Sunshine Coast Broadcasters Pty Ltd v The Australian Communications & Media Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 77 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Sunshine Coast Broadcasters Pty Ltd v The Australian Communications and Media Authority [2012] FCA 1205

Citation: Sunshine Coast Broadcasters Pty Ltd v The Australian Communications & Media Authority [2012] FCA 1205
Parties: SUNSHINE COAST BROADCASTERS PTY LTD (ACN 009 719 528), SOUTHERN CROSS MEDIA SERVICES PTY LTD (ACN 010 711 056), SOUTHERN CROSS MEDIA AUSTRALIA PTY LTD (ACN 109 243 110), SOUTHERN CROSS MEDIA AUSTRALIA HOLDINGS PTY LTD (ACN 110 357 036) and SOUTHERN CROSS MEDIA GROUP LTD (ACN 116 024 536) v THE AUSTRALIAN COMMUNICATIONS AND MEDIA AUTHORITY
File number: VID 1155 of 2011
Judge: KENNY J
Date of judgment: 2 November 2012
Catchwords:

STATUTORY INTERPRETATION — Broadcasting Services Act 1992 (Cth) — Functions under sections 24, 25 and 26 — Authority received request to vary a licence area plan under section 26(2) — Whether decision not to propose draft variation to licence area plan performed function under section 26(2) — Decision performed function incidental or conducive to function under section 26(2) — Decision performed function under section 10(1)(s) of the Australian Communications and Media Authority Act 2005 (Cth).

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW — Judicial review of decision incidental to a function under the Broadcasting Services Act 1992 (Cth) — Authority received request to vary a licence area plan under section 26(2) — Section 27(1) required provision for wide public consultation when varying a licence area plan — Decision not to propose a variation — No public consultation conducted — Whether wide public consultation required — Whether authority misdirected itself — Whether failure to take account of a relevant consideration — Whether irrelevant considerations taken into account — Wide public consultation not required — No related basis for review — Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 (Cth) ss 5(1)(b), 5(1)(e), 5(1)(f), 5(2)(a), 5(2)(b).

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW — Judicial review of decision incidental to a function under the Broadcasting Services Act 1992 (Cth) — Authority received request to vary a licence area plan under section 26(2) — Authority applied policy not to vary licence area plans without good reason — Whether decision made in accordance with policy without regard to the merits of the case — Where policy required consideration of merits — Where authority had regard to merits — No basis for review — Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 (Cth) ss 5(1)(e), 5(2)(f).

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW — Judicial review of decision incidental to a function under the Broadcasting Services Act 1992 (Cth) — Authority received request to vary a licence area plan under section 26(2) — Authority considered there was no sufficient reason to propose a variation — Whether decision so unreasonable that no reasonable person could have so decided — Where authority considered request and conducted additional research — Where authority’s conclusion open on the evidence it considered — Decision not unreasonable — Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 (Cth) ss 5(1)(e), 5(2)(g).

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE — Leave to amend application for judicial review after hearing — Applicants proposed to add two further grounds of review —…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sunshine Coast Broadcasters Pty Ltd v The Australian Communi... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] FCA 1205
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Sunshine Coast Broadcasters Pty Ltd, controlled by Southern Cross Media Group Ltd, sought judicial review of a decision by the Australian Communications and Media Authority (ACMA) to decline its request to vary the Nambour licence area plan (LAP). The applicants argued that the ACMA was required to conduct wide public consultation before declining the request, as mandated by s 27(1) of the Broadcasting Services Act 1992 (Cth). They further contended that the ACMA misdirected itself by not considering relevant factors and took into account irrelevant considerations.

The primary legal issue was whether the ACMA was required to conduct wide public consultation before declining the request to vary the LAP. This depended on whether the decision was made in the course of performing a function under s 26(2) of the Broadcasting Services Act 1992 (Cth), which would engage s 27(1). The court found that the statutory context, nature of the functions conferred on the ACMA, and the purpose of the obligation under s 27(1) did not support the applicants' proposition that the ACMA was required to undertake a function under s 26 merely by requesting a variation of a LAP. Therefore, the obligation under s 27(1) did not arise.

The court also considered whether the ACMA had misdirected itself by not considering relevant factors and taking into account irrelevant considerations. It found that the ACMA had considered the merits of the case, in accordance with its policy, and had conducted additional research to reach its conclusion that there was no sufficient case to propose a variation to the Nambour LAP. The court held that the decision was open on the evidence the ACMA considered and was not so unreasonable that no reasonable person could have so decided.

The court rejected the applicants' proposed amendments to their application for judicial review, finding that the new grounds were not fairly arguable. The court dismissed the application and ordered the parties to file any submissions on costs by 9 November 2012.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The applicants have leave to amend their amended application for an order of review in the terms of pages 3–7 and in the terms of the proposed amendments to paragraphs [6] and [7] on page 8 of their draft further amended application. Leave to amend is not otherwise granted.

