Lee v Commonwealth of Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 82 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Lee v Commonwealth of Australia [2014] FCA 432

Citation: Lee v Commonwealth of Australia [2014] FCA 432
Parties: DANIEL THOMAS LEE and GRAEME PETER JAMES GROPLER v COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA and MURRAY DARLING BASIN AUTHORITY
File number: VID 1129 of 2012
Judge: NORTH J
Date of judgment: 2 May 2014
Catchwords:

CONSTITUTIONAL LAW – challenges to validity of the Water Act 2007 (Cth) – Act creates Basin Plan to increase environmental flows in the Murray-Darling Basin – Basin Plan sets limits on levels of water extraction for irrigation – Government policy to purchase water entitlements to increase environmental flows – claims pursuant to ss 99 and 100 of the Constitution – principle in Morgan v Commonwealth (1947) 74 CLR 421 – whether Act made or capable of being made pursuant to trade and commerce power, s 51(i) of the Constitution – characterisation – claim pursuant to s 92 of the Constitution – whether Act discriminates against interstate trade and confers protection on intrastate trade and commerce – whether some differences in extraction limits and trading limits on trade in water entitlements discriminate against interstate trade and commerce – claim that Act infringes the principle in Melbourne Corporation (1947) 74 CLR 31 – whether Act curtails the capacity of Basin States to function as such – claim pursuant to s 101 of the Constitution – whether applicants have standing to bring claim – whether have special interest beyond an emotional or intellectual satisfaction – s 254 of the Act – claim that water entitlements were acquired from the applicants other than on just terms – whether property acquired from the applicants – whether measurable advantage conferred on Commonwealth

Held: no infringement of ss 99 and 100 – challenged provisions not made or capable of being made pursuant to s 51(i) – rather, exercise of power to legislate in respect of external affairs, s 51(xxix) – Act does not infringe s 92– Act does not discriminate between inter and intrastate trade in a protectionist sense – differences in extraction limits between different areas not directed to trade and commerce – trading limits on trade in water entitlements established pursuant to State laws – no infringement of Melbourne Corporation principle – no curtailment of the capacity of Basin States to function as such – Act directed to State control of natural resources – directed to setting and enforcing limits on extraction of water – s 101 claim – no special interest established – s 254 claim – reduction in water entitlements does not amount to acquisition of property – deprivation of rights – ICM Agriculture v Commonwealth (2009) 240 CLR 140 – no property acquired by the Commonwealth

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application pursuant to s 31A Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) – whether applicants in the proceeding have no reasonable prospect of successfully prosecuting the proceeding – Spencer v Commonwealth (2010) 241 CLR 118

Held: applicants have no reasonable prospect of success on each of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lee v Commonwealth of Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] FCA 432
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Lee v Commonwealth of Australia, the applicants, Mr Lee and Mr Gropler, challenged the constitutional validity of the Water Act 2007 (Cth) and the Basin Plan made under that Act. They claimed the Act and the Basin Plan discriminated against interstate trade, conferred protection on intrastate trade, and curtailed the capacity of Basin States to function as such. They also claimed the government policy to purchase water entitlements to increase environmental flows was unconstitutional and that the water entitlements were acquired without just terms. The applicants sought relief under various sections of the Constitution, including sections 92, 99, 100, and 101. The respondents, the Commonwealth of Australia and the Murray-Darling Basin Authority, applied for summary judgment under section 31A of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), arguing the applicants had no reasonable prospect of successfully prosecuting the proceeding.

The Court considered the legal issues, including whether the challenged provisions were made or capable of being made pursuant to the trade and commerce power, whether the Act discriminated against interstate trade, whether it curtailed the capacity of Basin States to function as such, and whether the applicants had standing to bring the claims. The Court concluded the challenged provisions were not made or capable of being made pursuant to the trade and commerce power but rather an exercise of power to legislate in respect of external affairs. The Act did not discriminate between inter and intrastate trade in a protectionist sense, nor did it curtail the capacity of Basin States to function as such. The Court also found the applicants did not have a special interest beyond an emotional or intellectual satisfaction and that the reduction in water entitlements did not amount to acquisition of property.

The Court found the applicants had no reasonable prospect of success on each of the constitutional challenges, as the success of the proceeding depended on propositions of law which would contradict binding High Court authority. The Court concluded the proceeding was dependent on a proposition of law which would contradict a binding decision of the High Court and, therefore, the applicants had no reasonable prospect of success. The Court made a judgment under section 31A for the respondents in the proceeding, dismissing the proceeding and ordering the applicants to pay the respondents' costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application to amend [45] of the statement of claim, and to add [47A], and [47B] to the statement of claim, is refused.

2. The interlocutory application filed by the applicants on 8 July 2013 seeking answers to separate questions is dismissed.

