Wong v National Australia Bank Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 78 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Wong v National Australia Bank Limited [2022] FCAFC 155

Appeal from: Wong v National Australia Bank Limited [2021] FCA 671
File number: VID 393 of 2021
Judgment of: KATZMANN, CHARLESWORTH AND O'SULLIVAN JJ
Date of judgment: 8 September 2022
Catchwords: EMPLOYMENT LAW – appeal from orders dismissing an application alleging contravention of s 340 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) – where primary judge found that an employer’s reasons for taking adverse actions against an employee did not include the fact that the employee had made complaints and inquiries about her employment – employer a corporation – where primary judge found that the employee’s immediate supervisor made a significant contribution to the employer’s decision – whether primary judge erred in concluding that it was unnecessary to interrogate the supervisor’s state of mind in considering whether the employer had discharged its burden of proof under s 361 – where primary judge held that the supervisor genuinely held opinions about the employee’s behaviour and performance – whether the primary judge erred in assessing the credit of the supervisor as a witness – whether the objective circumstances precluded a finding that the supervisor’s opinions were genuinely held – role of the Court on an appeal by way of rehearing in respect of factual findings based in part on impressions the primary judge formed of the supervisor as a witness
Legislation: Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) ss 340, 341, 342, 346, 360, 361, 550, 570, 793
Cases cited:

Abalos v Australian Postal Commission (1990) 171 CLR 167

Australian Red Cross Society v Queensland Nurses’ Union of Employees (2019) 273 FCR 332

Australian Workers’ Union v John Holland Pty Ltd (2001) 103 IR 205

Board of Bendigo Regional Institute of Technical and Further Education v Barclay [No 1] (2012) 248 CLR 500

Brennan v Comcare (1994) 50 FCR 555

Clark Boyce v Mouat [1994] 1 AC 428

Comcare v PVYW (2013) 250 CLR 246

Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v BHP Coal Pty Ltd (2014) 253 CLR 243

Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v Claremont Coal Pty Ltd (2015) 253 IR 166

Devers v Kindilan Society [2010] FCAFC 72; 269 ALR 404

Devries v Australian National Railways Commission (1993) 177 CLR 472

Elliot v Kodak Australasia Pty Ltd (2001) 129 IR 251

Fox v Percy (2003) 214 CLR 118

General Motors-Holden’s Pty Ltd v Bowling (1976) 51 ALJR 235

Jones v Hyde (1989) 63 ALJR 349

Lee v Lee (2019) 266 CLR 129

Liberty Mutual Insurance Company Australia Branch (t/as Liberty Speciality Markets) v Icon Co (NSW) Pty Ltd [2021] FCAFC 126; 396 ALR 193

National Tertiary Education Union v Royal Melbourne Institute of Technology (2013) 234 IR 139

Nocton v Lord Ashburton [1914] AC 932

Roberts v General Motors-Holden’s Employees’ Canteen Society Inc (1975) 172 CAR 1073

Sica v Brophy [2020] NSWCA 181

Voigtsberger v Pine Rivers Shire Council (1981) 1 IR 198

Wong v National Australia Bank Limited [2021] FCA 671

Wood v City…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Wong v National Australia Bank Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] FCAFC 155
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Wong v National Australia Bank Limited involved Ms. Wong appealing against orders that dismissed her application alleging contravention of section 340 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) by the National Australia Bank Limited (NAB). Ms. Wong argued that NAB took adverse actions against her because she had made complaints and inquiries about her employment. The primary judge concluded that Ms. Wong's immediate supervisor, Mr. Darran Arnott, did not participate in the decision-making process to a degree that warranted interrogation of his state of mind. Furthermore, the judge found that even if Mr. Arnott had participated, his reasons for acting were not influenced by the complaints and inquiries made by Ms. Wong.

The legal issues before the court were whether the primary judge erred in concluding that it was unnecessary to interrogate Mr. Arnott's state of mind and whether the judge erred in assessing the credit of Mr. Arnott as a witness. The court needed to determine if the primary judge had correctly applied the principles concerning the role of an immediate supervisor in the decision-making process and the assessment of witness credibility. The role of the court on appeal was to review the primary judge's factual findings and legal conclusions.

