Commissioner of Taxation v Pike

Link copied
Case Copied 48 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Commissioner of Taxation v Pike [2020] FCAFC 158

Appeal from: Pike v Commissioner of Taxation [2019] FCA 2185
File number: QUD 35 of 2020
Judgment of: DAVIES, WHITE AND STEWARD JJ
Date of judgment: 22 September 2020
Catchwords:

TAXATION – Australia and Thailand double taxation treaty Art 4(3) – “tiebreaker” provisions regarding residency – where respondent’s de facto wife and children lived in Australia and respondent worked in Thailand –whether respondent had an habitual abode in both Australia and Thailand – whether assessment based on more than days spent in one contracting state over the other – whether respondent’s personal and economic relations were closer to Australia or Thailand – conjunctive test applied by primary judge – conclusion of primary judge not wrong on facts of case – appeal and cross-appeal dismissed

TAXATION – whether respondent a resident of Australia for tax purposes – definition of “resident” in s 6 of Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth) – application of “ordinary concepts test” – unnecessary to consider “domicile test”

Legislation:

Australian Citizenship Act 2007 (Cth)

Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth) s 6(1)

Agreement between Australia and the Kingdom of Thailand for the Avoidance of Double Taxation and the Prevention of Fiscal Evasion with respect to Taxes on Income, signed 31 August 1989, [1989] ATS 36, Art 4

Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties, opened for signature 23 May 1969, 1155 UNTS 331, Arts 31, 32

Cases cited:

Branir Pty Ltd v Owston Nominees (No 2) Pty Ltd [2001] FCA 1833; 117 FCR 424

Burton v Federal Commissioner of Taxation [2019] FCAFC 141; 271 FCR 548

Bywater Investments Limited v Commissioner of Taxation [2016] HCA 45; 260 CLR 169

Commissioner of Taxation v Addy [2020] FCAFC 135

Commissioner of Taxation v Scone  Race Club Limited [2019] FCAFC 225; 374 ALR 189

Commissioner of Taxation v SNF (Australia) Pty Ltd [2011] FCAFC 74; 193 FCR 149

FFF v Commissioner of Inland Revenue [2011] NZTRA 8

Harding v Federal Commissioner of Taxation [2018] FCA 837; 108 ATR 137

Harding v Federal Commissioner of Taxation [2019] FCAFC 29; 269 FCR 311

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v SZVFW [2018] HCA 30; 264 CLR 541

Thielv Commissioner of Taxation [1990] HCA 37; 171 CLR 338

Warren v Coombes [1979] HCA 9; 142 CLR 531

Model Tax Convention on Income and on Capital (OECD commentaries)

Division: General Division
Registry: Queensland
National Practice Area: Taxation
Number of paragraphs: 42
Date of hearing: 24 August 2020
Counsel for the Appellant: Mr P A Looney QC with Mr D J Butler
Solicitor for the Appellant: Australian Government Solicitor
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr P G Bickford
Solicitor for the Respondent: Irish Bentley Lawyers

ORDERS

QUD 35 of 2020
BETWEEN:

COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION

Appellant

AND:

BRADLEY TITUS PIKE

Respondent

AND BETWEEN:

BRADLEY TITUS PIKE

Cross-Appellant

AND:

COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION

Cross-Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

DAVIES, WHITE AND STEWARD JJ

DATE OF ORDER:

22 SEPTEMBER 2020

THE COURT ORDERS…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Commissioner of Taxation v Pike and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] FCAFC 158
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Commissioner of Taxation v Pike, the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia considered an appeal and cross-appeal concerning the residency status of Mr Pike for Australian income tax purposes. The central issue was whether Mr Pike was a resident of Australia for tax purposes in the relevant income years, and whether the relevant Australian tax provisions properly applied to him. The Court was required to decide whether Mr Pike's habitual abode was in Australia or Thailand, and if so, whether Australia was the country with which his personal and economic relations were closer. The Court also had to determine whether the application of the "ordinary concepts test" or the "domicile test" was appropriate for assessing Mr Pike's residency status.

The Court held that the primary judge's conclusions were not wrong on the facts of the case. The Court found that the conjunctive test applied by the primary judge, which considered both the number of days Mr Pike spent in Australia and his personal and economic relations with Australia, was appropriate. The Court held that the facts did not compel a different conclusion from that reached by the primary judge. The Court further held that it was unnecessary to consider the "domicile test" as the application of the "ordinary concepts test" was sufficient to determine Mr Pike's residency status. Accordingly, the appeal and cross-appeal were dismissed. The Court ordered that the parties confer to reach an agreement on the appropriate costs order, and if they could not agree, they were to provide written submissions for the Court's determination of the costs issue.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be dismissed.

