EEU20 v Meat Industry Employees' Superannuation Fund Pty Ltd (Trustee)

Link copied
Case Copied 50 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

EEU20 v Meat Industry Employees’ Superannuation Fund Pty Ltd (Trustee) [2020] FCA 1359

File number: VID 946 of 2019
Judgment of: MORTIMER J
Date of judgment: 23 September 2020
Catchwords: SUPERANNUATION – appeal from decision of the Superannuation Complaints Tribunal – death benefit –deceased and another man died in a fight – primary beneficiary charged with the murder of the other man shortly before the Tribunal’s decision – Tribunal did not adjourn or seek further information – procedural fairness – legal unreasonableness – relevant considerations
Legislation:

Superannuation (Resolution of Complaints) Act 1993 (Cth) ss 25, 33, 34, 37, 42, 46

Superannuation Industry (Supervision) Act 1993 (Cth) s 52

Cases cited:

AIA Australia Ltd v Lancaster [2017] FCA 962

Board of Trustees of the State Public Sector Superannuation Scheme vEdington [2011] FCAFC 8; 119 ALD 472

Chapman v QSuper Board [2020] FCA 88

Citicorp Life Insurance Ltd v Smith [2005] FCAFC 102

Commonwealth Bank Officers Superannuation Corporation Pty Ltd v Beck [2016] NSWCA 218; 334 ALR 692

Dranichnikov v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2003] HCA 26; 197 ALR 389

Finch v Telstra Super Pty Ltd [2010] HCA 36; 242 CLR 254

Kioa v West [1985] HCA 81; 159 CLR 550

Mercer Superannuation (Australia) Ltd v Billinghurst [2016] FCA 1274; 161 ALD 338

Minister for Aboriginal Affairs v Peko-Wallsend [1986] HCA 40; 162 CLR 24

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v MZYTS [2013] FCAFC 114; 230 FCR 431

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v Singh [2014] FCAFC 1; 231 FCR 437

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v Stretton [2016] FCAFC 11; 237 FCR 1

Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v Li [2013] HCA 18; 249 CLR 332

Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v SZJSS [2010] HCA 48; 243 CLR 164

Retail Employees Superannuation Pty Ltd v Crocker [2001] FCA 1330; 48 ATR 359

Southwell v Equity Trustees Ltd [2015] FCA 536

Stead v State Government Insurance Commission [1986] HCA 54; 161 CLR 141

Division: General Division
Registry: Victoria
National Practice Area: Administrative and Constitutional Law and Human Rights
Number of paragraphs: 102
Date of hearing: 15 June 2020
Counsel for the Applicants: Mr S Burt
Solicitor for the Applicants: Legal GP

ORDERS

VID 946 of 2019
BETWEEN:

EEU20 BY HER LITIGATION REPRESENTATIVE EEV20

First Applicant

EEW20

Second Applicant

EEX20

Third Applicant

AND:

MEAT INDUSTRY EMPLOYEES’ SUPERANNUATION FUND PTY LTD AS TRUSTEE OF THE MEAT INDUSTRY EMPLOYEES’ SUPERANNUATION FUND

First Respondent

SUPERANNUATION COMPLAINTS TRIBUNAL

Second Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

MORTIMER J

DATE OF ORDER:

23 SEPTEMBER 2020

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Until further order, pursuant to s 37AF(1)(a) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), on the ground specified in s 37AG(1)(a):

(a)all references in the file and reasons to the first applicant by name are to be replaced with the pseudonym “EEU20”;

(b)all references in the file and reasons to the second applicant by name are…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read EEU20 v Meat Industry Employees' Superannuation Fund Pty Ltd... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] FCA 1359
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of EEU20 v Meat Industry Employees' Superannuation Fund Pty Ltd (Trustee) involved a dispute over the distribution of a deceased member's death benefit. The deceased member had recently remarried and died in a violent altercation with the spouse's ex-husband. The deceased member's three daughters, the applicants, sought a review of the trustee's decision to distribute the death benefit to the spouse. The Superannuation Complaints Tribunal (SCT) upheld the trustee's decision, leading to the applicants' appeal to the Federal Court of Australia. The central legal issue was whether the SCT's decision was legally unreasonable due to procedural unfairness and whether the SCT failed to consider relevant factors. The applicants argued that the SCT did not properly consider the potential involvement of the spouse in the deceased's death and the ex-husband's death, as well as the spouse's motivations for nominating herself as the sole beneficiary.

