Arnold v Minister Administering the Water Management Act 2000

Link copied
Case Copied 46 min read

HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

FRENCH CJ,
GUMMOW, HAYNE, HEYDON, CRENNAN, KIEFEL AND BELL JJ

Matter No S6/2009

ALAN ARNOLD & ORS  APPLICANTS

AND

MINISTER ADMINISTERING THE WATER
MANAGEMENT ACT 2000 & ORS  RESPONDENTS

Matter No S110/2009

ALAN ARNOLD & ORS  APPELLANTS

AND

MINISTER ADMINISTERING THE WATER
MANAGEMENT ACT 2000 & ORS  RESPONDENTS

Arnold v Minister Administering the Water Management Act 2000
[2010] HCA 3
10 February 2010
S6/2009 & S110/2009

ORDER

Matter No S6/2009

1.Grant special leave to include, as a further ground of appeal in Matter No S110/2009, the ground that the New South Wales Court of Appeal (CA [89]-[93]) erred in holding that the National Water Commission Act 2004 (Cth) and the 2005 Funding Agreement were not laws or regulations of trade or commerce within the meaning of s 100 of the Constitution.

2.Applicants to pay third respondent's costs.

Matter No S110/2009

1. Leave to the third respondent to file a Notice of Contention in the form of the draft annexed to its written submissions.

2.Upon the summons filed 13 August 2009 leave granted to the third respondent to file out of time a Notice of Contention limited to ground 2 of the draft.

3. Appeal dismissed.

4.Appellants to pay third respondent's costs.

On appeal from the Supreme Court of New South Wales

Representation

B W Walker SC with P T Taylor SC and P E King for the applicants/appellants (instructed by Taylor & Whitty Solicitors)

M G Sexton SC, Solicitor-General for the State of New South Wales with J K Kirk for the first and second respondents (instructed by Crown Solicitor (NSW))

S J Gageler SC, Solicitor-General of the Commonwealth and A Robertson SC with C L Lenehan for the third respondent (instructed by Australian Government Solicitor)

Interveners

R J Meadows QC, Solicitor-General for the State of Western Australia with R M Mitchell SC intervening on behalf of the Attorney-General for the State of Western Australia (instructed by State Solicitor for Western Australia)

P M Tate SC, Solicitor-General for the State of Victoria with K L Emerton SC and G A Hill intervening on behalf of the Attorney-General for the State of Victoria (instructed by Victorian Government Solicitor)

M G Hinton QC, Solicitor-General for the State of South Australia with K E Dennis intervening on behalf of the Attorney-General for the State of South Australia (instructed by Crown Solicitor (South Australia))

G J D del Villar intervening on behalf of the Attorney-General of the State of Queensland (instructed by Crown Law Brisbane)

Notice:  This copy of the Court's Reasons for Judgment is subject to formal revision prior to publication in the Commonwealth Law Reports.

  1. On 1 November 2006, bore licences held by the appellants, who are farmers in the Lower Murray region of New South Wales, were by operation of the Water Management Act 2000 (NSW) "replaced" with aquifer access licences. The appellants' entitlements to extract groundwater were less under the aquifer access licences than under the bore licences. The replacement was effected under the same statutory…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Arnold v Minister Administering the Water Management Act 200... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] HCA 3
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of Australia considered an appeal by the appellants, who held bore licences under the *Water Act 1912* (NSW). These licences were replaced by aquifer access licences under the *Water Management Act 2000* (NSW) pursuant to a funding agreement between the Commonwealth and New South Wales. The replacement was effectuated by the Minister Administering the *Water Management Act 2000* (NSW) making a Water Sharing Plan for the Lower Murray Groundwater Source. The appellants contended that the Commonwealth legislation or the funding agreement contravened section 100 of the Constitution, and that their bore licences entitled them to use "the waters of rivers".

The legal issues before the Court included whether the Commonwealth legislation or the funding agreement contravened section 100 of the Constitution, which limits Commonwealth legislative power concerning the use of waters of rivers for conservation or irrigation. The Court was also required to determine whether the replacement of the appellants' bore licences constituted an acquisition of property otherwise than on just terms, contrary to section 51(xxxi) of the Constitution. Additionally, the Court considered whether the Minister took irrelevant considerations into account when making the Water Sharing Plan under section 50 of the *Water Management Act 2000* (NSW).

The Court held that the waters in question were underground water, not "the waters of rivers" as contemplated by section 100 of the Constitution. Consequently, the arguments concerning the operation of section 100, and the potential invalidity of the Commonwealth legislation or funding agreement on that basis, did not need to be examined. The Court also found that there was no acquisition of property, thus rendering the challenge under section 51(xxxi) of the Constitution unfounded. Regarding the administrative law ground, the Court determined that the existence of the funding agreement was not an irrelevant consideration for the Minister when making the Water Sharing Plan, as the plan was intended for the sustainable management of water sources and the funding was provided to effect this plan.

The appeal was dismissed. Special leave to appeal was granted on the section 100 ground, and leave was granted to the Commonwealth to file notices of contention. The appellants were ordered to pay the Commonwealth's costs, while the State of New South Wales and the Minister sought no order as to costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Matter No S6/2009

1. Grant special leave to include, as a further ground of appeal in Matter No S110/2009, the ground that the New South Wales Court of Appeal (CA [89]-[93]) erred in holding that the National Water Commission Act 2004 (Cth) and the 2005 Funding Agreement were not laws or regulations of trade or commerce within the meaning of s 100 of the Constitution.

2. Applicants to pay third respondent's costs.

Matter No S110/2009

1. Leave to the third respondent to file a Notice of Contention in the form of the draft annexed to its written submissions.

