Atkins v North Australian Aboriginal Justice Agency Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 75 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Atkins v North Australian Aboriginal Justice Agency Ltd [2024] FCA 686

File number: NTD 3 of 2023
Judgment of: CHARLESWORTH J
Date of judgment: 27 June 2024
Catchwords:

CORPORATIONS – employee alleging her employer (a company) purported to dismiss her from her employment – employee alleging the purported dismissal was not legally effective – whether a resolution of the Board of a company for the termination of the company’s Chief Executive Officer was made in compliance with the company’s Constitution – consequences of non-compliance – whether s 1322(2) of the Corporation Act 2001 (Cth) operated to cure a procedural irregularity – whether substantial injustice would result if the procedural irregularity were so cured

INDUSTRIAL LAW – alleged contraventions of s 340 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) – employee alleging her employer took five adverse actions because she exercised or threatened to exercise workplace rights – employer having the onus to prove that the adverse actions were not taken because the employee had exercised or proposed to exercise workplace rights – where members of a Board of directors gave evidence – whether the evidence was sufficient to prove that persons other than the witnesses materially participated or brought about the decisions – where some witness testimony about the reasons for the taking adverse actions could not be accepted in light of objective facts – relevance of temporal coincidence between employee’s exercise of workplace rights and employer’s adverse actions – whether the employer’s evidence established that some directors of a Board had not acted on a report the existence of which may have resulted from the acts or omissions of a person actuated by a prohibited reason – where presumption in s 361 of the Fair Work Act applied by reason of deficiencies in the case presented by the employer  

Legislation:

Australian Charities and Not-for-profits Commission Act 2012 (Cth)

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 1247B, 1322, 1382

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) s 191

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) ss 340, 341, 342, 360, 361, 546, 793

Heydon JD, Cross on Evidence (14th ed, LexisNexis Australia, 2024)  

Cases cited:

Alam v National Australia Bank Ltd (2021) 288 FCR 301

Australian Red Cross Society v Queensland Nurses’ Union of Employees (2019) 273 FCR 332

Automatic Fire Sprinklers Pty Ltd v Watson (1946) 72 CLR 435

Board of Bendigo Regional Institute of Technical and Further Education v Barclay (2012) 248 CLR 500

Browne v Dunn (1893) 6 R 67

Byrne v Australian Airlines Ltd (1995) 185 CLR 410

Carter v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (2020) 279 FCR 83

Central Innovation Pty Ltd v Garner (No 4) [2020] FCA 1796

Community Public Sector Union v Telstra Corporation Ltd (2001) 107 FCR 93

Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v BHP Coal Pty Ltd (2014) 253 CLR 243

Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v Claremont Coal Pty Ltd (2015) 253 IR 166

Elliot v Kodak Australasia Pty Ltd (2001) 129 IR 251

Garner v Central Innovation Pty Limited [2022]…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Atkins v North Australian Aboriginal Justice Agency Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] FCA 686
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Atkins v North Australian Aboriginal Justice Agency Ltd involved a legal dispute where the plaintiff, Ms Atkins, alleged that her employer, NAAJA, had improperly dismissed her. Ms Atkins claimed that the purported dismissal was not legally effective and that the Board's resolution for her termination did not comply with the company's Constitution. The court had to determine whether the resolution was made in accordance with the company's Constitution and if non-compliance had any legal consequences. Additionally, the court examined whether section 1322(2) of the Corporation Act 2001 (Cth) could cure any procedural irregularities and whether substantial injustice would result from such a cure.

The legal issues before the court included the validity of the Board's resolution for Ms Atkins' dismissal and the potential consequences of non-compliance with the company's Constitution. The court also considered whether NAAJA contravened section 340 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) by taking adverse actions against Ms Atkins for exercising her workplace rights. The employer had the onus to prove that the adverse actions were not related to the exercise of workplace rights. The court had to evaluate whether the evidence provided by the Board members was sufficient to establish that the adverse actions were not taken for prohibited reasons and whether the employer's evidence established that some directors had not acted on a report that may have been influenced by a prohibited reason.

The court found that NAAJA's Board resolution for Ms Atkins' dismissal did not comply with the company's Constitution, and the failure to follow the prescribed procedure resulted in the resolution being invalid. The court determined that section 1322(2) of the Corporation Act could not cure the procedural irregularity in this case. The court also found that NAAJA contravened section 340 of the Fair Work Act by taking adverse actions against Ms Atkins for exercising her workplace rights. The employer failed to provide sufficient evidence to prove that the adverse actions were not related to the exercise of workplace rights. The court concluded that substantial injustice would result if the procedural irregularity were to be cured.

The court ordered a further case management hearing to be held on 4 July 2024 and directed Ms Atkins to provide proposed minutes of order for the preparation of the trial on the issue of remedies by 3 July 2024. The minutes were to propose dates for the exchange of proposed declarations of contravention, the filing of affidavits, and the exchange of written submissions.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. There be a further case management hearing at 10.00am on 4 July 2024.

