NEW SOUTH WALES COURT OF APPEAL
CITATION: Idoport v National Australia Bank Limited & Anor [2006] NSWCA 202
FILE NUMBER(S):
40681/05
HEARING DATE(S): 7 April 2006
DECISION DATE: 24/07/2006
PARTIES:
Idoport Pty Limited (Appellant)
National Australia Bank Limited (First Respondent)
National Markets Group Limited (Second Respondent)
JUDGMENT OF: Mason P Beazley JA Ipp JA
LOWER COURT JURISDICTION: Supreme Court - Equity Division
LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S): SC 50046/05
LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER: Bergin J
COUNSEL:
B Walker SC; J Harris SC; J Stephenson (Appellant)
T F Bathurst QC; R A Dick (Respondents)
SOLICITORS:
Sarvaas Ciappara (Appellant)
Freehills (Respondents)
CATCHWORDS:
ORDER – party barred by the court from bringing new proceedings in same cause of action or claim for relief – construction of barring order – whether new proceedings were “concerning any cause of action or the whole or any part of any claim for relief” that arose in earlier proceedings – new proceedings against entities not in existence previously – previous proceedings broad enough to encompass new proceedings
ABUSE OF PROCESS – courts inherent power to prevent abuse of its processes – proceedings brought without costs being paid for first action
LEGISLATION CITED:
Supreme Court Act 1970 (NSW) s 101(2)(e)
Supreme Court Rules 1970 (NSW) Pt 40 r 8, Pt 53 r 4
DECISION:
The appeal is dismissed with costs.
JUDGMENT:
- 47 -
IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COURT OF APPEAL
CA 40681/05
MASON P
BEAZLEY JA
IPP JA24 July 2006
IDOPORT PTY LIMITED
v
NATIONAL AUSTRALIA BANK LIMITED & ANOR
Headnote
Facts
The appellant brought proceedings (the present proceedings) against the respondents claiming the payment of amounts owed, both presently and in the future, under a Consulting Agreement.
The appellant had previously brought proceedings against the respondents claiming the payment of amounts owed under the same Consulting Agreement. Those proceedings were dismissed by Einstein J in the Supreme Court Equity Division due to the failure of the appellant to provide security for costs as had previously been ordered by the Court. In addition, Einstein J made a barring Order prohibiting the bringing of “fresh proceedings concerning any cause of action or the whole or any part of any claim for relief by it in these proceedings, until costs in these proceedings have been paid in full”.
The respondents applied by Notice of Motion to set aside, dismiss, or stay the present proceedings. The Notice of Motion came before Bergin J who ordered that the present proceedings be dismissed. The appellant brought this appeal against her Honour’s order, the issue on appeal thereby being whether the present proceedings were barred by the terms of the barring Order.
The respondents filed a Notice of Contention claiming, inter alia, that the Court should dismiss the present proceedings in the exercise of its inherent power to prevent an abuse of its own processes.
Held per Beazley JA (Mason P and Ipp JA agreeing):
(i) The present proceedings came within the terms of the barring Order.
(ii)…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Idoport Pty Ltd v National Australia Bank Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2006] NSWCA 202
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Court of Appeal was required to determine whether the new proceedings, brought against entities not previously named, fell within the scope of the earlier barring order. Specifically, the court had to consider whether the claims in the new proceedings were "concerning any cause of action or the whole or any part of any claim for relief" that arose in the earlier proceedings, and whether the inherent power of the court to prevent abuse of process was engaged, particularly in light of the appellant's failure to pay costs for the first action.
The Court of Appeal, affirming the primary judge's reasoning, held that the claims in the new proceedings were indeed encompassed by the earlier barring order. The court found that the appellant's pleadings and opening submissions in the main proceedings were intentionally broad, using phrases such as "and otherwise" and referring to systems "whether in existence" or "subsequently developed" by "any other person." This broad framing was designed to ensure that the main proceedings would be determinative of the issues now raised in the new proceedings, even if specific entities had not been expressly named. The court concluded that the claims made in the main proceedings were exceptionally wide and sufficient to capture all claims made in the present proceedings, thus constituting an abuse of process.
The appeal was dismissed with costs.
Orders
Orders of the court
The appeal is dismissed with costs.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
After having referred to the opening, set out at [94] above, her Honour at [50], [51] and [52] also referred to the appellant’s written Outline of the opening and its written reply to the respondents' opening;"50A written Outline of the opening relating to issues in the pleadings was provided to Einstein J. That Outline stated that the definition of AUSMAQ Service in the Consulting Agreement 'is ambulatory for the duration of the Consulting Agreement' and 'catches any service with equivalent or similar functionality'. It was noted that the term 'functionality' was not defined in the Consulting Agreement but that it 'must be understood in the light of the AUSMAQ Service’s actual and potential functionality'. 51In respect of 'operating entity' the written outline stated as follows (emphasis added): 67. It is [the appellant's] case:(1)That [the first respondent] and any other entity whether a body corporate or otherwise, which is developing, exploiting, commercialising or marketing each of the four NAB services, is doing so in respect of services with equivalent or similar functionality to the AUSMAQ Service as defined in the Consulting Agreement.…70.Furthermore, the definitions of System IP Rights and AUSMAQ Service are inter-related and of ambulatory effect during the continuance of the Consulting Agreement.…71. Consequently, (1) 'entity' as used in the definition of 'Operating Entity' in clause 1.1 of the Consulting Agreement includes: Her Honour concluded that the phrase “and otherwise” in the pleading was intentional, had work to do and was not a mere drafting slip. She said:"53… The words 'and otherwise' were [appropriate] for the broad nature of the claims made by [the appellant] in the Main Proceedings. Those words were not a slip or a drafter’s flourish. They were totally consistent with the very high and wide claims made in relation to systems 'whether in existence' in 1996 or 'subsequently developed' by [the second respondent] 'or any other person' and operating entities whether named or not. 54The Summons in the present proceedings makes claims in respect of operating entities that, except for NAFM, have not previously been expressly named in the Main Proceedings … I am satisfied that [the appellant] was, by its pleadings in the Main Proceedings and, by its Senior Counsel’s opening in the Main Proceedings, concerned to ensure, and did ensure, that the Main Proceedings would be determinative of the very issues raised for determination in these proceedings." I agree with her Honour's reasons. The claims made in the Main Proceedings were exceptionally wide – wide enough to capture every claim made in the present proceedings. It is conceivable that at some stage during the hearing of the Main Proceedings there may have been an argument about particulars in the sense that the respondents may have conceivably sought to limit the ambit of the claims sought to be pursued because there had been no particularisation of e.g. a particular entity or a particular operating system with the same functionality of the Ausmaq Service. But the appeal was not fought on particulars.