Southern British National Trust Ltd v Pither

Link copied
Case Copied 45 min read
57 CLR 89

THE SOUTHERN BRITISH NATIONAL TRUST

LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION)

PITHER AND ANOTHER

RESPONDENTS.

PLAINTIFF AND DEFENDANT,

ON APPEAL FROM THE SUPREME COURT OF

QUEENSLAND. Assignment-Chose in action-Right to future dividends-Dividends to be applied in

payment for debentures-Construction of charging clause in debentures-Assign- ment fraudulently obtained-Rights of other debenture holders-Equities.

The plaintiff, who was a creditor of a bank, proved his debt in its liquidation. After receiving some dividends he was induced by fraud to assign his right to future dividends to a trust company, which, subsequently, was ordered to be wound up. The deed of assignment provided that the dividends should be applied by the trust company in payment of the purchase price of certain debentures applied for by the plaintiff. The debentures were part of a series of debentures to be issued by the trust company, which informed the plaintiff that he had been allotted a specified number of those debentures. He did not take up or receive the debenture scrip, but his name was placed on the trust company's list of debenture holders. By the debentures each debenture holder obtained a charge on, inter alia, "all investments net proceeds of sales of debentures of this series' and "all moneys being net proceeds of sales of debentures of this series

held by the trust pending investment." The plaintiff claimed a declaration that by reason of the fraud the assignment was void and inoperative and not binding upon him and payment to him of outstanding dividends. The claim was resisted on the ground that innocent third parties, namely, the other holders of debentures of the series, had acquired rights in the chose in action the subject matter of the assignment.

57 CLR 90

Held that the plaintiff was entitled to the relief claimed :- By Latham C.J., on the ground that the chose in action did not fall within the charging clause of the debentures and the duty of the directors of the trust company to preserve property which might become subject to the charge did not confer any interest in such property on the debenture holders.

By Rich and Dixon JJ., on the ground that, assuming that the debenture holders acquired an equitable interest in the chose in action, they took subject to all equities affecting the title of their assignor, the trust company.

APPEAL from the Supreme Court of Queensland.

In a suit brought in the Supreme Court of Queensland by Abraham Pither of Benambra, Victoria, grazier, against the Primary Producers Bank of Australia Ltd. (In Liquidation) and the Southern British National Trust Ltd. (In Liquidation), the plaintiff alleged that on 6th December 1933 the Southern British National Trust Ltd. (In Liquidation)-referred to as the trust company-by false and fraudulent representations induced him to sign (a) an application to the directors of the trust company for the allotment to him of a number of " B ' series perpetual income first mortgage investment trust debentures of £10 each upon the terms of a prospectus issued by…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Southern British National Trust Ltd v Pither and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1937] HCA 28
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The plaintiff, Abraham Pither, sought a declaration that a deed of assignment he executed was void due to fraud. The assignment transferred his right to future dividends from the liquidation of the Primary Producers Bank to The Southern British National Trust Ltd. (the trust company). The trust company intended to use these dividends to pay for debentures Pither had applied for. The dispute arose because the trust company argued that other debenture holders of the same series had acquired rights in the assigned dividends, thus precluding Pither from rescinding the assignment. The case was heard on appeal in the High Court of Australia.

The central legal issues before the court were: firstly, whether the plaintiff's right to future dividends constituted a chose in action that fell within the charging clause of the trust company's debentures, thereby creating an interest for other debenture holders; and secondly, if such an interest was created, whether the debenture holders took subject to the plaintiff's equity to set aside the assignment due to the fraud perpetrated by the trust company.

Latham C.J. found that the plaintiff's right to future dividends did not fall within the charging clause of the debentures. He reasoned that the clause specifically covered investments and moneys derived from the net proceeds of debenture sales, and the right to receive future dividends did not fit this description. He also noted that while directors have a duty to preserve property that might become subject to a charge, this duty does not confer an interest in that property upon the debenture holders. Rich and Dixon JJ. took a different approach, stating that even if the debenture holders acquired an equitable interest in the chose in action, they took that interest subject to all equities affecting the title of their assignor, the trust company. This meant they were subject to Pither's right to rescind the assignment due to the fraud.

The High Court dismissed the appeal and affirmed the judgment of the Supreme Court of Queensland. The plaintiff was therefore entitled to a declaration that the assignment was void and inoperative, and to receive the outstanding dividends from the bank.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.