Connor v Australian Financial Complaints Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 50 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Connor v Australian Financial Complaints Authority [2024] FCA 711  

File number(s): ACD 51 of 2022
Judgment of: HALLEY J
Date of judgment: 3 July 2024
Catchwords: APPEALS – appeal from determination of the Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA) affirming decision of the Commonwealth Superannuation Corporation (CSC) as trustee of the Commonwealth Superannuation Scheme – where AFCA determined the CSC’s decisions were fair and reasonable – scope and content of appeals to the Federal Court on a “question of law” pursuant to s 1057 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (Act) – whether AFCA’s determination was “contrary to law” within the meaning of s 1055(7) of the Act – whether determination “contrary to law” because AFCA did not apply common law legal principles on damages – s 1055(7) of the Act does not impose positive obligation on AFCA to make determinations consistently with common law legal principles in the same manner as a court – where the Act directs attention to whether decision was “fair and reasonable” in its operation in relation to complainant – whether AFCA’s determination was unreasonable, illogical or irrational – whether determination lacked any evident or intelligible justification – AFCA’s determination was not a decision that no reasonable decision maker could make – whether AFCA failed to respond to substantial, clearly articulated argument – whether AFCA overlooked applicant’s principal complaint – AFCA’s determination must be considered as a whole and read fairly and broadly – grounds of appeal not made out – appeal dismissed
Legislation:

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) Pt 7.10A, ss 1053, 1055, 1057

Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 (Cth) s 304-10

Superannuation (Resolution of Complaints) Act 1993 (Cth) s 37

Superannuation Industry (Supervision) Regulations 1994 (Cth)

Tax and Superannuation Laws Amendment (Release Conditions for Non-concessional Contributions) Regulation 2015 (Cth)

Treasury Laws Amendment (Putting Consumers First – Establishment of the Australian Financial Complaints Authority) Act 2018 (Cth)

Cases cited:

Board of Trustees of the State Public Sector Superannuation Scheme v Edington (2011) 119 ALD 472; [2011] FCAFC 8

Danichnikov v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural & Indigenous Affairs (2003) 197 ALR 389; [2003] HCA 26

Investors Exchange Ltd v Australian Financial Complaints Authority Ltd [2020] QSC 74

Minister for Immigration & Border Protection v Eden (2016) 240 FCR 158; [2016] FCAFC 28

Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v Li (2013) 249 CLR 332; [2013] HCA 18

Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v SZMDS (2010) 240 CLR 611; [2010] HCA 16

Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs v Liang (1996) 185 CLR 259

QSuper Board v Australian Financial Complaints Authority (2020) 276 FCR 97; [2020] FCAFC 55

R v Australian Broadcasting Tribunal; Ex parte Hardiman (1980) 144 CLR 13

Rauchle v Q-Super Board [2022] FCA 1537

Retail Employees Superannuation Pty Ltd v Crocker (2001) 48 ATR 359; [2001] FCA 1330

Rushton v Commonwealth Security Corporation (No 3) [2021] FCA 358

Sharma v H.E.S.T. Australia Ltd (2022) 159 ACSR 635; [2022] FCA…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Connor v Australian Financial Complaints Authority and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] FCA 711
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Connor v Australian Financial Complaints Authority, the appellant, Mr Connor, contested the Australian Financial Complaints Authority's (AFCA) decision to affirm the Commonwealth Superannuation Corporation's (CSC) decisions regarding his superannuation benefits. Mr Connor argued that the CSC's decisions, which involved not compensating him beyond the additional taxation liability and not providing certain information, were unfair and unreasonable. The central issue before the court was whether AFCA erred in its determination that the CSC's decisions were fair and reasonable under section 1055 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth).

The court examined whether AFCA's decision was "contrary to law" under section 1055(7) of the Act, which mandates that AFCA must not make decisions that would be contrary to law. The court noted that section 1055(7) does not impose a positive obligation on AFCA to align its decisions with common law legal principles, but rather, it requires that decisions not contravene the law. The court also considered whether AFCA's decision was unreasonable, illogical, or irrational, and whether it lacked any evident or intelligible justification. After a thorough analysis, the court found that AFCA's determination was not a decision that no reasonable decision maker could make, and it was not contrary to law. The court concluded that the appeal did not meet the necessary threshold, and AFCA's determination was affirmed.

