Davis v Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 35 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Davis v Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission [2024] FCA 736

File number(s): QUD 256 of 2023
Judgment of: SARAH C DERRINGTON J
Date of judgment: 9 July 2024
Catchwords:

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – application for judicial review of decision by the Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission calculating rate of incapacity payments pursuant to Pt 4, Ch 4 of the Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 2004 (Cth) (MRCA) – whether Commission had regarding to ss 157(1) and 157(2) of the MRCA – interpretation of ss 157(1) and 157(2) – whether Commission breached rules of natural justice in connection with the making of the decision – whether mandatory procedures to be observed by law were not observed by the Commission – whether the delegate accounted for an irrelevant consideration – whether the decision raises an error of law

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application for summary judgment under s 31A(2) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) and/or r 26.01(1)(a) of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) – whether application for judicial review has no reasonable prospects of success

Legislation:

Acts Interpretation Act 1901 (Cth) s 15AB

Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 (Cth) ss 5(1)(a), 5(1)(b), s 5(1)(e), 5(1)(f), 5(2)(a), 10

Australian Veterans’ Recognition (Putting Veterans and Their Families First) Act 2019 (Cth) ss 7, 10(1), 10(2)

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) ss 31A(2), 31A(3), 37M, 37N

Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 2004 (Cth) Pt 6, Div 2, Ch 4, Pt 4, ss 5, 7A, 99, 113, 118, 125(1), 129, 130, 131, 148, 153(1), 154, 155, 156, 157, 157(1), 157(2), 172, 319(1), 352, 354(1), 361, 362

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) r 26.01(1)(a)

Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Bill 2004 cll 117, 157

Cases cited:

Burrows v The Ship ‘Merlion’ [2024] FCA 220

Certain Lloyd’s Underwriters v Cross [2012] HCA 56; 248 CLR 378

CIC Insurance Ltd v Bankstown Football Club Ltd [1997] HCA 2; 187 CLR 384

Davis v Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission [2024] FCA 322

Leach v Burston [2022] FCA 87

Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v Li [2013] HCA 18; 249 CLR 332

Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs v Nystrom [2006] HCA 50; 228 CLR 566

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v WZARH [2015] HCA 40; 256 CLR 326

Mondelez Australia Pty Ltd v Automotive, Food, Metals, Engineering, Printing and Kindreds Industries Union [2020] HCA 29; 271 CLR 495

Prior v South West Aboriginal Land and Sea Council Aboriginal Corporation [2020] FCA 808

Project Blue Sky Inc v Australian Broadcasting Authority [1998] HCA 28; 194 CLR 355

Spencer v Commonwealth [2010] HCA 28; 241 CLR 118

SZATL v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2017] HCA 34; 262 CLR 362

SZRMQ v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2013] FCAFC 142; 219 FCR 212

Taylor v Public Service Board (NSW) [1976] HCA 36; 137 CLR 208

The Queen v A2 [2019] HCA 35; 93…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Davis v Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] FCA 736
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Mr Davis, a former part-time Reservist, sought judicial review of a decision by the Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission (MRCC) concerning the calculation of his incapacity payments. The MRCC determined that Mr Davis’ incapacity payments should be calculated based on his earnings from Fire & Safety Industries (F&SI), rather than including wages from his casual employment with the Department of Home Affairs (DHA). Mr Davis argued that the MRCC failed to consider his DHA wages, did not follow proper procedures, and made an error of law. The court was required to decide whether Mr Davis’ claims of procedural unfairness, procedural errors, legal errors, and irrelevant considerations had reasonable prospects of success.

The court found that Mr Davis's claims did not demonstrate reasonable prospects of success. The court noted that the misidentification of the correct decision-maker in the MRCC’s decision was a factual error and not material to the outcome. The court also concluded that Mr Davis's complaints about findings of fact were not suitable for judicial review, as they were within the MRCC’s province and better suited for merits review. Furthermore, the court held that Mr Davis's insistence on pursuing judicial review despite more appropriate avenues for review was inconsistent with his obligations under the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth).

