Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Australian Competition Tribunal

Link copied
Case Copied 84 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Competition & Consumer Commission v Australian Competition Tribunal
[2006] FCAFC 83

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – judicial review – gas pipelines access law – application for review of decision of Australian Competition Tribunal to vary access arrangement drafted and approved by regulator – review function of the Tribunal – whether Tribunal erred in law as to construction and application of code – function of regulator – whether regulator incorrectly or unreasonably exercised discretion – calculation of reference tariff – factors to be considered in establishing initial capital base – depreciation methodology

CONSTITUTIONAL LAW – co-operative legislative action of parliaments of the Commonwealth and the States – where Commonwealth administrative body or tribunal exercises functions under State law

Constitution:  ss 51, 61, 75, 77
Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth): s 39B

Pipeline Authority Act 1973 (Cth)

Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth): Pt IIIA, ss 44ZZM, 44ZZMA, 44ZZMB, 44ZZOA
Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth): s 23

Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 (Cth): Sch 3, ss 5, 6, 8

Moomba‑Sydney Pipeline System Sale Act 1994 (Cth)

Gas Pipelines Access (Commonwealth) Act1998 (Cth): ss 16, 18, 19

Gas Pipelines Access (South Australia) Act 1997 (SA): Sch 1 ss 38, 39; Sch 2 ss 2, 3, 8
Gas Pipelines Access (NSW) Act 1998 (NSW):  ss 10, 16, 18, 19, 21   
Gas Pipeline Access Act 1998 (ACT): ss 6, 15, 20
Evidence Act 1958 (Vic): s 55

R v Hughes (2000) 202 CLR 535, considered
Re Michael; Ex parte Epic Energy (WA) Nominees Pty Ltd (2002) 25 WAR 511, applied
R v Duncan; Ex parte Australian Iron and Steel Pty Ltd (1983) 158 CLR 535, considered
Re Cram; ex parte NSW Colliery Proprietors’ Association Ltd (1987) 163 CLR 117, considered
R v Cook; ex parte Twigg (1980) 147 CLR 15, cited
R v Toohey; ex parte Northern Land Council (1981) 151 CLR 170, cited
Application by GasNet Australia (Operations) Pty Ltd (2004) ATPR 41‑978, applied
Application by Epic Energy South Australia Pty Ltd (2003) ATPR 41‑932, applied
Morley v National Insurance Co [1967] VR 566, considered

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION v AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION TRIBUNAL and EAST AUSTRALIAN PIPELINE LIMITED
NSD 1191 OF 2004

FRENCH, GOLDBERG AND FINKELSTEIN JJ
2 JUNE 2006
MELBOURNE


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES  DISTRICT REGISTRY

NSD 1191 OF 2004

BETWEEN:

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION
Applicant

AND:

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION TRIBUNAL
First Respondent

EAST AUSTRALIAN PIPELINE LIMITED
Second Respondent

JUDGES:

FRENCH, GOLDBERG & FINKELSTEIN JJ

DATE OF ORDER:

2 JUNE 2006

WHERE MADE:

MELBOURNE (HEARD IN SYDNEY)

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.        The Australian Competition Tribunal decision of 19 May 2005 is set aside.

2.The parties are to file written submissions within seven days as to which, if any, portion of the reasons for the judgment of the Court should be treated as confidential on account of reference to confidential information before the Court.

3.The parties are to file submissions within seven…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Australian... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] FCAFC 83
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Australian Competition Tribunal, the primary dispute centred on the valuation of the Inland Main Supply Pipeline (MSP) and the calculation of the Economic Written Down Value (EWDV) for the pipeline. The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) contested the Australian Competition Tribunal's decision regarding the valuation and regulatory treatment of the MSP, asserting that the Tribunal had erred in its interpretation and application of the relevant provisions of the Code. The ACCC's appeal was grounded on the Tribunal's determination of the In-Place Cost Base (ICB) and the application of depreciation rates to the asset.

The central legal issue before the court was whether the Australian Competition Tribunal had correctly applied the Code in determining the appropriate valuation of the ICB for the MSP. The ACCC argued that the Tribunal had misinterpreted the criteria set out in section 8.10(g) of the Code, which pertains to the valuation of the ICB, and had not adequately considered the economic depreciation and historical returns, as required by section 8.10(f) of the Code. The ACCC further contended that the Tribunal had misapplied the depreciation rates, leading to an overestimation of the asset's value and an incorrect calculation of the EWDV.

