ThoughtWare Australia Pty Limited v IonMy Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 82 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

ThoughtWare Australia Pty Limited v IonMy Pty Ltd [2023] FCA 906  

File number: QUD 107 of 2023
Judgment of: DERRINGTON J
Date of judgment: 4 August 2023
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – summary judgment – where question of construction is involved – where some complexity should not prevent summary judgment
Legislation:

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth)

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth)

Cases cited:

AGL Victoria Pty Ltd v SPI Networks (Gas) Pty Ltd (formerly TXU Networks (Gas) Pty Ltd) [2006] VSCA 173

Australian Vintage Ltd v Belvino Investments No 2 Pty Ltd (2015) 90 NSWLR 367

Buurabalayji Thalanyji Aboriginal Corporation v Onslow Salt Pty Ltd (No 2) [2018] FCA 978

Canaipa Developments Pty Ltd v TLC Jones Pty Ltd [2021] QSC 237

Caterpillar Inc v Sun Forward Pty Ltd (1996) 36 IPR 411

Chandrasekaran v Commonwealth of Australia (No 3) [2020] FCA 1629

Codelfa Construction Pty Ltd v State Rail Authority of New South Wales (1982) 149 CLR 337

Comandate Marine Corp v Pan Australia Shipping Pty Ltd (2006) 157 FCR 45

Cook Inc v World Medical Manufacturing Corp (2003) 58 IPR 193

Crocker v Toys ‘R’ Us (Australia) Pty Ltd (No 3) [2015] FCA 728

Electricity Generation Corporation v Woodside Energy Ltd (2014) 251 CLR 640

Francis Travel Marketing Pty Ltd v Virgin Atlantic Airways Ltd (1996) 39 NSWLR 160

Galileo Miranda Nominee Pty Ltd v Duffy Kennedy Pty Ltd [2019] NSWSC 1157

Hastie Group Limited (in liq) v Multiplex Constructions Pty Ltd (Formerly Brookfield Multiplex Constructions Pty Ltd) (No 3) [2022] FCA 1280

Holt v Cox (1997) 23 ACSR 590

Illawarra Community Housing Trust Ltd v MP Park Lane Pty Ltd [2020] NSWSC 751

Jefferson Ford Pty Ltd v Ford Motor Company of Australia Ltd (2008) 167 FCR 372

John Nelson Developments Pty Ltd v Focus National Developments Pty Ltd [2010] NSWSC 150

Jones v Sherwood Computer Services plc [1992] 1 WLR 277

Kanivah Holdings Pty Ltd v Holdsworth Properties Pty Ltd (2002) 11 BPR 20,201

Kowalski v MMAL Staff Superannuation Fund Pty Ltd (2009) 178 FCR 401

L’Estrange v F Graucob Ltd [1934] 2 KB 394

Lainson Holdings Pty Ltd v Duffy Kennedy Pty Ltd [2019] NSWSC 576

Legal & General Life of Australia Ltd v A Hudson Pty Ltd (1985) 1 NSWLR 314

Lepcanfin Pty Ltd v Lepfin Pty Ltd (2020) 102 NSWLR 627

Lipman Pty Ltd v Emergency Services Superannuation Board [2011] NSWCA 163

Mercury Communications Ltd v Director General of Telecommunications [1996] 1 WLR 48

Peter Kent Development Pty Ltd v ANZ Banking Group Ltd (Supreme Court of New South Wales, Hunt J, 6 May 1980)

Polar Aviation Pty Ltd v Civil Aviation Safety Authority (No 4) (2011) 203 FCR 293

Prior v South West Aboriginal Land and Sea Council Aboriginal Corporation [2020] FCA 808

Rinehart v Welker (2012) 95 NSWLR 221

Sino Iron Pty Ltd v Mineralogy Pty Ltd (2019) 55 WAR 89

SK Foods LP v SK Foods Australia Pty Ltd (in liq) (No 3)

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read ThoughtWare Australia Pty Limited v IonMy Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FCA 906
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of ThoughtWare Australia Pty Limited v IonMy Pty Ltd involved a dispute between the parties over the interpretation and application of the Business Sale Agreement (BSA) concerning the sale of ThoughtWare's business to IonMy. The primary focus was on the calculation of the purchase price, particularly the reduction of instalments based on the average annual gross profit of the business. ThoughtWare sought summary judgment under section 31A of the Federal Court Act 1976 (Cth) and rule 26.01 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth). The legal issues before the court involved the interpretation of the BSA, particularly clause 3.5, which outlined the conditions under which the instalments could be reduced.