2. The cross-appeal be dismissed.

3. Within seven (7) days of this order, the parties are to confer with a view to reaching agreement about the appropriate costs order and, in the absence of agreement, each party is to provide written submissions of no more than three (3) pages and, subject to any further order, the Court will then determine the issue of costs on the papers.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Mr Pike has cross-appealed the findings that:(a)he was a resident of Australia in the income years in question pursuant to the ordinary concepts test; (b)he was a resident of Australia pursuant to the domicile test from April 2014; and(c)Art 4(3)(b) of the Double Tax Agreement did not deem him to be a resident solely of Thailand during the 2009 to 2014 income years. THE FACTS The facts as found by the primary judge were not disputed by either party. Those facts are found at [4]–[44] of the judgment below and were as follows:(a)Mr Pike was born in 1972 in what was then the British colony of Southern Rhodesia and later became the Republic of Zimbabwe: [4];(b)in Zimbabwe, Mr Pike developed a career in the tobacco industry. By 2004 he had become highly experienced in tobacco selection, production and sales: [5];(c)Mr Pike was then, and continues to be, in a long standing de facto relationship with Ms Michelle Thornicroft. She was also born in Southern Rhodesia in 1971 and they have two sons, each born in Zimbabwe in 1995 and 1999 respectively: [5];(d)by 2004, the economic crisis and shortages of food and basic supplies in Zimbabwe caused Mr Pike and Ms Thornicroft to decide to leave that country with their children. To that end, Ms Thornicroft sought, was offered, and accepted an appointment in Ernst & Young’s Brisbane office: [5];(e)that appointment was due to commence on 4 April 2005. Mr Pike was then employed in Harare under a contract with the tobacco industry company, Alliance One. Prompted by the decision to relocate to Australia, Mr Pike negotiated an arrangement with Alliance One, under the terms of which he would receive a payment after serving out the term of his existing contract: [6];(f)in February 2005, Ms Thornicroft was granted a subclass 457 visa and Mr Pike and their sons were also granted visas allowing them to accompany Ms Thornicroft to live in Australia during the currency of her subclass 457 visa: [7];(g)on 17 March 2005 the family travelled to Australia: [8];(h)from 2000 until they left for Australia, Mr Pike, Ms Thornicroft and their sons lived in a home in Harare which they had purchased from Ms Thornicroft’s mother (Harare home): [8];(i)upon their arrival in Australia, Mr Pike and Ms Thornicroft leased an apartment in Fortitude Valley, Brisbane. The lease was taken out in joint names: [9];(j)Mr Pike returned to Zimbabwe shortly after the family’s arrival in Australia to serve out his contract with Alliance One, to sell some assets (two cars and a boat but not the Harare home) that the couple owned in that country and to pack up and arrange the transportation to Australia of their furniture. He returned to Australia in September 2005: [9];(k)on his return to Australia Mr Pike sought employment, but the period during which he and Ms Thornicroft transitioned from Zimbabwe to Australia coincided with the winding up of the tobacco growing industry in Australia and Mr Pike found he was unable to find suitable employment in Australia. In light of this, he sought to enrol in tertiary level studies in business so as to reskill for alternative employment, but the enrolment requirements were such that he could not readily pursue this course of action. That led him to fall back on his existing skill and experience and international tobacco industry contacts which he had developed during his time in Zimbabwe. By this means, Mr Pike became aware in March 2006 of the availability of work in Thailand, where a tobacco industry was being established: [11];(l)that month Mr Pike travelled to Thailand and in late 2006 he was offered and took up a position based in Thailand as a tobacco and leaf consultant with Premium Tobacco (Asia) Limited. His initial contract for this work was for six months. However, in June 2006, he entered into a further contract with Premium Tobacco (Asia) Limited as a sales manager. This position was for an indefinite duration. His duties required that he be based in Thailand but also that he undertake duties elsewhere in Asia as required: [12];(m)Mr Pike was granted a work visa by the Thai government which allowed him to live and work in Thailand. He opened a bank account in Thailand and his salary was paid into that account: [13];(n)over the next eight years Mr Pike continued to be based in Thailand for employment purposes, travelling elsewhere in the Asian region as required. He was granted successive Thai work visas, each keyed, in terms of a right to live and work in Thailand, to ongoing employment in that country. Though he intended to, and