The court found that the SCT's decision was legally unreasonable. The SCT did not adjourn the proceedings or seek further information despite the applicants' submission that the spouse had been charged with the murder of the ex-husband shortly before the SCT's decision. The court emphasised that the SCT's role was to determine if the trustee's decision was fair and reasonable, but it failed to consider critical allegations and evidence regarding the spouse's potential involvement in the deceased member's death and her motivations for altering the nomination of dependants. The court concluded that the SCT's failure to consider these factors constituted a procedural unfairness and resulted in a legally unreasonable decision.

The court allowed the application, set aside the SCT's decision, and remitted the matter back to the SCT for reconsideration according to law. The court also ordered that the applicants' names and their mother's name be replaced with pseudonyms for privacy reasons. Furthermore, it was ordered that the applicants' mother be appointed as litigation representative for the first applicant and that leave be required for any non-party to access any document on the Court’s file. The applicants were given a deadline to file submissions for any orders for costs, with a corresponding deadline for the respondents to respond.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Until further order, pursuant to s 37AF(1)(a) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), on the ground specified in s 37AG(1)(a):

(a) all references in the file and reasons to the first applicant by name are to be replaced with the pseudonym “EEU20”;

(b) all references in the file and reasons to the second applicant by name are to be replaced with the pseudonym “EEW20”;

(c) all references in the file and reasons to the third applicant by name are to be replaced with the pseudonym “EEX20”; and

(d) all references in the file and reasons to the applicants’ mother by name are to be replaced with the pseudonym “EEV20”.

2. Rules 9.63(2) and (3) of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) be dispensed with.

3. EEV20 be appointed as litigation representative for the first applicant.

4. Until further order, leave is required for any non-party to access any document on the Court’s file.

5. The application be allowed.

6. Set aside the decision of the Superannuation Complaints Tribunal made on 30 July 2019.

7. Remit the matter to the Superannuation Complaints Tribunal to be dealt with according to law.

8. If the applicants seek any orders for costs:

(a) the applicants are to file and serve written submissions, limited to two pages, specifying the orders sought, by 30 September 2020; and

