Cessnock City Council v 123 259 932 Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 71 min read

HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

GAGELER CJ,
GORDON, EDELMAN, STEWARD, GLEESON, JAGOT AND BEECH‑JONES JJ

CESSNOCK CITY COUNCIL  APPELLANT

AND

123 259 932 PTY LTD  RESPONDENT

Cessnock City Council v 123 259 932 Pty Ltd

[2024] HCA 17

Date of Hearing: 13 February 2024
Date of Judgment: 8 May 2024

S115/2023

ORDER

Appeal dismissed with costs.

On appeal from the Supreme Court of New South Wales

Representation

J T Gleeson SC with L G Moretti for the appellant (instructed by Holding Redlich)

D L Williams SC with B D Kaplan for the respondent (instructed by Dentons Australia)

Notice:  This copy of the Court's Reasons for Judgment is subject to formal revision prior to publication in the Commonwealth Law Reports.

  1. GAGELER CJ.   This appeal concerns the recoverability in damages for breach of contract of expenditure incurred by an innocent party (a plaintiff), in reliance on an expectation of performance of a contract, rendered futile as a result of non-performance of the contract by a defaulting party (a defendant).

  2. The principle governing recovery of such "wasted expenditure" was stated in the decision of the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of New South Wales under appeal as follows:[1]

    "To sum up: a plaintiff who is unable or does not undertake to demonstrate whether or to what extent the performance of a contract would have resulted in a profit may claim its wasted expenditure. In such a case, expenditure incurred by a plaintiff in reliance on a contractual promise made by the defendant and 'wasted' because of non-performance by the defendant is recoverable, except to the extent that the defendant shows that the plaintiff would not have recouped its expenditure had the contract been performed."

    The Court of Appeal emphasised that recovery is limited by the principle of remoteness of damage associated with Hadley v Baxendale,[2] in respect of which the Court of Appeal added:[3]

    "[T]he proper application of Hadley v Baxendale as a control on remoteness of damage in a claim for wasted expenditure is whether, when the contract was made, it was within the reasonable contemplation of the parties that the relevant expenditure would be incurred and, if the contract were breached in the relevant manner, wasted."

  3. In my opinion, the Court of Appeal was correct. The principle governing the recovery of damages for wasted expenditure can be generalised as follows. A plaintiff establishes a prima facie entitlement to recover damages for breach of contract if and to the extent that the plaintiff establishes that expenditure it has incurred in reliance on an expectation of performance of the contract has in fact been wasted upon breach of the contract by the defendant. The prima facie entitlement of the plaintiff prevails unless and except to the extent that…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Cessnock City Council v 123 259 932 Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] HCA 17
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal concerned a dispute between Cessnock City Council, the owner of land on which an airport was located, and 123 259 932 Pty Ltd, a respondent who had entered into an agreement with the Council to lease a prospective lot at the airport. The Council had breached its contractual obligation to take all reasonable action to apply for and obtain registration of a plan of subdivision. The respondent had incurred considerable expenditure in anticipation of or reliance on the Council's performance, which was rendered wasted due to the Council's breach. The case was heard by the High Court of Australia.

The central legal issue before the court was the proper approach to assessing damages for wasted expenditure incurred by a plaintiff in reliance on a defendant's contractual performance, where the defendant's breach has caused that expenditure to be wasted. Specifically, the court considered how a plaintiff should establish the position they would have been in had the contract been performed, particularly when the breach creates uncertainty regarding the recoupment of such expenditure.

The High Court affirmed the application of the "facilitation principle" in assessing damages. This principle, consistent with previous High Court decisions, operates to ease the plaintiff's burden of proof by presuming that reasonably incurred, but wasted, expenditure would likely have been recouped had the contract been performed. The court emphasised that this principle is not rigid and its application depends on the specific circumstances, including the extent of uncertainty caused or increased by the defendant's breach. In this instance, the Council's breach had created considerable uncertainty, justifying the application of the principle.

