JURISDICTION : SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA
IN CIVIL
CITATION: MIRVAC (WA) PTY LTD -v- BINNINGUP NOMINEES PTY LTD [2020] WASC 28
CORAM: ARCHER J
HEARD: 29 APRIL - 16 MAY, 20 & 21 MAY 2019
DELIVERED : 11 FEBRUARY 2020
FILE NO/S: CIV 1018 of 2015
BETWEEN: MIRVAC (WA) PTY LTD
Plaintiff
AND
BINNINGUP NOMINEES PTY LTD
Defendant
BINNINGUP NOMINEES PTY LTD
Plaintiff by Counterclaim
AND
MIRVAC (WA) PTY LTD
First Defendant by Counterclaim
MIRVAC LTD
Second Defendant by Counterclaim
Catchwords:
Development services agreement - Termination - Outstanding loan account - Contractual rights - Good faith obligation - No hindering obligation - Prevention principle - Limited recourse versus limited liability - Damages - Inadequacy of evidence - Net present value - Circuity - Tort of interference - Aggravated and exemplary damages
Legislation:
Nil
Result:
Judgment for the plaintiff
Counterclaim dismissed
Category: B
Representation:
Original Action
Counsel:
| Plaintiff | : | B Dharmananda SC & B K Lim |
| Defendant | : | D J Marsh & D H Solomon |
Solicitors:
| Plaintiff | : | Minter Ellison |
| Defendant | : | Solomon Brothers |
Counterclaim
Counsel:
| Plaintiff by Counterclaim | : | D J Marsh & D H Solomon |
| First Defendant by Counterclaim | : | B Dharmananda SC & B K Lim |
| Second Defendant by Counterclaim | : | B Dharmananda SC & B K Lim |
Solicitors:
| Plaintiff by Counterclaim | : | Solomon Brothers |
| First Defendant by Counterclaim | : | Minter Ellison |
| Second Defendant by Counterclaim | : | Minter Ellison |
Case(s) referred to in decision(s):
Atlas Tiles Ltd v Briers (1978) 144 CLR 202
Australis Media Holdings v Telstra Corp Ltd (1998) 43 NSWLR 104
Black Box Control Pty Ltd v Terravision Pty Ltd [2016] WASCA 219
British Transport Commission v Gourley [1956] AC 185
Byrne v Australian Airlines Ltd [1995] HCA 24; (1995) 185 CLR 410
Civic Video Pty Ltd v Paterson [2016] WASCA 69
Concut Pty Ltd v Worrell [2000] HCA 64; (2000) 75 ALJR 312
CSR Ltd v Adecco (Australia) Pty Ltd [2017] NSWCA 121
Cullen v Trappell [1980] HCA 10; (1980) 146 CLR 1
Daebo Shipping Co Ltd v Ship Go Star [2012] FCAFC 156; (2012) 294 ALR 635
EDWF Holdings 1 Pty Ltd v EDWF Holdings 2 Pty Ltd [2010] WASCA 78; (2010) 41 WAR 23
Electricity Corporation v Woodside Energy Ltd [2014] HCA 7; (2014) 251 CLR 640
Georgiou Building Pty Ltd v Perrinepod Pty Ltd [2102] WASC 72 (S)
Gold City Developments Pty Ltd v Portpride Pty Ltd [2010] WASC 148
Grainger v Williams [2009] WASCA 60
Gray v Motor Accident Commission [1998] HCA 70; (1998) 196 CLR 1
Idameneo (No 123) Pty Ltd v Gross [2012] NSWCA 423; (2012) 83 NSWLR 643
Koompahtoo Local Aboriginal Land Council v Sanpine Pty Ltd [2007] HCA 61; (2007) 233 CLR 115
Marmax Investments Pty Ltd v RPR Maintenance Pty Ltd [2015] FCAFC 127; (2015) 237 FCR 534
Noye v Robbins [2010] WASCA 83
Paciocco v Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Ltd [2015] FCAFC 50; (2015) 236 FCR 199
Probuild Constructions (Aust)
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Mirvac (WA) Pty Ltd v Binningup Nominees Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2020] WASC 28
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues for the court to decide were whether Mirvac WA was entitled to repayment of the OLA following the termination of the Services Agreement, and if so, the extent of such repayment. The court was also required to consider the impact of the prevention principle, the principle of circuity, and set-off on Mirvac WA's right to recover the OLA. Binningup argued that Mirvac WA could not rely on the repayment clause in the Services Agreement because it was Mirvac WA who had repudiated the agreement, thereby preventing Binningup's performance. Binningup also asserted that, due to the principle of circuity, Mirvac WA was not entitled to the OLA because the amount they sought to recover from Binningup was identical to the amount Binningup would have been entitled to recover from Mirvac WA if the Services Agreement had not been breached.
