Eckel v Ballarat Community Health Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 63 min read

Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia

(Division 2)

Eckel v Ballarat Community Health Ltd [2022] FedCFamC2G 890

File number(s): MLG 2742 of 2018
Judgment of: JUDGE SYMONS
Date of judgment: 27 October 2022
Catchwords: INDUSTRIAL LAW – Fair Work – general protections – where applicant exercised workplace rights – where applicant alleges adverse action (refusal to employ) taken as a result – where decision not to employ informed by panel interview process – where one of the panel members did not give evidence at hearing – where evidence of other panel members failed to expose decision-making process – where explanation as to scoring of applicant during interview unsatisfactory – reverse onus not discharged by employer – contravention of s 340(1) of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) established
Legislation: Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) ss 340, 341, 342, 345, 360, 361, 368, 539, 793
Cases cited:

Alam v National Australia Bank Limited (2021) 393 ALR 629; [2021] FCAFC 178.

Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v CoreStaff WA Pty Ltd (2020) 296 IR 459; [2020] FCA 893.

Australian Workers’ Union v BHP Iron-Ore Pty Ltd (2001) 106 FCR 482; [2001] FCA 3.

Fox v Percy (2003) 214 CLR 118; [2003] HCA 22.

Klein v Metropolitan Fire and Emergency Services Board (2012) 208 FCR 178; [2012] FCA 1402.

Lamont v University of Queensland (No 2) [2020] FCA 720.

Murrihy v Betezy.com.au Pty Ltd (2013) 238 IR 307; [2013] FCA 908.

Serpanos v Commonwealth of Australia [2022] FCA 1226.

Shea v TruEnergy Services Pty Ltd (No 6) (2014) 242 IR 1; [2014] FCA 271.

Transport Workers’ Union of Australia v Qantas Airways Ltd (2021) 308 IR 244 ; [2021] FCA 873.

Qantas Airways Ltd v Transport Workers’ Union of Australia (2022) 402 ALR 1; [2022] FCAFC 71.

Wong v National Australia Bank Limited [2022] FCAFC 155

Division: Division 2 General Federal Law
Number of paragraphs: 147
Date of last submission/s: 27 August 2021
Date of hearing: 25-27 August 2021
Place: Melbourne
Applicant In person
Counsel for the Respondent Mr N. Harrington
Solicitor for the Respondent K&L Gates

ORDERS

MLG 2742 of 2018

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA (DIVISION 2)

BETWEEN:

BRENDAN ECKEL

Applicant

AND:

BALLARAT COMMUNITY HEALTH LTD

Respondent

order made by:

JUDGE SYMONS

DATE OF ORDER:

27 October 2022

THE COURT DECLARES THAT:

1.The respondent contravened section 340(1) of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) by taking adverse action against the applicant for a prohibited reason by refusing to employ him in the role of Clinical Liaison and Withdrawal Nurse.

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

2.The proceedings are adjourned to 7 December 2022 at 10:00am for further directions.

Note: The form of the order is subject to the entry in the Court’s records.

Note: This copy of the Court’s Reasons for judgment may be subject to review to remedy minor typographical or grammatical errors (r 17.05(2)(g) Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Eckel v Ballarat Community Health Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] FedCFamC2G 890
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Eckel v Ballarat Community Health Ltd involved a dispute between the plaintiff, Mr Eckel, and the defendant, Ballarat Community Health Ltd (BCH), regarding the nature and duration of Mr Eckel's employment contract. The case was heard by the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia. Mr Eckel alleged that his fixed-term contract had been extended indefinitely, while BCH argued that it was for a specific duration and ended on 30 June 2018.

The court had to determine whether Mr Eckel's contract was indeed extended indefinitely or if it expired on 30 June 2018 as BCH claimed. This involved examining the communications between the parties, particularly the letter dated 10 June 2015 extending the contract until 30 June 2018, and a subsequent letter dated 2 May 2018 notifying Mr Eckel of the contract's conclusion. The court also needed to assess the credibility of Mr Eckel's testimony about his understanding of the contract's terms and whether he had a reasonable basis for believing that it was extended indefinitely.

The court found that the documentary evidence, particularly the letter from Erica Smith dated 10 June 2015, clearly outlined the extension of Mr Eckel's contract until 30 June 2018. This letter was supported by another document detailing changes to employment conditions. Mr Eckel did not provide any countervailing documents to substantiate his claim of an indefinite extension. The court accepted BCH's evidence that the extension was tied to the duration of the service agreement with the Department of Health and Human Services. The court also noted that Mr Eckel did not challenge the characterisation of his employment status with BCH's CEO until it was too late. Consequently, the court ruled in favour of BCH, determining that Mr Eckel's contract did not extend indefinitely but rather expired on 30 June 2018.

