Harding v Commissioner of Taxation

Link copied
Case Copied 75 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Harding v Commissioner of Taxation [2018] FCA 837

File number(s): QUD 417 of 2017
Judge(s): DERRINGTON J
Date of judgment: 8 June 2018
Catchwords: TAXATION – Residency of taxpayer – Whether resident according to ordinary concepts – Whether resident according to Domicile test – Meaning of “permanent place of abode” outside Australia – Whether rented accommodation for a temporary purpose was a “permanent place of abode”
Legislation:

Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth)

Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth)

Migration Act 1958 (Cth)

Domicile Act1982 (Cth)

Cases cited:

Applegate v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1978) 18 ALR 459

Armstead v Armstead [1954] VLR 733

Comcare Australia (Defence) v O'Dea (1998) 87 FCR 451

Commissioner of Inland Revenue v Diamond [2015] NZCA 613

Commissioner of Taxation v Miller (1946) 73 CLR 93

Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Applegate (1979) 27 ALR 114

Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Applegate (1979) 9 ATR 899

Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Jenkins (1982) 59 FLR 467

Gregory v Deputy Federal Commissioner of Taxation (WA) (1937) 57 CLR 774

Hafza v Director-General of Social Security (1985) 6 FCR 444

Koitaki Para Rubber Estates Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1941) 64 CLR 241

Levene v Inland Revenue Commissioners [1928] AC 217

LK v Director-General, Department of Community Services (2009) 237 CLR 582, 599

Miller v Teale (1954) 92 CLR 406

Re Cartier [1952] SASR 280

Re Dempsey and Federal Commissioner of Taxation (2014) 98 ATR 698

ReIyengar and Federal Commissioner of Taxation (2011) 85 ATR 924

Re Sneddon and Federal Commissioner of Taxation (2012) 89 ATR 739

Revenue and Customs Commissioners v Grace [2009] All ER (Dig) 280

Scargill v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (2003) 129 FCR 259

Smith v Smith [1975] 1 NSWLR 725

Taylor v Natwest Australia Bank Limited (unreported, FCA, Wilcox, Burchett, Foster JJ, 16 October 1992)

The Queen v Reeder [1975] DTC 5160

Thompson v Minister for National Revenue [1946] SCR 209

Date of hearing: 28 March 2018
Registry: Queensland
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Taxation
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 153
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr H Lakis
Solicitor for the Applicant: Cooper Grace Ward
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr D Butler
Solicitor for the Respondent: ATO Dispute Resolution
Table of Corrections
27 July 2018 In the Cases cited on the cover page, “Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Applegate [2015] NZCA 613” has been corrected to “Commissioner of Inland Revenue v Diamond [2015] NZCA 613”.
27 July 2018 In paragraph 17, at the end of the fourth sentence, “therm” has been corrected to “them”.
27 July 2018 In paragraph 32, the question mark at the end of the second last sentence has been changed to a full stop.
27 July 2018 In paragraph 57, in the third sentence, “here where the intention is” has been corrected to “where the intention is”.
27 July 2018 In paragraph 65, in the fourth sentence “is also is suspicious” has been replaced…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Harding v Commissioner of Taxation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] FCA 837
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Harding v Commissioner of Taxation involved Mr. Harding, an Australian national, and the Commissioner of Taxation. The dispute centred on Mr. Harding's residency status for tax purposes, specifically whether he was a resident of Australia according to the ordinary concepts of residency and the domicile test as outlined in section 6 of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (ITAA). The Federal Court of Australia was tasked with determining these issues.

The primary legal issue the Court had to address was whether Mr. Harding was a resident of Australia for tax purposes during the relevant income years. This involved interpreting the meaning of "resident" under both the ordinary concepts test and the domicile test. The Court also had to determine whether Mr. Harding's rented accommodation in Australia could be considered a "permanent place of abode" under the domicile test. The Court needed to assess the intention of Mr. Harding as reflected in his actions and statements, including his use of the Warana property and the details provided on his passenger cards.

The Court found that, despite various indicators suggesting Mr. Harding maintained ties to Australia, his intention was not to reside in Australia. The evidence demonstrated that Mr. Harding left Australia with the intention of permanently residing in the Middle East, pursuing his career and lifestyle there. The Court emphasized that although Mr. Harding had significant investments in Australia and maintained some presence there, his actions were not driven by an intention to reside in Australia. The Court concluded that Mr. Harding was not a resident under the ordinary concepts test because his presence in Australia was not accompanied by an intention to reside there. Regarding the domicile test, the Court determined that the rented accommodation in Australia did not constitute a "permanent place of abode" as it was used temporarily for visiting his family. The Court dismissed the appeal, holding that Mr. Harding was not a resident of Australia for tax purposes during the relevant period.