(b) the respondents are to file and serve any written submissions in response, limited to two pages, by 7 October 2020.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons set out below the application will be allowed, the decision of the Tribunal made on 30 July 2019 set aside, and the matter remitted to the Tribunal for determination according to law.BACKGROUND The deceased died on 12 March 2016 at 49 years of age. He was recently re-married, with two step-sons. He had three daughters from his former marriage, the applicants. He died in violent circumstances, during a fight with another man, who was the spouse’s ex-husband. In early 2019, the spouse was charged with the murder of her ex-husband. It was the circumstances which led to that event which were the catalyst for the applicants’ challenge before the Tribunal to the proposed distribution by the trustee, and which form the factual basis for their arguments on this application. To understand those circumstances, it is necessary to set out the narrative that emerges from the documents contained in the court book and supplementary court book, all of which were before the Tribunal on its review. For present purposes, the narrative begins with the deceased commencing a relationship with the spouse. There were differing accounts before the Tribunal as to when this happened. The spouse said it was in November 2014. The deceased’s daughters provided death benefit application forms to the trustee in which they said it was 16 February 2015. There is no explanation why the Tribunal selected (as it did) the account of the spouse. On 18 June 2015, the deceased completed a nomination of dependants form as follows:(a)The oldest daughter: 20%(b)The middle daughter: 20%(c)The youngest daughter: 20%(d)The spouse: 40% At that time, the oldest daughter was 18 years old, the middle daughter was 16 years old, and the youngest daughter was 14 years old. On 20 January 2016, the deceased completed a new nomination of dependants form. That form altered the proportions to the following:(a)The oldest daughter: 10%(b)The middle daughter: 10%(c)The youngest daughter: 10%(d)The spouse: 70% At that time, the oldest daughter was 18 years old, the middle daughter was 17 years old, and the youngest daughter was 15 years old. On 27 February 2016, the deceased married the spouse. On 12 March 2016, as I have stated, the deceased died. A media report of the death of the deceased and the spouse’s ex-husband, which was before the Tribunal, stated:Homicide squad detectives have spoken with [the spouse’s ex-husband’s] partner, [redacted], who was taken to the Royal Melbourne Hospital in a serious but stable condition and later discharged. In other words, the information before the Tribunal indicated that at least four people were reported to have been involved in the men’s deaths – the spouse, the deceased, the spouse’s ex-husband and his partner. On 26 May 2016, the applicants completed death benefit application forms, seeking one third each of the deceased’s death benefit. The oldest daughter wrote:The reason I would like 1/3 of the amout is due to being 1 of his 3 biological daughters and I am not working due to the grief. Also we have not got any of Dads belongings due to his wife (of two weeks) keeping everything and planning his whole service and not allowing me nor by sisters any part in anything. And [the spouse’s] boy will be getting his father’s money and no doubt she will try and get everything if possible like she already has.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 21 August 2019, the former spouse wrote to the Tribunal stating:I am writing as I am surprised a decision has been made since circumstances have changed.I have sent emails to [redacted] and received no response and when I have tried to phone I have been told she is not available or on leave.[The spouse] was charged with murder and has been in jail since the 19/6/19. She has been charged with the murder of [redacted], her ex partner and father of her youngest son, [redacted]. [The deceased] died the same night. [Redacted] is the detective involved in the case since they both died and is available to answer any questions you have. His number is [redacted].I await a swift response as if you are unwilling to put a decision on hold I only have till the 27/8/19 to apply to court as stated in the last emails from the SCT tribuneral.THE TRIBUNAL’S DECISION On 1 August 2019, the Tribunal issued its determination, which is dated 30 July 2019. The Tribunal set aside the decision of the trustee and substituted it with the same decision, save that tax was not deducted from the oldest daughter’s 10%. At [8], the Tribunal appears to note the email I have extracted at [39] above, describing it as “further information” which was provided to all parties. At [17], the Tribunal set out the relevant parts of the trust deed in its reasons, which I reproduce below at [66] to [71]. There is no doubt that all of the applicants, as well as the spouse and her two sons, fell within the definition of “dependent”. As I have explained, the former spouse had not contended any part of the deceased’s death benefit should be paid to her. That is, her submissions to the Tribunal were on behalf of her daughters. The Tribunal set out aspects of the parties’ submissions before it. It did not set out those parts of the material submitted by the former spouse and her daughters which went to the truthfulness and motivations of the spouse in making a claim for 100% of the deceased’s death benefit, nor the allegation of her role in the deceased’s change of death benefit preferences in the weeks before his death, all of which I have summarised above. At [21]-[22], the Tribunal emphasised its role was to determine if the trustee’s decision was fair and reasonable, rather than to decide for itself how the trustee’s discretion should be exercised. At [33]-[34], the Tribunal found:Further, the Spouse contends the Deceased Member’s death has resulted in her facing considerable financial difficulties. In the absence of any contrary evidence, the Tribunal accepts this to be the case.In her final submission to the Tribunal, the Former Spouse made some allegations about the Spouse. However, these allegations are uncorroborated by independent evidence. Regardless of the veracity of these allegations, the issue for the Tribunal’s consideration is whether the Spouse was a dependant of the Deceased Member at the date of his death. For the reasons articulated above the Tribunal is so satisfied.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established