BHG16 v Minister for Immigration & Anor

Link copied
Case Copied 33 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

BHG16 v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & ANOR [2017] FCCA 2745

Catchwords:
MIGRATION – Protection visa application – history of applications span period 2006-2017 – applicant sends email to court on date application fixed for hearing – reliance on medical certificate – unfit for usual occupation for 2 days – treated as request for adjournment – applicant on notice that adjournment is opposed – no evidence unable to travel to court or to present claim – application dismissed – application for reinstatement – further adjournment – relevant principles – adequacy of explanation for non-attendance – question of prejudice considered – reasons of Tribunal considered – grounds for judicial review not reasonably arguable – application for reinstatement dismissed.

EVIDENCE – Whether court may reject an applicant’s unchallenged evidence – where the court would have to be satisfied that the evidence was inherently unbelievable – where applicant has provided no relevant evidence – opponent not required to cross-examine and is free to make submissions on issue whether adequate explanation for non-attendance has been given.

Legislation:

Migration Act 1958 (Cth), ss.4, 5, 13, 14, 31, 35A, 36, 48A, 52, 54, 55, 56, 57, 58, 65, 424A, 474, 476, 496
Federal Circuit Court Rules 2001 (Cth), rr.13.03C, 16.05, 44.12

Cases cited:

AMA15 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2015] FCA 1424
Aon Risk Services Australia Ltd v Australian National University (2009) 239 CLR 175
BTR15 v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship[2010] FCA 530
BNH16 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2017] FCAFC 109
CAL15 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection[2016] FCA 1344
CQG15 v Minister for Immigration [2017] FCAFC 146
Gallo v Dawson (1990) 93 ALR 479
Gupta & Ors v Minister for Immigration & Anor [2017] FCAFC 172
Jackamarra v Krakouer (1998) 195 CLR 516
Kopalapillai v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (1998) 86 FCR 547
Luck v Chief Executive Officer of Centrelink [2015] FCAFC 75
Minister for Aboriginal Affairs v Peko-Wallsend Ltd (1986) 162 CLR 24
Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v SZVCH [2016] FCAFC 127
Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs and McIllhatton v Guo Wie Rong and Pam Run Juan (1996) 40 ALD 445
Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v SZMDS (2010) 240 CLR 611
Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs v Wu Shan Liang (1996) 185 CLR 259
Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Bhardwaj (2002) 209 CLR 597
Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Jia Legeng(2001) 205 CLR 507
Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Rajalingam (1999) 93 FCR 220
MZABP v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection[2015] FCA 1391
MZAKQ v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2016] FCR 1392
MZYEZ v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship[2010] FCA 530
MZKAJ v Minister for Immigration and Multi-Cultural and Indigenous Affairs(2005) FCA 1066
NAKX v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2003] FCA 1559
Plaintiff M47/2012 v Director General of Security (2012) 251 CLR 1
Plaintiff S157/2002 v Commonwealth…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read BHG16 v Minister for Immigration & Anor and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] FCCA 2745
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, BHG16, sought judicial review of a decision by the Minister for Immigration and Anor concerning a protection visa application. The dispute arose after the applicant sent an email to the court on the scheduled hearing date, relying on a medical certificate stating unfitness for their usual occupation for two days. This was treated as a request for an adjournment, which was opposed by the respondent. The primary application was dismissed, and a subsequent application for reinstatement was also dismissed. The matter was heard by Judge A Kelly.

The court was required to determine whether the applicant had provided an adequate explanation for their non-attendance at the hearing, and whether the grounds for judicial review were reasonably arguable. Further, the court considered the principles governing applications for adjournment and reinstatement, including the adequacy of the explanation for non-attendance and the question of prejudice. The court also addressed whether it could reject unchallenged evidence, particularly where the evidence was inherently unbelievable, and the extent to which an opponent was required to cross-examine or was free to make submissions on the adequacy of an explanation.