The court found that the primary judge did not err in concluding that it was unnecessary to interrogate Mr. Arnott's state of mind. The court accepted that Mr. Arnott's role, while significant, did not elevate him to the rank of decision-maker. The decision to dismiss Ms. Wong was ultimately Ms. MacLeod's, and the court held that it was not necessary to interrogate Mr. Arnott's state of mind to determine NAB's reasons for the adverse actions. Regarding the assessment of Mr. Arnott's credibility, the court found no error in the primary judge's evaluation of his evidence. The court concluded that the primary judge's findings were supported by the evidence and that there was no basis to interfere with those findings on appeal.

The appeal was dismissed, and the orders of the primary judge were upheld. The court did not find merit in Ms. Wong's arguments concerning the primary judge's assessment of the evidence and the role of Mr. Arnott in the decision-making process. The findings of the primary judge were affirmed, and the appeal was accordingly dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal is dismissed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons that follow we consider there to be merit in that submission.Facts The role of Mr Arnott in the decision-making process, culminating in the removal of Ms Wong from her role was summarised by the primary judge in the following terms (at [193]):There is no doubt that Mr Arnott had a significant role to play in the process that culminated in Ms Wong’s removal from the role of ‘Manager[,] Internet Banking’. Mr Arnott, of course, was Ms Wong’s immediate supervisor. On any view, he had greater visibility of her work, her conduct, her strengths and her imperfections than did Ms MacLeod. He was, on any view unsurprisingly, Ms MacLeod’s primary (though not sole) source of information concerning Ms Wong. It cannot be doubted that the reasons that actuated Ms MacLeod’s decision—or ‘formal decision’, as the case may be—to remove Ms Wong from her role were reasons that formed in Ms MacLeod’s mind because of (or partially or largely because of) information or advice that Mr Arnott fed to her. It is also plain beyond doubt that he played a not-insignificant administrative role in the process that culminated in Ms Wong’s removal. By way of example, he assisted with the drafting of the 21 March 2017 Announcement and a script to which Ms MacLeod spoke at her meeting with Ms Wong earlier that day. The primary judge later summarised the information conveyed to Ms MacLeod (at [239]):… Over a series of discussions, he told Ms MacLeod about the behavioural problems that he and others had encountered or observed (including Ms Wong’s aggressive and dismissive interactions with colleagues and her seeming unwillingness to accept feedback with which she disagreed), and the disproportionate amount of time that he was spending dealing with her and with problems associated with the internet banking platform (including, most recently, problems associated with the NPP). Mr Arnott told Ms MacLeod of his concerns that Ms Wong’s impact on others threatened to sound in ‘team members taking stress leave or leaving NAB’. He told her that he did not think that he could continue to work with Ms Wong, noting words to the effect that ‘Ms Wong is the most difficult person I have had to deal with in my life’. The findings recited in those paragraphs are not the subject of challenge by any party. The following intermediary facts are the subject of findings elsewhere in the reasons for judgment or are otherwise undisputed. Ms MacLeod sent an email to Ms Wong on 21 March 2017 by which she summarised what had occurred during a meeting earlier that day and notified Ms Wong of the decision to remove her from her role. The meeting was attended by Ms MacLeod, Ms Wong and a member of NAB’s human resources department, Mr Adrian Sbrugnera. The email (accurately) recorded that Ms MacLeod had raised three issues. First, Ms MacLeod said that she was concerned about the performance of the internet banking platform for which Ms Wong was responsible. The concerns were summarised as follows:•Consistent feedback from stakeholders within and outside of Digital that the platform is incredibly challenging to deal with.•Clear lack of leadership, direction and coherence across the team.•Ongoing loss of key people within the team (key examples include UX & Design resources, and digital technology staff).•Lack of transparency and clear articulation of risks and issues within the platform.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

