Lee v Commonwealth of Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 80 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Lee v Commonwealth of Australia [2014] FCAFC 174

Citation: Lee v Commonwealth of Australia [2014] FCAFC 174
Appeal from: Lee v Commonwealth of Australia [2014] FCA 432
Parties: DANIEL LEE and GRAEME PETER JAMES GROPLER v COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA and MURRAY-DARLING BASIN AUTHORITY
File number: VID 274 of 2014
Judges: MIDDLETON, BARKER AND GRIFFITHS JJ
Date of judgment: 18 December 2014
Catchwords: CONSTITUTIONAL LAW – application for leave to appeal against summary dismissal of claim pursuant to s 31A Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) – challenge to validity of provisions of Water Act 2007 (Cth) and claim for damages as a result of impairment by abridgment or acquisition of water entitlements and allocations – proper approach to interpretation of ss 99 and 100 Constitution in light of Morgan v Commonwealth (1947) 74 CLR 421 and subsequent decisions – whether primary judge erred in finding that impugned provisions of Water Act 2007 (Cth) could not be characterised as a law relating to trade or commerce under s 51(i) Constitution – whether primary judge erred in finding that claim under s 92 Constitution had no reasonable prospects of success – whether primary judge erred in finding that appellants had no reasonable prospect of prosecuting claim for acquisition of property otherwise than on just terms under s 254 Water Act 2007 (Cth) and s 51(xxxi) Constitution – whether primary judge should have found that claim under s 100 Constitution did not involve a relevant “matter”
Legislation:

Commonwealth Constitution s 51(i), s 51(xxix), s 51(xxxi), s 92, s 98, s 99, s 100, s 101, s 102

Acts Interpretation Act 1901 (Cth) s 15A
Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 31A
Financial Management and Accountability Act 1997 (Cth)
Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth) s 39B(1A)(b), s 44, s 78B
Water Act 2007 (Cth) Pt 1, Pt 2, Pt 2A, Pt 6, Pt 8, Pt 9, Pt 10, Pt 10A, Pt 11, Pt 11A, Pt 12, s 3(d)(i), s 4, s 11, s 18A, s 19(2), s 20(e), s 22(1) (items 2, 6, 7, 8, 10, 11, 12), s 22(3), s 22(3)(b), s 22(3)(c), s 22(3)(g), s 23, s 24, s 25(1)(a), s 25(1)(b), s 26, s 34, s 35, s 35(1), s 36(3), s 37(3), s 39, s 41, s 60(3), s 61(3), s 63(1), s 63(6), s 68, s 69, s 73(14)(d)(iv), s 104, s 105(1), s 105(2), s 105(3), s 105(4), s 106, s 140, s 144, s 146, s 163, s 164, s 165(1)(b), s 165(1)(c), s 165(3), s 166(1), s 241, s 241(1)(b), s 242, s 242(1), s 242(3), s 243(1), s 244(1), s 245(2), s 254, Sch 1A, Sch 3 (cl 3, cl 4), Sch 4

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) R 16.21
Water Amendment Regulation (No 1) 2012 (Cth)
Water Amendment Regulation (No 2) 2012 (Cth)

Water Act 1989 (Vic)
Water Management Act 2000 (NSW) s 71Z

Cases cited: Airlines of NSW Pty Ltd v New South Wales [No 2] [1965]…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lee v Commonwealth of Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] FCAFC 174
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Lee v Commonwealth of Australia involved an appeal against the summary dismissal of a claim against the Commonwealth, challenging the validity of provisions in the Water Act 2007 (Cth) and seeking damages for the alleged impairment of water entitlements and allocations. The Federal Court was required to determine whether the primary judge erred in dismissing the claim for various reasons, including the characterisation of the impugned provisions under the Constitution and the prospects of success of the claim.

The legal issues before the court centred on the interpretation of sections 99 and 100 of the Constitution, particularly in light of Morgan v Commonwealth (1947) 74 CLR 421 and subsequent decisions. The court examined whether the primary judge correctly found that the Water Act provisions could not be characterised as a law relating to trade or commerce under section 51(i) of the Constitution, and whether the primary judge was correct in finding that the appellants' claims had no reasonable prospects of success. The court also assessed whether the primary judge should have found that the appellants' claim under section 100 of the Constitution did not involve a relevant “matter”.