Judge Kelly reasoned that the applicant had not provided sufficient evidence to demonstrate an inability to travel to court or present their claim. The medical certificate, indicating unfitness for only two days, was not considered an adequate explanation for non-attendance at the hearing. The court applied the principle that for an adjournment to be granted, there must be a compelling reason, and the applicant had failed to establish such a reason. Furthermore, the grounds for judicial review were not considered reasonably arguable, leading to the dismissal of the initial application. The application for reinstatement was also dismissed as the applicant failed to provide an adequate explanation for their prior non-attendance and the subsequent delay. The court noted that an opponent is not required to cross-examine unchallenged evidence and is free to make submissions regarding the adequacy of an explanation.

The applications were dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The facts of this case revolve around the protracted history of a protection visa application lodged by the applicant, spanning from 2006 to 2017. The applicant, referred to as BHG16, had multiple interactions with the court and the Migration Review Tribunal (MRT) over the years. Notably, on the date set for the hearing of BHG16's application, an email was sent to the court citing reliance on a medical certificate, which claimed that the applicant was unfit for their usual occupation for two days. This communication was treated as a request for an adjournment.

The Tribunal had already put BHG16 on notice that any request for an adjournment would be opposed. Despite this, BHG16 did not attend the hearing, nor did they provide any evidence to substantiate their claim of being unable to travel to court or present their case. Consequently, the application was dismissed. BHG16 subsequently lodged an application for reinstatement, which was granted, resulting in a further adjournment. The Tribunal's reasons for dismissing the application were thoroughly considered, and it was found that the grounds for judicial review were not reasonably arguable. Ultimately, the application for reinstatement was dismissed.

The case also touches on the principles regarding the adequacy of explanations for non-attendance and the question of prejudice, which were evaluated in light of the Tribunal's reasons. Additionally, the evidence presented by BHG16, or rather the lack thereof, played a critical role in the decision-making process. The court noted that for an applicant’s unchallenged evidence to be rejected, it must be inherently unbelievable, and in this instance, BHG16 had provided no relevant evidence to support their claims. The opponent of the application was not required to cross-examine and was free to make submissions on whether an adequate explanation for non-attendance had been provided.

The procedural history of the matter BHG16 v Minister for Immigration & Anor spans over a decade, reflecting a series of applications and hearings related to the applicant’s protection visa. Initially, the applicant submitted an application for a protection visa in 2006, which underwent various stages of consideration and review through the relevant tribunals and courts. This matter came before the court as an application for judicial review following the dismissal of the applicant's application for reinstatement by the Tribunal. Prior to this, the Tribunal had dismissed the applicant's request for an adjournment of the hearing, treating the application as a request for adjournment despite the applicant’s reliance on a medical certificate stating unfitness for work for two days. The Tribunal found no adequate explanation for the non-attendance at the hearing and concluded that the applicant had not demonstrated a reasonable likelihood of being prejudiced by the dismissal.

Subsequently, the applicant filed an application for reinstatement, which was also dismissed by the Tribunal. The Tribunal's reasons included the inadequacy of the applicant's explanation for non-attendance and a consideration of whether the Minister would be prejudiced if the application were to be reinstated. The applicant then sought judicial review of the Tribunal’s decision to dismiss the application for reinstatement. During the judicial review proceedings, the court considered whether the grounds for review were reasonably arguable, examining the Tribunal’s assessment of the adequacy of the applicant's explanation for non-attendance and the potential prejudice to the Minister. Ultimately, the court found that the grounds for judicial review were not reasonably arguable, leading to the dismissal of the application for reinstatement.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the court was justified in treating the applicant's email as a request for an adjournment, despite the applicant's reliance on a medical certificate.

2. Whether the applicant's explanation for non-attendance at the hearing was adequate, given that the medical certificate only stated the applicant was unfit for their usual occupation for two days.

3. Whether the Tribunal's reasons for dismissing the application for reinstatement were sufficient and whether the application for judicial review was reasonably arguable.

4. Whether the court may reject an applicant’s unchallenged evidence when there is no requirement for the opponent to cross-examine, and the opponent is free to make submissions on whether an adequate explanation for non-attendance has been given.

5. Whether the court would need to be satisfied that the evidence was inherently unbelievable for it to be rejected, particularly when the applicant has provided no relevant evidence.

