Lucas Stuart Pty Ltd v Hemmes Hermitage Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read

NEW SOUTH WALES COURT OF APPEAL

CITATION:
Lucas Stuart Pty Ltd v Hemmes Hermitage Pty Ltd [2010] NSWCA 283

FILE NUMBER(S):
2009/298813

HEARING DATE(S):
26 October 2010

JUDGMENT DATE:
1 November 2010

PARTIES:
Lucas Stuart Pty Ltd (Applicant)
Hemmes Hermitage Pty Ltd (Respondent)

JUDGMENT OF:
Campbell JA Macfarlan JA Young JA   

LOWER COURT JURISDICTION:
Supreme Court

LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S):
SC 2009/298813

LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER:
Macready AsJ

LOWER COURT DATE OF DECISION:
21 September 2010

LOWER COURT MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION:
Lucas Stuart Pty Ltd v Hemmes Hermitage Pty Ltd [2010] NSWSC 1101

COUNSEL:
M Ashhurst SC/D Hand (Applicant)
S A Kerr SC/T Breakspear (Respondent)

SOLICITORS:
BCP Lawyers & Consultants (Applicant)
Mallesons Stephen Jaques (Respondent)

CATCHWORDS:
CONTRACTS – building and construction contracts – performance bonds – whether entitlement of principal to call on performance bonds conditioned upon the objective fact of material non-compliance by the contactor with its contractual obligations – Clough Engineering v Oil & Gas Corporation (2008) 249 ALR 458 considered – grant of interlocutory injunction – whether contractually unjustified call on bonds likely to damage reputation and financial standing of contractor
EQUITY - injunction to restrain breach of negative stipulation in contract - exercise of equity's auxiliary jurisdiction - need to demonstrate inadequacy of relevant legal remedies including an award of damages - test for grant of interlocutory injunction

LEGISLATION CITED:
Building and Construction Industry Security of Payment Act 1999

CATEGORY:
Principal judgment

CASES CITED:
American Cyanamid Co v Ethicon Ltd [1975] AC 396
Bankstown City Council v Alamdo Holdings Pty Ltd [2005] HCA 46; (2005) 223 CLR 660
Barclay Mowlem Construction Ltd v Simon Engineering (Aust) Pty Ltd (1991) 23 NSWLR 451
Bateman Project Engineering Pty Ltd v Resolute Ltd [2000] WASC 284; (2000) 23 WAR 493
Clough Engineering Ltd v Oil & Natural Gas Corporation Ltd [No 3] [2007] FCA 2082
Clough Engineering Ltd (ACN 009 093 869) v Oil & Natural Gas Corporation Ltd [2008] FCAFC 136; (2008) 249 ALR 458
Curro v Beyond Productions Pty Ltd (1993) 30 NSWLR 337
Dalgety Wine Estates Pty Ltd v Rizzon [1979] HCA 41; (1979) 141 CLR 552
Doherty v Allman (1878) 3 App Cas 709
Fletcher Construction Australia Ltd v Varnsdorf Pty Ltd [1998] 3 VR 812
House v The King [1936] HCA 40; (1936) 55 CLR 499
J C Williamson Ltd v Lukey and Mulholland [1931] HCA 15; (1931) 45 CLR 282
Malik v Bank of Credit and Commerce International SA [1998] AC 20
Murphy v Lush [1986] HCA 37; (1986) 60 ALJR 523
Patrick Stevedores Operations No 2 Pty Ltd v Maritime Union of Australia [1998] HCA 30; (1998) 195 CLR 1
Reed Construction Services Pty Ltd v Kheng Seng (Australia) Pty Ltd (1999) 15 BCL 158
Varley v Varley [2006] NSWSC 1025

TEXTS CITED:
N C Seddon and M P Ellinghaus, Cheshire and Fifoot's Law of Contract, 9th Aust ed (2008) LexisNexis Butterworths
J Beatson and H G Beale, Chitty on Contracts 28th ed (1999)…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lucas Stuart Pty Ltd v Hemmes Hermitage Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] NSWCA 283
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Supreme Court of New South Wales, Court of Appeal, Lucas Stuart Pty Ltd (the applicant) sought to appeal an interlocutory decision concerning its entitlement to call upon performance bonds provided by Hemmes Hermitage Pty Ltd (the respondent). The dispute arose from a building and construction contract, where the respondent sought to cash in performance bonds based on alleged non-compliance by the applicant with a notice issued under the contract. The applicant contended that these calls on the bonds were contractually unjustified and would cause significant damage to its reputation and financial standing.

