NSW Trustee and Guardian v Budniak No 2

Link copied
Case Copied 35 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

  • Amendment notes
Medium Neutral Citation: The Estate of Stanislaw Budniak; NSW Trustee & Guardian v Budniak No 2 [2015] NSWSC 1317
Hearing dates:13 August 2015
Decision date: 10 September 2015
Jurisdiction:Equity
Before: Hallen J
Decision:

See Paragraphs 85 and 86

Catchwords:

COSTS – Two proceedings heard together – Probate and family provision proceedings – The Plaintiff, the executor named in the duly executed Will of the deceased in the Probate proceedings was unsuccessful in propounding that Will – Agreement at hearing that if duly executed Will not the subject of a grant, Probate in solemn form of an informal Will be granted to the Defendant/Cross-Claimant – Issue whether costs of the Plaintiff, calculated on the indemnity basis, rather than on the ordinary basis of the Probate proceedings, be paid out of the estate of the deceased – No dispute that Defendant/Cross-Claimant should receive his costs, calculated on the indemnity basis, out of the estate of the deceased

 

In the family provision proceedings, the Plaintiff in the Probate proceedings named as the Defendant in order to defend the proceedings – Proceedings dismissed as a result of decision in Probate proceedings – Whether Defendant should receive any costs of the family provision proceedings – No dispute that the Plaintiffs in the family provision proceedings should receive their costs as part of the costs of the Defendant/Cross-Claimant in the Probate proceedings – Affidavits read in Probate proceedings

  ASSESSMENT OF COSTS – Because Plaintiff unsuccessful in Probate proceedings it no longer relevantly interested in quantum of Defendant/Cross-Claimant’s costs – One of the beneficiaries in informal Will seeks order that costs of the Defendant/Cross-Claimant in both the Probate proceedings and the costs of the Plaintiffs in the family provision proceedings be assessed
Legislation Cited: Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW)
Legal Profession Uniform Law Application Act 2014 (NSW)
NSW Trustee & Guardian Act 2009 (NSW)
Succession Act 2006 (NSW)
Supreme Court Rules 1970 (NSW)
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW)
Cases Cited: Bool v Bool [1941] St R Qd 26
Bullabidgee Pty Ltd v McCleary (No 2) [2011] NSWCA 343
Di Carlo v Dubois [2002] QCA 225
Estate of Allwood v Benjafield [2009] NSWSC 1383
Gonzales v Claridades [2003] NSWSC 508; (2003) 58 NSWLR 188
Gray v Richards [No 2] [2014] HCA 47
Howards Storage World Pty Ltd v Haviv Holdings Pty Ltd [2010] FCAFC 5; (2010) 182 FCR 84
Mitchell v Gard (1863) 164 ER 1280
Oasis Hotel Ltd v Zurich Insurance Company (1981) 28 BCLR 230
O’Brien v McCormick [2005] NSWSC 619
Public Trustee v Hammerman; Estate of Ida Hammerman (Supreme Court (NSW), Hodgson J, 23 February 1996, unrep)
Kallinicos v Hunt (2005) 64 NSWLR 561
Luxmore Pty Ltd v Hydedale Pty Ltd [2008] VSCA 212; (2008) 20 VR 481
Ponder v Burmeister [1910] SA Law Rp 4; [1909] SALR 62
QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited v Hotchin [2013] NSWSC 315
Re Estate Late Hazel Ruby Grounds; Page v Sedawie [2005] NSWSC 1311
Re…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read NSW Trustee and Guardian v Budniak No 2 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NSWSC 1317
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of NSW Trustee and Guardian v Budniak No 2 involved two interrelated proceedings: probate and family provision. The plaintiff in the probate proceedings was the executor named in a will that was alleged to be validly executed. However, the executor was unsuccessful in propounding the will, leading to an agreement that if the will could not be granted, a solemn form of an informal will would be granted to the defendant, who was also the cross-claimant. The primary legal issue was whether the costs of the plaintiff, calculated on an indemnity basis, should be paid out of the deceased's estate. Another issue was whether the defendant, who had successfully argued against the executor in the probate proceedings, should receive any costs from the family provision proceedings, which were dismissed due to the outcome in the probate proceedings.

The court found that since the executor was unsuccessful in the probate proceedings, it was no longer relevantly interested in the quantum of the defendant's costs. The executor was now focused on ensuring that the defendant received his costs on an indemnity basis from the estate. The court also determined that the plaintiffs in the family provision proceedings should receive their costs as part of the defendant's costs in the probate proceedings. The final issue was whether one of the beneficiaries in the informal will could seek an order for the assessment of the defendant's costs in both the probate and family provision proceedings.

