Al Muderis v Nine Network Australia Pty Limited (Trial Judgment)

Link copied
Case Copied 75 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Al Muderis v Nine Network Australia Pty Limited (Trial Judgment) [2025] FCA 909

File number(s): NSD 917 of 2022
Judgment of: ABRAHAM J
Date of judgment: 8 August 2025
Catchwords:

DEFAMATION – where the applicant is a well-known orthopaedic surgeon – where applicant sues in defamation over a 60 Minutes program broadcast by Nine Network – where publications televised, published online and in print – where 75 defamatory imputations alleged

DEFAMATION – defences – substantial truth – justification defence – s 25 of the Defamation Act 2005 (NSW) – where imputations conveyed may be summarised into 9 stings – imputations involving improper sales tactic, misleading osseointegration patients, poor patient selection, negligent post-operative care, illegal procedures in the United States, prioritising money, fame, reputation and numbers, mistreating staff, lying to journalists, unethical conduct case

DEFAMATION – defences – contextual truth – s 26 of the Defamation Act 2005 (NSW) – some imputations established as substantially true – whether imputations not substantially true or where there is no truth defence do not further harm the applicant’s reputation – contextual truth considers the facts, matters and circumstances relied upon to support the substantial truth of the contextual imputations rather than the terms of the imputation – defence established

DEFAMATION – defences – public interest – s 29A of the Defamation Act 2005 (NSW) – consideration of legislative construction – whether the respondents reasonably believed the matters published was in the public interest – flaws in a matter will not necessarily preclude the defence – inform prospective patients about a cohort of the applicant’s patients who had negative experiences – defence established

EVIDENCE – observation as to fact-finding, onus and standards of proof – inferences in relation to the failure of a party to call a particular witness: Jones v Dunkel [1959] HCA 8; (1959) 101 CLR 298 – principles in Browne v Dunn (1893) 6 R 67 (HL) – consideration of contemporaneous documents – consideration of standard practice and inferences that may be drawn – consideration of the impact of mental health issues and trauma on the reliability of evidence

Legislation:

Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth), Sch 2, Australian Consumer Law, ss 18, 21(4), 33, 54

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) ss 63, 64, 79, 126K, 140, 164(1), 174

Defamation Act 2005 (NSW) ss 3(b), 4, 8, 25, 26, 29A, 30(4), 31

Defamation Act 1974 (NSW) (repealed) s 16

Defamation Act 2013 (UK) s 1, 4

Fla Stat § 456.065

Ky Rev Stat Ann § 311.560 (2017)

La Rev Stat Ann § 37:1271 (2018)

Medical Practice Act of 1987, 225 Ill Comp Stat 60/3, 60/3.5, 60/50, 60/59 (2017)

NY Education Law §§ 6512, 6520-6521 (2018)

NY Public Health Law (2018)

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) r 23.13

Explanatory Note, Defamation Amendment Bill 2020 (NSW)

Cases cited:

Allen v Tobias [1958] HCA 13; (1958) 98 CLR 367

Allianz Australia Insurance Limited v Delor Vue Apartments CTS 39788 [2021] FCAFC 121; (2021) 287 FCR 388

Allied Pastoral…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Al Muderis v Nine Network Australia Pty Limited (Trial Judgm... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] FCA 909
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Dr Munjed Al Muderis, an orthopaedic surgeon, brought a defamation action against Nine Network Australia Pty Limited over a 60 Minutes program broadcasted by the network, which was published online and in print. The program alleged 75 defamatory imputations against Dr Al Muderis, including improper sales tactics, misleading patients, poor patient selection, negligent post-operative care, illegal procedures in the United States, prioritising money and fame, mistreating staff, lying to journalists, and unethical conduct. The court was required to determine whether these imputations were substantially or contextually true, and whether the defendants had a reasonable belief that publishing the imputations was in the public interest.

The court found that some of the imputations were substantially true, but the others were not substantially true or where there was no truth defence, they did not further harm the applicant’s reputation. The court considered the facts, matters, and circumstances relied upon to support the substantial truth of the contextual imputations rather than the terms of the imputation. The court also found that the defendants reasonably believed the matters published were in the public interest. The court dismissed the proceedings and held that costs would follow the event.