The court dismissed the appeal and upheld AFCA's decision, noting that the statutory provisions focused on fairness and reasonableness, rather than strict legal rights and liabilities. Consequently, the appeal was dismissed, and the parties were instructed to submit their costs-related submissions by a specified date. The court's decision underscored the distinction between the statutory mandate for fairness and reasonableness and the common law principles of compensation and damages.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The further amended notice of appeal be dismissed.

2. The parties are to file and serve any submissions as to costs, not exceeding three pages in length, and any affidavits in support, by 4.30 pm on Wednesday, 17 July 2024, and any dispute as to costs will be determined on the papers unless a party seeks an oral hearing.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons that follow, I have determined that the appeal must be dismissed, and AFCA’s determination is to be affirmed. B. BACKGROUND Mr Connor was born in 1965. On 19 January 1984, Mr Connor joined the CSS and made contributions up to his retirement on 2 January 2020. On 10 November 2014, Mr Connor was provided with a formal benefit estimate statement from the CSC, which provided the following retirement benefit options available to him for 31 March 2015: (a) preserved benefit, (b) payment of a transfer value to another eligible scheme, (c) full lump sum with no pension, (d) maximum pension plus refund of productivity component, or (e) standard pension plus refund of member and productivity components. In July 2015, the definition of “preservation age” in the Superannuation Industry (Supervision) Regulations 1994 (Cth) (SIS Regulations) was changed, relevantly for Mr Connor, from 55 years to 60 years, pursuant to the Tax and Superannuation Laws Amendment (Release Conditions for Non-concessional Contributions) Regulation 2015 (Cth). The CSC did not immediately incorporate this definition change in its systems, and therefore, for a period of time, members who had not yet reached the “preservation age”, as amended, were able to select a retirement option to receive their productivity benefit as a lump sum payment, contrary to the requirements in the SIS Regulations. Mr Connor was one of these members. On or about 6 April 2018, Mr Connor changed his investment profile with the CSC from the default option with a higher risk and higher return (Default) to the cash option with a lower risk and lower return (Cash). On 23 August 2019, the CSC provided Mr Connor with another benefit estimate which provided three retirement options available to Mr Connor for 2 January 2020: (a) a preserved benefit, (b) a payment of a transfer value to another eligible scheme, or (c) a full lump sum payment with no pension. Mr Connor elected to take the full lump sum payment with no pension. On 2 January 2020, Mr Connor retired from employment. On 7 January 2020, Mr Connor reached the age of 55. On 15 January 2020, the CSC made a lump sum payment to Mr Connor, in the amount of $128,165.75 (gross). On 27 February 2020, the CSC identified that it had incorrectly interpreted the legislation, and that the lump sum option should have been rolled over until Mr Connor reached his preservation age of 60 years old. By a letter dated 17 March 2020, the CSC reported the error to the Australian Taxation Office (ATO) and requested the Commissioner of Taxation (Commissioner) to exercise their discretion under s 304-10(4) of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 (Cth) so that the incorrectly paid lump sum productivity benefits could remain subject to concessional superannuation lump sum tax rates, as opposed to marginal tax rates. This would have the effect that the 306 incorrectly paid members would not incur any negative tax effects because of the CSC’s error. The Commissioner acceded to that request.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The principal issue arising on this appeal is whether AFCA made an error of law in forming the opinion that the CSC’s decisions were fair and reasonable in all the circumstances, in relation to:(a)the CSC’s decision not to pay Mr Connor any compensation beyond the additional taxation liability of $1,621.90 (Compensation Decision); and(b)the CSC’s decision not to provide certain information to Mr Connor (Information Request Decision). Mr Connor seeks for the Determination to be set aside, and for the matter to be remitted to AFCA for determination in accordance with the law. For the reasons that follow, I have determined that the appeal must be dismissed, and AFCA’s determination is to be affirmed. B. BACKGROUND Mr Connor was born in 1965. On 19 January 1984, Mr Connor joined the CSS and made contributions up to his retirement on 2 January 2020. On 10 November 2014, Mr Connor was provided with a formal benefit estimate statement from the CSC, which provided the following retirement benefit options available to him for 31 March 2015: (a) preserved benefit, (b) payment