The Court of Appeal was required to determine whether the respondent's entitlement to call upon the performance bonds was conditioned upon the objective fact of material non-compliance by the applicant with its contractual obligations. Furthermore, the Court had to consider the test for granting an interlocutory injunction, specifically whether the applicant had demonstrated a serious question to be tried regarding the validity of the respondent's notice, whether the balance of convenience favoured the grant of interim relief, and whether damages would be an inadequate remedy for the likely harm to the applicant's reputation and financial standing.

The Court found that the primary judge had misconstrued the contract in his exercise of discretion. Applying the principles for granting an interlocutory injunction, the Court determined that there was a serious question to be tried as to the validity of the respondent's notice. The Court reasoned that further calls on the bonds, if contractually unjustified, were likely to increase the damage already suffered by the applicant, and that a restraint on such calls would tend to lessen the adverse impact. Consequently, the balance of convenience favoured the grant of interim relief, and damages were considered an inadequate remedy.

The Court allowed the appeal, set aside the orders of the primary judge, and granted an interlocutory injunction restraining the respondent from converting into cash any unconditional undertaking provided by the applicant, where such conversion was sought in reliance upon any failure, or purported failure, to comply with the terms of the notice dated 19 July 2010. The respondent was ordered to pay the applicant's costs of the motion and the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

(1) Leave to appeal granted;

(2) Appeal allowed;

(3) Orders made by Macready AsJ on 21 September 2010 set aside;

(4) Upon the applicant by its counsel giving to the Court the usual undertaking as to damages, and until further order of this Court or of the court at first instance, restrain the respondent from converting into cash, pursuant to Clause 16.3 of the Contract between the parties, any unconditional undertaking provided by the applicant to the respondent where such conversion is sought to be made by the respondent in reliance upon any failure, or purported failure, of the applicant to comply with the terms of the Notice dated 19 July 2010 issued by the respondent to the applicant;

(5) Order the respondent to pay the applicant’s costs of the applicant’s Notice of Motion filed on 17 September 2010 and of the proceedings on appeal; and

(6) The respondent to have a certificate under the Suitor’s Fund Act 1951, if qualified.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Contrary to the submission of the respondent, I do not consider that this occurrence negates the applicant’s evidence that it will suffer a loss of reputation and financial standing if bonds are called upon. The respondent submits that because the bonds have been in part called upon, it can be inferred that any damage to the applicant’s reputation and financial standing has already been suffered and will not be increased by further calls. I do not agree. On the contrary, I see no reason why in the absence of evidence indicating otherwise that the Court should not assume that further calls are likely to increase the damage and that a restraint upon further calls, upon the basis that they would be, and the earlier calls were, arguably contractually unjustified would tend to lessen the adverse impact of the earlier calls.Conclusion As I have indicated earlier, the primary judge’s exercise of discretion miscarried because he acted upon a misconstruction of the contract. Accordingly, it is for this Court to re-exercise that discretion. As I consider that there is a serious question to be tried as to the validity of the respondent’s Notice, the balance of convenience favours the grant of interim relief and damages would arguably be an inadequate remedy, I consider that the interlocutory injunction that the applicant seeks should be granted. I propose the following orders:(1) Leave to appeal granted;(2) Appeal allowed;(3) Orders made by Macready AsJ on 21 September 2010 set aside;(4)Upon the applicant by its counsel giving to the Court the usual undertaking as to damages, and until further order of this Court or of the court at first instance, restrain the respondent from converting into cash, pursuant to Clause 16.3 of the Contract between the parties, any unconditional undertaking provided by the applicant to the respondent where such conversion is sought to be made by the respondent in reliance upon any failure, or purported failure, of the applicant to comply with the terms of the Notice dated 19 July 2010 issued by the respondent to the applicant;(5)Order the respondent to pay the applicant’s costs of the applicant’s Notice of Motion filed on 17 September 2010 and of the proceedings on appeal; and(6)The respondent to have a certificate under the Suitor’s Fund Act 1951, if qualified. YOUNG JA: There is pending in the Building and Technology List of the commercial section of the Equity Division a weighty building case involving the construction of a large building in George Street Sydney. The present applicant, Lucas Stuart Pty Ltd, is the contractor and the opponent, Hemmes Hermitage Pty Ltd, is the proprietor. The litigation seems to have been commenced some time in 2009 and raises multiple issues as to the construction of the relevant contract and who should pay damages to whom for what in respect of various breaches. On 19 July 2010, not it would appear for the first time, the proprietor sought to cash in some of securities provided by the builder by way of performance bonds issued by the QBE Insurance Company.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.