ThoughtWare Australia Pty Limited v IonMy Pty Ltd (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

ThoughtWare Australia Pty Limited v IonMy Pty Ltd (No 2) [2023] FCA 1161

File number: QUD 107 of 2023
Judgment of: DERRINGTON J
Date of judgment: 18 August 2023
Date of publication of reasons: 27 September 2023
Catchwords:

CONTRACTS – dispute as to construction of business sale agreement referred to expert determination – whether determination binding – meaning of “gross profit”

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – summary judgment – question of construction – granting summary judgment in complex cases

Legislation:

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth)

Corporations Regulations 2001 (Cth)

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth)

Cases cited:

Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services & Multicultural Affairs v AAM17 (2021) 272 CLR 329

ThoughtWare Australia Pty Limited v IonMy Pty Ltd [2023] FCA 906

Todorovic v Moussa (2001) 53 NSWLR 463

Division: General Division
Registry: Queensland
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Commercial Contracts, Banking, Finance and Insurance
Number of paragraphs: 79
Date of hearing: 18 August 2023
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr D Keane KC
Solicitor for the Applicant: HWL Ebsworth Lawyers
Solicitor for the Respondent: Mr D Ward of Brown Ward King
Solicitor for an interested person: Mr N Chase Berry of ERA Legal

ORDERS

QUD 107 of 2023
BETWEEN:

THOUGHTWARE AUSTRALIA PTY LIMITED ACN 086 417 338

Applicant

AND:

IONMY PTY LTD ACN 639 514 480

Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

DERRINGTON J

DATE OF ORDER:

18 AUGUST 2023

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

Leave to proceed

1.The applicant have leave to proceed with this proceeding pursuant to s 453S of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth).

Leave — Amendments

2.The applicant have leave to file:

(a)an Amended Originating Application pursuant to r 8.21 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) in the form annexed as exhibit “WPJ-56” to the Affidavit of Warren Peter Jiear sworn 15 August 2023; and

(b)an Amended Concise Statement pursuant to r 16.53 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) in the form annexed as exhibit “WPJ-57” to the Affidavit of Warren Peter Jiear sworn 15 August 2023.

Judgment

3.There be judgment for the applicant in the sum of $2,368,903.59.

4.An order that the respondent pay the applicant interest on the judgment:

(a)pursuant to the Business Sale Agreement dated 30 June 2020 (BSA) for the dates payment was required, to commencement of these proceedings; and

(b)pursuant to s 51A of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) from commencement of these proceedings to judgment,

fixed in the sum of $55,444.25.

5.There be declarations that as at 14 August 2023:

(a)the respondent was unable to pay the Purchase Price instalments as per clause 3.2 of the BSA; and

(b)the BSA was terminated.

6.There be specific performance of clause 13.3(c) of the BSA, with the respondent to within 21 days:

(a)return operating control of the Business and the Assets (as defined in the BSA) to the applicant;

(b)deliver to the applicant or procure delivery of:

(i)all documents of title relating to the Assets;

(ii)assignments of each Contract to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read ThoughtWare Australia Pty Limited v IonMy Pty Ltd (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FCA 1161
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of ThoughtWare Australia Pty Limited v IonMy Pty Ltd (No 2), the Federal Court was called upon to determine several key issues arising from a business sale agreement (BSA) between ThoughtWare and IonMy. The central dispute centred on the calculation of "gross profit" as defined in clause 3.5(a) of the BSA, which determined the amount of instalments IonMy was required to pay ThoughtWare. This dispute had previously been referred to expert determination, which found in favour of ThoughtWare. IonMy contested the binding nature of the expert's determination and failed to make the required instalment payments. ThoughtWare sought summary judgment for the unpaid instalments, interest, and specific performance of certain BSA clauses.

The court had to decide whether the expert's determination on the meaning of "gross profit" was binding on the parties and whether summary judgment was appropriate in this complex case. The court also needed to determine whether IonMy was unable to pay the purchase price and if the BSA was therefore terminated, and if specific performance of the BSA's termination clause was warranted.