of a transfer value to another eligible scheme, (c) full lump sum with no pension, (d) maximum pension plus refund of productivity component, or (e) standard pension plus refund of member and productivity components. In July 2015, the definition of “preservation age” in the Superannuation Industry (Supervision) Regulations 1994 (Cth) (SIS Regulations) was changed, relevantly for Mr Connor, from 55 years to 60 years, pursuant to the Tax and Superannuation Laws Amendment (Release Conditions for Non-concessional Contributions) Regulation 2015 (Cth). The CSC did not immediately incorporate this definition change in its systems, and therefore, for a period of time, members who had not yet reached the “preservation age”, as amended, were able to select a retirement option to receive their productivity benefit as a lump sum payment, contrary to the requirements in the SIS Regulations. Mr Connor was one of these members. On or about 6 April 2018, Mr Connor changed his investment profile with the CSC from the default option with a higher risk and higher return (Default) to the cash option with a lower risk and lower return (Cash). On 23 August 2019, the CSC provided Mr Connor with another benefit estimate which provided three retirement options available to Mr Connor for 2 January 2020: (a) a preserved benefit, (b) a payment of a transfer value to another eligible scheme, or (c) a full lump sum payment with no pension. Mr Connor elected to take the full lump sum payment with no pension. On 2 January 2020, Mr Connor retired from employment. On 7 January 2020, Mr Connor reached the age of 55. On 15 January 2020, the CSC made a lump sum payment to Mr Connor, in the amount of $128,165.75 (gross). On 27 February 2020, the CSC identified that it had incorrectly interpreted the legislation, and that the lump sum option should have been rolled over until Mr Connor reached his preservation age of 60 years old.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The CSC submits that whether a court properly assessing the strict legal rights and liabilities of the parties may have reached a different conclusion is insufficient to demonstrate that a decision is “contrary to law”. F.1.4. Consideration The contention that AFCA must apply legal and equitable principles applicable to the determination of compensation in negligent misstatement cases in determining whether a decision is fair and reasonable for the purposes of s 1055 of the Corporations Act is not supported by the text, context or legislative purpose of that provision and the other provisions in Div 3 of Pt 7.10A of the Corporations Act. The statutory text of s 1055 of the Corporations Act is directed at the concepts of “fairn[ess]” and “reasonable[ness]”. Most relevantly, ss 1055(2), (4) and (6) of the Corporations Act provide that AFCA (a) must affirm a decision or conduct if it is satisfied that the decision or conduct was “fair and reasonable in all the circumstances”, and (b) may, if it is satisfied that a decision or conduct is “unfair or unreasonable, or both,” vary or set aside the decision, and (c) may only vary or set aside a decision for the purpose of placing the complainant, as nearly as practicable, in such a position that any “unfairness, unreasonableness, or both” no longer exists. Placing a complainant in a position where, as nearly as practicable, any unfairness or unreasonableness no longer exists does not carry with it any necessary implication that the concepts of fairness and reasonableness are constrained by equitable and common law principles for the assessment of loss. Further, s 1055(7) of the Corporations Act provides that AFCA must not make a decision that “would be contrary to law”. It is a negative stipulation, it does not impose a positive obligation to make determinations consistently with any legal and equitable principles. It naturally speaks to the terms of the relevant trust deed or statutory provisions, as identified by Rares J in Rushton at [50]. The Revised Explanatory Memorandum to the Treasury Laws Amendment (Putting Consumers First – Establishment of the Australian Financial Complaints Authority) Act 2018 (Cth) stated that (a) the AFCA scheme will provide a “fast and fair” resolution of disputes between consumers and providers of financial and credit services (at [1.4]), (b) the AFCA scheme will be based on an ombudsman model (at [1.14]), (c) AFCA members will be contractually bound to comply with AFCA’s operating rules (at [1.15]), (d) although the operational aspects of the AFCA scheme will be based on contractual obligations between AFCA and the financial firms who are members of the scheme, AFCA will be provided with certain statutory powers to enable it to manage superannuation complaints effectively (at [1.25]), and (e) a right of appeal on a question of law to the Federal Court will be maintained for superannuation complaints given the compulsory nature of superannuation and the obligation imposed on trustees to act in the best interests of all the beneficiaries of a fund (at [1.36]).