The court considered whether IonMy had a reasonable prospect of successfully defending the claim and whether the BSA was clear enough to warrant a summary judgment. The court found that the BSA's terms were unambiguous and that IonMy's interpretation of "gross profit" was incorrect. The court held that Mr Peisley's determination regarding the calculation of gross profit was correct, and therefore, IonMy had no reasonable prospect of success in defending the claim. The court also noted that IonMy's failure to provide timely responses and objections did not change the outcome.

The court granted ThoughtWare's application for summary judgment, awarding ThoughtWare the sum of $368,903.59, representing the unpaid instalments based on the correct calculation of gross profit. The interlocutory application was adjourned to allow ThoughtWare to seek further relief, and the costs of the interlocutory application were reserved for later determination.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The applicant have judgment against the respondent in the sum of $368,903.59 (three hundred and sixty-eight thousand, nine hundred and three dollars and fifty-nine cents).

2. The interlocutory application be otherwise adjourned to a date to be fixed, at which time the applicant may seek further relief as it sees fit.

3. The costs of the interlocutory application to date be reserved.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons that follow, IonMy and ThoughtWare are bound by Mr Peisley’s determination. Even if it was permissible to go behind the determination, Mr Peisley was entirely correct in his resolution of the critical issue of the construction of the expression “gross profit”, and in his subsequent assessment of the average annual gross profit of the business over the financial years ending 30 June 2020 and 30 June 2021. It follows that ThoughtWare is entitled to succeed on the substance of its application for summary judgment, subject to certain intricacies that are addressed in the course of these reasons. BackgroundThe evidence As at the date of the hearing of this application, ThoughtWare had filed a Concise Statement and several affidavits, all of which were relied upon for the purposes of the application. Objection was taken on various grounds by Mr O’Brien, Counsel for IonMy, to certain passages in two of the affidavits. None of those objections was stubbornly resisted. Ultimately, the passages to which objection was taken were of relatively limited importance and the hearing proceeded on the basis that they would be treated as submissions, or evidence of certain things having been said in correspondence, rather than evidence of the truth of the matters concerned. IonMy’s position at the time of the hearing was somewhat difficult to discern. On 29 March 2023, this Court made orders by consent of the parties, timetabling a number of procedural steps in relation to the present application and the overall proceeding. By paragraph 4 of those orders, IonMy was directed to file and serve the following documents by 4:00 pm on 12 April 2023:a. A response to the Concise Statement of 5 pages or less setting out, in summary:i. What, if any, of the facts indicated in the Concise Summary are in dispute;ii. What parts, if any, of the relief are not in dispute; iii. What parts, if any, of the relief are in dispute and why; and, b. Any Affidavit material upon which it wishes to rely for the hearing of the balance of the interlocutory application; and, c. Any objections to any of the Applicant’s Affidavit material (including a description of the basis and reasons for each objection). IonMy filed a Concise Statement in Response on 17 April 2023, several days after the date set in the orders. It put on no affidavit evidence prior to the hearing of the application, and its objections to ThoughtWare’s affidavit material (to which reference is made above) were received only on 26 April 2023, the day prior to the hearing. There was no particular explanation for any of these delays, or the decision not to put on any evidence. The sale of ThoughtWare’s business and the BSA ThoughtWare carried on business developing and supplying governance, risk and compliance software, under the business name “IonMy” (the Business). At all relevant times, its directors have been Ms Sonja Bernhardt and Mr Robin Craig. On 30 June 2020, Ms Bernhardt and Mr Craig, on behalf of ThoughtWare, executed the BSA, pursuant to which the Business and certain associated assets were sold to IonMy, “for the Purchase Price and on the terms and conditions of this agreement as at Completion, effective on and from the Effective Date”: BSA cl 2.1.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

