Elder's Trustee and Executor Co Ltd v Commonwealth Homes and Investment Co Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 34 min read
65 CLR 603

ELDER'S TRUSTEE AND EXECUTOR

COMPANY LIMITED

COMMONWEALTH HOMES AND INVEST-

RESPONDENT.

MENT CO. LTD.

ON APPEAL FROM THE SUPREME COURT OF

SOUTH AUSTRALIA. Company-Allotment of shares Voidable allotments-Rescission-Election to affirm H. C. OF

-Knowledge of right-Companies Act 1892 (S.A.) (55 &56 Vict. No. 557), Where a shareholder in a company, having in fact two independent grounds for rescinding the contract of membership, and being aware of the facts giving rise to one of them but not of his right in point of law to rescind, loses by his conduct the right to rescind on that ground, he is not thereby precluded from rescinding on his subsequently discovering the existence of the other ground. Quare as to the position where, having in fact two grounds for rescission, but being ignorant of one and aware of the other, he elects to affirm with knowledge of his right in law to rescind.

Where a shareholder in a company has reason to know facts conferring a right to rescind the contract of membership, his conduct in merely continuing for a long time to act as a shareholder and failing to disclaim that character without doing anything inconsistent with rescission does not, in the absence of knowledge that he has the right in point of law to rescind, enable an inference that he has made an election to affirm or raise an equity against allowing him to rescind.

A writ claiming a declaration that an allotment was not binding upon him was issued by a shareholder in a company some six weeks before the lodgment of a petition for winding up the company. At the time of the issue of the writ the company was in a hopeless financial position.

65 CLR 604

Held, distinguishing on the facts Tennent v. City of Glasgow Bank, (1897) 4 App. Cas. 615, that the action for rescission did not fail on the ground that when the writ was issued the liquidation of the company had virtually com-

Decision of the Supreme Court of South Australia (Full Court): Marshall V. Commonwealth Homes and Investment Co. Ltd., (1941) S.A.S.R. 74, reversed.

APPEAL from the Supreme Court of South Australia.

In an action in the Supreme Court of South Australia by Albert Frederick Marshall against Commonwealth Homes and Investment Co. Ltd. the plaintiff claimed a declaration that an allotment of 2,040 shares to him was not binding upon him, rescission of the contract to take such shares, and rectification of the register of members of the defendant company by removing his name, and consequential relief. Before the action was brought to a hearing the plaintiff died, and his executor, Elder's Trustee and Executor Co. Ltd., carried on the proceeding.

Of the grounds on which the plaintiff's claim was based, it is sufficient to mention for the purposes of this report non-compliance with sub-secs. a and b respectively of sec. 226 of the Companies Act 1892 of South Australia.1

The parties concurred in stating a special case for…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Elder's Trustee and Executor Co Ltd v Commonwealth Homes and... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1941] HCA 31
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Elder's Trustee and Executor Co Ltd, as executor of the estate of Albert Frederick Marshall, appealed to the High Court of Australia from a decision of the Supreme Court of South Australia. The dispute concerned the validity of an allotment of shares in Commonwealth Homes and Investment Co Ltd to Mr Marshall. Mr Marshall had sought a declaration that the allotment was not binding upon him, rescission of the contract to take the shares, and rectification of the company's register. The grounds for his claim included alleged non-compliance with specific provisions of the Companies Act 1892 (S.A.) concerning share allotments made pursuant to a prospectus.

The legal issues before the High Court were whether the allotment of shares to Mr Marshall was voidable due to the company's failure to comply with statutory requirements regarding the minimum number of shares subscribed and the payment of application and allotment moneys as stipulated in the abridged prospectus. Additionally, the Court had to consider whether Mr Marshall, by his conduct, had lost his right to rescind the contract of membership, particularly in light of the company's impending liquidation at the time the writ was issued.

The Court held that the company's failure to meet the conditions outlined in section 226 of the Companies Act 1892 (S.A.) rendered the allotment of shares voidable at the instance of the applicant. The Court distinguished the present case from *Tennent v. City of Glasgow Bank* by noting that Mr Marshall's actions, such as continuing to act as a shareholder for a period without knowledge of his legal right to rescind, did not amount to an election to affirm the contract. Crucially, the Court found that Mr Marshall had not lost his right to rescind merely because the company was in a hopeless financial position and a winding-up petition was imminent when he issued the writ, especially as he lacked full knowledge of the facts giving rise to his right to rescind until shortly before commencing proceedings.

The appeal was allowed, and the decision of the Supreme Court of South Australia was reversed. The High Court ordered that the allotment of shares to Mr Marshall was not binding upon him, that the contract to take the shares be rescinded, and that the register of members of the defendant company be rectified by removing his name.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established