The court found that the primary judge's decisions were correct. The court held that the terms and operation of the Water Act did not impair the capacity of the Basin States to function as such, and there was no logical link between the challenged provisions and the complaints made. Additionally, the court found that there was no acquisition of property from the appellants and no measurable advantage conferred on the Commonwealth, as the economic consequences of the Water Act did not result in any acquisition of property by the Commonwealth. The court also noted that the appellants' claims were based on factual errors and did not constitute sustainable claims under section 254 of the Water Act.

The court granted the appellants leave to appeal but dismissed the appeal itself, with the appellants ordered to pay the respondents' costs. The interlocutory application to read further affidavits was also refused. The court concluded that the primary judge's findings were sound and that the appeal had no reasonable prospects of success.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Mr Lee and Mr Gropler be granted leave to appeal.

2. The interlocutory application dated 21 August 2014 to read the further affidavits of Mr Gropler dated 12 August 2014 and Mr Lee made on 12 August 2014, be refused.

3. The appeal be dismissed.

4. The appellants pay the costs of the respondents upon the application for leave to appeal and the appeal, to be assessed, if not agreed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Given our findings above in respect of the s 100 case advanced on behalf of the appellants, it is not necessary to consider this issue raised by the notice of contention.Conclusion and orders For these reasons, the following orders should be made:1.Mr Lee and Mr Gropler be granted leave to appeal.2.The interlocutory application dated 21 August 2014 to read the further affidavits of Mr Gropler dated 12 August 2014 and Mr Lee made on 12 August 2014, be refused.3.The appeal be dismissed.4.The appellants pay the costs of the respondents upon the application for leave to appeal and the appeal, to be assessed, if not agreed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

As to the Melbourne Corporation case, his Honour found the terms and operation of the challenged provisions of the Water Act did not impair the capacity of the Basin States to function as such. As to the s 101 or Inter‑State Commission case, his Honour found that the way in which the challenge to the establishment of the Authority was said to give rise to a claim under s 101 of the Constitution, seemed to be that the Authority was formed in place of the Inter‑State Commission. If that were so, his Honour said there was no logical link asserted between the terms of s 101 and the complaint made. As to the s 254 compensation case advanced by Mr Lee and Mr Gropler in relation to carryover water, his Honour found that there was no acquisition of property from the appellants and no measurable advantage conferred on the Commonwealth. Further, as to the allegation that water entitlements had become stranded and hence acquired, his Honour found, on their face, the pleadings made no sense as a claim under s 254 of the Water Act, as the acquisition about which complaint was made was said to have occurred as a result of actions of the Water Holder or allocations acquired from irrigators other than the appellants. His Honour further noted that when understood in the way counsel for the appellants had endeavoured to develop the case, the claim was that the way in which the legislative scheme operated had resulted in an increase in the delivery costs incurred by the remaining irrigators. He noted that Mr Lee and Mr Gropler gave evidence that the value of their properties had declined because irrigators in their localities had sold out their water allocations to the Commonwealth and their farms were no longer used as irrigation properties. His Honour said that, accepting for the purposes of argument that the operation of the Water Act has resulted in an increase in the costs of access to the irrigation delivery infrastructure and a decline in the value of Mr Lee and Mr Gropler’s farms, those economic consequences did not result in any acquisition of property by the Commonwealth. As to an allegation made on behalf of Mr Lee in [71] of the amended statement of claim and on behalf of Mr Gropler in [75], his Honour found that insofar as the claim depended on the sale of environmental water by the Water Holder prior to the hearing, it was based on a factual error. His Honour noted that the complaint that Mr Lee and Mr Gropler did not achieve a better price in the market than when they sold to the Commonwealth, was not a sustainable claim under s 254. His Honour also noted that, after the hearing of the respondents’ application, the respondents filed a second interlocutory application by which, in effect, they sought answers from the Court to a series of questions which reflected the matters argued on the original interlocutory application. His Honour considered that the more convenient course was to resolve the initial interlocutory application and dismiss the later one.