Accordingly, the court granted the MRCC’s application for summary judgment, dismissing Mr Davis’ claims. The court ordered Mr Davis to pay the MRCC’s costs on the standard basis only, as the MRCC did not seek an extended costs order. This decision underscores the importance of pursuing appropriate review mechanisms and highlights the limited scope of judicial review in administrative law matters.

The final orders of the court were that judgment be entered in favour of the MRCC and that Mr Davis pay the MRCC’s costs on the standard basis.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Pursuant to s 31A(2) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) and r 26.01(1)(a) of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth), judgment be entered in favour of the respondent for the whole of the proceeding.

2. The applicant pay the respondent’s costs of the interlocutory application filed on 29 April 2024, and the proceeding.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons that follow, I am satisfied that Mr Davis has no reasonable prospects of succeeding on his application for judicial review. It is, therefore, appropriate to grant summary judgment in favour of the Commission.BACKGROUNDEntitlement to incapacity payments Mr Davis served during peacetime as a part-time Reservist in the ADF. He claims the period of his service was from 28 November 2011 until 19 February 2019. Although nothing turns on it in the current proceeding, documents filed by the Commission refer to his service commencing from 23 November 2017: First Cooper Affidavit LJC-4. In the course of his service, Mr Davis was injured and medically discharged from the ADF. It is not disputed that, as a result of his injuries, Mr Davis was, and remains, entitled to compensation from the Commonwealth for incapacity for work: MRCA ss 118(1) and 319(1). It is also apparent that his injuries are accepted by the Commission to amount to a total permanent incapacity. The amount of Mr Davis’ incapacity payments is determined according to his Normal Earnings (NE). In the role of a part-time Reservist, engaged in civilian work, his NE were calculated, for a weekly period, according to the formula set out at s 153(1) of the MRCA, reproduced below: The relevant history of Mr Davis’ entitlement to incapacity payments can be stated shortly. On 4 February 2019, by his initial “Claim for Incapacity for Service/Work” received on 7 December 2018, the Commission determined the civilian component of Mr Davis’ NE according to his casual employment with the DHA, which was calculated to be $749.38 gross per week. Mr Davis last received earnings for hours worked at the DHA on 24 January 2019. Mr Davis subsequently applied for review of the 4 February 2019 decision, which had incorrectly determined his discharge date as 22 January 2019, rather than 19 February 2019. By a decision of 9 April 2020, the 4 February 2019 decision was set aside, and Mr Davis’ entitlement to incapacity payments was recalculated. The civilian component of Mr Davis’ NE was determined based on his payslips from F&SI, calculated as $1,442.31 gross per week. Mr Davis had begun working at F&SI on 28 January 2019, with an annual income of $75,000. Having sought a further review of the decisions of 4 February 2019 and 9 April 2020, a decision dated 29 May 2020 set aside both prior decisions, due to “a higher history of reserve days”. Mr Davis’ entitlement was, again, recalculated, and the civilian component of his NE was, again, determined according to his F&SI earnings. Following the 29 May 2020 decision, on 10 June 2020, Mr Davis withdrew his appeal to the Veterans’ Review Board (VRB), on the basis that,[t]he DVA have issued a new determination letter under S347 MRCA dated 29/05/2020 and I am satisfied with this written decision and how my incapacity payments are being calculated. For reasons that are unexplained, some three years later, Mr Davis apparently became aware that wages from his past casual employment with the DHA were not (but, allegedly, should have been) accounted for in the civilian component of his NE. On 1 May 2023, he emailed the General Enquiries email address of the DVA, advising that “the Delegate calculating [his] discharge pay (Military and Civilian) did not offer the opportunity to calculate [his] ‘casual’ work” and that this “[had] therefore impacted calculations moving forward”. Mr Davis asked for the “correct form to be completed” to rectify the alleged miscalculation of his entitlement.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