The court found that the expert's determination on "gross profit" was indeed binding on IonMy, as previously upheld in ThoughtWare v IonMy. The methodology used by IonMy to calculate gross profit was inconsistent with the expert's findings and thus not applicable. Consequently, the average annual gross profit for the relevant period exceeded $1 million, meaning no deductions were applicable to the instalments. The court granted summary judgment to ThoughtWare for the unpaid instalments and interest, declaring that IonMy was unable to pay the purchase price and that the BSA was terminated. The court also ordered specific performance of clause 13.3(c) of the BSA, requiring IonMy to return control of the business and assets to ThoughtWare within 21 days.

The court's decision included granting ThoughtWare judgment for the unpaid instalments and interest, declaring IonMy's inability to pay the purchase price and the termination of the BSA, and ordering specific performance of BSA clause 13.3(c). Additionally, the court restrained IonMy from transferring or dealing with the business or assets without ThoughtWare's consent. The orders also included provisions for costs and a special costs order.

Orders

Orders of the court

Leave to proceed

1. The applicant have leave to proceed with this proceeding pursuant to s 453S of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth).

Leave — Amendments

2. The applicant have leave to file:

(a) an Amended Originating Application pursuant to r 8.21 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) in the form annexed as exhibit “WPJ-56” to the Affidavit of Warren Peter Jiear sworn 15 August 2023; and

(b) an Amended Concise Statement pursuant to r 16.53 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) in the form annexed as exhibit “WPJ-57” to the Affidavit of Warren Peter Jiear sworn 15 August 2023.

Judgment

3. There be judgment for the applicant in the sum of $2,368,903.59.

4. An order that the respondent pay the applicant interest on the judgment:

(a) pursuant to the Business Sale Agreement dated 30 June 2020 (BSA) for the dates payment was required, to commencement of these proceedings; and

(b) pursuant to s 51A of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) from commencement of these proceedings to judgment,

fixed in the sum of $55,444.25.

5. There be declarations that as at 14 August 2023:

(a) the respondent was unable to pay the Purchase Price instalments as per clause 3.2 of the BSA; and

(b) the BSA was terminated.

6. There be specific performance of clause 13.3(c) of the BSA, with the respondent to within 21 days:

(a) return operating control of the Business and the Assets (as defined in the BSA) to the applicant;

(b) deliver to the applicant or procure delivery of:

(i) all documents of title relating to the Assets;

(ii) assignments of each Contract to the applicant and written consent of the other party to those assignments, or executed novations of the Contracts together with the originals of all Contracts;

(iii) all Records;

(iv) all Assets together with title documents

(v) all documents necessary to fully discharge any Encumbrance in respect of any Asset;

(vi) all documents necessary to record the changes of ownership of any of the Assets at each place the relevant Asset is registered or recorded;

(vii) all other documents and things required to be done or delivered or which are reasonably required to vest full ownership, title, possession and benefit of the Assets in the applicant to enable the applicant to conduct the Business in the same manner as the respondent has been conducting it.

7. Until further order, the respondent, by its directors, servants, agents, employees be restrained from transferring any part of the Assets or the Business (as defined in the BSA) to any other party or otherwise dealing with them other than with the consent in writing of the applicant by its solicitors, so as to be able to transfer the Business to the applicant in accordance with clause 13.3(c) of the BSA if required.

Costs

8. The respondent pay the applicant’s costs to 4 August 2023 on the standard basis.

9. The respondent pay the applicant’s costs from 4 August 2023 on the indemnity basis to be taxed if not agreed.

Special Costs Order

10. The applicant have leave to make any application it sees fit in relation to the making of a special costs order.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