The Court further directed that the parties were to be heard on the question of costs. The orders of the Court were to dismiss the appeal and to address the issue of costs separately.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal is dismissed.

2. The parties are to be heard on the question of costs.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

An additional complication in relation to the definition of “resident of Australia” in s 6 of the ITAA is that the section contains an expanded definition of “resident” which, in part, utilises concepts of domicile and “a permanent place of abode”. That latter expression lacks precision in a number of respects. In addition, as is discussed below, the expanded definition of resident appears to contemplate that a person may have an Australian domicile whilst, at the same time, having a permanent place of abode outside of Australia. On the ordinary meaning of the expression “permanent place of abode”, such a concept is incongruous as, if a person had established a permanent place of abode outside Australia, they must necessarily have lost their domicile here. The facts As is often the case in matters of this nature, the facts are not greatly in dispute save, perhaps, for the subjective intention of the taxpayer concerning issues relevant to his residency or place of abode. Mr Harding is an Australian national having been born here on 11 July 1965. He is an Australian citizen and holds an Australian passport. He also holds a British passport. It appears that Mr Harding started his working life as an aircraft engineer with BAE Systems. He left Australia at a relatively young age and was married to his first wife (Ms Tracey Harding – a British national) on 20 July 1990 in the United Kingdom. In December 1990, Mr Harding’s employment with BAE Systems caused him and his wife to move to Khamis Mushayt in the south-west of Saudi Arabia. Mr and Mrs Harding lived there for about 7 years after which they moved to Riyadh. For all of that time Mr Harding continued his employment with BAE Systems. During this period Mr and Mrs Harding had two children and on each occasion Mrs Harding returned to the United Kingdom for their birth and only returned once they were about six weeks old. The uncontested evidence before the Court is that, Mr and Mrs Harding enjoyed life in the Middle East as part of the expatriate community. Indeed, it is apparent that Mr Harding was particularly enamoured with that way of life. It also appears that his expertise and abilities could be put to great use in that part of the world. The political and geopolitical situation in the Middle East worsened after the events which occurred in the United States of America on 11 September 2001. A number of armed attacks occurred in Saudi Arabia against Westerners. One of Mr and Mrs Hardings’ close friends was killed in the course of such an attack. Other attacks occurred in and around the area where the Hardings were living. For these reasons Mrs Harding returned to England with her two sons where those boys continued their schooling. Although they returned to the Middle East in August 2003, in the following year Mr and Mrs Harding decided to relocate to Australia. In her affidavit, Mrs Harding deposed that the move to Australia was always intended to be temporary and only until the security situation in the Middle East improved. At this time she was pregnant with her third child. In Australia Mr and Mrs Harding built a house at Warana on the Sunshine Coast in Queensland which was completed in early 2004. Although it was not stated explicitly, it appears that the location was chosen due to its proximity to Mr Harding’s parents and siblings. In any event, Mrs Harding and her two boys moved into the property in June 2004. Mr Harding remained in Riyadh until May 2006 at which time he decided to leave the Middle East and re-join his family in Australia.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Commissioner also relied upon the fact that when Mr Harding returned to Australia he stayed at the Warana property. Indeed, there is no doubt that he stayed there for not insignificant periods of time during the relevant income year. The evidence suggests that he was there for 91 days in total. However, the circumstances of his presence there cannot warrant the conclusion that he resided there. He was only there for the singular purpose of visiting his spouse and children and he was, in substance and in effect, on holidays there. Whilst he did “catch up” with friends on those occasions, that was obviously incidental to visiting his family. There is no evidence that he continued to treat the house at Warana as his home or his second home. That is, perhaps, best exemplified by the fact that in order to be there he was required to bring personal clothes and personal items with him. I accept that this is an unusual conclusion in cases of the type of which the present is one, however, it is warranted in the exceptional situation which occurred.The passenger cards – evidence of intention The Commissioner obtained copies of outgoing passenger cards and incoming passenger cards which Mr Harding completed for the purpose of international travel during the relevant financial year thereafter. He entered Australia on a number of occasions during the relevant financial year. On the outgoing passenger cards Mr Harding invariably indicated that he was an “Australian resident departing temporarily”. That was so for the period from July 2010 until July 2015. On the incoming passenger cards he, similarly, identified himself as a “resident returning to Australia”. However, on those cards he also identified that he did not “intend to live in Australia for the next 12 months”. If the incoming and outgoing passenger cards are taken at face value they could only mean that Mr Harding was, at all relevant times, an Australian resident. Whilst his stated intention when entering Australia that he will be living overseas for the following 12 months is important, it does not diminish the fact that he identified himself as remaining a “resident” here. On the face of the cards the two statements taken together are not inconsistent. At the very least they would indicate that Mr Harding was resident in two places. In his submissions Mr Butler, for the Commissioner, relied upon the decision of the Full Court in Taylor v Natwest Australia Bank Limited (unreported, FCA, Wilcox, Burchett, Foster JJ, 16 October 1992) where it was held that statements made by a person on a passenger card that they were an Australian resident, constitutes an admission in subsequent litigation to the effect that they were a resident at the relevant date. Their Honours said:We agree with counsel for the appellant that his client’s self-descriptions on the immigration cards should not be treated as necessarily conclusive. Theoretically, it may be possible to outweigh such evidence by material showing that a person was not in fact ordinarily resident in Australia. However, the descriptions on the cards of 29 March and 6 July constitute admissions by the appellant that he was an Australian resident at those dates. They are some evidence of his place of ordinary residence. They lie near to, and on either side of, the relevant date - the date of the act of bankruptcy. Whilst it is open to a person in the position of the appellant to show that admissions of this type are erroneous, the appellant has not done so.

