Alcock v Commonwealth of Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Alcock v Commonwealth of Australia [2012] FCA 870

Citation: Alcock v Commonwealth of Australia [2012] FCA 870
Parties: ROBERT JAMES ALCOCK v COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA and STATE OF VICTORIA
File number: VID 406 of 2012
Judge: DODDS-STREETON J
Date of judgment: 1 August 2012
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Application for leave to appeal from interlocutory judgment – relevant principles – whether sufficient doubt to warrant reconsideration – whether substantial injustice – leave granted
Legislation: Constitution s 51(xxxi)
Coastal Waters (State Powers) Act 1980 (Cth)
Coastal Waters (State Title) Act 1980 (Cth)
Evidence Act 1995 (Cth), s 75
Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), s 24
Federal Court Rules 1979 (Cth), O 29 r 1
Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth)
Fisheries Management Act 1991 (Cth)
Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth)
Seas and Submerged Lands Act 1973 (Cth)
Fisheries Act 1995 (Vic)
National Parks (Marine National Parks and Marine Sanctuaries) Act 2002 (Vic)
Cases cited: Alcock v Commonwealth [2011] FCA 392 cited
Alcock v Commonwealth [2009] FCA 820 cited
Arnold v Minister Administering the Water Management Act 2000 (2010) 240 CLR 242 cited
Bienke v Minister for Primary Industries and Energy (1996) 63 FCR 567 cited
Bienstein v Bienstein (2003) 195 ALR 225 cited
Commonwealth v Tasmania (1983) 158 CLR 1 cited
Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v Radisich [2010] FCA 1004 considered
Décor Corporation Pty Ltd v Dart Industries Inc (1991) 33 FCR 3 applied
Ex parte Bucknell (1936) 56 CLR 221 considered
ICM Agriculture Pty Ltd v The Commonwealth of Australia (2009) 240 CLR 140 cited
Johnson Tiles Pty Ltd v Esso Australia Pty Ltd (2000) 104 FCR 564 considered
Luck v University of Southern Queensland [2009] FCAFC 73 considered
Newcrest Mining (WA) Ltd v Commonwealth (1990) 190 CLR 513 cited
Ogawa v University of Melbourne (No 2) [2004] FCA 1275 cited
Robinson v Western Australian Museum (1977) 138 CLR 283 cited
Samsung Electronics Co Limited v Apple Inc [2011] FCAFC 156 discussed/approved
Smith v ANL Ltd (2000) 204 CLR 493 cited
Spencer v The Commonwealth (2010) 241 CLR 118 cited
Welsh v Digilin Pty Ltd [2008] FCA 78 considered
Date of hearing: 1 August 2012
Date of publication of reasons: 16 August 2012
Date of last submissions: 1 August 2012
Place: Melbourne
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 82
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr P E King
Solicitor for the Applicant: Waters Timms
Counsel for the First Respondent: Mr P Gray SC with Mr L Brown
Solicitor for the First Respondent: Australian Government Solicitor
Counsel for the Second Respondent: Ms R Orr
Solicitor for the Second Respondent: Victorian Government Solicitors Office

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

VID 406 of 2012

BETWEEN:

ROBERT JAMES ALCOCK
Applicant

AND:

COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA
First Respondent

STATE OF VICTORIA
Second Respondent

JUDGE:

DODDS-STREETON J

DATE OF ORDER:

1 AUGUST 2012

WHERE MADE:

MELBOURNE

OTHER MATTERS:

1.Counsel for the applicants informed the court that the applicants would not seek to vary…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Alcock v Commonwealth of Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] FCA 870
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Alcock v Commonwealth of Australia, the applicant, along with Susan Alcock, initially sought legal redress in a representative capacity against the Commonwealth of Australia. The case involved complex issues concerning the constitutional validity of certain legislation and its impact on the applicant's property rights, specifically an abalone fishing licence. The proceedings had a convoluted history, with earlier statements of claim being struck out, and subsequent attempts to amend them being challenged. Ultimately, the case reached a stage where specific questions were formulated for determination by the court.

The legal issues the court had to decide centred on whether certain legislation and an arrangement between the Commonwealth and Victoria were laws with respect to the acquisition of property under the Australian Constitution, and whether they impaired the constitutional guarantee. Additionally, the court needed to determine if the applicant was entitled to compensation under a particular section of the Fisheries Management Act 1991 (Cth), and if there was an inconsistency between the National Parks (Marine National Parks and Marine Sanctuaries) Act 2002 (Vic) and the Seas and Submerged Lands Act 1973 (Cth). The court also considered whether certain conduct of the Commonwealth was within the scope of trade or commerce under the Fair Trading Act 1999 (Vic) and the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth). Finally, the court had to address whether the Fisheries Act 1995 (Vic) was repugnant to the Constitution.

The reasoning of the court, led by Tracey J, involved a meticulous examination of the legislative provisions and their interaction with the constitutional provisions. The court found that the abalone fishing licence held by the applicant was considered "property" under the Constitution. However, the court concluded that none of the specified laws or the arrangement between the Commonwealth and Victoria were laws with respect to the acquisition of property. Consequently, the court determined that the applicant was not entitled to compensation, and there was no inconsistency between the specified acts. The court also ruled that the conduct of the Commonwealth did not fall within trade or commerce, and that the Fisheries Act 1995 (Vic) was not repugnant to the Constitution.

The final orders of the court granted the applicant leave to appeal from the judgment, with costs reserved to the Full Court in the appeal. This decision underscored the importance of precise legal arguments and the need for a clear and admissible evidentiary foundation in constitutional litigation.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The applicant has leave to appeal from the judgment of Tracey J given on 24 May 2012 at Melbourne.

2. Costs be reserved to the Full Court in the appeal.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The following material was filed in opposition:(1)the first respondent’s written submissions dated 24 July 2012; and(2)the second respondent’s written submissions dated 25 July 2012.BACKGROUND The proceeding was commenced by an application dated 16 June 2008 by the applicant and Susan Alcock acting for themselves and in a representative capacity. (At the hearing of the application, I was informed that Ms Alcock was at one point removed as an applicant, but counsel for the applicant indicated that she remained a party). As appears from the materials filed and Ryan J’s reasons published on 19 April 2011, his Honour gave directions for the formulation of separate questions against the backdrop of the applicant’s “considerable difficulty in framing a statement of claim which the respondents accept discloses a cause of action and is otherwise immune from striking out under O 11 r 16 of the Federal Court Rules” (Alcock v Commonwealth [2011] FCA 392 at [1]). On 4 August 2009, a statement of claim was struck out with leave to file and serve another amended statement of claim and application (Alcock v Commonwealth [2009] FCA 820). On 17 December 2009, Ryan J ordered that a further amended statement of claim and an amended application be struck out with no immediate leave to replead or amend, for reasons his Honour explained in Alcock v Commonwealth [2009] FCA 1478. Ryan J’s order was stayed pending the applicant’s application to remove the matter to the High Court pursuant to s 40 of the Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth) (“Judiciary Act”), which was later discontinued. Ryan J declined to give the applicant immediate leave to replead or amend without sighting a draft further amended statement of claim to determine whether the previous defects were cured. Following discontinuance of the removal application, the stay imposed on 17 December 2009 was dissolved on 12 November 2010. Ryan J ordered the applicant to file and serve a proposed amended application and further amended statement of claim. His Honour ordered that in the absence of agreement between the parties that such documents “properly disclose a cause of action or otherwise conform with the Rules of this Court, there be a hearing … of an application by the applicant for leave to rely on” such documents. A draft further amended statement of claim was filed and served on 17 December 2010 and was challenged by the respondents. Following some minor amendments to that document, the pleading described as the FASOC was filed on 5 April 2011, and was challenged by the respondents. On 4 March 2011, at a mention before Ryan J, his Honour proposed to order separate questions for determination in the proceeding. The following exchange occurred between Ryan J and Mr King, counsel for the applicant (transcript page 5):HIS HONOUR: … But it does occur to me that these debates about sufficiency of pleadings and whether a particular statement of claim discloses a cause of action can be somewhat sterile, and they haven’t progressed this matter very far, and one thing that might commend itself to the parties is the identification of a separate or preliminary question arising in the matter which could be resolved as it were as part of the pleading summons, but would result in a binding ruling, or at least a ruling that the parties could, if so advised, appeal from, which might limit the scope of this action or concentrate the minds of the parties on specific issues.… But I simply say – make those observations to invite your comments. Yours first, Mr King.MR KING: We don’t have any objection to that course, your Honour …(emphasis added)

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Mr Waters also deposed to a number of factual matters in relation to compensation paid to licensed fishers under the Fisheries Act 1995 (Vic) (“the Fisheries Act”) other than Central Zone abalone fishers, the market value of the applicant’s licence, and the losses incurred by the State of Victoria as a result of imposing the National Parks (Marine National Parks and Marine Sanctuaries) Act 2002 (Vic) (“the NP Act”). Mr Waters’ affidavit included argument and submissions which were inadmissible. Further, the respondents objected to assertions based on secondhand hearsay and/or for which the ultimate source was unclear. In so far as such factual matters were relevant to the leave application and were otherwise admissible pursuant to s 75 of the Evidence Act1995 (Cth), I attributed them minimal weight. See United Dairy Power Pty Ltd v Murray Goulburn Co-operative Co Ltd [2011] FCA 762.THE JUDGMENT BELOW On 24 May 2012, Tracey J made the following orders:1.The questions ordered to be separately determined be answered as follows: Question 1: Does the Revised Further Amended Statement of Claim filed herein on 5 April 2011 (FASC) (paragraphs 3 and 4) identify rights of the Applicant that are “property” within the meaning of s 51(xxxi) of the Constitution? Answer: Yes, but only in respect of the abalone fishing license number A41.Question 2: If yes to Question 1, in relation to the Applicant’s property identified in the FASC and in the circumstances alleged therein, are any of the following a law of the Parliament with respect to “the acquisition of property” within the meaning of s 51 (xxxi) or executive action which impairs the constitutional guarantee:2.1the National Parks (Marine National Parks and Marine Sanctuaries) Act 2002 (Vic) (the Marine Parks and Sanctuaries Act)? (in the circumstances set forth in paragraphs 5-9 of the FASC)2.2.the Fisheries Management Act 1991 (Cth) (the Management Act)? (in the circumstances set forth in paragraphs 5 and 27 of the FASC)2.3.the arrangement dated 29 October 1997, that commenced on 1 November 1997, under Part 5 of the Fisheries Management Act 1991 (Cth) between the Commonwealth and Victoria (the October 1997 arrangement)? (in the circumstances set forth in paragraphs 5 to 9 of the FASC)or,2.4.any combination of the Marine Parks and Sanctuaries Act, the Management Act and the October 1997 arrangement?Answer: (as to each part): No.Question 3: If yes to any of Questions 2.1, 2.2, 2.3 or 2.4, does s 167A(1) of the Management Act entitle the Applicant to compensation? Answer: Does not arise.Question 4: Does the FASC (paragraph 13) identify any inconsistency between the Marine Parks and Sanctuaries Act and the Seas and Submerged Lands Act 1973 (Cth) for the purposes s 109 of the Constitution? Answer: No.Question 5: If “yes” to Question 4, what provision or provisions of the Marine Parks and Sanctuaries Act is or are invalid for that reason? Answer: Does not arise.Question 6: Is the conduct alleged against the Commonwealth in paragraph 18 of the FASC conduct of the Commonwealth “in trade or commerce” within the meaning of the Fair Trading Act 1999 (Vic) or the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) (as taken to be continued in force by item 6(1) of Schedule 7 to the Trade Practices (Australian Consumer Law) Amendment Act (No 2) 2010)? Answer: No.Question 8: Is the Fisheries Act 1995 (Vic) repugnant to the Constitution to the extent that it extended past the low water mark into the Central Zone in Bass Strait and/or impaired or interfered with the applicant’s property rights (paragraph 35 of the FASC)?” Answer: No2.A further directions hearing be fixed for 7 September 2012 at 9:30 am.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established