did, return to his family in Australia, circumstance required that he spend most of his time working and living in Thailand: [14];(o)between 2006 and 2014 Mr Pike occupied a succession of rented apartments or cottage accommodation in Thailand, which he furnished to his taste and also to accommodate Ms Thornicroft and their two sons when they visited it. He regarded that accommodation as his home when in Thailand. During his time in Thailand, Mr Pike joined and actively patronised golf, rugby and cricket clubs and also formed enduring friendships. He used his Zimbabwean driver’s licence for the purpose of securing permission to drive in Thailand and was allocated a company car for work and private use: [15];(p)also over this period and in succession to the apartment at Fortitude Valley, Mr Pike and Ms Thornicroft jointly rented a home in Taringa, Brisbane, and then later a four bedroom home at Seventeen Mile Rocks. Ms Thornicroft, their sons and, when in Australia, Mr Pike, always occupied these premises as a family. The successive Brisbane residential relocations were the result of joint discussion and decision making by Mr Pike and Ms Thornicroft. The properties they rented were unfurnished and they jointly purchased furniture and household appliances as required for these properties. They also jointly purchased motor vehicles for their use in Australia: [16];(q)Ms Thornicroft’s mother moved to Australia from Zimbabwe in 2012 and joined them in these rented premises: [17];(r)during the whole of his time in Thailand Mr Pike lodged taxation returns with Thailand’s Revenue Department. He did not lodge income tax returns in Australia, save for the 2014 income year: [18];(s)in September 2006, when Mr Pike’s family initially visited him in Thailand, Mr Pike and Ms Thornicroft discussed moving the family there, but Ms Thornicroft was not agreeable to this proposal: [19];(t)in 2010 Ms Thornicroft sustained a wrist injury and took extended leave from Ernst & Young. In 2011, after the leave had come to an end, she relinquished her position: [20];(u)both before and after Ms Thornicroft’s injury and to this day, Mr Pike has supported her and their sons by regular financial contributions. Mr Pike established an Australian bank account in his own name when the family first moved to Australia and, shortly after that, a joint Australian bank account with Ms Thornicroft. He also obtained a credit card with an Australian bank: [21];(v)as well as supporting his immediate family financially, Mr Pike continued to support his father, his mother and his two brothers financially, all of whom remained living in Zimbabwe: [22];(w)on 16 February 2009 Ms Thornicroft, Mr Pike and their sons were granted permanent residency in Australia. Mr Pike’s permanent residency visa included a return travel facility that allowed travel in and out of Australia for a period of five years. That limitation caused a problem for Mr Pike in 2014 when he sought to return to the family home and had to obtain a further Australian visa at short notice, as he had not by then completed all requirements for the conferral of Australian citizenship: [23];(x)in September 2010 Mr Pike and Ms Thornicroft purchased vacant land at Brookwater, a residential golf community in Ipswich, Queensland. Their intention was to build a family home and also to provide something tangible in Australia for their sons. They sold the Harare home in October 2010 and used the proceeds of sale to reduce the borrowings taken out to acquire the Brookwater land. As it later transpired, it was not possible for them to build a home on the land and it was sold in November 2013: [24];(y)in August 2010 Ms Thornicroft and the couple’s two sons were granted Australian citizenship. The primary judge at [25] stated that Ms Thornicroft and Mr Pike “had aspired to this eventuality for themselves and their sons ever since relocating to Australia in 2005”;(z)later in 2010 Mr Pike made enquiries in Brisbane with the Department of Immigration and Citizenship (as it then was) about obtaining Australian citizenship. Up until then he had been using his Zimbabwean passport for international travel purposes, but increasingly found that his use of that passport occasioned him particular scrutiny at international borders. However, he did not pursue a citizenship application until April 2013: [26];(aa)Mr Pike’s Zimbabwean passport was renewed on 15 September 2010 and again on 6 December 2012, the latter current for 10 years: [27];(bb)Mr Pike made an application for Australian citizenship in April 2013 and gave as his residential address the then rented family home at Taringa. He also specified as his home telephone number the landline (inferentially) connected to those premises. In contrast, his mobile telephone number was his Thai number and the contact email address he specified was his Thai work email address. He specified his then current citizenship as Zimbabwean. He also stated on the application that he