Decision

Reasons for decision

It should be added that the factor of where a person maintains investments may, in these days, have little bearing on where a person resides. In the past quarter of a century there has been a growing internationalisation of investment markets which has increased the ability of people in one country to make investments in businesses in other countries. In this case it is, perhaps, not surprising that Mr Harding maintained significant investments in the relatively stable financial markets in Australia despite having abandoned his residency here.Conclusion on residency under the Ordinary Concept test Unquestionably, the circumstances of this case are most rare. It is an extraordinary situation where a husband and father would leave his erstwhile home in Australia, where his wife and family reside, to go to live and work in another country and be steadfast in that resolve regardless of whether his wife and family followed him. Although such a conclusion is somewhat counterintuitive, nevertheless, the evidence in this case points to Mr Harding having that exact interest. When he left Australia in 2009 he did not intend to return to live here. His entire expectations were that he would live in the Middle East and within a few years his wife and youngest child would follow. That was the basis on which he left. However, it does not follow that changing his residency was conditional upon his wife and family following. Contrary to the Commissioner’s submissions the existence of such an unconditional intention was borne out by the evidence. When, in 2011, Mrs Harding chose to remain in Australia, Mr Harding’s only thought was to encourage her to relocate to Bahrain. There was no suggestion that Mr Harding would return to Australia. Indeed, as the events played out, Mr Harding put his career and lifestyle ahead of his relationships with his wife and children and pursued the work opportunities in the Middle East. This same attitude was reflected a few years later when he sacrificed his relationship with Ms Gonzalez to move to work in Oman. On his departure from Australia, Mr Harding’s intention was to permanently leave Australia and his residence here. He intended to resume his residency in the Middle East in one country or another and to pursue his career there regardless of what his family did. It is clear that there are many factors in the circumstances of this case which are suggestive of Mr Harding retaining a residency in Australia. The Commissioner’s conclusion that Mr Harding remained a resident of Australia in the relevant income year pursuant to the Ordinary Concepts test is far from being unreasonable. However, the difficulty in this unusual case is that the many indicia of Mr Harding’s presence in Australia are not co-extensive with any intention to reside here. In those circumstances, he was not a resident under the Ordinary Concept. Residency under the Domicile test The Domicile test in sub-paragraph (a)(i) of the definition of resident in s 6(1), is an expanded test of “residency” for the purposes of the ITAA36. It provides that a person is a resident of Australia if they have an Australian domicile “unless the Commissioner is satisfied that the person’s permanent place of abode is outside of Australia”. Although the test is briefly stated, its application is far from easy or straightforward. A textual analysis of the Domicile test

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established