The court found that the defendants had established the defences of substantial and contextual truth and public interest. The court held that the substantial truth of some imputations did not further harm the applicant’s reputation, and that the contextual truth of the imputations was established. The court also held that the defendants reasonably believed the matters published were in the public interest, and that the publication of the imputations was in the public interest. The court found that the applicant’s submissions did not undermine the respondents’ reasonable belief. The court dismissed the proceedings and held that costs would follow the event.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application is dismissed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

PART 1 — INTRODUCTION

[1]

Section 1 — Introductory remarks

[1]

Section 2 — Overview

[11]

Dr Munjed Al Muderis

[10]

Osseointegration

[22]

The journalists

[31]

Ms Charlotte Grieve

[31]

Mr Tom Steinfort

[32]

Ms Natalie Clancy

[33]

Section 3 — The present proceedings

[34]

The parties sued

[34]

PART 2 — THE DEFAMATORY IMPUTATIONS

[35]

Section 1 — The pleaded imputations

[35]

Section 2 — Legal principles

[36]

Section 3 — Consideration

[42]

The Denied Imputations

[48]

The Disputed Imputations

[59]

The Sneak Peek

[78]

The Broadcast

[83]

The Articles

[90]

Conclusion

[100]

Section 4 — Meaning of “negligence” and “unethical” in the imputations

[101]

Negligence

[101]

Unethical

[108]

PART 3 — FACT FINDING

[110]

Section 1 — Onus and standard of proof

[110]

Section 2 — Browne v Dunn

[122]

Section 3 — Jones v Dunkel

[134]

Section 4 — Contemporaneous documents

[153]

Section 5 — Standard practice

[165]

PART 4 — DEFENCES: INTRODUCTORY REMARKS

[179]

PART 5 — SECTIONS 25 AND 26

[184]

Overview

[184]

Preliminary observation

[187]

Section 1 — Legal principles

[213]

Substantial truth

[213]

Contextual truth

[220]

Section 2 — Defamatory stings

[234]

Section 3 — Temporal limitation

[242]

Section 4 — Generalisation

[251]

Section 5 — The applicant’s witnesses

[263]

Dr Al Muderis

[265]

Ms Claudia Roberts

[293]

Expert witnesses

[305]

Dr Kevin Tetsworth

[307]

Dr Razvan Stoita

[323]

Dr S. Robert Rozbruch

[329]

Other witnesses

[332]

Dr Tim O’Carrigan

[332]

Dr Mustafa Alttahir

[334]

Dr Abdul Haidary

[336]

Dr Karan Doshi

[339]

Mr Stefan Laux

[341]

Section 6 — The respondents’ witnesses

[347]

Expert witnesses

[348]

Dr Stephen Ruff

[348]

Dr Michael Leung

[351]

Dr Paul Stalley

[355]

Dr John Anstee

[368]

Dr Saul Geffen

[374]

Observations in relation to expert witnesses

[377]

Other witnesses

[383]

Mr Mitch Grant

[383]

Mr Fred Hernandez

[410]

Ms Shona Stewart (formerly Wilmot)

[447]

PART 6 — PATIENT CASE STUDIES

[494]

Section 1 — General observations

[494]

The patients

[494]

Consultation reports

[537]

Standard practice – application

[597]

Multidisciplinary approach

[615]

Brochures – misleading statements

[634]

Fundraising

[656]

Section 2 — Ms Megan McIntyre and Mr Donald Grieve

[671]

Ms Megan McIntyre

[671]

Mr Donald Grieve

[700]

Section 3 — Mr Kerry Ford and Patient X

[745]

Mr Kerry Ford

[745]

Patient X

[767]

Section 4 — International patients

[827]

Mr Billy Wynne III

[827]

Ms Rachael Ulrich

[898]

Mr Chris Bruha

[968]

Ms Lisa Schaeffer

[1071]

Ms Michelle Koolhoven (née Ortiz)

[1106]

Mr Jeff Ladouceur

[1135]

Ms Lisa Çalan

[1148]

Observations about the international patients

[1245]

Section 5 — Ms Eang Srey Da and Mr Pril Sina

[1304]

Section 6 — Domestic patients: upper limb osseointegration

[1342]

Mr Shane Mortimer

[1342]

Mr Shannon Haskett

[1418]

Section 7 — Domestic patients: lower limb osseointegration

[1508]

Mr Mark Urquhart

[1508]

Mr Brennan Smith

[1596]

Ms Rowena Mattiske

[1693]

Ms Carol Todd

[1748]