As discussed below, the primary judge proceeded to consider and make findings concerning Mr Arnott’s state of mind on the assumption that his conclusion that Mr Arnott was not “relevantly a decision-maker” was wrong (at [203]). The greater portion of his Honour’s reasons for judgment are devoted to that topic and are the subject of grounds 5 to 7. As Counsel for Ms Wong properly acknowledged, the appeal cannot succeed unless those grounds are also made good.DID THE PRIMARY JUDGE ERR BY ACCEPTING MR ARNOTT’S EVIDENCE THAT HE WAS NOT ACTUATED BY THE PROHIBITED REASON (GROUNDS 5 TO 7)? Ground 5 concerns the primary judge’s conclusion that nothing Mr Arnott (and therefore NAB) did in relation to the removal decision was because of, or for reasons that included, the making of any of the complaints or inquiries upon which Ms Wong relied. It alleges that the primary judge erred in the following respects:a.his Honour erred in concluding that the evidence led to establish the veracity of the opinions about Ms Wong to which Mr Arnott attributed his conduct rose no higher than to establish that those opinions were formed wrongly or unfairly (Decision [206] and [280]). His Honour should have regarded the veracity (or otherwise) of the opinions of Ms Wong to which Mr Arnott attributed his conduct as important to the overall facts and circumstances in assessing whether NAB had discharged its onus pursuant to s.361 of the FW Act;b.his Honour failed to give adequate or sufficient weight to evidence and arguments that Mr Arnott’s concerns about Ms Wong’s behaviour were exaggerated and were not an actuating reason for removing Ms Wong from her role as Internet Banking Manager (Decision [242]-[249]);c.his Honour failed to give adequate or sufficient weight to the evidence and arguments that the allegations of poor performance levelled against Ms Wong relating to the late notification of the cost increase to the Internet Banking platform on the NPP Project were not part of the real reason for removing Ms Wong from her role as Manager, Internet Banking and were manufactured as an excuse to remove Ms Wong from that role (Decision [251]-[269]);d.his Honour failed to have regard to the evidence (or failed to provide adequate reasons for not having regard to the evidence) that established that Mr Arnott did not like the fact that Ms Wong complained;e.his Honour erred in concluding that the evidence that Mr Arnott gave about the views that he formed about Ms Wong and their influence on his conduct were not exaggerated or untruthful (Decision [283]). Specifically, his Honour erred:i.in concluding that none of the aspects of Mr Arnott’s evidence that were plainly wrong or inconsistent were of essential importance (Decision [274]), in circumstances where they were of central importance; andii.in concluding that Mr Arnott did not try to downplay his role in providing the figures and information to Ms MacLeod in relation to the alleged NPP costs blowout, in the face of evidence led by NAB itself of Ms MacLeod that she relied on Mr Arnott for the figures and information about the alleged costs blowout to the NPP (Decision [276]);f.his Honour failed to give adequate reasons for his conclusion that the views Mr Arnott formed about Ms Wong and their influence on his conduct were not exaggerated or untruthful (Decision [283]) (the credibility of Mr Arnott and his evidence being a critical issue to be determined in the proceeding); …