2. At or before 3.00pm on 3 July 2024, the applicant is to provide to the respondent and to the Court proposed minutes of order for the preparation of the trial on the issue of remedies, such minutes to propose dates for:

(a) the exchange of proposed declarations of contravention giving effect to the reasons published today;

(b) the filing of affidavits; and

(c) the exchange of written submissions.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Section 793 of the FW Act attributes certain conduct and states of mind to a body corporate. It too will be discussed elsewhere in these reasons.PART 3: KEY EVENTS AND FACTS Before turning to the pleadings it is convenient to set out some facts as agreed in a Statement of Agreed Facts dated 14 July 2023 as amended on 30 October 2023 (SOAF), and facts admitted on the pleadings. In this part of my reasons, I will also record some preliminary findings based on evidence that was not seriously contested.NAAJA, the Constitution and the Board NAAJA is a charity registered with the Australian Charities and Not for Profit Commission (ACNC) under the Australian Charities and Not-for-profits Commission Act 2012 (Cth). Its Constitution is dated 7 May 2018 and is lodged with the ACNC. It has more than 160 employees and has offices in Darwin, Palmerston, Katherine, Alice Springs and Tennant Creek. NAAJA receives its funding through the Commonwealth Attorney-General’s Department, the Department of Prime Minister and Cabinet and the Northern Territory Government. The funding typically occurs in accordance with funding agreements renewed in five yearly cycles. The object of NAAJA is set out in clause 1.2 of its Constitution. It is to provide high quality and culturally appropriate legal aid and related services for Aboriginal people in need of benevolent relief within the Northern Territory, including by providing representatives to act as support officers for Aboriginal people in custody, to assist with their rehabilitation and reform, by providing legal education to communities and by engaging in law reform relevant to those objectives. Clause 1.3 requires that NAAJA apply its funding and income solely toward promoting its objects. In due course it will be necessary to extract and construe some critical parts of the Constitution. For now, it is sufficient to record only some of its features. The Board is constituted in a way that ensures representation of Aboriginal people from across four defined Regions of the Northern Territory, referred to as Katherine Region, Darwin Region, Miwatj Region and Southern Region. Clause 3.3 requires that NAAJA have at least eight directors, consisting of at least two from each Region. There are to be no more than 16 directors in total, with no more than four from each Region. Membership of NAAJA is divided into four classes, comprising Aboriginal persons who have lived in a Region for at least one year prior to the date of their nomination for membership and who continue to have their usual place of residence in that Region: Constitution, clause 2.2. Under clause 3.2, directors from each Region are appointed by members of that Region’s class. Subject to some exceptions that are not presently relevant, the powers of the Board can only be exercised by resolutions passed at a meeting of the Board or in accordance with certain delegations of power: Constitution, clause 7.2. Provisions relating to the quorum for meetings are discussed in Part 9 of these reasons.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The same may be said of Mr Taziwa. He is an obvious witness who had knowledge of matters requiring an explanation, specifically in connection with his dealings with Ms Evans and the identity of persons who provided him with documents (or did not provide him with documents as the case may be). Like all litigants, NAAJA made choices about the presentation of its case. Its approach was to simply ignore the inferences that could be drawn from the documents that evidenced Ms Evans’ involvement in the process culminating in (at least) the BDO Report, rather than positively grappling with their implications or adducing evidence to put a different complexion on them. Given her connection with the Complaint and her motivations as I have found them, that is highly unusual. The consequence of the choice not to call Ms Evans or Mr Taziwa is that the Court cannot be satisfied of NAAJA’s pleaded case because there is a body of unexplained evidence that significantly detracts from it. It is not necessary to categorise either Ms Evans or Mr Taziwa as a “decision-maker” to reach that conclusion.Alleged Board consideration of Ms Evans’ response to the Complaint NAAJA’s case was that the Board resolved not to do anything further about the allegations made against Ms Evans in the Complaint after the considering her response and satisfying itself that the matters raised in it were “operational in nature”. I accept that is the impression conveyed in Mr Brown’s letter to Ms Evans of 30 January 2023. However, I do not consider that letter to be a reliable business record, at least for the purpose of proving the truth of the matters sated in it. On the material before me, it has not been demonstrated that all directors considered Ms Evans response and formed a joint view about it, whether at a meeting or at all. Several directors said that they had not been made aware of Ms Evans’ response at all. They include Mr McLennan, Mr Hill and Ms Assan. That is a further example of NAAJA witnesses and lawyers using the word “Board” too loosely in order to suggest that collective decisions had been made when the objective evidence does not demonstrate that any such thing occurred. I am not satisfied that Ms Evans’ response to the Complaint had been resolved at the level of the Board at any time before the January Meeting or the February Meeting. The evidence supports a finding that the Board had done nothing to address some of the allegations made in the Complaint. They include an allegation that Ms Evans made an offer on a property at Tenant Creek and an allegation that she had caused NAAJA to procure a large quantity of laptop computers but had refused to produce them or disclose their whereabouts to Ms Atkins when directed to do so. The adjective “operational” was used by nearly all of the NAAJA’s directors in connection with the matters raised in the Complaint. To describe the matters as “operational” says nothing about gravity of the issues that had been raised.