Nezville Pty Ltd v Australian Broadcasting Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 48 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Nezville Pty Ltd v Australian Broadcasting Authority [2001] FCA 29

BROADCASTING AND RADIOCOMMUNICATIONS ‑ Planning of radio spectrum ‑ Determination of Licence Area Plan (LAP) by Australian Broadcasting Authority ‑ LAP lists numbers of national, commercial, community and open narrowcasting (ONC) radio services to be available for broadcasting ‑ Whether in determining LAP Authority obliged to take into account content and merits of existing ONC licence holders’ programs ‑ In determining LAP Authority obliged to make provision for wide public consultation ‑ Whether Authority did so ‑ Person affected by LAP invited to comment within seven days on proposed change to draft LAP ‑ At request of person affected ten days allowed for comment ‑ Whether extended time limit denial of procedural fairness ‑ Statement in LAP that provider of ONC services “will be determined by use of price based allocation system” ‑ Authority no power to make such determination ‑ Whether a decision of Authority or statement of expectation ‑ Source of Authority’s power to make ONC services available.

Broadcasting Services Act 1992 (Cth) ss 23, 26, 27, 34
Radiocommunications Act 1992 (Cth) ss 31, 100, 102, 106

Minister for Aboriginal Affairs v Peko‑Wallsend Ltd (1986) 162 CLR 24 cited
Bread Manufacturers of NSW v Evans (1981) 180 CLR 404 cited
Melbourne Pathology Pty Ltd v Minister for Human Services and Health (1996) 40 ALD 565 cited
SAT FM Pty Ltd v Australian Broadcasting Authority (1997) 75 FCR 604 cited
Project Blue Sky Inc v Australian Broadcasting Authority (1998) 194 CLR 355 applied

NEZVILLE PTY LTD and HARRY STAMOULIS v AUSTRALIAN BROADCASTING AUTHORITY

V 546 of 2000

SUNDBERG J
31 JANUARY 2001
MELBOURNE


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

V 546 OF 2000

BETWEEN:

NEZVILLE PTY LTD (ACN 006 982 878)
and
HARRY STAMOULIS
APPLICANTS

AND:

AUSTRALIAN BROADCASTING AUTHORITY
RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

SUNDBERG J

DATE OF ORDER:

2 APRIL 2001

WHERE MADE:

MELBOURNE

THE COURT DECLARES THAT the Licence Area Plan for Melbourne Radio determined by the Respondent on 22 June 2000, a copy of which is exhibit “MTS2C” to the affidavit of Michelle Margaret Taylor‑Sands (“the LAP”), is invalid in so far as it provides that:

(a)a commercial radio broadcasting service is to be available on frequency 1116 kHz through service licence number SL 4139 (the applicable part of the second paragraph on page 2 of the LAP, attachment number 1.14 and the applicable part of item 12 in Schedule 1); and

(b)a community broadcasting service is to be available on frequency 1503 kHz through service licence number SL1150722 (the applicable part of the second paragraph on page 2 of the LAP, attachment number 1.23 and item 21 in Schedule 1).

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The relief sought in the Amended Application dated 9 November 2000 be otherwise refused.

2.The operation of the above declaration be stayed for 48 hours.

3.The applicants pay four fifths of the respondent’s costs of the proceeding, including reserved costs.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Nezville Pty Ltd v Australian Broadcasting Authority and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] FCA 29
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Nezville Pty Ltd v Australian Broadcasting Authority involved a challenge by Nezville Pty Ltd against the Australian Broadcasting Authority's (ABA) decision regarding the provision of On-Demand Commercial (ONC) radio services. The central dispute centred around the ABA's authority in determining the availability of radio frequencies and the allocation of apparatus licences for ONC services. The Federal Court of Australia was tasked with determining whether the ABA had correctly exercised its powers under the Broadcasting Services Act 1992 (BS Act) and the Radiocommunications Act 1992 (Radcom Act).

The primary legal issues before the court included whether the ABA had the authority to determine that radio frequencies should be made available for ONC services under section 34 of the BS Act and whether the ABA could establish a price-based allocation system for issuing apparatus licences under section 106 of the Radcom Act. The applicants argued that the ABA had failed to properly assess the need for or benefit of Greek, Chinese, and Italian radio broadcasting services. They also contended that the ABA's decision to implement a price-based allocation system exposed inconsistencies in its policy regarding the relevance of content at different stages of the licensing process.

The court found that the ABA did not have the authority to determine that certain frequencies should be made available for ONC services under section 34 of the BS Act. The court also ruled that the ABA did not have the power to decide on a price-based allocation system for issuing apparatus licences under section 106 of the Radcom Act, as this power was specifically vested in the Australian Communications Authority (ACA) and could not be delegated to the ABA. The court dismissed the applicants' claims, holding that the ABA's decisions were beyond its statutory powers.

In conclusion, the Federal Court upheld the ABA's decisions regarding the availability of radio frequencies and the allocation of apparatus licences for ONC services. The applicants' claims were dismissed, and the court ordered that the applicants pay four-fifths of the respondent's costs of the proceeding, including reserved costs. The operation of the declaration was stayed for 48 hours to allow for any necessary adjustments.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The relief sought in the Amended Application dated 9 November 2000 be otherwise refused.

