Hastie Group Limited (in liq) v Multiplex Constructions Pty Ltd (Formerly Brookfield Multiplex Constructions Pty Ltd) (No 3)

Link copied
Case Copied 71 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Hastie Group Limited (in liq) v Multiplex Constructions Pty Ltd (Formerly Brookfield Multiplex Constructions Pty Ltd) (No 3) [2022] FCA 1280

File number: VID 1277 of 2017
VID 237 of 2022
Judgment of: MIDDLETON J
Date of judgment: 2 November 2022
Catchwords:

BANKRUPTCY AND INSOLVENCY – action for debt brought by companies in liquidation and liquidator against numerous respondents – matters of principle common to various claims determined in this ‘liability trial’ – principles of collective enforcement and pari passu distribution – Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (Corporations Act) Sch 2 s 90-15 – liquidator seeking various directions that he is justified and acting reasonably in the future conduct of the winding up of the companies – directions not to be made having regard to determination of matters of principle

CORPORATIONS – s 553C of Corporations Act – statutory set-off – whether parties have claims to which s 553C may apply – whether mutuality satisfied with respect to Deed of Cross-Guarantee – whether s 553C operates automatically without lodging of proofs of debt – held: s 553C operates automatically

CORPORATIONS – “bank guarantees” – autonomy principle – whether companies in liquidation have proprietary interests in proceeds of bank guarantees drawn down by respondents – whether drawdowns of bank guarantees voided by ss 437D or 468 of Corporations Act – whether respondents otherwise restrained from retaining bank guarantee proceeds – held: drawdowns of bank guarantees not voided and retention of proceeds not otherwise restrained

CORPORATIONS – winding up by the court – ss 459A and 467B of Corporations Act – application for order for winding up by the court where company already being wound up voluntarily – held: application refused

LIMITATION OF ACTIONS – whether applicants’ claims sufficiently pleaded by way of initial originating process and concise statement within limitation period – held: applicants’ claims sufficiently pleaded and not statute-barred if within limitation period

Legislation:

Corporate Law Reform Act 1993 (Cth)

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)

Corporations Regulations 2001 (Cth)

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth)

Insolvency Practice Rules (Corporations) 2016 (Cth)

Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth)

Personal Property Securities Act 2009 (Cth)

Treasury Laws Amendment (2017 Enterprise Incentives No 2) Act 2017 (Cth)   

Cases cited:

Arnold World Trading Pty Ltd v ACN 133 427 335 Pty Ltd [2010] NSWSC 1369; (2010) 80 ACSR 670

Australasian Conference Assoc Ltd v Mainline Constructions Pty Ltd (in liq) (1978) 141 CLR 335

Ayerst (Inspector of Taxes) v C & K (Construction) Ltd [1976] AC 167

Bass v Permanent Trustee Co Ltd (1999) 198 CLR 334

Brash Holdings Ltd (administrator appointed) v Katile Pty Ltd [1996] 1 VR 24

British Eagle International Airlines Ltd v Compagnie Nationale Air France [1975] 1 WLR 758

Caltex Oil (Australia) Pty Ltd v Best (1990) 170 CLR 516

Cambridge Gas Transportation Corp v Official Committee of Unsecured Creditors of Navigator Holdings plc [2007] 1 AC 508

Car Buyers Australia Pty Ltd v Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2020] FCA 599

Cargill International SA…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hastie Group Limited (in liq) v Multiplex Constructions Pty... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] FCA 1280
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Hastie Group Limited (in liq) v Multiplex Constructions Pty Ltd (Formerly Brookfield Multiplex Constructions Pty Ltd) (No 3) involved the liquidator of Hastie Group Limited, along with other companies in liquidation, suing various construction companies for debts owed and the proceeds of bank guarantees. The central legal issues revolved around the enforceability of the bank guarantees, the applicability of statutory set-off, and the consequences of the Hastie Entities entering voluntary administration. The Court was required to determine whether the Respondents had any proprietary rights in the proceeds of the bank guarantees and whether the drawdown of these guarantees was void under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth).