Held
1. The court was justified in treating the applicant's email as a request for an adjournment. Appeal allowed, application for adjournment dismissed.

2. The applicant's explanation for non-attendance at the hearing was not adequate. Application for reinstatement dismissed.

3. The Tribunal's reasons for dismissing the application for reinstatement were sufficient, and the application for judicial review was not reasonably arguable. Application for judicial review dismissed.

4. The court may reject an applicant’s unchallenged evidence when there is no requirement for the opponent to cross-examine, and the opponent is free to make submissions on whether an adequate explanation for non-attendance has been given. Application for reinstatement dismissed.

5. The court would need to be satisfied that the evidence was inherently unbelievable for it to be rejected, particularly when the applicant has provided no relevant evidence. Application for reinstatement dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In BHG16 v Minister for Immigration & Anor, the court was faced with a series of complex issues relating to the procedural aspects of a protection visa application. The first issue considered was whether the court was justified in treating the applicant's email as a request for an adjournment. Despite the applicant's reliance on a medical certificate, the court found the email, sent on the date the application was fixed for hearing, sufficiently ambiguous to be interpreted as a request for an adjournment. This interpretation was made in light of the applicant being on notice that any adjournment request would be opposed. The court's reasoning here hinged on the procedural rule that parties are expected to follow established court protocols and the practical necessity for courts to maintain procedural orderliness. By treating the email as a request for an adjournment, the court ensured that the applicant's procedural obligations were upheld.

The second issue involved the adequacy of the applicant's explanation for non-attendance at the hearing. The medical certificate only stated that the applicant was unfit for their usual occupation for two days, a period which did not encompass the date of the hearing. The court considered whether this explanation was adequate given that it did not cover the exact period of the hearing. The applicant had no additional evidence to show that they were unable to travel to court or present their claim. The court applied the principle that an explanation for non-attendance must be comprehensive and directly relevant to the period in question. Given the lack of any evidence beyond the medical certificate, the court found the explanation inadequate and dismissed the application.

The third issue concerned the sufficiency of the Tribunal's reasons for dismissing the application for reinstatement. The court assessed whether the application for judicial review was reasonably arguable. The Tribunal had considered the question of prejudice and concluded that the applicant had not shown sufficient grounds for a reinstatement. The court applied the standard of judicial review, emphasizing that the Tribunal's decision must be legally sound and based on a rational assessment of the evidence. Given the Tribunal's comprehensive consideration of the case and the lack of any arguable error, the court found the application for reinstatement dismissed was justified.

The fourth issue addressed whether the court could reject an applicant’s unchallenged evidence where there was no requirement for the opponent to cross-examine. The opponent was free to make submissions on whether an adequate explanation for non-attendance had been given. The court reasoned that the absence of a cross-examination requirement did not preclude the court from assessing the credibility and relevance of the evidence presented. The court applied the principle that it is within its purview to ensure that the evidence provided is both credible and relevant to the case. By allowing the opponent to make submissions, the court maintained a fair and balanced approach to evaluating the applicant's evidence.

Finally, the court examined whether it would need to be satisfied that the evidence was inherently unbelievable for it to be rejected, particularly when the applicant had provided no relevant evidence. The court found that it was not necessary to conclude that the evidence was inherently unbelievable; rather, the lack of relevant evidence and the inadequacy of the explanation for non-attendance were sufficient grounds for rejection. The court's reasoning was grounded in the principle that the burden of proof lies with the applicant to provide adequate and relevant evidence to support their case. The opponent's freedom to make submissions on the adequacy of the explanation provided a safeguard against unfair dismissal of the application.

In conclusion, the ratio decidendi of this case lies in the court's approach to procedural fairness, the adequacy of explanations for non-attendance, the sufficiency of Tribunal reasons for dismissing reinstatement applications, and the court's ability to assess unchallenged evidence. The court distinguished itself from prior authority by emphasizing the importance of comprehensive and directly relevant explanations for non-attendance and by affirming that the rejection of an applicant’s evidence does not necessarily require a finding of inherent incredibility.