Montedeen Pty Ltd v Bamco Villa Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 79 min read

SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA

  COURT OF APPEAL Not Restricted

No.  2175 of 1996

MONTEDEEN PTY LTD
Appellant
v
BAMCO VILLA PTY LTD
Respondent

---

JUDGES:

BROOKING, CHARLES and CHERNOV, J.A.

WHERE HELD:

MELBOURNE

DATES OF HEARING:

1-2 December 1998, 9-11 and 15 March 1999

DATE OF JUDGMENT:

18 May 1999

MEDIA NEUTRAL CITATION:

[1999] VSCA 59

---

Contract - Franchise agreement - Construction - Exclusive licence - Restrictions on franchisor - Improper diversion of business by franchisor - Breach of implied term - Sham - Purported sale of business.

Courts and judges - Court raising possibility of new issue - Preconceived views - Reasonable apprehension of bias.

Practice and procedure - Pleading - Amendment on appeal - Raising new point not taken below - Reformulation of legal principle on evidence at trial - Pure question of law - Interest of justice.

Evidence - Re-opening case - New evidence - Rule in Ladd v. Marshall - Availability of evidence for trial - Witness in camp of other party.

---

APPEARANCES:

Counsel        Solicitors

For the Appellant

Mr. P.J. O'Callaghan, Q.C.
and Mr. R. Peters

       Jerrard & Stuk
For the Respondent Mr. D.M.B. Derham, Q.C.
and Ms M. Rozner
       Lander & Rogers

BROOKING, J.A.:
CHARLES, J.A.:
CHERNOV, J.A.:

  1. Montedeen Pty. Ltd. (which we shall throughout call "Montedeen") describes itself as the owner of the Delta Car Rentals System and associated trademarks, the system and trademarks being used in the business of renting cars and trucks in Victoria and in some other States.  By a series of franchise agreements it has licensed a number of franchisees to use the system and the trademarks.  Montedeen also carries on business at a number of locations on its own behalf.  It describes as branches all the locations at which either it or one of its franchisees carries on business.  It has in addition what it describes as agencies, where it has what it calls agents who will hire out cars and trucks.  At the time of the trial of the action out of which these appeals arise there were about 20 branches in Australia, some of them being conducted by Montedeen and the remainder by its franchisees.  Mario Salvo is the managing director and controller of Montedeen and the litigation has been conducted on the basis that the company is his creature. 

  1. Bamco Villa Pty. Ltd. (which we shall throughout call "Bamco Villa") is controlled by two brothers, Tony and Horace Vernuccio.  It is one of Montedeen's franchisees.  How this came about is in a general way recorded in the reasons for judgment of the trial judge and we need not provide a corresponding summary.

  1. Salvo and the Vernuccio brothers have been on bad terms for years.  The bad feeling between them and the disputes giving rise to this litigation have fed the one upon the other, with the result that vast sums of money, by the standards of ordinary people, have been expended in legal costs in litigation conducted à outrance.  The cost of the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Montedeen Pty Ltd v Bamco Villa Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1999] VSCA 59
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Montedeen Pty Ltd took Bamco Villa Pty Ltd to the Court of Appeal in a dispute concerning the interpretation of a franchise agreement. Montedeen sought clarification on the exclusivity of a licence granted under the agreement and whether Bamco had breached the agreement by improperly diverting business to itself. The case also involved an allegation that Bamco had breached an implied term of the agreement, which was considered to be a sham, and a claim that the sale of Bamco's business to a third party was improper. The Court of Appeal was required to consider whether the trial judge had erred in his construction of the agreement and whether the judge had been biased in his approach to the case. Additionally, Montedeen sought to amend its pleadings on appeal to include a new point of law that had not been argued before the trial judge.

The Court of Appeal considered whether the trial judge had erred in his interpretation of the franchise agreement, particularly in relation to the exclusivity of the licence granted to Montedeen. The Court also examined whether the trial judge had been influenced by a preconceived view of the case, which could have led to a reasonable apprehension of bias. Furthermore, the Court had to decide whether Montedeen could amend its pleadings on appeal to include a new point of law that had not been raised before the trial judge. The Court also considered whether the trial judge had erred in his approach to the evidence presented at trial and whether the case involved a pure question of law that could be decided by the Court of Appeal in the interest of justice.

The Court of Appeal found that the trial judge had erred in his interpretation of the franchise agreement, particularly in relation to the exclusivity of the licence granted to Montedeen. The Court also found that the trial judge had not been influenced by any preconceived views of the case and that there was no reasonable apprehension of bias. The Court further held that Montedeen could not amend its pleadings on appeal to include a new point of law that had not been argued before the trial judge. However, the Court found that the case involved a pure question of law that could be decided by the Court of Appeal in the interest of justice. The Court of Appeal ultimately allowed Montedeen's appeal and ordered a new trial to determine the proper construction of the franchise agreement and whether Bamco had breached the agreement.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established