In the latter proceeding, Mr Davis seeks review of a decision of the Commission dated 15 May 2023 (the May 2023 Decision) under Ch 4 of the Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 2004 (Cth) (MRCA), concerning his entitlement to incapacity compensation payments. Mr Davis is currently receiving weekly payments pursuant to the provisions of the MRCA in the amount of $1,403.70 gross. He will continue to receive payments (in an amount subject to change) until 18 August 2047. In a “Claim for Incapacity for Service/Work” dated 11 May 2023, Mr Davis had claimed that casual wages earned by him through the Department of Home Affairs (DHA), prior to him commencing his full-time position with Fire & Safety Industries (F&SI), ought be considered in the calculation of the civilian component of his ‘Normal Earnings’, notwithstanding that there was no period either before or after the date that he was discharged from the Australian Defence Force (ADF) in which he simultaneously derived earnings from both the DHA and F&SI. On 17 May 2023, a delegate on behalf of the Department of Veteran Affairs (DVA) communicated to Mr Davis by email that his “Claim for Incapacity for Service/Work” had been denied and attached the May 2023 Decision. Mr Davis asserted that, in the making of the May 2023 Decision, he was denied procedural fairness, procedural requirements were not followed, the decision involved an error of law, and it accounted for an irrelevant consideration. Except for Mr Davis’ assertion that the May 2023 Decision involved an error of law, his complaints rise no higher than ones as to findings of fact that were solely within the province of the decision-maker and, although susceptible to merits review, are not the proper subject of an application for judicial review. In support of its application for summary judgment, the Commission relied on two affidavits of Ms Lindsay Cooper (Senior Lawyer – AGS) dated 19 April 2024 (the First Cooper Affidavit) and 29 April 2024 (the Second Cooper Affidavit), written submissions filed on 29 April 2024 and reply submissions filed on 13 May 2024. Two further affidavits of Ms Cooper dated 13 May 2024 and 16 May 2024) (the Fourth Cooper Affidavit) were subsequently filed by the Commission. Mr Davis relied on written submissions filed on 7 May 2024 and three affidavits to oppose the application, one by Mr Davis dated 7 May 2024, and two by Mr Matthew Jensen dated 7 May 2024 and 14 May 2024. Mr Jensen describes himself as a “Representative Advocate for Veterans”. His affidavits were read, but as they contained matters of opinion and comment, I have treated them as submissions made on behalf of Mr Davis. They are of no probative value. I also note that both parties, by their written submissions, made arguments about the appropriateness of Mr Davis’ complaint in respect of the May 2023 Decision being heard on a merits review. Those matters are not relevant to the current application, and I have no regard to them.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Ground 2 has no reasonable prospects of success.Ground 4 – An irrelevant consideration (s 5(1)(e))? As has already been explained above, and as was accepted by Mr Davis’ solicitor at the hearing, the reference to the “Veteran Review Board” in the May 2023 Decision is an error of fact. Mr Davis has not demonstrated that the delegate’s misidentification of the correct decision-maker was in any way material to the May 2023 Decision. Ground 4 has no reasonable prospects of success.DISPOSITION I cannot be satisfied that any ground on which Mr Davis relies in his originating application demonstrates that he has any reasonable prospects of success in prosecuting this proceeding. It is appropriate that the Commission’s application for summary judgment be granted. Mr Davis has, for the second time, used the resources of a superior court in circumstances where he had every opportunity to have the decision about which he complains reviewed by the VRB and the AAT. His insistence on pursuing his application for judicial review in the face of the more appropriate alternatives was inconsistent with his obligations under ss 37M and 37N of the FCA Act. The Commission has not, however, sought anything more than a standard costs order. Consequently, Mr Davis will be ordered to pay the Commission’s costs on the standard basis only.