The application of precedents such as TCN Channel Nine and Bartlett was noted, reinforcing the approach that the employer's lawful termination would have been on notice, not summarily. The court underscored the importance of assessing damages despite the inherent difficulties, referencing Amann Aviation Pty Ltd v Commonwealth, which highlighted the obligation to estimate damages as accurately as possible.
The outcome of the case was that the damages and compensation were awarded based on the assumption that the employer would have retained the employee but for the wrongful summary dismissal. However, this amount was discounted to reflect the contingencies involved, acknowledging that there was no certainty the employer would have retained the employee in the postulated scenario. This approach ensured that the compensation reflected both the losses suffered and the uncertainties inherent in the case.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Macfarlan JA said that the application of TCN Channel 9 required the court to “determine as a matter of probability whether, but for the wrongful summary dismissal, [the employer] would have given the [employee] six months’ notice of termination and if, so, when”. The determination of that question, in turn, required the court:[39]to postulate a situation in which all the facts remained as they occurred but [the employer] formed the view that, or was advised that, it was not entitled to summarily terminate the [employee’s] employment. This does not mean that the [employee’s] conduct should be ignored or that [the employer] should be taken to have adopted a more benign approach to it.[39] Willis Australia Group Services Pty Ltd v Mitchell-Innes [2015] NSWCA 381, at [122] (emphasis added). His Honour concluded as follows (emphasis added):[40]If this approach is taken, it is to my mind clear, at least on the balance of probabilities, that [the employer] would have given immediate notice of termination. Its adverse view of the [employee’s] conduct would have been unchanged but it would have known that it could not summarily terminate the [employee’s] employment. There is no apparent reason why it would not have given effect to its adverse view of that conduct by dismissing him on notice. The evidence that [the employer] had on several occasions evinced a desire to “get rid of” the [employee] confirms the likelihood of this occurring. It is true . . . that [the employer] had not given effect to this desire prior to the Sales 2.0 conference but the [employee’s] misconduct at that conference provided him with the opportunity to do so, and the excuse for doing so. It is not necessary . . . to conclude that there is a presumption in such a situation that such a contractual power would be exercised. It is sufficient to consider the issue as a matter of fact and regard the probability of [the employer] exercising its right to give six months’ notice of termination as a “natural inference” in the circumstances (see TCN Channel Nine v Hayden Enterprises quoted at [117] above).Application of TCN Channel 9 to employment contracts – Bartlett[40] Willis Australia Group Services Pty Ltd v Mitchell-Innes [2015] NSWCA 381, at [123] (emphasis added). The second judgment of Macfarlan JA on which LOA relies is the judgment his Honour gave in Bartlett v Australia & New Zealand Banking Group Ltd,[41] the facts of which LOA, in its written submissions, submits “are apposite to this case”.[42] In Bartlett the employer engaged a Mr McGowan to conduct an investigation according to the procedures provided for by the employer’s “Performance Improvement & Unacceptable Behaviour Policy” into whether an employee had amended a copy of a confidential email and posted it to a journalist. In the course of his investigation Mr McGowan commissioned a forensic document and handwriting examiner to determine whether certain handwriting was that of the employee. The examiner concluded it was highly probable that the handwriting in question was the employee’s. Mr McGowan concluded his investigation by producing a report in which he concluded there was sufficient circumstantial evidence to show the employee was responsible for the media leak, as a consequence of which the employee breached the employer’s code of conduct and ethics; and the report was provided to Mr Corbally, who “was the decision-maker at the [employer] who was responsible for deciding what would be done as a result of the investigation”.[43][41] Bartlett v Australia & New Zealand Banking Group Ltd [2016] NSWCA 30[42] Respondent’s Submissions on Damages and Compensation, at [18][43] Bartlett v ANZ Banking Group Ltd [2014] NSWSC 1662, at [36]
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
The final point to note relates to the difficulties that are usually encountered when assessing damages; and I need only refer to the following passage from the judgment of Deane J in Amann:[62]The mere fact that damages cannot be assessed without difficulty and uncertainty does not, however, relieve a court from the responsibility of attempting to assess them as best it can. As was pointed out by Dixon and McTiernan JJ in Fink v. Fink, at 143: “Where there has been an actual loss of some sort, the common law does not permit difficulties of estimating the loss in money to defeat the only remedy it provided for breach of contract, an award of damages”.[62] Commonwealth v Amann Aviation Pty Ltd (1991) 174 CLR 64, at page 125 (footnotes omitted)Mr Haley’s claims, submissions, and evidence In his written submissions Mr Haley identifies a number of heads of damage he claims he suffered because of LOA’s summary dismissal of his employment, and the amounts of damages he claims for each head of damage.Loss of income up to 5 April 2022 The first head of damage is the income Mr Haley says he lost up to 5 April 2022. It appears Mr Haley has chosen 5 April 2022 because that represents income Mr Haley earned for the years ended 5 April 2021 and 5 April 2022, as disclosed in Her Majesty’s Revenue & Customs Tax Returns for 2021 and 2022 Mr Haley prepared in the United Kingdom.[63] The tax returns disclose Mr Haley earned income of £49,856 for the year ended 5 April 2021 and £49,564 for the year ended 5 April 2022. Mr Haley converted these amounts to AUD91,336.19 and AUD88,218.96 (totalling $179,555.15) at the exchange rates prevailing as at 5 April 2021 and 2022 respectively.[64] [63] Exhibit L[64] Applicant’s Submissions on s 117(2) of the FW Act, and on Damages and Compensation (Applicant’s Submissions on Compensation), [105]. Mr Haley obtained the exchange rate from Office of National Statistics, UK. Mr Haley claims as damages up to 5 April 2022 an amount that represents the difference between benefits he would have received under the Employment Contract up to 5 April 2022 less the income he earned. Mr Haley submits that, under the Employment Contract, he would have received a monthly salary of $36,753.25. That amount has been calculated on the basis that he would have received an annual salary of $393,900, $25,000 superannuation, and $22,139 “relating to BUPA cover approved in May 2019”.[65] [65] Applicant’s Submissions on Compensation, [106] The “BUPA cover” is a reference to insurance premiums LOA agreed it would pay. Mr Haley requested LOA pay these premiums in an email he sent to Ms Kate Whittaker on 9 April 2019. In that email Mr Haley said that Mr Chatwin had referred Mr Haley to Ms Whittaker, and he noted that treatment was being provided in the United Kingdom under “our company BUPA policy”, and LOA (through Mr Chatwin) had agreed that “BUPA cover would be provided in Australia to ensure we could continue the treatment”.[66] In an email sent to Mr Chatwin on 10 April 2019 Ms Whittaker asked that Mr Chatwin confirm that the total costs of the cover would be $11,733.84 per annum, which, with fringe benefits tax, would cost LOA $22,139 per annum. By email sent to Mr Chatwin on 20 May 2019 Mr Cathal O’Rourke approved the request that LOA pay the amount for BUPA coverage.[67][66] Exhibit TH-E4-003 (CB447)[67] Exhibit TH-E4-003 (CB444)
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi