Addy v Commissioner of Taxation

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

KIEFEL CJ,
GAGELER, GORDON, EDELMAN AND GLEESON JJ

CATHERINE VICTORIA ADDY  APPELLANT

AND

COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION  RESPONDENT

Addy v Commissioner of Taxation

[2021] HCA 34

Date of Hearing: 24 June 2021
Date of Judgment: 3 November 2021

S25/2021

ORDER

1.Appeal allowed with costs. 

2. Set aside orders 1 and 3 of the orders of the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia made on 6 August 2020 and, in their place, order that the appeal to that Court be dismissed.

On appeal from the Federal Court of Australia

Representation

T H J Hyde Page for the appellant (instructed by Harmers Workplace Lawyers)

S B Lloyd SC with G J D del Villar QC for the respondent (instructed by Australian Government Solicitor)

Notice:  This copy of the Court's Reasons for Judgment is subject to formal revision prior to publication in the Commonwealth Law Reports.

  1. KIEFEL CJ, GAGELER, GORDON, EDELMAN AND GLEESON JJ.   The appellant, Ms Catherine Addy, is a national of the United Kingdom. On 3 July 2015, she applied for and was granted a Working Holiday (Temporary) (Class TZ) (Subclass 417) visa under the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (a "working holiday visa")[1]. Ms Addy travelled to Australia on her British passport and, on 20 August 2015, entered Australia on her working holiday visa. Between August 2015 and May 2017, Ms Addy primarily lived and worked in Australia while holding a working holiday visa. During the 2017 income year, Ms Addy derived taxable income of $26,576 working in casual employment as a food and beverage waiter in Sydney.

    [1]The tax rates applicable to holders of working holiday visas under Pt III of Sch 7 to the Income Tax Rates Act 1986 (Cth) also relevantly apply to holders of a Work and Holiday (Temporary) (Class US) (Subclass 462) visa: s 3A(1).

  2. In December 2016, a new tax rate applicable to persons holding working holiday visas was enacted by inserting a new Pt III into Sch 7 to the Income Tax Rates Act 1986 (Cth) ("the Rates Act"), to take effect in relation to assessable income derived on or after 1 January 2017[2]. Part III applied a flat rate of tax of 15 per cent to the first $37,000 of an individual's "working holiday taxable income"[3], a maximum tax liability of $5,550. Under Pt I of Sch 7 to the Rates Act, the tax burden for an Australian national deriving taxable income from the same source as an individual earning working holiday taxable income during the same period would be less; they were entitled to a tax‑free threshold for the first $18,200 and were then taxed at 19 per cent up to $37,000[4], a maximum tax liability of $3,572.

    [2]Income Tax Rates Amendment (Working Holiday Maker Reform) Act 2016 (Cth), s 2 and Sch 1, items 7 and 8.

    [3]Rates Act, Sch 7, Pt III, cl 1, table item 1.

    [4]Rates Act, Sch 7, Pt I, cl 1, table item…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Addy v Commissioner of Taxation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] HCA 34
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of *Addy v Commissioner of Taxation* concerned an appeal to the High Court of Australia by Ms Addy, a United Kingdom national, against the Commissioner of Taxation. The dispute arose from the application of new tax rates introduced by Part III of Schedule 7 to the *Income Tax Rates Act 1986* (Cth) to individuals holding a Working Holiday (Temporary) (Class TZ) (Subclass 417) visa. Ms Addy, who was an Australian resident for tax purposes, argued that these new rates imposed a more burdensome tax than that applied to Australian nationals deriving income from the same source during the same period, thereby contravening Article 25(1) of the Convention between Australia and the United Kingdom for the Avoidance of Double Taxation.

The central legal issue before the High Court was whether the application of Part III of Schedule 7 to the *Income Tax Rates Act 1986* to Ms Addy, a United Kingdom national and Australian tax resident holding a working holiday visa, contravened Article 25(1) of the Australia-United Kingdom Double Taxation Convention. Article 25(1) provides that nationals of one contracting state shall not be subjected in the other contracting state to taxation which is other or more burdensome than the taxation to which nationals of that other state in the same circumstances are or may be subjected. The Commissioner contended that the differential taxation was based on visa type, not nationality, and that an Australian national could not be in the "same circumstances" as Ms Addy because they could not hold a working holiday visa.

The High Court, allowing Ms Addy's appeal, reasoned that Article 25(1) of the Convention prohibits discriminatory taxation based on nationality. The Court found that the differential tax rates imposed by Part III of Schedule 7 were indeed more burdensome for Ms Addy, a United Kingdom national, than for Australian nationals in comparable circumstances. The Court rejected the Commissioner's argument that the "same circumstances" requirement meant that a hypothetical Australian comparator must be able to hold the same visa. Instead, the Court held that the relevant comparison was between a United Kingdom national holding a working holiday visa and an Australian national who is a resident for tax purposes and derives income from the same source. The Court concluded that the tax treatment of Ms Addy was discriminatory on the basis of her nationality, contrary to the Convention.

The High Court ordered that the appeal be allowed with costs, setting aside the orders of the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia and dismissing the appeal to that Court.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Appeal allowed with costs.

2. Set aside orders 1 and 3 of the orders of the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia made on 6 August 2020 and, in their place, order that the appeal to that Court be dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Ms Addy, a British national, was issued a Working Holiday (Temporary) (Class TZ) (Subclass 417) visa ("working holiday visa") and was in Australia as a resident for tax purposes. Pursuant to Part III of Schedule 7 of the Income Tax Rates Act 1986, new tax rates were applied to persons holding working holiday visas, including Ms Addy, who was subject to these rates for her income earned from 1 January 2017. The Commissioner of Taxation assessed Ms Addy under these new rates, which she argued were more burdensome than the tax rate imposed on Australian nationals deriving taxable income from the same source during the same period, and thus contravened Article 25(1) of the Convention between Australia and the United Kingdom for Avoidance of Double Taxation and Prevention of Fiscal Evasion with respect to Taxes on Income and on Capital Gains ("United Kingdom convention"). Ms Addy contended that the new tax rates constituted discriminatory treatment based on nationality, in breach of the non-discrimination clause in the United Kingdom convention, which provides that United Kingdom nationals should not be subjected in Australia to "other or more burdensome" taxation than imposed on Australian nationals "in the same circumstances, in particular with respect to residence." The Commissioner, however, argued that the differential tax rates were imposed due to the visa type, not nationality, and that the circumstances of Australian nationals were not "identical in all matters relevant to the imposition of taxation except nationality" to those of Ms Addy.

The primary judge found that the new tax rates did indeed discriminate against Ms Addy on the basis of her nationality, in contravention of Article 25(1) of the United Kingdom convention, and remitted the matter to the Commissioner for the making of an amended assessment. The Commissioner's appeal to the Full Court of the Federal Court was allowed by majority. Derrington J held that Article 25(1) was not infringed as the holding of a particular type of visa was not necessarily bound to nationality, and thus there was no causal nexus between Ms Addy's nationality and her liability to pay tax at the rates imposed by Part III of Schedule 7. Steward J reasoned similarly, holding that Article 25(1) was not offended because it was not a part of the discrimen for the application of the rates in Part III of Schedule 7 that a person bear any particular nationality.

The matter of Addy v Commissioner of Taxation originated in the Federal Court of Australia, where the primary judge determined that the rates of tax specified in Part III of Schedule 7 to the Income Tax Rates Act 1986 (Cth) discriminated against Ms Addy on the basis of her nationality, in contravention of Article 25(1) of the Convention between Australia and the United Kingdom for Avoidance of Double Taxation and Prevention of Fiscal Evasion with respect to Taxes on Income and on Capital Gains. The primary judge remitted the matter to the Commissioner for the making of an amended assessment on the basis that, until Ms Addy left Australia on 1 May 2017, she was a "resident" as defined by section 6(1) of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth) and that the rates of tax specified in Part III of Schedule 7 to the Rates Act did not apply to her income from 1 January 2017.

The Commissioner appealed to the Full Court of the Federal Court, where the appeal was allowed by majority. Derrington J held that Article 25(1) was not infringed because the holding of a particular type of visa was not necessarily bound to nationality, such that there was no causal nexus between Ms Addy's nationality and her liability to pay tax at the rates imposed by Part III of Schedule 7. His Honour reasoned that although Ms Addy held a working holiday visa, she did not hold it because she was a British national: it was "not a necessary concomitant" of her nationality. His Honour further held that the comparison that was required to be made under Article 25(1) could not be undertaken because holding a working holiday visa was a distinguishing tax-related characteristic which could not be excluded when attempting to make the required comparison. Steward J reasoned to a similar effect, holding that Article 25(1) was not offended because it was "no part of the discrimen" for the application of the rates in Part III of Schedule 7 that a person bear any particular nationality.

Ms Addy appealed to the High Court of Australia, which allowed the appeal and ordered that the appeal to the Full Court be dismissed. The Court held that the Full Court erred in concluding that the comparison under Article 25(1) could not be undertaken because holding a working holiday visa was a distinguishing tax-related characteristic. The Court held that it was the Commissioner's burden to demonstrate that the tax treatment of Ms Addy was not discriminatory, and that the Full Court had failed to properly consider the evidence before it in making its determination. The Court remitted the matter to the Full Court for reconsideration in light of its decision.

Decision

Reasons for decision

KIEFEL CJ, GAGELER, GORDON, EDELMAN AND GLEESON JJ
Ms Addy contended, first, that Art 25(1) is not confined to prohibiting discriminatory treatment based solely on nationality (such that the paragraph would also prohibit discriminatory tax treatment based on, for example, ethnicity). Second, Ms Addy contended that, in any event, contrary to Art 25(1), Pt III of Sch 7 does discriminate solely on the basis of nationality. The Commissioner, on the other hand, contended that Art 25(1) is concerned with differential taxation that is imposed solely by reason of nationality, but that here the differential rates were imposed because of Ms Addy's visa type and not her nationality. The Commissioner further submitted that the words "in the same circumstances" in Art 25(1) mean "identical in all matters relevant to the imposition of taxation except nationality" and that, because here "it was not possible for an Australian national to earn working holiday income while holding a working holiday visa", an Australian national could never be "in the same circumstances" as Ms Addy. Accordingly, the Commissioner submitted, Art 25(1) was not engaged.Decisions below The primary judge held that the rates of tax in Pt III of Sch 7 did discriminate against Ms Addy on the basis of her nationality in contravention of Art 25(1). The primary judge remitted the matter to the Commissioner for the making of an amended assessment on the footing that, until 1 May 2017 (when Ms Addy left Australia), Ms Addy was a "resident" as defined by s 6(1) of the Income TaxAssessment Act 1936 and that the rates of tax specified in Pt III of Sch 7 to the Rates Act did not apply to her income from 1 January 2017. The Commissioner's appeal to the Full Court of the Federal Court was allowed by majority. Derrington J held that Art 25(1) was not infringed because the holding of a particular type of visa was not necessarily bound to nationality, such that there was no causal nexus between Ms Addy's nationality and her liability to pay tax at the rates imposed by Pt III of Sch 7. His Honour reasoned that although Ms Addy held a working holiday visa, she did not hold it because she was a British national: it was "not a necessary concomitant" of her nationality. His Honour further held that the comparison that was required to be made under Art 25(1) could not be undertaken because holding a working holiday visa was a distinguishing tax‑related characteristic which could not be excluded when attempting to make the required comparison. Steward J reasoned to a similar effect. His Honour held that Art 25(1) was not offended because it was "no part of the discrimen" for the application of the rates in Pt III of Sch 7 that a person bear any particular nationality. His Honour reached that conclusion on two primary bases: first, that s 3A of the Rates Act did "not refer at all to a person's nationality"; and second, that the circumstances of the hypothetical taxpayer that go to, or affect, tax liability had to be the "same" in order for Art 25(1) to be engaged and the circumstances therefore had to include the holding of the same visa.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: KIEFEL CJ, GAGELER, GORDON, EDELMAN AND GLEESON JJ

The Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia, in the case of Addy v Commissioner of Taxation, was tasked with determining whether the application of Part III of Schedule 7 to the Income Tax Assessment Act 1986 (Cth) contravened Article 25(1) of the United Kingdom Convention for the Avoidance of Double Taxation and Prevention of Fiscal Evasion with respect to Taxes on Income and on Capital Gains. The central issue in the case was whether the tax rates imposed by Part III of Schedule 7 constituted discrimination based on nationality under the Convention. The Court had to consider whether Article 25(1) prohibited discriminatory tax treatment based on factors other than nationality, such as visa type, and whether the differentiation in tax rates between working holiday visa holders and other Australian residents constituted such discrimination.

The Court began by examining the scope of Article 25(1) of the United Kingdom Convention. It considered whether the article is limited to prohibiting discriminatory treatment based solely on nationality or if it extends to prohibit discrimination based on other factors, such as visa type. The Court concluded that Article 25(1) does not restrict its application to nationality alone but encompasses other factors that might be relevant to taxation, such as visa status. This interpretation aligns with the broader purpose of double taxation treaties to ensure fair treatment of taxpayers and prevent discrimination based on arbitrary criteria.

The Court then addressed whether the application of Part III of Schedule 7 to Ms Addy's tax assessment contravened Article 25(1) of the United Kingdom Convention. It held that the differentiation in tax rates between working holiday visa holders and other Australian residents constituted discrimination based on nationality. The Court noted that the imposition of higher tax rates on working holiday visa holders, regardless of their nationality, created a disparity in tax treatment that contravened the non-discrimination principle enshrined in Article 25(1).

The Court also considered the interpretation of the phrase "in the same circumstances" in Article 25(1). It held that these words do not mean "identical in all matters relevant to the imposition of taxation except nationality". Instead, the Court interpreted the phrase to mean that taxpayers must be compared in circumstances that are substantially similar, taking into account all relevant factors, including visa status. This interpretation required the Court to compare Ms Addy's circumstances with those of a hypothetical Australian national who could have earned working holiday income under the same visa, thereby engaging Article 25(1).

Further, the Court examined whether Ms Addy was "in the same circumstances" as Australian nationals for the purposes of Article 25(1). It held that because Ms Addy held a working holiday visa and an Australian national could not hold such a visa, she was not "in the same circumstances" as Australian nationals. However, the Court held that holding a working holiday visa is a distinguishing tax-related characteristic that must be included in the comparison under Article 25(1). Consequently, Ms Addy's visa status, combined with her nationality, created a scenario where she was not "in the same circumstances" as an Australian national earning working holiday income.

The Court then considered whether holding a working holiday visa could be considered a distinguishing tax-related characteristic that must be included when comparing taxpayers under Article 25(1). It held that visa status is a relevant factor in determining whether taxpayers are "in the same circumstances" for tax purposes. The Court found that the differentiation in tax rates based on visa status, in conjunction with nationality, constituted discriminatory treatment under the Convention.

Finally, the Court addressed whether there was a causal nexus between Ms Addy's nationality and her liability to pay tax at the rates imposed by Part III of Schedule 7, as required to engage Article 25(1). It held that there was no such causal nexus because the differential tax treatment was based on visa status rather than nationality alone. However, the Court also found that the differentiation in tax rates, when combined with the visa status, created a discriminatory effect based on nationality, thereby engaging Article 25(1).

In conclusion, the ratio decidendi of the case is that the differentiation in tax rates between working holiday visa holders and other Australian residents, when combined with the visa status, constitutes discriminatory treatment based on nationality in contravention of Article 25(1) of the United Kingdom Convention. The Court's decision highlights the importance of considering all relevant factors, including visa status, when comparing taxpayers to ensure compliance with the non-discrimination principle in double taxation treaties.