2. The operation of the above declaration be stayed for 48 hours.

3. The applicants pay four fifths of the respondent’s costs of the proceeding, including reserved costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Class licences are issued under Part 3.4 of the Radcom Act. A class licence authorises a person to operate a radiocommunications device of a kind or for a purpose that may be specified in the licence itself. Class licences may be for the provision of subscription radio broadcasting services, subscription radio narrowcasting services, subscription television narrowcasting services, ONC radio services and ONC television services. Class licences must be consistent with the spectrum plan and any relevant frequency band plan. Class licences may also be determined by the ABA under Part 8 of the BS Act (ss 117‑121). A person who is able to operate under a class licence must also have an apparatus licence. Thus a class licence does not authorise the operation of a radio service. Rather it sets the conditions within which a person, if otherwise licensed, is to operate such a service.AGREED FACTSONC licences On 1 October 1992 the ABA, pursuant to s 117 of the BS Act, determined a class licence for the provision of ONC radio services. On 22 April 1994 the ABA exercised its power under s 34 of the BS Act, and made radio frequencies 116kHz, 1422kHz and 1593 kHz available in Melbourne for the period from 22 April 1994 to 22 October 1996 for the provision of ONC services. This process of making unused frequencies available for other radio services is known as “dropping through”. According to counsel for the ABA, one imagines various levels of broadcasting services bands with bands being primarily available for national, commercial and community broadcasting services. When a part of the spectrum is not being used for those services, it “drops through” to the next level so as to be available for other services including ONC services. Also on 22 April the predecessor of the ACA determined under s 106(1) of the Radcom Act a price‑based allocation system for the issuing of apparatus (transmitter) licences for the provision of ONC services. An auction of the apparatus licences took place on 16 June 1994. Applicants were informed that channels had been made available under s 34 of the BS Act for specified periods of time, namely from 21 April 1994 to 21 April 1996, and that if the completion of the next LAP was delayed, the ABA would decide whether to exercise its power “to again make the relevant spectrum available … for a limited period.” Completion of the next LAP was delayed, and in anticipation of the expiry of the licences the ABA decided on 12 June 1996 to make the frequencies available for ONC services until 21 December 1997, and to re-issue the apparatus licences for one year until 22 October 1997. Three later determinations made the frequencies available for additional twelve month periods. But for a further determination made after I had reserved my decision, the frequencies would have been available until 31 December 2000, on which date the apparatus licences would have expired. The current expiry date is 30 June 2001. The first applicant acquired the 1422 kHz apparatus licence on 14 February 2000, and the second applicant acquired the 1116 kHz apparatus licence on 5 December 1997.Licence Area Plan

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

SUNDBERG J
The claim is that the ABA failed to make any or any proper assessment of the need for or benefit to the community or sections of the community of Greek, Chinese and/or Italian radio broadcasting services. This ground must also fail for the reasons given in pars 24 to 26.“Allocation decision” It will be recalled that after determining that frequencies 1422 kHz and 1593 kHz would continue to be available for ONC services, the ABA said that “The provider will be determined by use of a price‑based allocation system under s 106 of the Radiocommunications Act 1992”. The applicants described this as the allocation decision. They did not in their oral submissions assert that the decision was beyond power. Indeed they asserted that the ABA had authority to make it. As I understood it the argument was that the allocation decision exposed the hypocrisy of the ABA’s argument that matters of content were not relevant at the planning (s 26) stage, but would arise for consideration at the licensing stage. However, under the price‑based allocation system decided upon by the ABA, matters of content would not arise at the licensing stage, because licences would in effect be put up for auction and go to the highest bidder. The ABA had no power to determine that there be a price‑based allocation system. The power in s 106 of the Radcom Act is conferred on the ACA. While the ACA can delegate to the ABA certain of its powers under the Radcom Act, the power in s 106 of that Act is not one of them. See s 238(3) of the Radcom Act. The history of frequencies 1422 kHz, 1116 kHz and 1593 kHz between 1994 and 2000 throws light on the meaning to be attributed to the ABA’s statement in Decision 8 that the provider “will be determined by use of a price‑based allocation system under s 106”. On 22 April 1994 the ABA made the three frequencies available under s 34 of the BS Act for the provision of ONC services for the period from 22 April 1994 to 22 October 1996. On the same day the ACA determined, under s 106 of the Radcom Act, a price‑based allocation system for allocating and issuing transmitter licences under s 100 of that Act for ONC services in the parts of the spectrum that under the ABA’s determination of 22 April 1994 were available for allocation. The apparatus licence for the 1116 kHz frequency was issued by the ABA under s 100 of the Radcom Act for the period from 21 July 1994 to 22 October 1996, and that for frequency 1422 kHz for the period 10 October 1994 to 22 October 1996. The licences were issued pursuant to the price‑based allocation system determined by the ACA. The ACA’s s 106 determination was expressed to operate in respect of the same period as the ABA’s s 34 determination. It thus expired on 22 October 1996. The availability of frequencies 1422 kHz, 1116 kHz and 1593 kHz was therefore extended by the ABA under s 34(1) of the BS Act and the 1116 kHz and 1422 kHz apparatus licences were reissued by the ABA under s 100 of the Radcom Act. The availability of the three frequencies would have terminated on 31 December 2000 but for the extension referred to in par 14. The 1422 kHz and 1116 kHz apparatus licences expired on 31 December 2000. Over the period 1994 to 2000 the ABA corresponded with the holders from time to time of the 1116 kHz and 1422 kHz apparatus licences, confirming that the “drop through” of spectrum under s 34(1) of the BS Act was for a limited period of time pending the completion of planning under s 26, and stating that if the relevant frequency were to be made available pursuant to the LAP for Melbourne for ONC services, transmitter licences would or probably would be issued by way of a price‑based allocation system. In some of the correspondence the ABA said the licences “will be issued by way of a price‑based allocation system under s 106 of the Radcom Act”. In a letter to solicitors Byrne & Clark in relation to 1116 kHz, the ABA was more cautious, saying only that the “most likely outcome” was that ONC licences would be auctioned under a price‑based allocation system.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: SUNDBERG J