2. The application is dismissed.

3. On or before 4:30 pm on 9 November 2012, the parties file any submissions on costs that they wish to make, having regard to the reasons for judgment delivered today.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicants relied on the affidavits of their solicitor, Howard Roger Rapke, sworn on 9 December 2011 and 7 February 2012. The ACMA relied on the affidavit of Sophie Kowald affirmed on 9 December 2011. Ms Kowald had the position of Business Manager, Digital Transition Division at the ACMA. There was no cross-examination.FACTUAL BACKGROUND Sunshine, which is controlled by Southern Cross Media Group Ltd (“Southern Cross Media”), holds two commercial radio broadcasting licences in the Nambour RA1 licence area established by the Nambour LAP prepared under s 26 of the Broadcasting Services Act 1992 (Cth) (“the BS Act”). The Nambour RA1 licence area, which broadly covers the Sunshine Coast region, lies immediately to the north of, and overlaps with, the Brisbane RA1 licence area. On 17 May 2011, Southern Cross Media finalised a corporate takeover. As part of this takeover, it had become, on 15 March 2011, a controller of two commercial radio broadcasting licences in the Brisbane RA1 licence area. Broadly speaking, under s 51 of the BS Act, the Brisbane RA1 licence area and the Nambour RA1 licence area are treated as one licence area for the purposes of Part 5 of the BS Act. This follows from a determination made by the ACMA on 16 June 2009 under s 30(5)(b) of the BS Act that in excess of 30% of the population of the Nambour RA1 licence area was attributable to the area overlapping with the Brisbane RA1 licence area. The result is that Southern Cross Media is in a position to control four commercial radio broadcasting licences in the same licence area. Section 54 of the BS Act provides that a person must not be in a position to exercise control of more than two commercial radio broadcasting licences in the same licence area. Section 67 of the BS Act permits a person to apply to the ACMA for an approval of a breach before a transaction that would place a person in breach of a provision such as s 54. On 25 March 2011, the ACMA approved a temporary breach of s 54 by Southern Cross Media for twelve months and issued a notice under ss 67(4)–(6) that required Southern Cross Media to divest itself of two licences by March 2012. On 23 February 2012, the ACMA determined to grant an extension of time for compliance under s 68. The current divestiture deadline appears to be 24 March 2013.Sunshine’s request On 25 May 2011, Sunshine requested that the ACMA vary the Nambour LAP to remove or reduce the overlap between the Nambour RA1 and Brisbane RA1 licence areas. If this were done, then these areas would cease to be deemed to be one area for the purposes of the prohibition in s 54. In their letter of 25 May 2011, Sunshine’s lawyers stated:We are enclosing an application by our client in accordance with section 26 of the Broadcasting Services Act 1992 (Cth) to vary the licence plan for Nambour RA1.Our client submits that the licence area should be decreased to remove the southern part of the licence area south of Beerburrum (including Bribie Island but retaining the Caboolture Hinterland) because, in the first place, the coverage within that part of the licence area, from FM transmitters located [at] Bald Knob, does not meet the minimum field strength for commercial FM radio services as specified in the ACMA Broadcasting Planning Manual and, in the second place, because there is little, if any, demographic connection between the residents of the southern part of the Nambour licence area and the remainder of the Nambour licence area.The request was accompanied by an expert’s report on radio coverage issues and a report on socio-economic and planning considerations prepared by SGS Economics and Planning (“SGS”).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The ACMA considered the ACMA paper at its meeting of 25 August 2011 and “agreed for the reasons set out in the paper that there was no sufficient case to propose a variation to the Nambour LAP changing the boundary of Nambour RA1”.Developments after the decision On 26 August 2011, a representative of the ACMA sent an email to Sunshine, stating that he “confirm[ed] [his] advice over the telephone yesterday that the Authority [had] decided not to issue a draft licence area plan for the Nambour RA1 licence area”. The email further stated:Having regard to the request to vary the Nambour RA1 LAP by changing the boundary of the licence area, the Authority decided that the objects of the Broadcasting Services Act 1992 (BSA) were best promoted by not proposing to vary the Nambour RA1 licence area plan.The Authority’s decision was based on an assessment of your clients’ specific arguments and the merits of the proposed variation against the broadcast planning requirements of the BSA. On balance, the Authority found that the submissions on the quality of coverage of the Nambour services, the extent of community-of-interest ties between the overlap area and the remainder of Nambour RA1, and competition and programming issues, as well as the effects of changing the boundary, were not such that they justified varying the licence area plan. Sunshine requested the ACMA’s reasons for the challenged decision. On 23 September 2011, without acknowledging that Sunshine had any entitlement to them, the ACMA provided Sunshine with reasons (“23 September 2011 reasons”). On 18 October 2011, Sunshine sought further details