[2017] HCATrans 147
IN THE HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Office of the Registry
Perth No P30 of 2017
B e t w e e n -
CPB CONTRACTORS PTY LTD (ACN 000 893 667)
Applicant
and
JKC AUSTRALIA LNG PTY LTD (ACN 154 383 409)
Respondent
Application for interim injunction
NETTLE ACJ
TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS
AT MELBOURNE ON FRIDAY, 14 JULY 2017, AT 10.27 AM
Copyright in the High Court of Australia
MR J.A. THOMSON, SC: May it please the Court, I appear with MR M.R. COLLINS on behalf of the applicant. (instructed by King & Wood Mallesons)
MR S.K. DHARMANANDA, SC: If it please the Court, I appear with my learned friend, MR T.J. PALMER, for the respondent. (instructed by DLA Piper Australia)
HIS HONOUR: Yes, Mr Thomson.
MR THOMSON: Thank you, your Honour. Thank you for agreeing to this this urgently. May I commence by identifying the material which the Court ought to have before it: the application for special leave to appeal and its attachments; there is a summons for interim injunction. There ought to have been filed, but I have with me, an undertaking as to damages – can I please ask if my solicitor could hand that up? It has been provided to my friend.
HIS HONOUR: Yes, thank you.
MR THOMSON: There also ought to be the submissions in support of an interim injunction which has been filed by the applicant. There are some opposing submissions filed by my learned friends for the respondents and there are two affidavits – the affidavit of Mr Jason Zeb, sworn on 10 July 2017 and an affidavit of Ms De Silva, affirmed on 12 July 2017, and with the Court’s leave I read those affidavits.
HIS HONOUR: Yes.
MR THOMSON: Thank you. The last affidavit of Ms De Silva contains the written reasons of the Court of Appeal for not granting an injunction to prevent the respondent calling upon the bonds which in aggregate are about $26 million until after determination of this application for special leave. Those written reasons were not available at the time that the submissions were filed by us and that is why it has been provided separately.
HIS HONOUR: Thank you.
MR THOMSON: At a threshold level, the question as to whether the Court ought to grant interim relief to the applicant pending the determination of its application for special leave depends upon how the Court assesses the prospects of success for the special leave application. Your Honour of course knows that the test which has been applied by this Court in a number of cases is whether there are substantial prospects that a special leave application will be granted and, as we draw attention to in our submissions, that test has been applied in certain cases by stating that an application does not have insubstantial prospects of special leave being granted, the reason being elaborated by her Honour the Chief Justice in Mercanti v Mercanti and that the…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read CPB Contractors Pty Ltd v JKC Australia LNG Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2017] HCATrans 147
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the High Court was whether CPB had substantial prospects of success in its application for special leave to appeal. This, in turn, depended on the proper construction of performance bonds and the contractual rights of recourse available to a party. CPB argued that the Court of Appeal had erred in inferring a subjective element into the right of recourse, suggesting that the commercial purpose of such bonds was primarily to provide security for properly payable damages, rather than to allocate risk during the pendency of a dispute. CPB contended that the wording of the bonds in this case did not expressly include a subjective belief requirement, and that inferring such a requirement would be an overstraining of the contractual language.
CPB's counsel submitted that the Court of Appeal's reasoning, which placed emphasis on the potential expiry of the bonds before a dispute could be resolved, did not inevitably lead to the conclusion that the bonds could be called upon regardless of the underlying dispute. CPB highlighted reservations expressed by the New South Wales and Queensland Courts of Appeal regarding similar reasoning in previous cases, suggesting a divergence of judicial opinion on the construction of such provisions. CPB also argued that the balance of convenience favoured granting the injunction, citing potential reputational damage and the destruction of the subject matter of the litigation if the bonds were called.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter came before this Court as an application for an interim injunction to preserve the status quo pending determination of an application for special leave to appeal. The application was brought by CPB Contractors Pty Ltd (CPB) against JKC Australia LNG Pty Ltd (JKC), concerning the interpretation and enforcement of bank guarantees provided by CPB to JKC under a construction sub-contract for the Ichthys LNG Project. CPB sought to prevent JKC from calling upon the bank guarantees amounting to approximately $26 million, which JKC claimed were due to CPB’s alleged delays in completing the sub-contract works. The application arose from a series of prior judicial decisions, including a dismissal of CPB’s application for an interlocutory injunction by Le Miere J in the Supreme Court of Western Australia, an appeal dismissed by the Court of Appeal, and a subsequent refusal by the Court of Appeal to grant an interlocutory injunction pending the special leave application. The interim injunction application in the High Court was heard on an expedited basis, with submissions made by both parties on the prospects of success of the special leave application, the balance of convenience, and the potential consequences of refusing the interim relief.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Does the application for special leave to appeal have substantial prospects of success?