That section is supplemented by r 26.01 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth), by which a party may apply for summary judgment. That rule provides relevantly as follows:26.01 Summary judgment(1)A party may apply to the Court for an order that judgment be given against another party because:…(e) the respondent has no reasonable prospect of successfully defending the proceeding or part of the proceeding.…(4) If an order is made under subrule (1) dismissing part of the proceeding, the proceeding may be continued for that part of the proceeding not disposed of by the order. The High Court has emphasised that s 31A should be applied in accordance with the statutory language; that is, summary judgment should be granted if, and only if, the Court is satisfied that the party against whom the claim is brought has “no reasonable prospect” of success: Spencer v Commonwealth (2010) 241 CLR 118, 140 – 141 [56] – [60] per Hayne, Crennan, Kiefel and Bell JJ (Spencer). In determining whether or not there is a reasonable prospect of success, much will depend on the case at hand, and no hard and fast rule can be laid down as to when summary judgment is available: Polar Aviation Pty Ltd v Civil Aviation Safety Authority (No 4) (2011) 203 FCR 293, 300 [17] per Kenny J. However, the power to dismiss an action summarily is not to be exercised lightly: Spencer at 131 – 132 [24] per French CJ and Gummow J, 141 [60] per Hayne, Crennan, Kiefel and Bell JJ. In this Court, it has been recognised that, because the assessment of prospects of success under s 31A necessitates the making of a value judgment in the absence of a full and complete factual matrix and full argument thereon, a discretion is reposed in the judge hearing the relevant application to grant summary judgment: Kowalski v MMAL Staff Superannuation Fund Pty Ltd (2009) 178 FCR 401, 408 – 409 [28] per Spender, Graham and Gilmour JJ. In the exercise of that discretion, it must be kept in mind that the section is concerned with substance, not just with form: White Industries Aust Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (2007) 160 FCR 298, 310 [50] per Lindgren J. The grant of summary judgment is therefore to be distinguished from the application of rules concerning deficient pleadings, as explained by Wigney J in Chandrasekaran v Commonwealth of Australia (No 3) [2020] FCA 1629 at paragraph [96]:Where the evidence shows that a person may have a reasonable cause of action or reasonable prospects of success, but the person’s pleading does not disclose that to be the case, the Court may be empowered to strike out the pleading under r 16.21, but is not empowered to summarily dismiss the proceeding under s 31A of the FCA Act: see White Industries Australia Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (2007) 160 FCR 298 at [47], referred to in Spencer at [23]. That said, a “failure after ample opportunity to plead a reasonable cause of action may suggest that none exists and therefore that the applicant has no reasonable prospects of success”: White Industries at [47].

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The “Purchase Price” was defined in cl 1.1 to be $7.5 million. However, that amount was to be paid in the specific manner set out in cl 3 of the BSA, which was headed “Consideration”. That clause is important for the present purposes, and it is convenient to set out its material parts as follows:3.1 ConsiderationThe consideration for the sale of the Assets and the Business is:(a) the payment of the Purchase Price to the Seller; and(b) the issue of the Buyer Shares to the Seller.…3.2 Payment of the Purchase PriceSubject to the terms of this agreement, the Buyer must pay the Purchase Price to the Seller as follows:(a) $500,000.00 (five hundred thousand dollars) on or before 30 June 2021;(b) $750,000.00 (seven hundred and fifty thousand dollars) on or before 30 June 2022;(c) $1,250,000.00 (one million, two hundred and fifty thousand dollars) on or before 30 June 2023;(d) $2,000,000.00 (two million dollars) on or before 30 June 2024; and(e) $3,000,000.00 (three million dollars) on or before 30 June 2025, (each of the foregoing payments being an Instalment).3.3 InterestIn addition to payment of the Instalments referred to in clause 3.2, the Buyer shall pay to the Seller, interest on the relevant Instalment calculated at the Prescribed Rate from the due date of the Instalment until the actual date of payment of the relevant Instalment.…3.5 Reduction of Instalments(a) The Buyer and the Seller agree that if the average annual gross profit of the Business for the two financial years immediately preceding the date that any Instalment is due for payment under clause 3.2 is less than $1,000,000.00 (one million dollars), the amount of the Instalment may be reduced on a pro rata basis by the Buyer and such reduced amount paid by the Buyer to the Seller in satisfaction of the Buyer's obligation to pay the relevant Instalment to the Seller pursuant to clause 3.2. Schedule 3 sets out working examples of how the reduction of any Instalments will be calculated.(b) The Buyer and the Seller further agree that if a licence fee payment is paid by the Buyer to the Seller pursuant to clause 3.6 during the financial year immediately preceding the date that any Instalment is due for payment under clause 3.2, then the amount of such Instalment payable by the Buyer to the Seller shall be reduced by an amount equal to 75% (seventy five percent) of the total amount of licence fee payments paid or payable to the Seller by the Buyer in respect of that financial year. Schedule 3 sets out working examples of how the reduction of any Instalments will be calculated. The manner in which this clause was intended to operate to apportion the Purchase Price is relatively uncomplicated. By cl 3.2, IonMy was to pay the specified “Instalments” of the “Purchase Price” to ThoughtWare by the corresponding dates. The amounts of those Instalments could be reduced by either of the two mechanisms set out in cl 3.5: the mechanism in cl 3.5(a) allowed the Instalments to be reduced on a pro rata basis if the “average annual gross profit” of the Business for the two financial years preceding the date for the Instalment was less than $1 million; and the mechanism in cl 3.5(b) allowed the Instalments to be reduced if ThoughtWare received certain “licence fee payments”.