The High Court dismissed the appeal with costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Appeal dismissed with costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Although there was some disagreement between the parties about the effect of the decision in The Commonwealth v Amann Aviation Pty Ltd,[101] the respondent's reliance on the principle that permits facilitation of its proof of the position that it would have been in if the contract had been performed is broadly consistent with the reasoning of Mason CJ and Dawson J, as well as Deane J, who spoke of the principle as a "presumption" in favour of the plaintiff, with Brennan J, who spoke of it as a "reversal of the onus", and with Toohey J and Gaudron J, who spoke of it as placing an "evidentiary onus" on a defendant. The description "facilitation principle" emphasises that the principle is not rigid. All the circumstances must be considered and the strength with which the principle applies to facilitate a plaintiff's proof by treating reasonably incurred, but wasted, expenditure as likely to be recouped will depend upon the extent of uncertainty caused or increased by the defendant's breach. In this case, there was considerable uncertainty as a result of the Council's breach. The principle was correctly applied by the Court of Appeal. The appeal should be dismissed with costs.Background[101](1991) 174 CLR 64 at 87-89, 94, 106, 126-128, 131, 142, 156. See also Berry v CCL Secure Pty Ltd (2020) 271 CLR 151 at 169-170 [29].The Council awards a tender for development of the airport The appellant is a local council which owns land on which the Cessnock Airport is located. The Cessnock local government area, as described by the Council, is "within relatively easy driving distance from Sydney, Newcastle and the Coast" and includes the Hunter Valley wine growing area, "Australia's oldest wine region and one of the most famous". The wine industry employed 2,500 people and the region recorded 737,240 visitors in 1994. In 1998, the Council requested expressions of interest for the development and management of the airport. The Council explained in the request that the airport was located in the "rapidly developing Vineyards area of the Lower Hunter Valley" and that it was one of only two airports in the lower Hunter Valley. The Council said that it considered the airport to have "significant potential to accommodate expanded operations for light RPT/Commuter, charter, general aviation and sports aviation traffic". The request for expressions of interest contained a "Cessnock Aerodrome Development Plan". In that development plan, the Council explained that among its proposals was a lengthened runway to accommodate significantly larger, long-range aircraft, an upgrade of terminal facilities for regular passenger and charter services, and subdivision of some of the airport land into lots for lease or sale, to be used for air-related activity. The Council observed that "the number of major projects before it" meant that it would not be appropriate for the Council to fully fund the airport development from its own resources. The Council said that it may be possible for the development to be funded from a combination of sources: sale of excess land, sale of land within the airport environment for air-related activity, or attaching private investor funding.

Decision

Reasons for decision

GAGELER CJ GORDON J EDELMAN, STEWARD, GLEESON AND BEECH-JONES JJ
Issues
1. Whether the respondent is entitled to recover wasted expenditure incurred in anticipation of or reliance on the appellant's performance of its contractual obligations.
2. What is the proper approach to the method of proof for the plaintiff to establish the position they would have been in if the contract had been performed?
3. How should the court assess damages in cases where the plaintiff incurs expenditure in anticipation of or reliance on the defendant's contractual obligation, and the defendant's breach results in the expenditure being wasted?
4. How should the "facilitation principle" be applied in the context of wasted expenditure, and what is the effect of the defendant's breach on the certainty of the plaintiff's proof?
5. Whether the principle of facilitation of proof is correctly applied by the Court of Appeal in this case.

Held
1. The court concluded that the respondent is entitled to recover wasted expenditure incurred in anticipation of or reliance on the appellant's performance of its contractual obligations. Result: Respondent's claim for wasted expenditure allowed.

2. The court held that the proper approach to the method of proof for the plaintiff to establish the position they would have been in if the contract had been performed involves considering all circumstances and the uncertainty caused by the breach. Result: Facilitation of proof principle applied.