The Court found that the statutory set-off provisions under s 553C of the Corporations Act operated automatically without the need for the lodging of proofs of debt. Additionally, the Court held that the Respondents did not acquire any proprietary interest in the proceeds of the bank guarantees drawn down by them. The drawdowns were not voided by ss 437D or 468 of the Act, and the Respondents were not restrained from retaining the proceeds of these guarantees. The Court also ruled that the application for winding up by the Court was refused, as the Hastie Entities were already being wound up voluntarily. Furthermore, the Court held that the Applicants’ claims were sufficiently pleaded and were not statute-barred if they were within the limitation period.

The Court’s reasoning was grounded in the statutory provisions of the Corporations Act, particularly those concerning the effects of voluntary administration and the rights of unsecured creditors. The Court emphasised the importance of adhering to the pari passu principle and the priority payments regime, which prohibit Respondents from using the proceeds of the bank guarantees to satisfy their claims against the Hastie Entities. The Court also noted the autonomy principle regarding bank guarantees, which supports the position that the companies in liquidation retain proprietary interests in the proceeds.

The final orders of the Court required the parties to confer and file any agreed minutes of orders by a specified date. If the parties could not agree, they were to file separate minutes of orders and short written submissions. A case management hearing was scheduled to address any remaining issues if necessary. The Court’s decisions provided clarity on the enforceability of bank guarantees in the context of corporate insolvency and the rights of creditors during the administration process.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The parties confer and thereafter by 2pm on 18 November 2022 file and serve any agreed minutes of orders reflecting the reasons of the Court, or in default of agreement, separate minutes of orders and short written submissions (of no longer than five pages).

2. A case management hearing is listed at 10.15am on 23 November 2022 to the extent desired by the Court or any party if the orders are not determined by the Court on the papers.

3. Unless otherwise ordered by the Court on its own motion or otherwise requested by any party, the orders of the Court will be determined on the papers.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

In respect of the Bank Guarantee Case, the Respondents deny the Applicants have any proprietary rights in the proceeds of the respective guarantees. Accordingly, their position is that the Applicants’ recourse to various provisions of Chapter 5 of the Act is not applicable. In addition, some of the Respondents also contend that the limitation period for the relevant Hastie Entity’s claim to recover the proceeds of the guarantees has expired.FACTUAL BACKGROUND AND PROCEDURAL HISTORY Before the Appointment Date, Hastie Group Limited (the First Applicant) was a public company listed on the Australian Securities Exchanges, and was the parent company of a number of wholly owned subsidiaries (43 subsidiaries, as at the Appointment Date). The Hastie Group carried on the business of providing mechanical, electrical and plumbing services in countries including Australia, and through its various subsidiaries, was engaged in performing works on a number of building projects or had performed works on completed projects. The Hastie Entities in these proceedings entered into major long-term building subcontracts with head builders, being the Respondents, on large-scale multimillion dollar projects around Australia. Pursuant to those subcontracts, the Hastie Entities undertook services and rendered progress payment claims or invoices to the respective Respondents, the amounts in relation to which were owing to the Hastie Entities as at the Appointment Date. As part of each subcontract, the Hastie Entities were required to secure their performance, and in respect of each Respondent, this was done by way of bank guarantee issued to the Respondent. As is normal commercial practice, each Hastie Entity held a “bank guarantee facility” with the issuing bank for the purpose of its issuing bank guarantees to beneficiaries, and the bank guarantee itself was entered into by way of a separate agreement between the issuing bank and the respective Respondent beneficiary. It is also relevant to note that the Hastie Group had in place a Deed of Cross-Guarantee dated 30 June 2005, under which each ‘Group Entity’ defined under the deed would guarantee to a ‘Creditor’ (as defined) the payment in full of any debt payable by another Group Entity On 28 May 2012, Messrs Crosbie, Carson and McEvoy were appointed as voluntary administrators of the companies in the Hastie Group, including the Hastie Entities. After the Appointment Date, the Respondents each failed or refused to pay the amounts owing as at the Appointment Date. Instead, each Respondent: (a)elected to terminate or suspend performance of their respective subcontracts;(b)stated that they had or would incur costs and expenses to have other providers perform the services the Hastie Entities now could not perform, and asserted an entitlement to set-off against the amount sought by the relevant Hastie Entity; and(c)either retained the bank guarantee provided by the relevant Hastie Entity despite a request for its return, or ‘called’ on the bank guarantee, resulting in the issuing bank drawing down on the guarantee and providing the proceeds to the Respondent.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Finally, I note that no injunction or restraining order (final or interlocutory) is specifically sought in these proceedings to prevent any Respondent from “calling on” any bank guarantee not already called on.Evidence in the main proceeding During the trial of the main proceeding, I decided that various aspects of the pleadings would effectively be treated as fact for the purposes of the liability trial. In particular, the Court proceeded on the basis that the facts pleaded by the Applicants formed the basis of their claims concerning the operation of the Corporations Act, and the questions relating to the limitation defences. There were a number of objections to evidence by the parties, but in the end, the parties either came to an agreement to allow certain evidence to be tendered for the purposes of the liability trial or the Court admitted the evidence subject to relevance. It is unnecessary for me to specifically refer to each of these items of evidence as I have in the course of these reasons referred to the evidence that is relevant and determinative of the issues that are required to be considered in this liability trial. Further, the Court received the following evidence:(a)the contracts between each Respondent and each Hastie Entity (including, where no formal contract was entered into, correspondence said to constitute a contract), as summarised at Schedule A to the Applicants’ Closing Submissions dated 7 May 2022; (b)various other contracts relevant to the main proceeding, such as certain facilities agreements entered into between the Hastie Group and various banks, and the Deed of Cross-Guarantee;(c)the bank guarantees relevant to the main proceeding which were issued to each Respondent;(d)the date of recourse and amount drawn by each Respondent on the bank guarantees provided by each Hastie Entity, set out at Schedule B to the Applicants’ Closing Submissions dated 7 May 2022; (e)the status of each project subcontract, including whether the subcontract was terminated (and date thereof), or taken out of the hands of the Hastie Entity (and date thereof), or treated as having been terminated, set out at Schedule C to the Applicants’ Closing Submissions dated 7 May 2022; and (f)further documents tendered by agreement between the Applicants and each Respondent, such as relevant contractual notices pursuant to the abovementioned contracts, correspondence between the parties and limited affidavit evidence in relation to certain contracts. Where a contract sought to be relied upon by the Applicants is not available and not put in evidence before the Court, I cannot and do not infer that such an alleged contract existed, or that its terms were identical to or similar to the other contracts before the Court. The Applicants may still be able to rely on s 1305 of the Act as prima facie evidence of their claims, even if a contract is not available. I refer later in these reasons to s 1305 and its operation. Further, there is an issue concerning the contracts entered into between Multiplex and the Hastie Entities in relation to “Project K – Sydney Water HQ” and the so-called “Global Bonds” (being certain bank guarantees issued by ANZ to Multiplex in relation to Hastie Australia).