Mr Blythe Warland

[1841]

Mr Peter Mailler

[1887]

Ms Anna Rochford

[1909]

Section 8 — Domestic patients: other orthopaedic patients

[1922]

Ms Leah Mooney

[1922]

Mrs Kim Gollan

[2040]

Ms Mary Heffernan

[2064]

Ms Fay Young

[2106]

Further patients

[2141]

Ms Deborah Brandon

[2141]

Ms Kathryn Hutton

[2151]

Mr Adam Wright

[2166]

Ms Lesa Anne Slater

[2177]

Ms Sharon Jones-Baldwin

[2187]

Mr Habibul Rahiman

[2197]

Mr Anthony Marlborough

[2199]

PART 7 — SECTION 26: FURTHER CONSIDERATION – IMPUTATIONS

[2210]

Section 1 — The defamatory stings

[2210]

Sting 1 — Improper sales tactics

[2220]

Sting 2 — Misleading osseointegration patients (false promises, downplaying risks and complications)

[2251]

Sting 3 — Poor patient selection

[2278]

Sting 4 — Negligent post-operative care

[2294]

Sting 5 — Illegal surgery in the United States

[2348]

Sting 6 — Prioritising money, fame, reputation and numbers

[2384]

Sting 7 — Mistreating staff

[2428]

Sting 8 — Lied to the journalists

[2434]

Sting 9 — Unethical conduct

[2438]

Remaining imputations

[2447]

Section 2 — Contextual truth

[2453]

The Broadcast

[2470]

The Articles

[2473]

The Grieve Video

[2476]

PART 8 — SECTION 26: CONCLUSION

[2479]

PART 9 — SECTION 29A

[2480]

Section 1 — Legal principles

[2482]

Issues as to interpretation

[2489]

Approach to s 29A

[2498]

Section 2 — Overview of Part 9

[2506]

Section 3 — The parties responsible for the defamatory matters

[2511]

Section 4 — The journalists

[2529]

Ms Grieve

[2534]

Mr Steinfort

[2546]

Ms Clancy

[2552]

Section 5 — Summary of submissions

[2555]

Section 6 — Failures of proof

[2562]

Evidence from known sources

[2564]

Material before Mr Steinfort and Ms Clancy

[2566]

Destruction of documents

[2569]

Use of confidential sources

[2588]

Section 7 — The respondents’ investigation

[2605]

Genesis of the investigation

[2606]

The investigation itself

[2613]

Section 8 — The material before the respondents

[2615]

Section 9 — The interview with Dr Al Muderis

[2619]

Section 10 — The Publications as a joint investigation

[2643]

Section 11 — Some issues relevant to subjective belief

[2651]

Section 12 — Some issues relevant to objective belief

[2699]

Section 13 — The applicant’s submissions

[2714]

Ms Grieve’s alleged conflict of interest

[2719]

Unpublished allegations

[2724]

Publication of positive patient experiences

[2735]

Ms Asch-Martin

[2758]

Downplaying the benefits of osseointegration

[2767]

Obtaining further material

[2775]

Knowing publication of false material

[2791]

Ms Grieve misleading Mr Steinfort and Ms Clancy

[2813]

Approach to sources

[2821]

Reliance on particular sources

[2825]

Testing Broadcast interview subjects

[2870]

Ms Amane Nasser

[2877]

Dr Anstee

[2879]

AHPRA

[2880]

Dr Qutaiba Al Maawi

[2886]

Conclusions as to the applicant’s submissions

[2904]

Section 14 — Conclusions

[2905]

Section 15 — Ongoing belief

[2916]

PART 10 — CONCLUSIONS WITH RESPECT TO THE PROCEEDINGS

[2956]

ANNEXURES

Annexure A — Sneak Peek transcript

Annexure B — Broadcast transcript

Annexure C — SMH Article

Annexure D — SMH Online Article

Annexure E — Age Article

Annexure F — Age Online Article

Annexure G — Grieve Video transcript

Annexure H — Pleaded Imputations

Annexure I — Imputations Table

Background

Background to the litigation

Dr Munjed Al Muderis, a well-known orthopaedic surgeon specialising in osseointegration, initiated legal proceedings against Nine Network Australia Pty Limited for defamation. The alleged defamatory material was broadcast in a 60 Minutes program, published online, and in print. The suit encompasses 75 defamatory imputations, which can be summarised into nine stings, involving various allegations of improper conduct, negligence, and unethical behaviour in Dr Al Muderis's professional practice. The case involves the experiences of ten patients who underwent osseointegration procedures with Dr Al Muderis. Osseointegration is a major elective and invasive orthopaedic surgery allowing direct attachment of an external prosthesis to the skeleton through the implantation of an intramedullary device. The case revolves around the publication of negative experiences of some of Dr Al Muderis’ patients, raising questions about the truth, context, and public interest of these allegations.

