Binningup Nominees Pty Ltd v Mirvac (WA) Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 72 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

TITLE OF COURT  :   THE COURT OF APPEAL (WA)

CITATION:   BINNINGUP NOMINEES PTY LTD -v- MIRVAC (WA) PTY LTD [2021] WASCA 130

CORAM:   MURPHY JA

BEECH JA

VAUGHAN JA

HEARD:   11 & 12 FEBRUARY 2021 & FURTHER SUBMISSIONS 20 APRIL 2021, 11 & 13 MAY 2021

DELIVERED          :   27 JULY 2021

FILE NO/S:   CACV 25 of 2020

BETWEEN:   BINNINGUP NOMINEES PTY LTD

Appellant

AND

MIRVAC (WA) PTY LTD

First Respondent

MIRVAC LTD

Second Respondent

ON APPEAL FROM:

Jurisdiction              :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

Coram:   ARCHER J

Citation: MIRVAC (WA) PTY LTD -v- BINNINGUP NOMINEES PTY LTD [2020] WASC 28

File Number            :   CIV 1018 of 2015


Catchwords:

Contract - Interpretation - Services Agreement and Loan Agreement - Dispute between Principal and Contractor - Long‑term Project with no set end date - Where Contractor required to provide a Programme and Budget for each stage of Project for approval or disapproval by Project Control Group - Where Project Control Group comprised of members of both Principal and Contractor - Whether judge erred in finding that Contractor's members of Project Control Group had a right to disapprove a Programme or Budget - Whether judge erred in finding that Completion of Project was not a contractual benefit conferred on Principal - Proper construction of Transaction Documents

Contract - Interpretation - Implied obligations - Whether judge erred in finding that there was no obligation on Contractor 'to endeavour to ensure' that Principal's obligation to repay each Advance under Loan Agreement on time could be met by sale proceeds

Contract - Repudiation - Principles - Whether trial judge erred in finding no repudiation

Appeals - Challenge to factual findings - Whether appellable error by judge in making findings of fact to the effect that Contractor had not made or implemented a decision not to proceed with Project unless it could renegotiate amendments to Services Agreement more commercially favourable to it - Trial judge's findings based to a substantial degree on assessment of credibility and reliability of witnesses - Turns on own facts

Legislation:

Nil

Result:

Appeal dismissed

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Appellant : D H Solomon
First Respondent : B Dharmananda SC & B Lim & M Hales
Second Respondent : B Dharmananda SC & B Lim & M Hales

Solicitors:

Appellant : Solomon Brothers
First Respondent : Minter Ellison
Second Respondent : Minter Ellison

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

Australian Broadcasting Commission v Australasian Performing Right Association Ltd [1973] HCA 36; (1973) 129 CLR 99

Australian Securities and Investment Commission v Rich [No 5] [2005] NSWSC 417; (2005) 191 FLR 385

Beerens v Bluescope Distribution Pty Ltd [2012] VSCA 209; (2012) 39 VR 1

Black Box Control Pty Ltd v TerraVision Pty Ltd [2016] WASCA 219

BP Refinery (Westernport) Pty Ltd v Hastings Shire Council (1977) 180 CLR 266

Briginshaw v Briginshaw [1938] HCA 34; (1938) 60 CLR 336

Butt v M'Donald (1896) QLJ 68

Campbell v Backoffice Investments Pty Ltd [2009] HCA…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Binningup Nominees Pty Ltd v Mirvac (WA) Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] WASCA 130
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Binningup Nominees Pty Ltd (BN) brought an action against Mirvac (WA) Pty Ltd in the Supreme Court of Western Australia, alleging breaches of a Services Agreement. BN claimed that Mirvac (WA) had wrongfully refused to proceed with a development project unless it could renegotiate the agreement for more favourable terms. BN also alleged that Mirvac (WA) had used deadlock provisions to pressure BN into agreeing to the changes. The dispute centred on whether Mirvac (WA) had breached the agreement by delaying the project and attempting to renegotiate terms unilaterally.

The court was required to determine whether Mirvac (WA) had breached the Services Agreement by refusing to proceed with the project unless it could renegotiate the agreement to its advantage. Additionally, the court needed to ascertain if Mirvac (WA) had implemented a deliberate strategy to delay the project, and whether such actions constituted a breach of the agreement. Furthermore, the court had to decide if Mirvac (WA) had engaged in conduct that amounted to a repudiatory breach of contract.