from the ACMA in relation to its reasons for its decision and, on 20 October 2011, the ACMA provided some internet hyperlinks in response to this request.APPLICATION FOR JUDICIAL REVIEW The applicants’ main complaint was that the challenged decision was not authorised by the BS Act because it had not been preceded by “wide public consultation”. The applicants sought to have the challenged decision set aside or quashed and to have Sunshine’s request referred to the ACMA subject to directions requiring the ACMA to carry out wide public consultation and otherwise reconsider the request according to law. The applicants’ originating application, as amended, stated their main point in various ways. It claimed that in making the challenged decision, the ACMA:·failed to observe procedures that were required by law to be observed, by failing to carry out wide public consultation (ground 1);·erred in law, through its misapprehension that it was not required in the circumstances to carry out wide public consultation (ground 2(a));·failed to take into account a relevant consideration, being the views of the public with respect to the proposed variation of the Nambour LAP that would have been received during wide public consultation (ground 4);·took into account an irrelevant consideration, being speculation as to the views of the public that would have been received had there been wide public consultation (grounds 5(a), (b), and (d)(i)).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Section 27, which mandates wide public consultation in certain circumstances, is also important. Section 27 provides as follows:(1)In performing its functions under sections 24, 25 and 26, the ACMA must make provision for wide public consultation.…Record-keeping requirements(2)The ACMA is to keep a record of, and make available for public inspection, all advice received by the ACMA, and all assumptions made by the ACMA, in performing its functions under sections 24, 25 and 26.CONSIDERATIONThe applicability of the wide public consultation requirement — Grounds 1, 2(a) The applicants’ fundamental proposition was that when the ACMA considered Sunshine’s request and decided that there was no sufficient case to propose a variation to the Nambour LAP by changing the boundary of the Nambour RA1 licence area, the ACMA was performing a function under s 26(2) of the BS Act. If this were so, then s 27(1) of the BS Act was engaged. Since s 27(1) required the ACMA to make provision for wide public consultation in performing its functions under s 26, then, so the applicants’ argument ran, the ACMA was in breach of the procedure mandated by the BS Act. The applicants had a subsidiary argument about the nature of the s 27(1) obligation to “make provision for” wide public consultation. Referring to Nezville Pty Ltd v Australian Broadcasting Authority [2001] FCA 29 (“Nezville”) at [37], the applicants maintained that this obligation required the ACMA to undertake the consultation in respect of the whole of a proposed LAP or LAP variation. For present purposes, this may be accepted — providing that the obligation under s 27(1) has arisen. The critical question in this proceeding is whether the obligation arose. If the challenged decision was not made in performance of a function under s 26, then there was no consultation obligation. In this event, it would be unnecessary to express any definitive view about the content of the obligation to which s 27(1) gives rise. There are numerous reasons why I would reject the applicants’ submission that, in making the challenged decision, the ACMA was performing a function under s 26(2) of the BS Act. The primary reason is that the content of Part 3 of the BS Act, the nature of s 26, the text of s 26(2) and the purpose of the obligation created by s 27(1) provide little support for the applicants’ position.Part 3 As already noted, ss 26 and 27 are located in Part 3 of the BS Act. In determining whether the ACMA was performing a function under s 26(2) such as to engage s 27(1), the first step is to consider these provisions in their statutory context. This requires consideration of Part 3 of the BS Act. The nature of the functions conferred on the ACMA by Part 3 militate against the proposition that, merely by requesting a variation of a LAP, Sunshine obliged the ACMA to undertake a function under s 26, thus engaging s 27(1). Part 3 does not, relevantly, operate to confer rights upon individuals. Part 3 sets out a series of steps that must be undertaken before a licence can be granted. The steps, which are of increasing particularity, determine how broadcasting rights will be allocated in a particular region. See generally RG Capital Radio Ltd v Australian Broadcasting Authority (2001) 113 FCR 185 (“RG Capital Radio”) at 190 [19], [21]. These steps include:1.determining, by notice in writing, the priorities as between particular areas of Australia and as between different parts of the broadcasting services bands for the preparation of frequency allotment plans and licence area plans (s 24);2.preparing frequency allotment plans that determine the number of channels available in particular areas of Australia to provide broadcasting services using a relevant part of the radiofrequency spectrum (s 25); and3.preparing LAPs, consistent with the relevant frequency allotment plan, that determine the number and characteristics, including technical specifications, of broadcasting services that are to be available in particular areas of Australia with the use of the broadcasting services bands (s 26(1)).