The case before the court was a defamation claim brought by Dr Munjed Al Muderis against Nine Network Australia Pty Limited. The matter was heard in the Federal Court of Australia. Prior to this trial, there were no specific details provided regarding previous hearings, applications, or rulings in this case. The current trial focused on the validity of the defamatory imputations, the defences of substantial and contextual truth, and the public interest defence under the Defamation Act 2005 (NSW). The court examined the evidence presented, including witness testimonies, expert opinions, and documentary evidence, to determine the validity of the defences raised by the respondents.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I agree as to their description as to what was exposed in the trial. In my view, the matters the applicant relies on do not undermine the respondents’ reasonable belief.PART 10 — CONCLUSIONS WITH RESPECT TO THE PROCEEDINGS As explained earlier, given my conclusions in respect to the s 26 and s 29A defences, it is unnecessary to consider the defence in s 30 of honest opinion. Given the defences have been successful, the question of damages does not arise. Any consideration would be hypothetical, and I do not consider that would be appropriate in this case. The proceedings are dismissed. In the ordinary course, costs would follow the event.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Generally, Dr Al Muderis conducts his consultations at the Limb Reconstruction Centre (LRC) in Macquarie University Hospital (which was formerly at Norwest Private Hospital). He is the Chairperson and Founder of the Osseointegration Group of Australia. His company, Osseointegration International, was incorporated on 20 February 2015. Osseointegration The Publications featured the experiences of ten of Dr Al Muderis’ osseointegration patients. It is helpful at this stage to briefly address the nature of this surgery. Traditionally, amputees used socket-mounted prostheses to mobilise and regain use of their affected amputated limb. The socket attaches to the amputation stump via suction, meaning that such prostheses do not require invasive surgical procedures. When used for the lower limb, an artificial knee joint and lower leg prosthesis attach to the socket. Osseointegration, is a term that describes the in-growth and integration of living bone onto the surface of an artificial implant, without an intermediate layer of soft tissue. In the 1960s, the concept of osseointegrated reconstruction originated in the dental implant field. In the 1990s, Dr Rickard Brånemark pioneered the use of a screw-fixation implant under the name OPRA (Osseointegrated Prosthesis for the Rehabilitation of Amputees), following which, transdermal osseointegrated implants for attachment of prosthetic limbs were first used. As a procedure, extremity osseointegration is a relatively new major elective and invasive orthopaedic surgery which allows for direct attachment of an external prosthesis to the skeleton through the surgical implantation of an intramedullary device (a device inserted into the medullary cavity of the femur or tibia, i.e. into the central cavity of the bone). The three basic elements of osseointegration are: the residual bone, the metal implant and the transdermal surface. The metal device is implanted into the end of the residual bone of the amputated limb, then exits the soft tissue and skin through a surgically created transdermal opening in the body, known as a stoma, to attach and interface with an external prosthesis. Osseointegrated devices are typically made of titanium, which is a particularly biocompatible material. Bone grows onto and integrates with the surface of the implant, and osseointegration occurs. Over time, this creates a stable and solid connection between implant and bone. Until about 2014, most osseointegration procedures worldwide were performed in two stages: the first stage to insert the intramedullary implant; and the second stage, to create the stoma, allowing for transcutaneous abutment attachment and prosthesis fitting. There were two main approaches for osseointegration procedures: the OPRA system and EndoExo system. Osseointegration using the OPRA system screws the implant into the bone in the first stage with a six to nine-month interval between stages. Implantation of the OPRA system occurs in two stages because the implant is not initially stable and time needs to be given to allow strong osseointegration to occur before load is placed on the implant, otherwise it may fail. By contrast, the EndoExo system inserts a press-fit implant made of cobalt chrome alloy, driven into the medullary cavity with a mallet (instead of being screwed in, per the OPRA system) and requires a four to eight-week interval between stages. A more recent version of the implant is called the Integral Leg Prosthesis (ILP).