It is convenient to begin by giving some background to the matter.Background The history of this matter was explained in detail in ThoughtWare v IonMy, but there is some value for the present purposes in recounting certain key points. ThoughtWare carried on business developing and supplying governance, risk and compliance software. On 30 June 2020, the parties formally executed the BSA, by which ThoughtWare sold that business to IonMy. ThoughtWare had previously operated under the business name “IonMy”, and it can be assumed that the respondent, IonMy, was incorporated under that name in connection with its acquisition of the business. “Completion” of the sale, as defined in the BSA, occurred on or about 15 December 2020. Under the BSA, the “Purchase Price” for the sale was $7.5 million. That amount was, pursuant to cl 3.2, to be paid in five “Instalments” with the first Instalment due on or before 30 June 2021 and the final Instalment due on or before 30 June 2025. The quantum of the Instalments was subject to certain terms and conditions, set out in cl 3.5 of the BSA. Clause 3.5(a), in particular, provided that the amount of an Instalment would be reduced on a pro rata basis if “the average annual gross profit of the Business for the two financial years immediately preceding the date that any Instalment is due for payment under clause 3.2 is less than $1,000,000.00”. Not long after the execution of the BSA, ThoughtWare and IonMy fell into dispute as to the meaning of the expression “gross profit” in cl 3.5(a). That dispute was referred to expert determination pursuant to cl 19 of the BSA in about May 2022. The expert’s determination was delivered on 6 February 2023, and substantially favoured the position taken by ThoughtWare. The expert concluded that the expression “gross profit” had the same meaning as was reflected in the accounts of the business contained in Annexure A to the BSA. That meaning was orthodox, though the expert acknowledged that different parties might have different views about those expenses that should fall within the “cost of goods sold” element of the “gross profit” equation. IonMy sought to challenge the determination, and asserted that it was not binding on the parties. It did not pay the first Instalment of $500,000 or the second Instalment of $750,000 on the dates stated in cl 3.2 of the BSA. ThoughtWare accordingly commenced this proceeding to enforce the determination against IonMy and obtain judgment in the amount of those Instalments. It conceded that certain deductions ought properly to be made to the first Instalment, in accordance with a separate (and presently irrelevant) reduction mechanism in cl 3.5(b) of the BSA, such that the total amount owing was $1,118,903.59. In ThoughtWare v IonMy, it was found that the parties were bound by the expert determination and that the expert’s conclusion as to the meaning of “gross profit” was entirely correct. IonMy was ordered to pay the first Instalment of the purchase price, less the conceded deductions, such that judgment was awarded against it in the amount of $368,903.59.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The three items of relief can be stepped through in turn.Judgment for the three Instalments plus interest The claim for judgment in the amount of the first three Instalments due under the BSA only requires it to be determined whether or not the average annual gross profit of the business conducted by IonMy for the two financial years immediately preceding the date on which each Instalment was payable was less than $1 million. Some accounts prepared by IonMy are before the Court which indicate that, on its view, the gross profit of the business over the relevant period has been negative or minimal. However, those accounts appear to have been produced in accordance with IonMy’s idiosyncratic view of what constitutes “gross profit”. The methodology that it has used is inconsistent with the findings made in ThoughtWare v IonMy. As was held in that decision, the method by which gross profit is properly to be calculated, including what expenses should be classified as part of the “cost of goods sold”, is that identified by the expert in his determination. IonMy is bound by that determination. IonMy’s accounts nevertheless contain the information necessary to ascertain the correct gross profits of the business in each of the relevant years. The reduction mechanism in cl 3.5(a) of the BSA can therefore be applied in order to determine the amount presently owing from IonMy to ThoughtWare. According to IonMy’s calculations, the business had a gross profit of $40,418.01 in 2020, $127,597.94 in 2021, -$114,349.57 in 2022 and $32,521.92 in 2023. These figures appear to have been produced by characterising substantial expenses for “Contractors - Development and Sales Support” and “Direct Wages” as part of the cost of goods sold. In the expert determination, it was found that the characterisation of such expenses as part of the cost of goods sold was, in the context of the BSA, incorrect. That conclusion was supported by the reasons in ThoughtWare v IonMy. The expert calculated that the average annual gross profit of the business in 2020 and 2021 was $1,291,106. That is over $1 million. It can now be ascertained that, once the improperly classified expenses are removed from the cost of goods sold category, the gross profit of the business was $1,118,644.38 in 2022 and $1,426,594.33 in 2023. The average annual gross profit of the business therefore exceeded $1 million over the whole of the period from 2020 to 2023. It follows that no deduction is to be made to the Instalments in accordance with cl 3.5(a) of the BSA. Mr Ward submitted at the hearing that he wished to determine if there was any evidence relating to the accuracy of the amounts in IonMy’s financial accounts. The difficulty is that this issue was not raised in the unsealed affidavit that he produced for the purposes of the hearing. There is simply no evidence before the Court to suggest that IonMy’s accounts are inaccurate. Indeed, nothing has been identified that can alter the conclusion that, properly calculated, the average annual gross profit of the business for the two years preceding the date of each of the three relevant Instalments was over $1 million.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