The court ordered that Mr Eckel's employment with BCH concluded on 30 June 2018 and dismissed his claims against BCH.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Mr Eckel told the Court however that when the initial contract expired it was his understanding that it had been extended on an indefinite or ongoing basis so that his employment status was one of permanent part-time employment. Mr Eckel did not produce any documents to substantiate this claim but instead referred to a conversation that he said had occurred in August or September 2015 during which Claire Ryan, his manager at the time, had told him (or words to this effect) that “You’re continuing on a permanent part-time position”. Mr Eckel told the Court that Ms Reeves was also present when the conversation took place. It was Mr Eckel’s evidence that the first time that he understood BCH took a different view of his employment status was when he met with Mr David Stevens, Corporate Services General Manager and Ms Measday, on 2 May 2018. According to Mr Eckel, during that meeting Mr Stevens told him that his contract was terminating as opposed to being rolled over and he was handed a letter (referred to below at [49]).BCH’s case and evidence Ms Reeves addressed the topic of Mr Eckel’s employment status in her affidavit. It was her evidence that Mr Eckel’s initial fixed term contract (ending on 30 June 2015) was extended to expire on 30 June 2018 and that this extension was based on the length of the service agreement with the (then) Department of Health and Human Services (DHHS) to provide services to the region via a consortium that comprised BCH, Djerriwarrh Health Service, Hepburn Health Service and Grampians Community Health. The service agreement expired on 30 June 2018. Ms Reeves produced two documents that she said supported this position. The first was a letter dated 10 June 2015 from Erica Smith, Human Resources Coordinator and addressed to “Brendon Eckle” c/- Ballarat Community Health. It read as follows:[5]Dear Brendon,Further to your discussions with Claire Ryan, I am writing to confirm the extension of your fixed-term contract in the AOD Nurse position.Your contract end date has been reviewed and will now end on 30th June 2018. All other terms and conditions remain unchanged from your previous contract.Brendon, we thank you for your continued work with the AOD Team.…[5] See exhibit “RR-2” annexed to the affidavit of Robyn Reeves affirmed on 14 May 2021; CB 320. The second document produced by Ms Reeves, which was a companion to the first, was a document bearing the title “Ballarat Community Health Changes to Employment Conditions”.[6] The document identified the staff member as “Brendon Eckle” and contained the following information:[6] See exhibit “RR-2” annexed to the affidavit of Robyn Reeves affirmed on 14 May 2021; CB 321.For changes other than minor amendments to change of days or hours of work, all proposed changes must be approved with the Senior Manager or CEO, prior to discussion and approval given to the staff member. Please follow checklist below.….Minor Change – Complete the below, staff member to sign and send to CEOOther Change – Complete the below, send to CEO for approval, then HR will send to staff member

Decision

Reasons for decision

Mr Eckel was also taken to a letter prepared by Ms Measday which contained the annotation “date sent 2.5.18” and which read as follows:[7][7] See exhibit “RR-9” annexed to the affidavit of Robyn Reeves affirmed on 14 May 2021; CB 365.Dear Brendan,Re: Conclusion of Fixed-term Contract as AOD Withdrawal NurseAs you know, your employment contract with Ballarat Community Health (BCH) is due to conclude on 30th June 2018. I am writing to formally advise you that the current position of AOD Withdrawal Nurse will not be maintained after that date. I therefore confirm that your employment with BCH as AOD Withdrawal Nurse will conclude on 30th June 2018.However, in order to meet our contractual obligations in non-residential withdrawal as well as care and recovery, BCH has developed two new (0.8 to 1.0 FTE) positions, one of which will absorb the vast majority of the current AOD Withdrawal Nurse’s functions. It is for this reason that the AOD Withdrawal Nurse role will not be maintained. The new position descriptions will be available for your consideration once they are finalised.It is envisaged that these roles will be advertised to candidates in May 2018. I will let you know when this occurs. All BCH employees are encouraged to apply for one or both of the new roles if within their skills and experience.I understand that you may be looking for alternative employment in the lead up to your contract coming to an end and BCH is willing to provide you with time away to attend interviews if required. Please let Suzanne know if and when you require such time off.Brendan, I understand that this news creates uncertainty and I would therefore encourage you to utilise BCH’s Employee Assistance Program. Please let me know if you require any information about this.… Mr Eckel acknowledged having read this letter at around the time that it was sent. It was his evidence that he disagreed with the letter’s reference to a fixed-term contract and that he had made his views known during the meeting referred to above that took place between himself, Ms Measday and Mr Stevens on 2 May 2018. Mr Eckel agreed that he had not gone to Ms Reeves to contest the issue of the characterisation of his employment status. He told the Court that he was reluctant to do so given that he had already made a complaint about her.THE CREATION OF AND MR ECKEL’S APPLICATION FOR EMPLOYMENT TO THE NEW ROLEMr Eckel’s case and evidence The case for Mr Eckel, as can be distilled from the first and second Eckel affidavit, Mr Eckel’s outline of submissions filed 14 May 2021, Mr Eckel’s outline of submissions – supplementary filed 28 May 2021, Mr Eckel’s outline of submissions – supplementary (2) filed 17 August 2021 and Mr Eckel’s closing written submissions, is as follows. As noted above, on 2 May 2018, Mr Eckel met with Mr Stevens and Ms Measday. During the meeting Mr Eckel was handed a “termination of contract” that identified 30 June 2018 as his last day. Ms Measday indicated the reason for termination was that funding from the DHHS was under threat of being lost because performance targets were not being met. Ms Measday indicated that the AOD Team had not been meeting the Drug Treatment Activity Units (“DTAUs”) but was not able to indicate what Mr Eckel’s DTAUs were.