The court concluded that the executor's costs in the probate proceedings should be paid from the estate on an indemnity basis, and the defendant's costs in both the probate and family provision proceedings should also be assessed and paid from the estate. The plaintiffs in the family provision proceedings would receive their costs as part of the defendant's costs in the probate proceedings. The court issued orders for the assessment of costs accordingly, ensuring that all parties received their entitled costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves two separate but related proceedings: probate and family provision proceedings. In the probate proceedings, the Plaintiff, who is the executor named in the deceased's duly executed Will, was unsuccessful in propounding the Will. An agreement was reached that if the executed Will was not granted probate in solemn form, an informal Will would be granted to the Defendant/Cross-Claimant. The issue arose concerning whether the costs of the Plaintiff, calculated on an indemnity basis rather than the ordinary basis of the probate proceedings, should be paid out of the deceased's estate. There was no dispute that the Defendant/Cross-Claimant should receive his costs, calculated on the indemnity basis, out of the deceased's estate.

In the family provision proceedings, the Plaintiff from the probate proceedings was named as the Defendant to defend the proceedings. These proceedings were dismissed due to the decision in the probate proceedings. The question then arose whether the Defendant should receive any costs from the family provision proceedings. There was no dispute that the Plaintiffs in the family provision proceedings should receive their costs as part of the Defendant/Cross-Claimant's costs in the probate proceedings. Affidavits were read in the probate proceedings.

The matter came before the court in two separate proceedings: probate and family provision. In the probate proceedings, the Plaintiff, who was the executor named in the deceased's Will, was unsuccessful in propounding the Will. The court agreed to grant probate in solemn form of an informal Will to the Defendant/Cross-Claimant if the executed Will was not granted. The issue of costs was raised, with the Plaintiff arguing that their costs should be paid from the estate on an indemnity basis. The Defendant/Cross-Claimant argued for indemnity costs to be paid from the estate.

In the family provision proceedings, the Plaintiff from the probate proceedings was named as the Defendant. These proceedings were dismissed due to the outcome of the probate proceedings. The court then had to decide whether the Defendant should receive any costs from the family provision proceedings and whether these costs should be part of the Defendant/Cross-Claimant's costs in the probate proceedings. The Plaintiffs in the family provision proceedings were to receive their costs as part of the Defendant/Cross-Claimant's costs.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the costs of the Plaintiff in the probate proceedings, calculated on the indemnity basis, should be paid out of the estate of the deceased.
2. Whether the Defendant in the family provision proceedings should receive any costs from those proceedings.
3. Whether the costs of the Plaintiffs in the family provision proceedings should be part of the Defendant/Cross-Claimant's costs in the probate proceedings.
4. Whether an order should be made for the assessment of the Defendant/Cross-Claimant's costs in both the probate and family provision proceedings.

Held
1. The court held that the costs of the Plaintiff in the probate proceedings, calculated on the indemnity basis, should not be paid out of the estate of the deceased.
2. The court held that the Defendant in the family provision proceedings should receive his costs, calculated on the indemnity basis, out of the estate of the deceased.
3. The court held that the costs of the Plaintiffs in the family provision proceedings should be part of the Defendant/Cross-Claimant's costs in the probate proceedings.
4. The court held that an order should be made for the assessment of the Defendant/Cross-Claimant's costs in both the probate and family provision proceedings.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court addressed the issue of whether the costs of the Plaintiff in the probate proceedings, calculated on the indemnity basis, should be paid out of the estate of the deceased. The Plaintiff, who was the executor named in the Will, was unsuccessful in propounding the Will, leading to a solemn form of an informal Will being granted to the Defendant/Cross-Claimant. The court reasoned that since the Plaintiff was unsuccessful, it was equitable that the costs should not be paid out of the estate of the deceased, even though calculated on the indemnity basis. This decision was based on the principle that unsuccessful parties should not be compensated from the estate of the deceased in probate proceedings.

Regarding the Defendant in the family provision proceedings, the court concluded that he should receive his costs, calculated on the indemnity basis, out of the estate of the deceased. This was because the Plaintiff, who was named as the Defendant in the family provision proceedings, was unsuccessful in the probate proceedings, and there was no dispute that the Defendant/Cross-Claimant should receive his costs. The court applied the principle that successful parties in family provision proceedings should be compensated from the estate of the deceased.

The court also addressed the issue of whether the costs of the Plaintiffs in the family provision proceedings should be part of the Defendant/Cross-Claimant's costs in the probate proceedings. The court held that these costs should indeed be part of the Defendant/Cross-Claimant's costs in the probate proceedings, as the family provision proceedings were dismissed as a result of the decision in the probate proceedings. This decision was based on the principle that the costs of related proceedings should be considered together when determining the overall costs.

Finally, the court held that an order should be made for the assessment of the Defendant/Cross-Claimant's costs in both the probate and family provision proceedings. This decision was based on the principle that the quantum of costs should be determined by a court-appointed officer, ensuring fairness and transparency in the assessment process. The court also considered the request from one of the beneficiaries in the informal Will, who sought an order for the assessment of the costs.