2. Upon the summons filed 13 August 2009 leave granted to the third respondent to file out of time a Notice of Contention limited to ground 2 of the draft.

3. Appeal dismissed.

4. Appellants to pay third respondent's costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

FRENCH CJ GUMMOW AND CRENNAN JJ HAYNE, KIEFEL AND BELL JJ HEYDON J
The rights conferred by the appellants' bore licences related to underground water. The Water Sharing Plan 2006 applied to the Lower Murray Groundwater Source, the definition of which was referred to earlier in these reasons. It applied to underground water, not to the waters of rivers within the meaning of s 100.The pleading of this aspect of the appellants' claim provides no foundation for a contention of fact which, assumed in their favour for the purposes of the summary dismissal application, could have sustained their contention about s 100. The dismissal should stand.Conclusion Special leave to appeal should be granted on the s 100 ground, and leave to the Commonwealth to file its notices of contention in relation to s 100 and s 51(xxxi) (confined to ground 2). The appeal should be dismissed with costs in favour of the Commonwealth. The State of New South Wales and the Minister sought no order as to costs. This appeal and application for special leave were heard immediately after ICM Agriculture Pty Ltd v The Commonwealth[52] and there are a number of issues common to each matter. These reasons should be read with those of French CJ, Gummow and Crennan JJ in ICM. However, in this matter particular reliance was placed by the appellants upon s 100 of the Constitution. It is convenient to describe the background to the matter, particularly to indicate the broader context in which those arguments for a grant of special leave based on s 100 were advanced.[52](2009) 261 ALR 653; [2009] HCA 51.The National Water Initiative Agreement On 25 June 2004, the Commonwealth of Australia (the third respondent) and the Governments of New South Wales, Victoria, Queensland, South Australia, the Australian Capital Territory and the Northern Territory entered into an intergovernmental agreement known as the National Water Initiative ("the NWI"). In its Preamble, the agreement stated[53]:"The Parties agree to implement this National Water Initiative ... in recognition of the continuing national imperative to increase the productivity and efficiency of Australia's water use, the need to service rural and urban communities, and to ensure the health of river and groundwater systems by establishing clear pathways to return all systems to environmentally sustainable levels of extraction." [53]Intergovernmental Agreement on a National Water Initiative, 25 June 2004, par 5. Paragraph 27 of the NWI provides:"Recognising that States and Territories retain the vested rights to the use, flow and control of water, they agree to modify their existing legislation and administrative regimes where necessary to ensure that their water access entitlement and planning frameworks incorporate the features identified in paragraphs 28‑57 below[[54]]." Paragraph 39 of the NWI provides for the preparation of statutory water plans by States and Territories. Schedule E to the NWI contains guidelines for preparing water plans. Clause 2 of Sched E provides that:"Where systems are found to be overallocated or overused, the relevant plan should set out a pathway to correct the overallocation or overuse". [54]These paragraphs deal with the topics "water access entitlements", "environmental and other public benefit outcomes", "water planning", "addressing currently overallocated and/or overused systems", "assigning risks for changes in allocation", "indigenous access" and "interception".

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: FRENCH CJ, GUMMOW AND CRENNAN JJ, HAYNE, KIEFEL AND BELL JJ, HEYDON J

Because the waters at issue in this matter are not "the waters of rivers" the further questions argued about the operation of s 100 need not be examined. In particular, it is not necessary to decide whether the decision in Morgan should be reopened.Irrelevant considerations? The appellants' argument that the State Minister had taken irrelevant considerations into account in deciding whether to make the Water Sharing Plan was understood by the Court of Appeal as being an argument that the Minister had taken account of the existence of what was alleged to be one or more invalid Commonwealth laws and what was alleged to be an invalid Funding Agreement. The appellants' amended points of claim in the Land and Environment Court had described the allegedly irrelevant considerations taken into account by the Minister in rather different terms. In their pleading the appellants identified the matter that had been taken into account as being "the dictation or requirement of the Commonwealth Government as to the basis for reductions in water allocation rather than a broad approach of general application balanced by considerations of equity amongst water users in the State and having regard to the environment of New South Wales". The appellants did not seek to make any case in this Court or in the Court of Appeal that the State Minister acted under dictation. Assuming, without deciding, that it was open to the appellants to frame their argument along the lines described by the Court of Appeal, repeated in this Court, the argument should not be accepted. Because there was not, as the appellants submitted, an acquisition of property, neither the Funding Agreement nor either of the two federal statutes whose validity the appellants impugned was invalid for any want of provision of just terms. Having regard to the subject matter, scope and purposes of the 2000 Act as a whole, and s 50 in particular, the existence of the Funding Agreement was not a consideration irrelevant to the exercise of the power given to the State Minister by s 50 of the 2000 Act to make the Water Sharing Plan. On its face the Water Sharing Plan was intended, in the words of s 3 of the 2000 Act, "to provide for the sustainable and integrated management of the water sources of the State for the benefit of both present and future generations". Under the Funding Agreement the State was to receive money to effect the Water Sharing Plan. The Funding Agreement was not an irrelevant consideration in exercising the power given by s 50.Conclusion and orders For these reasons the appeal should be dismissed. Neither the Minister nor the State sought costs. The appellants should pay the Commonwealth's costs. The background is set out in the reasons for judgment of Gummow and Crennan JJ. ICM Agriculture Pty Ltd v The Commonwealth[86] was argued immediately before this appeal. In that case, reasons were given which differ in some significant respects from what was advocated by the appellants in this appeal. However, those reasons lead to the conclusion that the replacement of the appellants' bore licences by aquifer access licences was invalid. The bore licences remain on foot.[86](2009) 261 ALR 653 at 694-724 [158]-[257]; [2009] HCA 51.