2. Whether a contractual provision can inform the proper construction of other contractual provisions if it is void or unenforceable because it ousts the Court’s jurisdiction?
3. When does a provision prescribing the circumstances in which recourse may be had to a bank guarantee have the purpose of allocating risk between contractual parties pending resolution of a dispute over whether an amount is due?
4. Does the balance of convenience lie in favour of the applicant in this case?
5. Can the subject matter of the application for special leave to appeal be said to be destroyed if the respondent calls upon the bank guarantees before the appeal is determined?
6. Is there a significant risk of reputational harm to the applicant if the respondent calls upon the bank guarantees before the appeal is determined?
7. Is it possible to mitigate any potential reputational harm by providing an alternative form of security?
8. Does the introduction of a subject development into a clause that does not explicitly address a right of recourse raise a question of general importance?
9. Is there a dispute over the enforceability or validity of the contractual provision in question?
10. Does the applicant have a valid argument regarding the purpose of the bank guarantees in this case?
Held
1. The application for special leave to appeal does not have substantial prospects of success.
2. The court concluded that a contractual provision can inform the proper construction of other contractual provisions even if it is void or unenforceable because it ousts the Court’s jurisdiction.
3. The court determined that a provision prescribing the circumstances in which recourse may be had to a bank guarantee has the purpose of allocating risk between contractual parties pending resolution of a dispute over whether an amount is due, based on the terms and context of the contract in question.
4. The balance of convenience does not lie in favour of the applicant in this case.
5. The court found that the subject matter of the application for special leave to appeal would not be destroyed if the respondent calls upon the bank guarantees before the appeal is determined.
6. The court acknowledged that there is a significant risk of reputational harm to the applicant if the respondent calls upon the bank guarantees before the appeal is determined.
7. The court considered that it is possible to mitigate any potential reputational harm by providing an alternative form of security.
8. The introduction of a subject development into a clause that does not explicitly address a right of recourse was deemed to raise a question of general importance.
9. The court concluded that there is a dispute over the enforceability or validity of the contractual provision in question.
10. The applicant's argument regarding the purpose of the bank guarantees in this case was not considered valid by the court.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Court considered CPB Contractors' application for an interim injunction to prevent JKC Australia from calling on bank guarantees, pending the determination of CPB Contractors' application for special leave to appeal. The Court examined several factors in deciding whether to grant the injunction, including the prospects of success for the special leave application, the balance of convenience, and whether the subject matter of the appeal would be destroyed if the bank guarantees were called upon.
Firstly, the Court found that CPB Contractors did not have substantial prospects of success in their application for special leave to appeal. Although CPB Contractors argued that the Court of Appeal had misconstrued the contractual provisions in question, the Court found that the Court of Appeal's reasoning was consistent with the weight of authority and the principles applicable to the construction of bank guarantees.
Secondly, the Court found that the balance of convenience did not lie in favour of CPB Contractors. Although CPB Contractors argued that the bank guarantees would be discharged if JKC called upon them, the Court found that this would not render the appeal nugatory, as the question of whether JKC was entitled to call upon the bank guarantees could still be argued after the fact. Moreover, the Court found that CPB Contractors could mitigate any potential reputational harm by providing an alternative form of security, such as tendering a sum equal to the amount of the claim on account.
Finally, the Court found that the introduction of a subject development into a clause that did not explicitly address a right of recourse did not raise a question of general importance. The Court found that the Court of Appeal had correctly construed the contractual provisions in question and had not engaged in any broad discussion of the general principles of bank guarantees.
In conclusion, the Court dismissed the application for an interim injunction, finding that the balance of convenience did not lie in favour of CPB Contractors and that they had not demonstrated substantial prospects of success in their application for special leave to appeal. The Court found that the principles applicable to the construction of bank guarantees were well-established and that the Court of Appeal's reasoning was consistent with the weight of authority.