The court considered the arguments presented and concluded that, even if Mirvac WA did breach the Services Agreement, the prevention principle did not preclude Mirvac WA from relying on the repayment clause. The court found that the Transaction Documents explicitly excluded the prevention principle from affecting Mirvac WA's entitlement to the OLA. The court also found that the principle of circuity did not apply because Binningup was not entitled to recover the OLA from Mirvac WA, and therefore, Mirvac WA was entitled to recover the OLA from Binningup. Additionally, the court held that Mirvac WA could set off the OLA against Binningup's damages, despite Binningup's argument that Mirvac WA's right of recovery was limited to the Project Assets.
In conclusion, the court ruled in favour of Mirvac WA, finding that it was entitled to repayment of the OLA from Binningup. The court held that the prevention principle and the principle of circuity did not prevent Mirvac WA from recovering the OLA, and that Mirvac WA could set off the OLA against any damages owed to Binningup. The court's decision provided clarity on the parties' contractual rights and obligations, ensuring that Mirvac WA could recover the OLA as stipulated in the agreement.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Binningup submits that, because, on its case, it was Mirvac WA who repudiated the Services Agreement, the 'prevention principle' means that Mirvac WA cannot rely on cl 5.5(b). 'The essence of the prevention principle is that a party cannot insist on the performance of a contractual obligation by the other party if it itself is the cause of the other party's non‑performance'.[7] Mirvac submits that the Transaction Documents exclude the prevention principle from operating on Mirvac WA's entitlement to be repaid the OLA under cl 5.5(b).[7] Spiers Earthworks Pty Ltd v Landtec Projects Corporation Pty Ltd (No 2) [2012] WASCA 53; (2012) 287 ALR 360 [47]. Binningup also submits that, because of the principle of circuity, Mirvac WA is not entitled to the OLA. The circuity principle prevents one party recovering an amount from another party that is identical to what that second party had a right to recover from the first. In essence, Binningup alleges that, if Mirvac WA had not breached the Services Agreement, the OLA would have been repaid. Therefore, Binningup asserts, its damages claim includes the OLA that would have been repaid and that component of its claim is identical to Mirvac WA's entitlement to the OLA. Binningup also pleads that, if it is found to owe any amount, the damages to which it is entitled should be set‑off in reduction or extinction of Mirvac WA's claim.[8] Binningup appears to argue that, because Mirvac WA's right of recovery is limited to the Project Assets, Mirvac WA is not entitled to set off all of the OLA against Binningup's damages. [8] Defence [12]. It is common ground that, if Mirvac WA did not breach the Services Agreement, it is entitled to the OLA under the First Pathway. If it did breach the Services Agreement, its entitlement will turn on whether the prevention principle applies and, if the principle does not apply, the effect, if any, of the principles of circuity and set‑off. Mirvac WA's second pathway alleges that an 'Event of Default' occurred as a result of Binningup's Termination Notice (Second Pathway). Clause 7.1 of the Loan Agreement defines an Event of Default as including a default under a Transaction Document, if a Trigger Event has occurred. Mirvac submits that Binningup's Termination Notice was a repudiation at common law,[9] and a default under the Services Agreement. It submits it accepted Binningup's repudiation, terminating the Services Agreement. The termination was a Trigger Event, making the default under the Services Agreement an Event of Default. [9] It was also alleged to be a 'Non‑Monetary Event of Default' within the meaning of the Services Agreement, and therefore a default under a Transaction Document, and therefore an Event of Default within the meaning of the Loan Agreement. However, Mirvac conceded it would succeed on both or fail on both. Accordingly, it is unnecessary to deal with this second basis. Clause 7.2 of the Loan Agreement relevantly provides that Binningup must immediately repay the OLA if there is an 'Event of Default' and Mirvac WA gives notice that the OLA is immediately repayable. Mirvac submits, therefore, that the OLA became payable by Binningup to Mirvac WA immediately on notice being given. Binningup denies it repudiated, and says it was entitled to terminate the Services Agreement.