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ms Wong’s appeal concerns three decisions made by NAB relating to her employment: a decision to remove her from her role on 21 March 2017 (removal decision), a decision to announce the removal in an email distributed to 423 of her colleagues on the same day and a decision to terminate her employment on 11 May 2017 (termination decision). According to NAB, those decisions were taken because of the poor performance of the internet banking platform under Ms Wong’s management and Ms Wong’s behaviour in the workplace. Part 3-1 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (FW Act) is titled “General protections”. Its objects expressly include the protection of workplace rights. Section 340 (contained in Pt 3-1) prohibits a person from taking “adverse action” against another person because the other person has (relevantly) exercised a “workplace right”. For the purposes of Pt 3-1, an employee has a workplace right if the person is “able to make” a complaint or inquiry in relation to his or her employment: FW Act, s 341(1)(c)(ii). The expression “adverse action” is defined to include the dismissal of a person from his or her employment and the alteration of an employee’s position to his or her prejudice: FW Act, s 342(1), Item 1. It is common ground that the removal of Ms Wong from her role, the announcement of the removal (hereafter the 21 March 2017 Announcement) and the termination of her employment each meets the statutory definition of adverse action. At first instance, Ms Wong relevantly alleged that NAB contravened s 340 of the FW Act by taking the adverse actions because she had exercised her workplace right to make complaints or inquiries concerning her employment. The case was founded on 19 discrete complaints and two discrete inquiries. The primary judge accepted that Ms Wong was “able to make” some (but not all) of those complaints and enquiries within the meaning of s 341. His Honour went on to find that NAB had not taken the adverse actions because of any of the pleaded complaints and inquiries and so rejected Ms Wong’s claims: Wong v National Australia Bank Limited [2021] FCA 671. A claim founded in tort was also unsuccessful. Ms Wong appeals from that part of the judgment concerning NAB’s alleged contraventions of the FW Act. Seven grounds were pleaded. Ground 1 was abandoned during the hearing of the appeal. Briefly summarised, the remaining are to the effect that the primary judge erred by:(1)finding that Ms Wong’s immediate supervisor, Mr Darran Arnott, did not participate in the decisions constituting the adverse actions in such a way that required any interrogation of his state of mind (grounds 2 to 4); and(2)finding that even if Mr Arnott participated in the decisions constituting the adverse actions such that his reasons for acting were to be attributed to NAB, he did not act for the prohibited reason that Ms Wong has made complaints and inquiries concerning her employment (grounds 5 to 7).OUTCOME OF THE APPEAL

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

As to the termination of Ms Wong’s employment, the primary judge accepted that Mr Arnott’s role in the process ending in that decision was “significant” (at [303]), but considered that his contribution was not “such as to elevate him to the rank of decision-maker, or to otherwise require, in the search for NAB’s reasons for dismissing Ms Wong, any interrogation of his state of mind” (at [303]). His Honour continued:304There is no evidence to suggest that Mr Arnott had any executive power or authority, formal or otherwise, and exercisable jointly with Ms MacLeod or otherwise, to bring an end to Ms Wong’s employment. That he enjoyed some influence—even a great degree of influence—over Ms MacLeod’s decision is not sufficient. Dismissal decisions often involve input from multiple sources, some more significant or powerful than others. It might be that, in some circumstances, an adviser might wield such a degree of influence over a decision-maker that he or she should be understood to have participated in the making of a given decision; but that is not the case here. Here, Ms Wong confuses a desire that she attributes to Mr Arnott to wield the influence that he had toward a particular end (namely, her dismissal) with his having possessed the means to effect that end. There is no evidence that Mr Arnott possessed any such means: he wielded no more influence over Ms MacLeod’s decision to dismiss Ms Wong than Mr Kane’s former employee organisation wielded in City of Melbourne or the AWU’s rival union wielded in John Holland.305That is not to say that Mr Arnott’s conduct, assuming that it was animated by some prohibited purpose, would necessarily be immune to challenge under Pt 3-1 of the FW Act. It might well be that, by having had the discussions about Ms Wong that he had and by having provided the assistance that he provided during the process that resulted in her dismissal (and, indeed, in the other instances of adverse action to which she was subjected), Mr Arnott exposed Ms Wong to some relevantly prejudicial alteration to her position as a NAB employee; and, thereby, took adverse action against her directly. Were that so, some interrogation of his state of mind would be necessary. That, though, is not the case that Ms Wong advances.306The decision to dismiss Ms Wong was Ms MacLeod’s. In determining the corporate state of mind with which NAB effected that decision, it is not necessary to interrogate the state of Mr Arnott’s conscience.Consideration The inquiry into whether Mr Arnott contributed to the decision-making process culminating in the adverse actions to a degree sufficient to warrant interrogation of his state of mind involved an evaluation of the objective facts in light of the principles stated in the authorities. We do not consider the underlying facts to be the subject of significant controversy. It is plain that the information Mr Arnott provided to Ms MacLeod was adopted by her for its truth, just as she accepted the truth of what other personnel told her. It is also plain that Ms MacLeod was motivated to remove Ms Wong from her role because of the breakdown in relations between her and Mr Arnott. She accepted Mr Arnott’s word that Ms Wong’s behaviour was the cause of the problem. She could not tolerate a situation in which Mr Arnott and Ms Wong could not work together.