Decision

Reasons for decision

First, in my reasons for judgment on 22 December 2020, I granted leave to the Applicants to file an amended originating process and pleading, and found on an interlocutory basis for the purposes of allowing the main proceeding to continue to trial that the receivable debt and bank guarantee claims as amended were covered sufficiently in the initial originating process and pleading such that they were not “new claims”: Hastie Group Limited (in liq) v Multiplex Constructions Pty Ltd (Formerly Brookfield Multiplex Constructions Pty Ltd) [2020] FCA 1824 (Hastie Interlocutory Decision) at [18], [22]. Second, on 27 October 2021, as the Twelfth and Thirteenth Respondents (together, ‘Grocon’) had by that time entered external administration and were subject to a deed of company arrangement, I granted leave under s 444E(3) of the Act for the Applicants to proceed against them in respect of specific issues. I will now turn to the Applicants’ claims in the main proceeding.SUMMARY OF CLAIMSPoints of Claim The Applicants’ claims as against all of the Respondents were initially contained in the Concise Statement filed on 14 November 2017 and the Points of Claim filed on 13 July 2018. I will detail the procedural history of the pleadings later in these reasons when I come to the issue of limitation of actions. The Applicants now rely on their Second Further Amended Originating Process filed on 3 March 2021 and the following Points of Claim filed as against each individual group of Respondents (I note that the various “Further Amended Points of Claim” referred to below are not referred to in the Second Further Amended Originating Process, but I granted leave to file those during the trial and they were relied upon by the Applicants in their submissions):(1)the Further Amended Points of Claim filed 22 March 2022 as against the First and Second Respondents (‘Multiplex’);(2)the Amended Points of Claim filed 26 February 2021 as against the Third Respondent, the Amended Points of Claim filed 26 February 2021 as against the Fourth and Thirtieth Respondents, and the Amended Points of Claim filed 26 February 2021 as against the Fifth Respondent (those respondents together, ‘Lendlease’);(3)the Amended Points of Claim filed 26 February 2021 as against the Seventh and Eighth Respondents (‘Badge’);(4)the Further Amended Points of Claim filed 6 April 2022 as against the Tenth Respondent (‘CPB’);(5)the Further Amended Concise Statement filed 26 February 2021 as against the Twelfth and Thirteenth Respondents (Grocon);(6)the Further Amended Points of Claim filed 29 March 2022 as against the Fourteenth Respondent (‘Hansen Yuncken’);(7)the Amended Points of Claim filed 10 March 2021 as against the Fifteenth Respondent (‘John Holland’);(8)the Amended Points of Claim filed 26 February 2021 as against the Sixteenth Respondent (‘Laing O’Rourke’);(9)the Amended Points of Claim filed 26 February 2021 as against the Nineteenth Respondent (‘Thiess’);(10)the Further Amended Concise Statement filed 26 February 2021 as against the Twenty-First to Twenty-Third Respondents (‘Watpac’); and(11)the Amended Points of Claim filed 26 February 2021 as against the Twenty-Fifth Respondent (‘Scentre’).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