The Supreme Court of Western Australia found that Mirvac (WA) had indeed breached the Services Agreement. The court concluded that Mirvac (WA) had made a decision not to proceed with the project unless it could renegotiate the agreement, which constituted a breach. The court also found that Mirvac (WA) had deliberately delayed the project to pressure BN into agreeing to more favourable terms, which was another breach of the agreement. Furthermore, the court held that Mirvac (WA) had engaged in conduct that amounted to a repudiatory breach by indicating that it was unlikely to proceed with the project unless certain conditions were met. Consequently, the court ruled in favour of BN, finding that Mirvac (WA) had breached the Services Agreement.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

BN alleged that Mirvac (WA) breached the Services Agreement by making, and implementing, a decision not to proceed with the Project unless it could renegotiate amendments to the Services Agreement that were more commercially favourable to it (alleged Refusal to Proceed decision).[43][43] Primary decision [26]. BN alleged that by no later than December 2012, Mirvac (WA), in order to give effect to the alleged Refusal to Proceed decision, made two further decisions (1) to use deadlock provisions in the Services Agreement to terminate the Services Agreement if BN did not agree to variations favourable to Mirvac (WA), and (2) in the meantime, to delay the progress of the Project until the Initial Advance became repayable under cl 5.6 of the Loan Agreement (on 11 January 2018), thereby putting pressure on BN to terminate or agree to terms more favourable to Mirvac (WA).[44][44] Primary decision [27]. BN alleged that Mirvac (WA) implemented the alleged Refusal to Proceed decision by (1) negotiating to vary the Services Agreement, and (2) delaying progress of the Project in relation to a second access road and by the potential development of the golf course land into residential land.[45][45] Primary decision [30] - [31]. In relation to the second access road, BN alleged that Mirvac (WA) deliberately caused delay in obtaining the Shire's approval by, in effect, resisting the Shire's demands in respect of a second access road, and thereby creating a 'false issue'.[46][46] Primary decision [32]. BN summarised the matters which it alleged 'manifested' the alleged Refusal to Proceed decision as follows:1.Mirvac (WA) deliberately delayed the progress of the Project, particularly in 2009, by its handling of the second access road issue and its dealings (particularly through Mr Adam Davidson) with the Shire on that issue.[47][47] Primary decision [40], [99] - [100].2.Mirvac (WA) also deliberately delayed the progress of the Project by 'attempting to cause' Coast Pastoral Company (Pastoral Co), a nearby landowner whose land would be needed for a second access road, 'not to sell that land'.[48][48] Primary decision [40], [101].3.As from 2009, Mirvac (WA) had decided to abandon 'Built form' work, which BN asserted Mirvac (WA) was obliged to undertake under the Services Agreement. 'Built form' work means, in effect, constructing and building on a lot before selling it.[49]4.An 'Approval for Additional Costs' document, prepared by Mr Adam Davidson in early 2009 for approval by Mr Draffen, allegedly concealed from Mr Draffen the extent of the fall in the internal rate of return since the 'Approval to Purchase' of 9 May 2007 was prepared.[50]5.In order to proceed, Mirvac would have needed an internal 'Approval to Commence Construction' document (ACC) and there was no prospect of such a document being issued because (1) Mirvac (WA) sought to renegotiate the Services Agreement (itself manifesting the alleged Refusal to Proceed decision) and its feasibility studies were based on assumptions that the Services Agreement would be varied, (2) in February 2013, Mirvac provisioned for a $18 million loss on its advance on the basis that BN would likely agree to release Mirvac (WA) from its obligations under the Services Agreement and refund the Initial Advance of $25 million, as it was thought that BN would not wish to have the deadlock provisions operate and lead to a sale of the land, and (3) in September 2013, Mirvac realised it was going to make a loss if the Services Agreement was not varied, even if the golf course was developed.[51]6.On 3 April 2014, Mirvac (WA) made an alleged repudiatory statement by Mr Draffen. Mr Draffen (allegedly) stated to Mr Waller of BN, at a meeting on 3 April 2014, in effect, that Mirvac's Board was unlikely to decide to carry out the Project, but if Stage 1 was carried out, the Board may possibly decide to proceed.[52] As to what was said at the meeting on 3 April 2014, BN relied on Mr Waller's purported minutes of the meeting.[53]7.After the meeting on 3 April 2014 between Mr Draffen of Mirvac (WA) and Mr Waller of BN, Mirvac did work to consider a possible Stage 1 to be located at the foreshore, away from established services. This was not a logical place to start, and showed that Mirvac 'never intended' to develop Stage 1.[54]8.On 13 June 2014, Mr Lawrance of Mirvac Ltd made a statement at a Project Control Group meeting to the effect that, in addition to approval by the Project Control Group, Mirvac would need internal approval prior to commencing Stage 1.[55]9.In September 2014, Mirvac (WA) deliberately delayed progress of the Project by proposing to the Project Control Group a Programme and Budget for approval to vary the Local Structure Plan so as to remove the golf course and change it to residential land.[56] 10.In September 2014, Mirvac (WA) refused to attend further Project Control Group meetings if those meetings were recorded (as was sought by BN).[57]

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.