The court found that the Tribunal had indeed erred in its determination of the ICB. It held that the Tribunal had not appropriately considered the basis on which tariffs had been set in the past, the economic depreciation, and historical returns as required by section 8.10(f) of the Code. The court also observed that the Tribunal's valuation of the ICB at $779 million did not align with the criteria stipulated in section 8.10(g), nor did it reflect the optimised replacement cost (ORC) of the assets depreciated over a 50-year asset life, consistent with the previous depreciation practices of the Eastern Australia Pipeline Limited (EAPL). Instead, the court concluded that the appropriate value for the ICB should be $559.3 million, based on the ORC depreciated over a 50-year asset life up to 2000 and an 80-year asset life from 2000 onwards, as per the Commission's assessment. Consequently, the court set aside the Tribunal's decision and ordered the parties to file written submissions regarding confidentiality and any consequential orders within seven days.

In its final orders, the court set aside the Australian Competition Tribunal's decision of 19 May 2005, mandated the filing of written submissions by the parties on the confidentiality of certain information within seven days, required submissions on any consequential orders to be filed within the same timeframe, and directed the second respondent to pay the applicant’s costs of the application.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The Australian Competition Tribunal decision of 19 May 2005 is set aside.

2. The parties are to file written submissions within seven days as to which, if any, portion of the reasons for the judgment of the Court should be treated as confidential on account of reference to confidential information before the Court.

3. The parties are to file submissions within seven days as to any consequential orders which should be made.

4. The second respondent is to pay the applicant’s costs of the application.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

FRENCH, GOLDBERG AND FINKELSTEIN JJ
The economic written down value of the MSP which reflected past under‑recoveries of depreciation and return on assets was said, at s 3.1.3, to reflect the original intention that the pipeline’s costs would be recovered over its life with early under‑recoveries being recouped in later years. Based on the ACCC’s calculation of the economic written down value of $1,291 million at 30 June 1994 EAPL estimated a value of $1,700 million at 30 June 2000.The ACCC’s Final Decision – 2 October 2003 In its Final Decision the ACCC set out a table identifying differences between various elements of the EAPL proposal as amended and the ACCC’s final decision. Differences relevant for present purposes were as follows: The ACCC’s Final Decision then addressed key issues. The first of these, grouped together, were Reference Tariff methodology, tariffs and revenue. The ACCC observed that as the NPV and price path methodologies used by EAPL are set out in the Code, it could have no objection to their use. It did, however, have concerns with individual parameters proposed by EAPL and had adopted different values for the ICB, rate of return, non‑capital costs and volumes. The ACCC referred to EAPL’s submission, based on s 8.10(g) of the Code, that the ICB should be valued at $779 million based upon ‘reasonable expectations under the prior regulatory regime’. The ACCC did not accept that an ICB of $779 million was underpinned by the previous regulatory regime or that it formed part of the 1994 Sale Agreement with the Australian Government. It did not consider that EAPL’s figure satisfied the criteria in s 8.10(g). It went on: ‘For the purposes of the Final Decision the Commission considers that the appropriate value for the ICB is $559.3 million. This valuation is based on the optimised replacement cost (ORC) of the assets, which the Commission has, over the period 1976 to 2000, depreciated on the basis of a 50 year asset life (the life assumed in the past by EAPL for depreciation purposes). Future depreciation charges, however, are based on an 80 year asset life, which EAPL submitted is now the useful life of the MSP and which the Commission has accepted. In determining the value for the ICB, the Commission has placed significant weight on section 8.10(f) of the Code which provides for consideration to be given to the basis on which tariffs have been (or appear to have been) set in the past, economic depreciation and historical returns. The Commission did not consider it appropriate to revalue the asset base upwards as a result of the variation to the useful life from 50 to 80 years. Revaluations upwards as a result of extensions to the useful life of an asset would result in the asset owner more than recovering its efficient costs over the life of the asset.’ Following a detailed discussion of its Draft Decision, submissions in response to it and its responses to those submissions, the ACCC set out its conclusions on the question of the ICB. It began by observing that s 8.11 of the Code provides that the value of the ICB should not normally fall outside the value of Depreciated Actual Cost (DAC) and DORC. It did not consider that the circumstances of the MSP would warrant a value outside this range. To support its valuation of the ICB at $559 million it gave ‘considerable weight’ to s 8.10(f) of the Code. It took as a starting point the value of ORC which it depreciated on the assumption of a 50 year asset life to 2000 consistent with the useful asset life previously assumed by EAPL. For the period from 2000 onwards the ACCC accepted and used the 80 year life, which EAPL had submitted was the current useful life of the system. This involved what was described as a ‘kinked’ depreciation.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: FRENCH, GOLDBERG AND FINKELSTEIN JJ