It follows that ThoughtWare is entitled to interest on the first, second and third Instalments in the amount of $55,444.25.Declarations that IonMy was unable to pay the Purchase Price and the BSA was terminated As previously mentioned, IonMy has failed to pay any amount of the Purchase Price, including the $368,903.59 amount that it was ordered to pay in ThoughtWare v IonMy. Mr Zammitt, its sole director, resolved at a meeting that took place yesterday that the company is insolvent or is likely to become insolvent at some future time. This affords some basis to believe that IonMy is indeed unable to pay the Purchase Price pursuant to the BSA. However, that conclusion can also be drawn more concretely by reference to financial records. The evidence before the Court shows that one of ThoughtWare’s directors, Mr Robin Craig, recently accessed the books and records maintained by IonMy, as he was entitled to do pursuant to the orders made on 27 April 2023. He considered the accounts in IonMy’s Xero accounting system and, on 14 August 2023, printed out a balance sheet for the company, which is exhibited to his affidavit in this proceeding. That balance sheet shows that the net assets of IonMy as at 14 August 2023 were ‑$516,257.50. That figure did not appear to take into account IonMy’s liability to ThoughtWare for the Instalments, which would increase the deficit substantially. This evidence is relied upon in support of the contention that IonMy was unable to pay the Instalments owed to ThoughtWare, that they have not been paid, and that IonMy cannot now pay them. That should be accepted. It is particularly notable that IonMy has taken no steps to pay the amount of $368,903.59 in accordance with the prior judgment of this Court. No reason has been given for its failure to pay a debt that is so obviously due. All of this tends to suggest that, as indicated by Mr Zammitt’s resolution on 17 August 2023, the company is insolvent or likely to become insolvent at some time in the future. The evidence perhaps supports the former conclusion more than the latter. There is nothing to demonstrate that the company can pay its debts. There has been no expression of willingness on the part of Mr Zammitt, or any other person, to advance the money necessary to comply with cl 3.2 of the BSA. Nor does there appear to be sufficient cash or other assets in the company to meet that obligation. It follows that IonMy was, and is, unable to pay the Purchase Price pursuant to the BSA. A declaration should therefore be made that IonMy was unable to pay the Purchase Price instalments as per clause 3.2 of the BSA. It should be declared, as a result, that the BSA was terminated. That is the necessary consequence of the operation of cl 13.3 of the BSA, to which I will now turn.Specific performance of cl 13.3(c) of the BSA Clause 13.3 of the BSA, in full, provides as follows:13.3 Termination due to Buyer actionsIf:(a)Completion has not occurred by 30 June 2021 or such other date as agreed in writing between the parties (acting in good faith); or(b)before full payment of the Purchase Price is completed the Buyer is unable to pay the Purchase Price instalments as per Clause 3.2 taking into account Clauses 3.5 to 3.7, for any reason including but not limited to:(i)Insolvency;(ii)Inability to run the Business successfully; or(iii)Sale of the Business or Assets unless the Seller consents to the sale;Then:(a)This agreement will terminate on that date;(b)If termination has occurred in accordance with clause 13.3(a), the Seller will repay to the Buyer any Purchase Price paid;(c)This Sale will be reversed, with full ownership of all IP, software and Goodwill in the Business and Assets being immediately transferred to the Seller;(d)The Buyer and Seller agree that revenue already earned by the Buyer up to that date comprises full and acceptable payment to the Buyer for any and all activities up to that date, and that any payments made according to Clauses 3 remain the property of the Seller;(e)The Seller will assist in this process with their best efforts; and(f)The Buyer will consider all claims against the Seller satisfied.