Sons of Gwalia Ltd v Margaretic

Link copied
Case Copied 86 min read

HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

GLEESON CJ,
GUMMOW, KIRBY, HAYNE, CALLINAN, HEYDON AND CRENNAN JJ

Matter No S208/2006

SONS OF GWALIA LTD (SUBJECT TO DEED
OF COMPANY ARRANGEMENT)  APPELLANT

AND

LUKA MARGARETIC & ANOR  RESPONDENTS

Matter No S209/2006

ING INVESTMENT MANAGEMENT LLC  APPELLANT

AND

LUKA MARGARETIC & ANOR  RESPONDENTS

Sons of Gwalia Ltd v Margaretic
ING Investment Management LLC v Margaretic
[2007] HCA 1
31 January 2007
S208/2006 & S209/2006

ORDER

In each matter, the appeal is dismissed with costs.

On appeal from the Federal Court of Australia

Representation

B W Walker SC with K J Mony De Kerloy for the appellant in Matter No S208/2006 and the second respondent in Matter No S209/2006 (instructed by Freehills)

T F Bathurst QC with P D Crutchfield for the appellant in Matter No S209/2006 and for the second respondent in Matter No S208/2006 (instructed by Arnold Bloch Liebler)

B A J Coles QC with K M Richardson for the first respondent in both matters (instructed by Jackson McDonald)

Notice:  This copy of the Court's Reasons for Judgment is subject to formal revision prior to publication in the Commonwealth Law Reports.

  1. GLEESON CJ.   These appeals raise an issue concerning the subordination of what are sometimes called "shareholder claims" to claims of other creditors in the application of the insolvency provisions of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ("the Act"). The resolution of the issue turns upon the meaning and effect of s 563A of the Act, which is in Div 6 (concerning proof and ranking of claims) of Pt 5.6 (concerning winding-up). That section provides:

    "Payment of a debt owed by a company to a person in the person's capacity as a member of the company, whether by way of dividends, profits or otherwise, is to be postponed until all debts owed to, or claims made by, persons otherwise than as members of the company have been satisfied."

  2. Section 553, which is also contained in Div 6 of Pt 5.6, provides that, subject to the Division, in every winding-up, all debts payable by, and all claims against, the company (present or future, certain or contingent, ascertained or sounding only in damages) are admissible to proof against the company. It is obvious that there are debts that may be owed by a company to a person who is a member of the company which are not owed to the person in the person's capacity as a member. It is equally obvious that, whatever be the precise test according to which the distinction is to be drawn, the subordination effected by s 563A is limited to debts owed to a member as a member, and does not apply to debts owed to a person otherwise than as a member. Debts owed by way of dividends, profits or otherwise to a person in the person's capacity as a member are contrasted with debts owed to, or claims made by, a person otherwise than as a member.

  3. The language of s 563A has a long history; a history that…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sons of Gwalia Ltd v Margaretic and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] HCA 1
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of Australia considered appeals from the Federal Court of Australia concerning the proof and ranking of claims in the winding-up of Sons of Gwalia Ltd. The primary dispute involved Mr. Margaretic, a shareholder who claimed damages against the company for misleading or deceptive conduct that induced him to purchase shares. ING Investment Management LLC, another creditor, had interests adverse to Mr. Margaretic. The central issue revolved around the interpretation of provisions within the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) as applied to these "shareholder claims."

The Court was required to determine whether a common law principle, purportedly established in *Houldsworth v City of Glasgow Bank*, precluded a member from proving in a winding-up for damages for misrepresentation if rescission of the share purchase was no longer available due to the company's insolvency. Furthermore, the Court had to consider whether Mr. Margaretic's claim was admissible to proof under s 553(1) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) and whether it should be postponed under s 563A of the Act as a debt owed to him in his "capacity as a member."

The Court reasoned that the supreme importance of statute law in Australian corporate insolvency proceedings meant that general principles of company law, particularly those derived from older British cases, were not a reliable guide. Instead, the resolution of the appeals depended on the true construction of the specific provisions of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). The Court concluded that the debt owed to Mr. Margaretic was not owed to him in his "capacity as a member" for the purposes of s 563A, distinguishing the present case from *Webb Distributors* and its reliance on earlier statutory provisions.

In each matter, the appeal was dismissed with costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

In each matter, the appeal is dismissed with costs. On appeal from the Federal Court of Australia

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

GLEESON CJ GUMMOW J (dissent) HEYDON J CRENNAN J
The decision in Webb Distributors neither requires nor supports any different outcome. Principles concerning the raising and maintenance of share capital led this Court to conclude that, on the true construction of s 360(1)(k) of the Victorian Code, the claims in that case should be treated as claims for sums due to members in their capacity as members. For the reasons already given it would be wrong to conclude that, on the true construction of s 563A of the Act, the debt owed to the respondent is owed to him in his capacity as a member of the first appellant.Conclusion Each appeal should be dismissed with costs. The resolution of the issues in these appeals turns upon the construction of certain provisions of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ("the Act") incorporated in a Deed of Arrangement to which Sons of Gwalia Ltd ("Gwalia") is subject. There is a dispute respecting the application of those provisions to "shareholder claims" by Mr Margaretic, the first respondent. The expression "shareholder claims" is used here to identify claims for damages against a company by a subscriber for, or purchaser of, its shares, where the claimant asserts reliance upon misleading or deceptive conduct of the company or other wrongful act or omission on its part which was causative of that shareholder's loss. ING Investment Management LLC ("ING") is a creditor of Gwalia which is not a shareholder and its interests are adverse to those of Mr Margaretic. The apparently seamless continuity in the reception and development of the common law in Australia is apt to distract attention from the supreme importance of statute law. In this vein, the submissions presented on these appeals to varying degrees proceeded from an implicit premise which is false. There are no "general principles of company law" applicable in a winding up and to which there must be reconciled those provisions of the Act and its predecessors (beginning with the Companies Act 1862 (UK) ("the 1862 UK Act")[28]) which stipulate a particular system of proof of debts and the ranking of debts and the placement of "shareholder claims" in that system.[28]25 & 26 Vict c 89. Further, in any quest to locate such general principles, the older case law is not always a satisfactory guide. Excessive significance should not be attributed to statements in nineteenth century British cases, decided at a time of endeavours to "flesh out" the developing body of statute law[29] by use of principles derived from a range of sources in the general law. These sources included the law of agency, partnership, bankruptcy, and trusts. It later was recognised that some of those endeavours miscarried. One was the attribution to directors of the character of trustees of the assets of the company, and another the treatment of a company in liquidation as trustee of its assets for distribution among creditors[30].[29]See Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Linter Textiles Australia Ltd (In liq) (2005) 220 CLR 592 at 609‑611 [39]-[49]; New South Wales v Commonwealth (2006) 81 ALJR 34 at 72-77 [96]-[124]; 231 ALR 1 at 34-41.[30]See, respectively, Clay v Clay (2001) 202 CLR 410 at 430‑431 [41]; Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Linter Textiles Australia Ltd (In liq) (2005) 220 CLR 592 at 611 [48]-[49].

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: GLEESON CJ, HEYDON J, CRENNAN J