intended to be absent from Australia for work for six weeks over the forthcoming 12 months: [28];(cc)Ms Thornicroft provided a letter in support of Mr Pike’s citizenship application. In this, apart from attesting to the length of their de facto relationship and their children, she stated: We moved from Zimbabwe to Australia in March 2005 and in 2006 was offered a position offshore in Thailand. He currently remains employed by Premium Tobacco as the Sales Manager for Thailand and China based out of Chiangmai Thailand. Bradley is now the primary bread winner in the family and needs to spend time abroad to fulfill his work responsibilities. I and our children became Australian citizens on 27 August 2010. Bradley has been a permanent resident since 16 February 2009. Prior to that, Bradley entered Australia on 17 March 2005 on the 457 visa as a result of my employment with Ernst and Young Brisbane. Australia and more so Brisbane is our family home. Bradley returns home regularly and is truly invested in our lives here. Further, we jointly own land in Springfield on which we planned to build a home.[sic]The reference in this letter to the land at Springfield is a reference to the Brookwater land: [29]–[30]; (dd)Mr Pike’s citizenship application was refused in 2013 on the basis of a decision by a ministerial delegate that he did not satisfy particular residential requirements specified in the Australian Citizenship Act 2007 (Cth): [34];(ee)Mr Pike lodged a further application for Australian citizenship in October 2013 and on that occasion he was successful and was issued with an Australian passport in 2014. He also enrolled on the electoral roll for the electorate in which the Seventeen Mile Rocks home was located and remained, at the time of the hearing before the primary judge, so enrolled, although at that time he had only voted once (in 2016) in an election in Australia: [35];(ff)in 2014 Mr Pike relocated to Tanzania for employment purposes. Mr Pike closed his Thai bank account and opened one in Tanzania on relocating there. His ability to live and work in Tanzania was conditioned by his visa to his ongoing employment in that country: [36];(gg)Mr Pike lived in fully furnished rented accommodation for the duration of his time in Tanzania and joined golf and tennis clubs there. The primary judge stated at [37]: “[a]s with Thailand, he made a home there”;(hh)in early 2016 Mr Pike was offered a promotion to a position based in Dubai in the United Arab Emirates (UAE) and took up this offer. His employment agreement was stated to be an “Unlimited Period Employment Contract”. He gave as his address that of the rented home at Seventeen Mile Rocks, Brisbane. His UAE visa was keyed to the continuance of his employment there. His UAE driver’s licence and other UAE identification documentation specified his nationality as Australian. At the time of the hearing before the primary judge, Mr Pike remained employed in Dubai: [38];(ii)in February 2016 Mr Pike entered into a tenancy contract in relation to an unfurnished apartment in Dubai. The initial duration of the tenancy was one year but it was later extended. He furnished the apartment to his taste and to provide for visits from his family. He also purchased a vehicle in Dubai and opened bank and credit card accounts there. At the time of the hearing before the primary judge, Mr Pike remained employed in Dubai, living in his rented accommodation whenever in the UAE. The primary judge stated at [39] “[y]et again, he has made a home there”;(jj)Ms Thornicroft chose not to relocate to Tanzania when Mr Pike was employed there: [40];(kk)the number of days that Mr Pike spent in Australia in particular income years and the related percentage of each of those years were set out in the primary judgment at [42] as follows:

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Thirdly, an evaluation of the facts does not persuade us that the conclusion of the primary judge was wrong: Warren v Coombes [1979] HCA 9; 142 CLR 531 at 551 per Gibbs ACJ, Jacobs and Murphy JJ; Branir Pty Ltd v Owston Nominees (No 2) Pty Ltd [2001] FCA 1833; 117 FCR 424 at 437–8 [28]–[29] per Allsop J; Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v SZVFW [2018] HCA 30; 264 CLR 541 at 559–63 [40]–[49] per Gageler J; Commissioner of Taxation v Scone Race Club Limited [2019] FCAFC 225; 374 ALR 189 at 198–9 [46] per Griffiths J. An appeal court will not overturn the decision of the primary judge merely because it prefers an outcome different from that adopted by the primary judge where both outcomes are equally available or finely balanced. In our view, this is such a case as the findings of fact upon which the Commissioner rested his case do not compel a different conclusion. Nor can it be said that the conclusion reached by the primary judge was not reasonably open. CONCLUSION Accordingly we would dismiss the appeal and cross‑appeal.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established