3. The proceeding is dismissed.

4. The applicants pay the respondents' costs of the proceeding.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

French CJ and Gummow J said at [25]:25.Where the success of a proceeding depends upon propositions of law apparently precluded by existing authority, that may not always be the end of the matter. Existing authority may be overruled, qualified or further explained. Summary processes must not be used to stultify the development of the law. But where the success of proceedings is critically dependent upon a proposition of law which would contradict a binding decision of this Court, the court hearing the application under s 31A could justifiably conclude that the proceedings had no reasonable prospect of success.[Emphasis added.]THE EVIDENCE The Commonwealth and the Authority filed five affidavits in support of the application, namely an affidavit affirmed on 13 May 2013 by Russell Alexander James, who is the Executive Director of the Policy and Planning Division of the Authority, an affidavit affirmed on 13 May 2013 by David John Papps, who holds the position of Commonwealth Environmental Water Holder, an affidavit affirmed on 13 May 2013 by Emily Jane Nance, who is a solicitor employed by the Australian Government Solicitor, the lawyers for the Commonwealth and the Authority, an affidavit affirmed on 13 May 2013 by Mary Beatrice Harwood, who is the First Assistant Secretary in the Water Efficiency Division of the Department of Sustainability, Environment, Water, Population and Communities (the Department), and an affidavit affirmed on 14 May 2013 by Anthony James Slatyer, who is the First Assistant Secretary in the Water Reform Division of the Department. Mr Lee and Mr Gropler relied on affidavits respectively sworn and affirmed by them on 21 June 2013. The argument on the interlocutory application centred largely on the pleading of the claim contained in the amended statement of claim. However, the affidavits filed by the Commonwealth and the Authority provided a useful explanation of the legislative scheme, and of government water policy relevant that scheme. In greatly oversimplified terms, the gist of the legislative scheme and government policy is to ensure that some water previously used for irrigation in the Murray-Darling Basin would be utilised to increase the volume of water for environmental watering to a level sufficient to protect the environment of the Basin. The affidavits filed by Mr Lee and Mr Gropler expressed their view that the legislative scheme and government policy impacted adversely on them. Again, in greatly oversimplified terms, their central, but not only concern was that the amount of water necessary for them to operate their farms was to be reduced so that their farm operations would become unviable. The evidence of Mr Lee and Mr Gropler is outlined in these reasons for judgment for the purpose of explaining the quite complex background against which the legal arguments must be assessed. But their evidence is set out at greater length than would usually be warranted in an application such as the present. That is for a particular reason. As will be explained later in these reasons, the pleading of the claims is deficient in many respects. Further, when pressed to explain the way in which the claims were made, Mr King, who appeared as counsel for Mr Lee and Mr Gropler, was often unable to provide a comprehensible legal analysis. Given the caution which must attend any order for summary judgment, it is important for the Court to ensure that the full circumstances of Mr Lee and Mr Gropler are taken into account in considering the interlocutory application.

Decision

Reasons for decision

These reasons for judgment explain why there must be judgment for the Commonwealth and the Authority on the pleaded case as explained by Mr King. At the same time there is no reason to doubt that Mr Lee and Mr Gropler have been adversely affected in recent times in their occupation as irrigation farmers. The changes in the legislative regime applicable to them, and the consequent change in government policy settings concerning water entitlements, have played a part in the difficulties which they have encountered. Other factors such as extended drought conditions have also contributed to their difficulties. The rejection of the legal arguments does not minimise the personal difficulty experienced by irrigation farmers in the Basin arising from these circumstances. CONCLUSION It follows from these reasons that:1.The application to amend [45] of the statement of claim, and to add [47A], and [47B] to the statement of claim, should be refused; and2.The Court is satisfied that Mr Lee and Mr Gropler have no reasonable prospect of successfully prosecuting any of the claims made in the proceeding and consequently there should be judgment under s 31A of the Federal Court Act for the Commonwealth and the Authority in the proceeding; and3.The interlocutory application filed by the Commonwealth and the Authority on 8 July 2013 seeking answers to separate questions should be dismissed; and4.Mr Lee and Mr Gropler should pay the respondents’ costs of the proceeding.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Basin Plan must also provide for rules for the trading or transfer of tradeable water rights in relation to Basin water resources (s 22(1) item 12). Preparation of Plans The Basin Plan must be prepared by the Authority and given to the Minister for adoption (s 41). The relevant Basin State may prepare a proposed water resource plan for a water resource plan area within that State (s 63(1)). The water resource plan must incorporate and apply the SDL for the water resource plan area (s 22(1) item 11 and s 22(3)(b)), and provide for the sustainable use and management of the water resources within that diversion limit (s 22(3)(c)). The water resource plan must also specify the circumstances in which tradeable water rights in relation to the water resource plan area may be traded or transferred and the conditions applicable to such trades or transfers (s 22(3)(g)). If the Minister is satisfied that the water resource plan is consistent with the Basin Plan, the Minister must accredit the water resource plan (s 63(6)). If the Basin State does not provide a water resource plan, the Minister may request the Authority to prepare such a plan for a water resource plan area and then may adopt that water resource plan (ss 68 and 69). This process is known as “step-in” action. Division 3 of Pt 2 of the Act provides for an extensive process before the step-in action is taken under ss 68 and 69. Step-in action cannot be taken unless the Minister is satisfied that there is no other feasible and effective alternative way of dealing with the circumstances (s 73(14)(iv)).Compliance Obligations The holders of water entitlements and bodies which manage water resources must not do any act inconsistent with the Basin Plan, and must not fail to do an act if the failure to do the act is inconsistent with the Basin Plan (s 35(1)). Where the obligation is specified in a water resource plan, then those obligations and not the obligations under the Basin Plan must be observed (s 39). Enforcement Part 8 of the Act provides for the enforcement of the obligations to comply with the Basin Plan or a water resource plan. Proceedings may be brought in a court for an injunction (s 140) or a declaration (s 144) or for the imposition of a civil penalty where a civil penalty is provided for (s 146). Further, the Authority may accept enforceable undertakings to comply with the Act (s 163), and these may be enforced by a court (s 164). The Authority may issue an enforcement notice for contravention of Pt 2 of the Act or if it is satisfied that a person has engaged in, is engaging in, is likely to engage in conduct, or has omitted, is omitting or is likely to omit to perform an act which omission would be, inconsistent with, prejudicial to, or would have an adverse effect on the Basin Plan or a water resource plan (s 165(1)(b) and (c)). Failure to comply with an enforcement notice attracts a civil penalty of 600 penalty units (s 166(1)). Further, the Authority has power to direct a person not to exercise water access rights, irrigation rights, or water delivery rights held by them (s 165(3)). Commonwealth Environmental Water Holder