3. The court determined that damages should be assessed by considering the wasted expenditure incurred in anticipation of or reliance on the defendant's contractual obligation, and treating it as likely to be recouped to the extent the breach caused uncertainty. Result: Reasonable wasted expenditure recoverable.

4. The court held that the "facilitation principle" should be applied by considering the extent of uncertainty caused by the defendant's breach and treating reasonably incurred, but wasted, expenditure as likely to be recouped. Result: Facilitation principle correctly applied.

5. The court concluded that the principle of facilitation of proof was correctly applied by the Court of Appeal in this case. Result: Appeal dismissed with costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: GAGELER CJ, GORDON J, EDELMAN, STEWARD, GLEESON AND BEECH-JONES JJ

The central issue in the Cessnock City Council v 123 259 932 Pty Ltd case revolves around whether the respondent is entitled to recover wasted expenditure incurred in anticipation of or reliance on the appellant's performance of its contractual obligations. The Court of Appeal addressed this issue by considering the facilitation principle, which allows for the assumption that wasted expenditure is likely to be recouped unless the defendant can demonstrate otherwise. The court examined the respondent's right to be placed in the position it would have been in had the contract been performed, and whether the facilitation principle was correctly applied in this context.

The court found that the respondent was indeed entitled to recover wasted expenditure due to the appellant's breach of contract. The facilitation principle, as articulated in previous cases such as The Commonwealth v Amann Aviation Pty Ltd and Berry v CCL Secure Pty Ltd, was applied to emphasize that the principle is not rigid but rather a presumption in favour of the plaintiff. The principle's application depends on the extent of uncertainty caused by the defendant's breach. Here, the Council's breach resulted in considerable uncertainty for the respondent.

The proper approach to the method of proof for the plaintiff to establish the position they would have been in if the contract had been performed was explored through the lens of the facilitation principle. The court held that the respondent should be facilitated in proving their position by treating reasonably incurred, but wasted, expenditure as likely to be recouped. This approach aligns with the reasoning of previous authorities that have recognized the facilitation principle as a means to reverse the onus of proof or place an evidentiary onus on the defendant.

In assessing damages in cases where the plaintiff incurs expenditure in anticipation of or reliance on the defendant's contractual obligation, and the defendant's breach results in the expenditure being wasted, the court adopted the facilitation principle. This principle allows for the assumption that the wasted expenditure is likely to be recouped unless the defendant can demonstrate otherwise. The court found that the respondent's expenditure was reasonably incurred and should be considered in the damages assessment.

The facilitation principle was applied in this case to address the effect of the defendant's breach on the certainty of the plaintiff's proof. The court determined that the Council's breach created considerable uncertainty for the respondent, thereby strengthening the application of the facilitation principle. This principle serves to facilitate the respondent's proof by presuming that the wasted expenditure is likely to be recouped, unless the Council could provide evidence to the contrary.

The principle of facilitation of proof was correctly applied by the Court of Appeal in this case. The court considered the extent of uncertainty caused by the Council's breach and appropriately applied the facilitation principle to allow the respondent to recover wasted expenditure. The reasoning was consistent with previous authorities that have recognized the facilitation principle as a means to reverse the onus of proof or place an evidentiary onus on the defendant. The court's decision was consistent with the broad approach taken in cases such as The Commonwealth v Amann Aviation Pty Ltd and Berry v CCL Secure Pty Ltd.

In summary, the ratio decidendi of this case is that the facilitation principle can be applied to permit the recovery of wasted expenditure incurred in anticipation of or reliance on the defendant's contractual obligations, provided the defendant's breach has resulted in the expenditure being wasted. The court correctly applied this principle to facilitate the respondent's proof and found that the respondent was entitled to recover the wasted expenditure. The facilitation principle is not rigid and its application depends on the extent of uncertainty caused by the defendant's breach. The appeal was dismissed with costs, affirming the lower court's decision.