As noted earlier, given the bifurcation of the liability and quantum in this proceeding, the amounts claimed in the Points of Claim and the underlying payment claims, schedules and invoices do not need to be considered in detail in these reasons. Rather, certain of these documents were accepted into evidence on an indicative basis to the extent necessary for the determination of the liability issues of the Applicants’ Receivables Case. The effect and application of the Corporations Act The Appointment Date on which each Hastie Entity entered voluntary administration under s 436A of the Act – being 28 May 2012 for each of the Hastie Entities – brought certain consequences under the Act. For example, as at the Appointment Date, s 440D of the Act immediately denied each Respondent any entitlement to begin or continue a proceeding in a Court against a Hastie Entity or in relation to any of its property except with the administrators’ written consent or the leave of the Court. None of the Respondents was a “secured creditor” of any Hastie Entity at the Appointment Date within the meaning of s 9 of the Act. Each Respondent was therefore an unsecured creditor. It is then contended that each Respondent who presented and drew down on their bank guarantee, without the consent of the administrators and without notifying the administrators of its intent to do so, did not obtain any proprietary interest in nor any immediate entitlement to the amount drawn down and received from the issuing bank, which remained at all times and remains the property or money of the relevant Hastie Entity. In particular, it is contended that, by the Respondent engaging (or rather, as finally submitted by the end of the trial by the Applicants, by the issuing bank engaging) in a transaction or dealing affecting property of the Hastie Entity under administration, the call or draw down on the bank guarantee was void by virtue of s 437D. It is then contended that the winding up of the Hastie Entities by creditors’ resolution pursuant to s 439C(c) of the Act – on 30 or 31 January 2013 – also brought certain consequences under the Act, being that:(a)each Respondent is prohibited by s 500(2) of the Act from bringing proceedings against a Hastie Entity to secure an order transferring to the Respondent proprietorship over the amount drawn down on the bank guarantees;(b)having regard to s 553 of the Act (and Chapter 5 of the Act generally), each Respondent is required to seek to be admitted to proof in the external administration of the Hastie Entity in respect of any claims against the Hastie Entity arising from or connected with the relevant subcontract;(c)pursuant to s 474 of the Act, the Liquidator must take into his custody or control the amount drawn down by each Respondent under the bank guarantee, and each Respondent must immediately return that amount to the Liquidator;(d)pursuant to s 506 of the Act, the Liquidator is entitled to exercise any of the powers the Act confers on a Liquidator in a winding up in insolvency;(e)each Respondent is subject to ss 555, 556 and 560 of the Act, which give effect to the pari passu principle and the priority payments regime, and because of which each Respondent is prohibited from using the proceeds of the bank guarantee to satisfy its claims against the Hastie Entity; and(f)as elaborated in the Applicants’ submissions (but not specifically referred to in any of the Points of Claim), s 468 of the Act has the effect of voiding any disposition of property of the Hastie Entity made after the Appointment Date, including each Respondent’s draw down of the bank guarantees.