Morgan v Commonwealth

Link copied
Case Copied 48 min read
74 CLR 421

THE COMMONWEALTH AND THE RATIONING

COMMISSION MORGAN

THE COMMONWEALTH AND ANOTHER Constitutional Law (Cth.)-National Security Regulations-Validity Substance of

regulations-Indirect effectDefence-Trade and commerce-Rationing of goods -Sale of Goods-The Constitution (63 &64 Vict. c. 12), 88. 51 (i), 98, 99, 100, 101, 102-National Security Act 1939-1946 (No. 15 of 1939- No. 15 of 1946) -National Security (Rationing) Regulations (S.R. 1942 No. 228 - 1945 No. 132) regs. 24, 25, 26-National Security (Prices) Regulations (S.R. 1940 No. 176-1946 No. 198)-Rationing Order No. 37-Prices Regulation Orders Nos. 1817, 2106.

Sections 98 to 102 inclusive of the Constitution should be read as applying only to laws which can be made under the power conferred by S. 51 (i).

The National Security (Rationing) Regulations, National Security (Prices) Regulations and Orders made thereunder are provisions with respect to defence and, although they produce effects in relation to trade and commerce, they are not laws or regulations of trade or commerce within the meaning of the words in S. 99 of the Constitution because they could not have been made by virtue of the legislative power conferred by S. 51 (i).

The Rationing Commission is empowered by regs. 24, 25 and 26 of the National Security (Rationing) Regulations to make an Order relating to the rationing of goods which is not applicable generally throughout Australia.

74 CLR 422

REFERENCE to the Full Court and CASE STATED by Dixon J.

In November 1946 the Attorney-General for the Commonwealth filed indictments in the High Court against Arthur Edward Morgan- who carried on business at North Richmond, Victoria, as a wholesale and retail butcher and small goods manufacturer-and certain of his employees for (a) conspiracy to effect an unlawful purpose, namely the supply of coupon-meat to other persons otherwise than in accord- ance with the provisions of Rationing Order No. 37, as amended and (b) offences of black marketing under the Black Marketing Act 1942 the alleged offences consisting in selling porterhouse and rump steak and veal and beef at prices greater than the maximum prices fixed by Prices Regulation Order No. 1817 as amended by Prices Regulation Orders up to and including Prices Regulation Order No. 2106.

By writs of summons issued out of the High Court on 14th February 1947, Morgan commenced actions against (a) the Commonwealth of Australia and the Rationing Commission wherein he claimed that Rationing Order No. 37, as amended, was invalid as contravening S. 99 of the Constitution: and (b) the Commonwealth of Australia and Mortimer Eugene McCarthy wherein he claimed that Prices Regulation Order No. 1817, as amended, was contrary to S. 99 of the Constitution and void.

These Orders were applicable only to the State of Victoria. The statement of claim in respect of the rationing order was substantially as follows :-

1. During the years 1944 and 1945 until about the month of April 1946 the plaintiff carried on business at North Richmond in the State of Victoria as a wholesale and retail butcher and small goods manu-…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Morgan v Commonwealth and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1947] HCA 6
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Arthur Edward Morgan, a butcher and small goods manufacturer, and certain of his employees were indicted for conspiracy to supply rationed meat unlawfully and for black marketing offences. Concurrently, Morgan commenced actions against the Commonwealth and the Rationing Commission, and the Commonwealth and the Commonwealth Prices Commissioner, challenging the validity of Rationing Order No. 37 and Prices Regulation Order No. 1817, respectively, and their subsequent amendments. These orders, which applied only to Victoria, were alleged to contravene section 99 of the Constitution. The matters were referred by Dixon J. to the Full Court of the High Court for determination.

The legal issues before the Full Court concerned the validity of the National Security (Rationing) Regulations and the National Security (Prices) Regulations, and the specific orders made thereunder, particularly in relation to section 99 of the Constitution, which prohibits any law or regulation of trade or commerce from giving preference to one State or part of a State over another. The court was required to determine whether the rationing and pricing orders, by reason of their differential application or the prices they fixed across different states or parts of states, constituted a contravention of section 99. Additionally, the court considered whether these regulations and orders were validly made under the defence power of the Constitution, or if they were laws with respect to trade and commerce, and whether the Rationing Commission was empowered to make orders not applicable generally throughout Australia.

The Court held that sections 98 to 102 of the Constitution should be read as applying only to laws that could be made under the power conferred by section 51(i). It found that the National Security (Rationing) Regulations, National Security (Prices) Regulations, and the orders made under them were provisions with respect to defence. Although these regulations had effects on trade and commerce, they were not laws or regulations of trade or commerce within the meaning of section 99 of the Constitution because they could not have been made by virtue of the legislative power conferred by section 51(i). The Court also determined that the Rationing Commission was empowered by the relevant regulations to make an order relating to the rationing of goods that was not applicable generally throughout Australia.

The Court's determination meant that the challenges to the validity of the rationing and pricing orders based on section 99 of the Constitution failed. Consequently, the indictments against Morgan and his employees for conspiracy and black marketing offences, which relied on the validity of these orders, would proceed. The Court did not make specific orders regarding the outcome of the criminal proceedings but clarified the legal basis for the regulations and orders in question.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.